State-based encoding of large asynchronous controllers

State encoding is one of the fundamental problems in the synthesis of asynchronous controllers. The requirement for a correct hazard-free implementation imposes severe constraints on the way encoding signals can be inserted in the specification of a controller. Even though some specification formalisms, such as Burst-mode machines or Signal Transition Graphs, enable to specify behaviors at the event level, the state encoding methods that provide the best good-quality solutions work at the state level. This imposes a severe limitation on the size of the controllers that can be handled by these methods. This paper proposes a method to solve the encoding problem for large asynchronous controllers using statebased methods. It is based on an iterative process of projection and re-composition that reduces the size specification by hiding signals, partially solves the encoding problem at the state level and re-composes the original specification using a synchronous product. The process iterates until all encoding conflicts have been solved. The method is proved to preserve the behavior of the specification (branching bisimilarity) and shown to be capable of providing good-quality solutions for controllers of more than 100 signals and 106 states.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

State encoding of asynchronous controllers using pseudo-boolean optimization

State encoding of asynchronous controllers is a challenging problem that faces a vast space of solutions. Subtle differences in the insertion of signals may result in significant variations in the complexity of the logic. This paper proposes a novel approach that models the encoding problem as Pseudo-Boolean formula. A cost function that estimates the complexity of the logic is incorporated, where the estimator of essential literals becomes one of the most important terms of the function. The new approach has been tested in 175 benchmarks with encoding conflicts, including 127 four-phase latch controllers. The presence of logic estimators in the formula contributes to an average reduction of 43% in literals when compared to a plain SAT version of the problem, at the expense of a longer runtime. When comparing to the region-based approach in petrify, an average reduction of 14% in literals is obtained.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Synthesis of variability-tolerant circuits with adaptive clocking

Improvements in circuit manufacturing have allowed, along the years, increasingly complex designs. This has been enabled by the miniaturization that circuit components have undergone. But, in recent years, this scaling has shown decreasing benefits as we approach fundamental limits. Furthermore, the decrease in size is nowadays producing an increase in variability: unpredictable differences and changes in the behavior of components. Historically, this has been addressed by establishing guardband margins at the design stage. Nonetheless, as variability grows, the amount of pessimism introduced by these margins is taking an ever-increasing cost on performance and power consumption. In recent years, several approaches have been proposed to lower the impact of variability and reduce margins. One such technique is the substitution of a classical PLL clock by a Ring Oscillator Clock. The design of the Ring Oscillator Clock is done in such a way that its variability is highly correlated to that of the circuit. One of the contributions of this thesis is in the automatic design of such circuits. In particular, we propose a novel method to design digital delay lines with variability-tracking properties. Those designs are also suitable for other purposes, such as bundled-data circuits or performance monitors. The advantage of the proposed technique is based on the exclusive use of cells from a standard cell library, which lowers the design cost and complexity. The other focus of this thesis is on state encoding for asynchronous controllers. One of the main properties of asynchronous circuits is their ability to, implicitly, work under variable conditions. In the near future, this advantage might increase the relevance of this class of circuits. One of the hardest stages for the synthesis of these circuits is the state encoding. This thesis presents a SAT-based algorithm for solving the state encoding at the state level. It is shown, by means of a comprehensive benchmark suite, that results obtained by this technique improve significantly compared to results from similar approaches. Nonetheless, the main limitation of techniques at the state level is the state explosion problem, to which the sequential modeling of concurrency is often subject to. The last contribution of this thesis is a method to process asynchronous circuits in order to allow the use of state-based techniques for large instances. In particular, the process is divided into three stages: projection, signal insertion and re-composition. In the projection step, the behavior of the controller is simplified until the signal insertion can be performed by state-based techniques. Afterwards, the re-composition generalizes the insertion of the signal into the original controller. Experimental results show that this process enables the resolution of large controllers, in the order of 10 6 states, by state-based techniques. At the same time, only a minor impact in solution quality is observed, preserving one of the main advantages for state-based approaches.A lo largo de los años, mejoras en la fabricación de circuitos han permitido diseños cada vez más complejos. Esta tendencia, que ha tenido lugar gracias a la miniaturización de los componentes que forman estos circuitos, recientemente está mostrando beneficios decrecientes a medida que nos acercamos a ciertas limitaciones fundamentales. Además de estos beneficios decrecientes, la reducción en tamaño está produciendo un aumento, cada vez mayor, en la variabilidad: diferencias impredecibles y cambios en el comportamiento de los componentes. Esto se ha compensado históricamente con el uso de márgenes de seguridad en la fase de diseño. No obstante, a medida que la variabilidad crece, la cantidad de pesimismo que estos márgenes introducen está afectando significativamente el coste en rendimiento y consumo energético. En los últimos años se han propuesto diferentes técnicas para limitar el impacto de la variabilidad y reducir márgenes de seguridad. Una de estas técnicas consiste en substituir un reloj PLL clásico por un Ring Oscillator Clock. El diseño de un Ring Oscillator Clock se realiza de manera que su variabilidad este altamente correlacionada con la del circuito. Una de las contribuciones de esta tesis consiste en el diseño automático de estos relojes. Concretamente, se propone un nuevo método para diseñar líneas de retardo digitales (digital delay lines) que tengan como propiedad la capacidad de imitar la variabilidad de un circuito dado. Estos diseños son también apropiados para otros propósitos, tal y como circuitos con ?bundled-data? o monitorizadores de rendimiento. La ventaja del método propuesto con respecto a otras técnicas similares radica en el uso exclusivo de celdas provenientes de una librería de celdas estándar, lo que reduce considerablemente el coste de diseño y su complejidad. Por otro lado, esta tesis también se centra en la codificación de estados de circuitos asíncronos. Una de las principales propiedades de estos circuitos reside en su capacidad implícita para trabajar bajo condiciones de variabilidad. Es previsible que, en un futuro próximo, esta ventaja se vuelva aún más relevante. La síntesis de circuitos asíncronos consta de varias etapas, una de las cuales es la codificación de estados. Este trabajo presenta un algoritmo basado en SAT que permite resolver la codificación de estados a nivel de estado. Mediante el uso de un exhaustivo banco de pruebas, esta tesis muestra como resultados obtenidos por esta técnica mejoran significativamente en comparación con otros métodos similares. A pesar de ello, técnicas que trabajan a nivel de estado tienen como principal limitación el problema conocido como "explosión de estados" que aparece habitualmente cuando se modelan elementos concurrentes de manera secuencial. Así pues, la última contribución de esta tesis es la propuesta de un método para procesar circuitos asíncronos de manera que técnicas a nivel de estado sean usables para instancias grandes. En concreto, el proceso está dividido en tres fases: proyección, inserción de señal y re-composición. En la etapa de proyección, el comportamiento del controlador es simplificado suficientemente como para que la inserción de la señal se pueda realizar con técnicas a nivel de estado. A continuación, la re-composición generaliza esta inserción en el controlador original. Resultados experimentales muestran que este proceso permite la resolución de grandes controladores, del orden de 10^6 estados, mediante el uso de técnicas a nivel de estado. Al mismo tiempo, solo se observa un impacto mínimo en la calidad de las soluciones, preservando una de las mayores ventajas de los métodos a nivel de estado

Interpreted graph models

A model class called an Interpreted Graph Model (IGM) is defined. This class includes a large number of graph-based models that are used in asynchronous circuit design and other applications of concurrecy. The defining characteristic of this model class is an underlying static graph-like structure where behavioural semantics are attached using additional entities, such as tokens or node/arc states. The similarities in notation and expressive power allow a number of operations on these formalisms, such as visualisation, interactive simulation, serialisation, schematic entry and model conversion to be generalised. A software framework called Workcraft was developed to take advantage of these properties of IGMs. Workcraft provides an environment for rapid prototyping of graph-like models and related tools. It provides a large set of standardised functions that considerably facilitate the task of providing tool support for any IGM. The concept of Interpreted Graph Models is the result of research on methods of application of lower level models, such as Petri nets, as a back-end for simulation and verification of higher level models that are more easily manipulated. The goal is to achieve a high degree of automation of this process. In particular, a method for verification of speed-independence of asynchronous circuits is presented. Using this method, the circuit is specified as a gate netlist and its environment is specified as a Signal Transition Graph. The circuit is then automatically translated into a behaviourally equivalent Petri net model. This model is then composed with the specification of the environment. A number of important properties can be established on this compound model, such as the absence of deadlocks and hazards. If a trace is found that violates the required property, it is automatically interpreted in terms of switching of the gates in the original gate-level circuit specification and may be presented visually to the circuit designer. A similar technique is also used for the verification of a model called Static Data Flow Structure (SDFS). This high level model describes the behaviour of an asynchronous data path. SDFS is particularly interesting because it models complex behaviours such as preemption, early evaluation and speculation. Preemption is a technique which allows to destroy data objects in a computation pipeline if the result of computation is no longer needed, reducing the power consumption. Early evaluation allows a circuit to compute the output using a subset of its inputs and preempting the inputs which are not needed. In speculation, all conflicting branches of computation run concurrently without waiting for the selecting condition; once the selecting condition is computed the unneeded branches are preempted. The automated Petri net based verification technique is especially useful in this case because of the complex nature of these features. As a result of this work, a number of cases are presented where the concept of IGMs and the Workcraft tool were instrumental. These include the design of two different types of arbiter circuits, the design and debugging of the SDFS model, synthesis of asynchronous circuits from the Conditional Partial Order Graph model and the modification of the workflow of Balsa asynchronous circuit synthesis system.EThOS - Electronic Theses Online ServiceEPSRCGBUnited Kingdo

Verification and synthesis of asynchronous control circuits using petri net unfoldings

PhD ThesisDesign of asynchronous control circuits has traditionally been associated with application of formal methods. Event-based models, such as Petri nets, provide a compact and easy to understand way of specifying asynchronous behaviour. However, analysis of their behavioural properties is often hindered by the problem of exponential growth of reachable state space. This work proposes a new method for analysis of asynchronous circuit models based on Petri nets. The new approach is called PN-unfolding segment. It extends and improves existing Petri nets unfolding approaches. In addition, this thesis proposes a new analysis technique for Signal Transition Graphs along with an efficient verification technique which is also based on the Petri net unfolding. The former is called Full State Graph, the latter - STG-unfolding segment. The boolean logic synthesis is an integral part of the asynchronous circuit design process. In many cases, even if the verification of an asynchronous circuit specification has been performed successfully, it is impossible to obtain its implementation using existing methods because they are based on the reachability analysis. A new approach is proposed here for automated synthesis of speed-independent circuits based on the STG-unfolding segment constructed during the verification of the circuit's specification. Finally, this work presents experimental results showing the need for the new Petri net unfolding techniques and confirming the advantages of application of partial order approach to analysis, verification and synthesis of asynchronous circuits.The Research Committee, Newcastle University: Overseas Research Studentship Award

Multi-resource approach to asynchronous SoC : design and tool support

As silicon cost reduces, the demands for higher performance and lower power consumption are ever increasing. The ability to dynamically control the number of resources employed can help balance and optimise a system in terms of its throughput, power consumption, and resilience to errors. The management of multiple resources requires building more advanced resource allocation logic than traditional 1-of-N arbiters posing the need for the efficient design flow supporting both the design and verification of such systems. Networks-on-Chip provide a good application example of distributed arbitration, in which the processor cores needing to transmit data are the clients; and the point-to-point links are the resources managed by routers. Building fast and smart arbiters can greatly benefit such systems in providing efficient and reliable communication service. In this thesis, a multi-resource arbiter was developed based on the Signal Transition Graph (STG) development flow. The arbiter distributes multiple active interchangeable resources that initiate requests when they are ready to be used. It supports concurrent resource utilization, which benefits creating asynchronous Multiple-Input-Multiple- Output (MIMO) queues. In order to deal with designs of higher complexity, an arbiter-oriented design flow is proposed. The flow is based on digital circuit components that are represented internally as STGs. This allows designing circuits without directly working with STGs but allowing their use for synthesis and formal verification. The interfaces for modelling, simulation, and visual model representation of the flow were implemented based on the existing modelling framework. As a result, the verification phase of the flow has helped to find hazards in existing Priority arbiter implementations. Finally, based on the logic-gate flow, the structure of a low-latency general purpose arbiter was developed. This design supports a wide variety of arbitration problems including the multi-resource management, which can benefit building NoCs employing complex and adaptive routing techniques.EThOS - Electronic Theses Online ServiceEPSRC grant GR/E044662/1 (STEP)GBUnited Kingdo

Exploiting robustness in asynchronous circuits to design fine-tunable systems

PhD ThesisRobustness property in a circuit defines its tolerance to the effects of process, voltage and temperature variations. The mode signaling and event communication between computing units in a asynchronous circuits makes them inherently robust. The level of robustness depends on the type of delay assumptions used in the design and specification process. In this thesis, two approaches to exploiting robustness in asynchronous circuits to design self-adapting and fine-tunable systems are investigated. In the first investigation, a Digitally Controllable Oscillator (DCO) and a computing unit are integrated such that the operating conditions of the computing unit modulated the operation of the DCO. In this investigation, the computing unit which is a self-timed counter interacts with the DCO in a four-phase handshake protocol. This mode of interaction ensures a DCO and computing unit system that can fine-tune its operation to adapt to the effects of variations. In this investigation, it is shown that such a system will operate correctly in wide range of voltage supply. In the second investigation, a Digital Pulse-Width Modulator (DPWM) with coarse and fine-tune controls is designed using two Kessels counters. The coarse control of the DPWM tuned the pulse ratio and pulse frequency while the fine-tune control exploited the robustness property of asynchronous circuits in an addition-based delay system to add or subtract delay(s) to the pulse width while maintaining a constant pulse frequency. The DPWM realized gave constant duty ratio regardless of the operating voltage. This type of DPWM has practical application in a DC-DC converter circuit to tune the output voltage of the converter in high resolution. The Kessels counter is a loadable self-timed modulo−n counter, which is realized by decomposition using Horner’s method, specified and verified using formal asynchronous design techniques. The decomposition method used introduced parallelism in the system by dividing the counter into a systolic array of cells, with each cell further decomposed into two parts that have distinct defined operations. Specification of the decomposed counter cell parts operation was in three stages. The first stage employed high-level specification using Labelled Petri nets (LPN). In this form, functional correctness of the decomposed counter is modelled and verified. In the second stage, a cell part is specified by combing all possible operations for that cell part in high-level form. With this approach, a combination of inputs from a defined control block activated the correct operation for a cell part. In the final stage, the LPNs were converted to Signal Transition Graphs, from which the logic circuits of the cells were synthesized using the WorkCraft Tool. In this thesis, the Kessels counter was implemented and fabricated in 350 nm CMOS Technology.Niger Delta Development Commission (NDD