A comprehensive video codec comparison

In this paper, we compare the video codecs AV1 (version 1.0.0-2242 from August 2019), HEVC (HM and x265), AVC (x264), the exploration software JEM which is based on HEVC, and the VVC (successor of HEVC) test model VTM (version 4.0 from February 2019) under two fair and balanced configurations: All Intra for the assessment of intra coding and Maximum Coding Efficiency with all codecs being tuned for their best coding efficiency settings. VTM achieves the highest coding efficiency in both configurations, followed by JEM and AV1. The worst coding efficiency is achieved by x264 and x265, even in the placebo preset for highest coding efficiency. AV1 gained a lot in terms of coding efficiency compared to previous versions and now outperforms HM by 24% BD-Rate gains. VTM gains 5% over AV1 in terms of BD-Rates. By reporting separate numbers for JVET and AOM test sequences, it is ensured that no bias in the test sequences exists. When comparing only intra coding tools, it is observed that the complexity increases exponentially for linearly increasing coding efficiency

Methodology for modeling and comparing video codecs: Hevc, evc, and vvc

none3noOnline videos are the major source of internet traffic, and are about to become the largest majority. Increasing effort is aimed to developing more efficient video codecs. In order to compare existing and novel video codecs, this paper presents a simple but effective methodology to model their performance in terms of Rate Distortion (RD). A linear RD model in the dB variables, Peak Signal-to-Noise Ratio (PSNR) and Bitrate (BR), easily allows us to estimate the difference in PSNR or BR between two sets of encoding conditions. Six sequences from the MPEG test set with the same resolution, encoded at different BR and different Quantization Parameters, were used to create the data set to estimate each RD model. Three codecs (HEVC, EVC, and VVC) were compared with this methodology, after estimating their models. Fitting properties of each model and a performance comparison between the models are finally shown and discussed.openBattista S.; Conti M.; Orcioni S.Battista, S.; Conti, M.; Orcioni, S

Low energy HEVC and VVC video compression hardware

Video compression standards compress a digital video by reducing and removing redundancy in the digital video using computationally complex algorithms. As spatial and temporal resolutions of videos increase, compression efficiencies of video compression algorithms are also increasing. However, increased compression efficiency comes with increased computational complexity. Therefore, it is necessary to reduce computational complexities of video compression algorithms without reducing their visual quality in order to reduce area and energy consumption of their hardware implementations. In this thesis, we propose a novel technique for reducing amount of computations performed by HEVC intra prediction algorithm. We designed low energy, reconfigurable HEVC intra prediction hardware using the proposed technique. We also designed a low energy FPGA implementation of HEVC intra prediction algorithm using the proposed technique and DSP blocks. We propose a reconfigurable VVC intra prediction hardware architecture. We also propose an efficient VVC intra prediction hardware architecture using DSP blocks. We designed low energy VVC fractional interpolation hardware. We propose a novel approximate absolute difference technique. We designed low energy approximate absolute difference hardware using the proposed technique. We propose a novel approximate constant multiplication technique. We designed approximate constant multiplication hardware using the proposed technique. We quantified computation reductions achieved by the proposed techniques and video quality loss caused by the proposed approximation techniques. The proposed approximate absolute difference technique and approximate constant multiplication technique cause very small PSNR loss. The other proposed techniques cause no PSNR loss. We implemented the proposed hardware architectures in Verilog HDL. We mapped the Verilog RTL codes to Xilinx Virtex 6 or Xilinx Virtex 7 FPGAs and estimated their power consumptions using Xilinx XPower Analyzer tool. The proposed techniques significantly reduced power and energy consumptions of these FPGA implementation

Deep perceptual preprocessing for video coding

We introduce the concept of rate-aware deep perceptual preprocessing (DPP) for video encoding. DPP makes a single pass over each input frame in order to enhance its visual quality when the video is to be compressed with any codec at any bitrate. The resulting bitstreams can be decoded and displayed at the client side without any post-processing component. DPP comprises a convolutional neural network that is trained via a composite set of loss functions that incorporates: (i) a perceptual loss based on a trained no-reference image quality assessment model, (ii) a reference-based fidelity loss expressing L1 and structural similarity aspects, (iii) a motion-based rate loss via block-based transform, quantization and entropy estimates that converts the essential components of standard hybrid video encoder designs into a trainable framework. Extensive testing using multiple quality metrics and AVC, AV1 and VVC encoders shows that DPP+encoder reduces, on average, the bitrate of the corresponding encoder by 11%. This marks the first time a server-side neural processing component achieves such savings over the state-of-the-art in video coding

Toward Generalized Psychovisual Preprocessing For Video Encoding

Deep perceptual preprocessing has recently emerged as a new way to enable further bitrate savings across several generations of video encoders without breaking standards or requiring any changes in client devices. In this article, we lay the foundation for a generalized psychovisual preprocessing framework for video encoding and describe one of its promising instantiations that is practically deployable for video-on-demand, live, gaming, and user-generated content (UGC). Results using state-of-the-art advanced video coding (AVC), high efficiency video coding (HEVC), and versatile video coding (VVC) encoders show that average bitrate [Bjontegaard delta-rate (BD-rate)] gains of 11%-17% are obtained over three state-of-the-art reference-based quality metrics [Netflix video multi-method assessment fusion (VMAF), structural similarity index (SSIM), and Apple advanced video quality tool (AVQT)], as well as the recently proposed nonreference International Telecommunication Union-Telecommunication?(ITU-T) P.1204 metric. The proposed framework on CPU is shown to be twice faster than × 264 medium-preset encoding. On GPU hardware, our approach achieves 714 frames/sec for 1080p video (below 2 ms/frame), thereby enabling its use in very-low-latency live video or game streaming applications

Machine Learning based Efficient QT-MTT Partitioning Scheme for VVC Intra Encoders

The next-generation Versatile Video Coding (VVC) standard introduces a new Multi-Type Tree (MTT) block partitioning structure that supports Binary-Tree (BT) and Ternary-Tree (TT) splits in both vertical and horizontal directions. This new approach leads to five possible splits at each block depth and thereby improves the coding efficiency of VVC over that of the preceding High Efficiency Video Coding (HEVC) standard, which only supports Quad-Tree (QT) partitioning with a single split per block depth. However, MTT also has brought a considerable impact on encoder computational complexity. In this paper, a two-stage learning-based technique is proposed to tackle the complexity overhead of MTT in VVC intra encoders. In our scheme, the input block is first processed by a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) to predict its spatial features through a vector of probabilities describing the partition at each 4x4 edge. Subsequently, a Decision Tree (DT) model leverages this vector of spatial features to predict the most likely splits at each block. Finally, based on this prediction, only the N most likely splits are processed by the Rate-Distortion (RD) process of the encoder. In order to train our CNN and DT models on a wide range of image contents, we also propose a public VVC frame partitioning dataset based on existing image dataset encoded with the VVC reference software encoder. Our proposal relying on the top-3 configuration reaches 46.6% complexity reduction for a negligible bitrate increase of 0.86%. A top-2 configuration enables a higher complexity reduction of 69.8% for 2.57% bitrate loss. These results emphasis a better trade-off between VTM intra coding efficiency and complexity reduction compared to the state-of-the-art solutions

Deep Video Precoding

Several groups worldwide are currently investigating how deep learning may advance the state-of-the-art in image and video coding. An open question is how to make deep neural networks work in conjunction with existing (and upcoming) video codecs, such as MPEG H.264/AVC, H.265/HEVC, VVC, Google VP9 and AOMedia AV1, AV2, as well as existing container and transport formats, without imposing any changes at the client side. Such compatibility is a crucial aspect when it comes to practical deployment, especially when considering the fact that the video content industry and hardware manufacturers are expected to remain committed to supporting these standards for the foreseeable future. We propose to use deep neural networks as precoders for current and future video codecs and adaptive video streaming systems. In our current design, the core precoding component comprises a cascaded structure of downscaling neural networks that operates during video encoding, prior to transmission. This is coupled with a precoding mode selection algorithm for each independently-decodable stream segment, which adjusts the downscaling factor according to scene characteristics, the utilized encoder, and the desired bitrate and encoding configuration. Our framework is compatible with all current and future codec and transport standards, as our deep precoding network structure is trained in conjunction with linear upscaling filters (e.g., the bilinear filter), which are supported by all web video players. Extensive evaluation on FHD (1080p) and UHD (2160p) content and with widely-used H.264/AVC, H.265/HEVC and VP9 encoders, as well as a preliminary evaluation with the current test model of VVC (v.6.2rc1), shows that coupling such standards with the proposed deep video precoding allows for 8% to 52% rate reduction under encoding configurations and bitrates suitable for video-on-demand adaptive streaming systems. The use of precoding can also lead to encoding complexity reduction, which is essential for cost-effective cloud deployment of complex encoders like H.265/HEVC, VP9 and VVC, especially when considering the prominence of high-resolution adaptive video streaming