10,403 research outputs found
Step-Indexed Relational Reasoning for Countable Nondeterminism
Programming languages with countable nondeterministic choice are
computationally interesting since countable nondeterminism arises when modeling
fairness for concurrent systems. Because countable choice introduces
non-continuous behaviour, it is well-known that developing semantic models for
programming languages with countable nondeterminism is challenging. We present
a step-indexed logical relations model of a higher-order functional programming
language with countable nondeterminism and demonstrate how it can be used to
reason about contextually defined may- and must-equivalence. In earlier
step-indexed models, the indices have been drawn from {\omega}. Here the
step-indexed relations for must-equivalence are indexed over an ordinal greater
than {\omega}
A Step-indexed Semantics of Imperative Objects
Step-indexed semantic interpretations of types were proposed as an
alternative to purely syntactic proofs of type safety using subject reduction.
The types are interpreted as sets of values indexed by the number of
computation steps for which these values are guaranteed to behave like proper
elements of the type. Building on work by Ahmed, Appel and others, we introduce
a step-indexed semantics for the imperative object calculus of Abadi and
Cardelli. Providing a semantic account of this calculus using more
`traditional', domain-theoretic approaches has proved challenging due to the
combination of dynamically allocated objects, higher-order store, and an
expressive type system. Here we show that, using step-indexing, one can
interpret a rich type discipline with object types, subtyping, recursive and
bounded quantified types in the presence of state
Relational Graph Models at Work
We study the relational graph models that constitute a natural subclass of
relational models of lambda-calculus. We prove that among the lambda-theories
induced by such models there exists a minimal one, and that the corresponding
relational graph model is very natural and easy to construct. We then study
relational graph models that are fully abstract, in the sense that they capture
some observational equivalence between lambda-terms. We focus on the two main
observational equivalences in the lambda-calculus, the theory H+ generated by
taking as observables the beta-normal forms, and H* generated by considering as
observables the head normal forms. On the one hand we introduce a notion of
lambda-K\"onig model and prove that a relational graph model is fully abstract
for H+ if and only if it is extensional and lambda-K\"onig. On the other hand
we show that the dual notion of hyperimmune model, together with
extensionality, captures the full abstraction for H*
A generic operational metatheory for algebraic effects
We provide a syntactic analysis of contextual preorder and equivalence for a polymorphic programming language with effects. Our approach applies uniformly across a range of algebraic effects, and incorporates, as instances: errors, input/output, global state, nondeterminism, probabilistic choice, and combinations thereof. Our approach is to extend Plotkin and Powerâs structural operational semantics for algebraic effects (FoSSaCS 2001) with a primitive âbasic preorderâ on ground type computation trees. The basic preorder is used to derive notions of contextual preorder and equivalence on program terms. Under mild assumptions on this relation, we prove fundamental properties of contextual preorder (hence equivalence) including extensionality properties and a characterisation via applicative contexts, and we provide machinery for reasoning about polymorphism using relational parametricity
Parametric polymorphism and operational improvement
Parametricity, in both operational and denotational forms, has long been a useful tool for reasoning about program correctness. However, there is as yet no comparable technique for reasoning about program improvement, that is, when one program uses fewer resources than another. Existing theories of parametricity cannot be used to address this problem as they are agnostic with regard to resource usage. This article addresses this problem by presenting a new operational theory of parametricity that is sensitive to time costs, which can be used to reason about time improvement properties. We demonstrate the applicability of our theory by showing how it can be used to prove that a number of well-known program fusion techniques are time improvements, including fixed point fusion, map fusion and short cut fusion
First steps in synthetic guarded domain theory: step-indexing in the topos of trees
We present the topos S of trees as a model of guarded recursion. We study the
internal dependently-typed higher-order logic of S and show that S models two
modal operators, on predicates and types, which serve as guards in recursive
definitions of terms, predicates, and types. In particular, we show how to
solve recursive type equations involving dependent types. We propose that the
internal logic of S provides the right setting for the synthetic construction
of abstract versions of step-indexed models of programming languages and
program logics. As an example, we show how to construct a model of a
programming language with higher-order store and recursive types entirely
inside the internal logic of S. Moreover, we give an axiomatic categorical
treatment of models of synthetic guarded domain theory and prove that, for any
complete Heyting algebra A with a well-founded basis, the topos of sheaves over
A forms a model of synthetic guarded domain theory, generalizing the results
for S
Relational Parametricity for Computational Effects
According to Strachey, a polymorphic program is parametric if it applies a
uniform algorithm independently of the type instantiations at which it is
applied. The notion of relational parametricity, introduced by Reynolds, is one
possible mathematical formulation of this idea. Relational parametricity
provides a powerful tool for establishing data abstraction properties, proving
equivalences of datatypes, and establishing equalities of programs. Such
properties have been well studied in a pure functional setting. Many programs,
however, exhibit computational effects, and are not accounted for by the
standard theory of relational parametricity. In this paper, we develop a
foundational framework for extending the notion of relational parametricity to
programming languages with effects.Comment: 31 pages, appears in Logical Methods in Computer Scienc
Selective Strictness and Parametricity in Structural Operational Semantics, Inequationally
Parametric polymorphism constrains the behavior of pure functional pro-grams in a way that allows the derivation of interesting theorems about them solely from their types, i.e., virtually for free. The formal background of such âfree theoremsâ is well developed for extensions of the Girard-Reynolds polymorphic lambda calculus by algebraic datatypes and general recursion, provided the resulting calculus is endowed with either a purely strict or a purely nonstrict semantics. But modern functional languages like Clean and Haskell, while using nonstrict evaluation by default, also provide means to enforce strict evaluation of subcomputations at will. The resulting selective strictness gives the advanced programmer explicit control over evaluation order, but is not without semantic consequences: it breaks standard parametricity results. This paper develops an operational semantics for a core calculus supporting all the language features emphasized above. Its main achievement is the characterization of observational approximation with respect to this operational semantics via a carefully constructed logical relation. This establishes the formal basis for new parametricity results, as illustrated by several example applications, including the first complete correctness proof for short cut fusion in the presence of selective strictness. The focus on observational approximation, rather than equivalence, allows a finer-grained analysis of computational behavior in the presence of selective strictness than would be possible with observational equivalence alone
Fifty years of Hoare's Logic
We present a history of Hoare's logic.Comment: 79 pages. To appear in Formal Aspects of Computin
- âŚ