Consistency of QSAR models: Correct split of training and test sets, ranking of models and performance parameters

<div><p>Recent implementations of QSAR modelling software provide the user with numerous models and a wealth of information. In this work, we provide some guidance on how one should interpret the results of QSAR modelling, compare and assess the resulting models, and select the best and most consistent ones. Two QSAR datasets are applied as case studies for the comparison of model performance parameters and model selection methods. We demonstrate the capabilities of sum of ranking differences (SRD) in model selection and ranking, and identify the best performance indicators and models. While the exchange of the original training and (external) test sets does not affect the ranking of performance parameters, it provides improved models in certain cases (despite the lower number of molecules in the training set). Performance parameters for external validation are substantially separated from the other merits in SRD analyses, highlighting their value in data fusion.</p></div

MODELING OF CARBONIC ANHYDRASE (II) INHIBITORY ACTIVITIES OF SULPHONILAMIDE SCHIFF BASES BY ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORK TRAINED WITH DIFFERENT NUMERICAL TECHNIQUES

Objective: The aim of the present study was to develop robust linear and non-linear Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship (QSAR) models for exploring the relationship between the structural features of a series of sulphanilamide Schiff bases and their CA (II) inhibition activities.Methods: QSAR modeling of carbonic anhydrase (II) inhibiting activities of a series of sulphanilamide Schiff bases as a function of theoretically derived molecular descriptors calculated by Dragon software was established linearly by stepwise multiple linear regression (SW-MLR) method and non-linearly by artificial neural network (ANN) method, trained with different numerical techniques namely, Scaled conjugate gradient (SCG), quasi-Newton (BFGS), and Levenberg-Marquardt (LM) algorithm. SW-MLR method was also used to select descriptors from large descriptor pool. After the selection of variables, best selected linear model was validated by Y-randomization test. The applicability domain was assessed by the normalized mean Euclidean distance value for each compound. The prediction quality of proposed non-linear QSAR models was tested externally using validation and test set.Results: The low value of R2average = 0.214 from the Y-randomization test and no significant correlation between the selected descriptors indicates that linear model is reliable, and robust. Applicability domain analysis has also revealed that the suggested model has acceptable predictability. To explore non-linear relationship between selected descriptors and the target property, ANN approach trained with three supervised algorithms (BFGS, SCG and LM) was used. Statistical comparison of the quality of models obtained using ANN method trained with above mentioned three algorithms with SW-MLR model shows that ANN with 4-3-1 architecture and trained with LM algorithm has better predictive power as indicated by low RMSEval (0.11), MAPEval (11.95) values and high R2val (0.96) value.Conclusion: The results of this work indicated the ANN trained with fastest Levenberg-Marqardt algorithm is a promising tool for establishing non-linear relationship between selected sulphanilamide Schiffbases and their CA (II) inhibition values

Development of a QSPR model for predicting thermal stabilities of nitroaromatic compounds taking into account their decomposition mechanisms

International audienceThe molecular structures of 77 nitroaromatic compounds have been correlated to their thermal stabilities by combining the quantitative structure-property relationship (QSPR) method with density functional theory (DFT). More than 300 descriptors (constitutional, topological, geometrical and quantum chemical) have been calculated, and multilinear regressions have been performed to find accurate quantitative relationships with experimental heats of decomposition (deltaH). In particular, this work demonstrates the importance of accounting for chemical mechanisms during the selection of an adequate experimental data set. A reliable QSPR model that presents a strong correlation with experimental data for both the training and the validation molecular sets (R 2 = 0.90 and 0.84, respectively) was developed for non-ortho-substituted nitroaromatic compounds. Moreover, its applicability domain was determined, and the model's predictivity reached 0.86 within this applicability domain. To our knowledge, this work has produced the first QSPR model, developed according to the OECD principles of regulatory acceptability, for predicting the thermal stabilities of energetic compounds

Chemometric QSAR Modeling and In Silico Design of Antioxidant NO Donor Phenols

An acceleration of free radical formation within human system exacerbates the incidence of several life-threatening diseases. The systemic antioxidants often fall short for neutralizing the free radicals thereby demanding external antioxidant supplementation. Therein arises the need for development of new antioxidants with improved potency. In order to search for efficient antioxidant molecules, the present work deals with quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) studies of a series of antioxidants belonging to the class of phenolic derivatives bearing NO donor groups. In this study, several QSAR models with appreciable statistical significance have been reported. Models were built using various chemometric tools and validated both internally and externally. These models chiefly infer that presence of substituted aromatic carbons, long chain branched substituents, an oxadiazole-N-oxide ring with an electronegative atom containing group substituted at the 5 position and high degree of methyl substitutions of the parent moiety are conducive to the antioxidant activity profile of these molecules. The novelty of this work is not only that the structural attributes of NO donor phenolic compounds required for potent antioxidant activity have been explored in this study, but new compounds with possible antioxidant activity have also been designed and their antioxidant activity has been predicted in silico

Computational approaches to virtual screening in human central nervous system therapeutic targets

In the past several years of drug design, advanced high-throughput synthetic and analytical chemical technologies are continuously producing a large number of compounds. These large collections of chemical structures have resulted in many public and commercial molecular databases. Thus, the availability of larger data sets provided the opportunity for developing new knowledge mining or virtual screening (VS) methods. Therefore, this research work is motivated by the fact that one of the main interests in the modern drug discovery process is the development of new methods to predict compounds with large therapeutic profiles (multi-targeting activity), which is essential for the discovery of novel drug candidates against complex multifactorial diseases like central nervous system (CNS) disorders. This work aims to advance VS approaches by providing a deeper understanding of the relationship between chemical structure and pharmacological properties and design new fast and robust tools for drug designing against different targets/pathways. To accomplish the defined goals, the first challenge is dealing with big data set of diverse molecular structures to derive a correlation between structures and activity. However, an extendable and a customizable fully automated in-silico Quantitative-Structure Activity Relationship (QSAR) modeling framework was developed in the first phase of this work. QSAR models are computationally fast and powerful tool to screen huge databases of compounds to determine the biological properties of chemical molecules based on their chemical structure. The generated framework reliably implemented a full QSAR modeling pipeline from data preparation to model building and validation. The main distinctive features of the designed framework include a)efficient data curation b) prior estimation of data modelability and, c)an-optimized variable selection methodology that was able to identify the most biologically relevant features responsible for compound activity. Since the underlying principle in QSAR modeling is the assumption that the structures of molecules are mainly responsible for their pharmacological activity, the accuracy of different structural representation approaches to decode molecular structural information largely influence model predictability. However, to find the best approach in QSAR modeling, a comparative analysis of two main categories of molecular representations that included descriptor-based (vector space) and distance-based (metric space) methods was carried out. Results obtained from five QSAR data sets showed that distance-based method was superior to capture the more relevant structural elements for the accurate characterization of molecular properties in highly diverse data sets (remote chemical space regions). This finding further assisted to the development of a novel tool for molecular space visualization to increase the understanding of structure-activity relationships (SAR) in drug discovery projects by exploring the diversity of large heterogeneous chemical data. In the proposed visual approach, four nonlinear DR methods were tested to represent molecules lower dimensionality (2D projected space) on which a non-parametric 2D kernel density estimation (KDE) was applied to map the most likely activity regions (activity surfaces). The analysis of the produced probabilistic surface of molecular activities (PSMAs) from the four datasets showed that these maps have both descriptive and predictive power, thus can be used as a spatial classification model, a tool to perform VS using only structural similarity of molecules. The above QSAR modeling approach was complemented with molecular docking, an approach that predicts the best mode of drug-target interaction. Both approaches were integrated to develop a rational and re-usable polypharmacology-based VS pipeline with improved hits identification rate. For the validation of the developed pipeline, a dual-targeting drug designing model against Parkinson’s disease (PD) was derived to identify novel inhibitors for improving the motor functions of PD patients by enhancing the bioavailability of dopamine and avoiding neurotoxicity. The proposed approach can easily be extended to more complex multi-targeting disease models containing several targets and anti/offtargets to achieve increased efficacy and reduced toxicity in multifactorial diseases like CNS disorders and cancer. This thesis addresses several issues of cheminformatics methods (e.g., molecular structures representation, machine learning, and molecular similarity analysis) to improve and design new computational approaches used in chemical data mining. Moreover, an integrative drug-designing pipeline is designed to improve polypharmacology-based VS approach. This presented methodology can identify the most promising multi-targeting candidates for experimental validation of drug-targets network at the systems biology level in the drug discovery process

Cheminformatics-aided pharmacovigilance: application to Stevens-Johnson Syndrome

Objective Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship (QSAR) models can predict adverse drug reactions (ADRs), and thus provide early warnings of potential hazards. Timely identification of potential safety concerns could protect patients and aid early diagnosis of ADRs among the exposed. Our objective was to determine whether global spontaneous reporting patterns might allow chemical substructures associated with Stevens-Johnson Syndrome (SJS) to be identified and utilized for ADR prediction by QSAR models

The Use of Pseudo-Equilibrium Constant Affords Improved QSAR Models of Human Plasma Protein Binding

To develop accurate in silico predictors of Plasma Protein Binding (PPB)

Review of QSAR Models and Software Tools for predicting Biokinetic Properties

In the assessment of industrial chemicals, cosmetic ingredients, and active substances in pesticides and biocides, metabolites and degradates are rarely tested for their toxicologcal effects in mammals. In the interests of animal welfare and cost-effectiveness, alternatives to animal testing are needed in the evaluation of these types of chemicals. In this report we review the current status of various types of in silico estimation methods for Absorption, Distribution, Metabolism and Excretion (ADME) properties, which are often important in discriminating between the toxicological profiles of parent compounds and their metabolites/degradation products. The review was performed in a broad sense, with emphasis on QSARs and rule-based approaches and their applicability to estimation of oral bioavailability, human intestinal absorption, blood-brain barrier penetration, plasma protein binding, metabolism and. This revealed a vast and rapidly growing literature and a range of software tools. While it is difficult to give firm conclusions on the applicability of such tools, it is clear that many have been developed with pharmaceutical applications in mind, and as such may not be applicable to other types of chemicals (this would require further research investigation). On the other hand, a range of predictive methodologies have been explored and found promising, so there is merit in pursuing their applicability in the assessment of other types of chemicals and products. Many of the software tools are not transparent in terms of their predictive algorithms or underlying datasets. However, the literature identifies a set of commonly used descriptors that have been found useful in ADME prediction, so further research and model development activities could be based on such studies.JRC.DG.I.6-Systems toxicolog

A Quantitative Structure Activity Relationship for acute oral toxicity of pesticides on rats: Validation, Domain of Application and Prediction

International audienceQuantitative Structure Activity Relationship (QSAR) models are expected to play an important role in the risk assessment of chemicals on humans and the environment. In this study, we developed a validated QSAR model to predict acute oral toxicity of 329 pesticides to rats because a few QSAR models have been devoted to predict the Lethal Dose 50 (LD50) of pesticides on rats. This QSAR model is based on 17 molecular descriptors, and is robust, externally predictive and characterized by a good applicability domain. The best results were obtained with a 17/9/1 Artificial Neural Network model trained with the Quasi Newton back propagation (BFGS) algorithm. The prediction accuracy for the external validation set was estimated by the Q2ext and the Root Mean Square error (RMS) which are equal to 0.948 and 0.201, respectively. 98.6% of external validation set is correctly predicted and the present model proved to be superior to models previously published. Accordingly, the model developed in this study provides excellent predictions and can be used to predict the acute oral toxicity of pesticides, particularly for those that have not been tested as well as new pesticides