Confidence Score Based Speaker Adaptation of Conformer Speech Recognition Systems

Speaker adaptation techniques provide a powerful solution to customise automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems for individual users. Practical application of unsupervised model-based speaker adaptation techniques to data intensive end-to-end ASR systems is hindered by the scarcity of speaker-level data and performance sensitivity to transcription errors. To address these issues, a set of compact and data efficient speaker-dependent (SD) parameter representations are used to facilitate both speaker adaptive training and test-time unsupervised speaker adaptation of state-of-the-art Conformer ASR systems. The sensitivity to supervision quality is reduced using a confidence score-based selection of the less erroneous subset of speaker-level adaptation data. Two lightweight confidence score estimation modules are proposed to produce more reliable confidence scores. The data sparsity issue, which is exacerbated by data selection, is addressed by modelling the SD parameter uncertainty using Bayesian learning. Experiments on the benchmark 300-hour Switchboard and the 233-hour AMI datasets suggest that the proposed confidence score-based adaptation schemes consistently outperformed the baseline speaker-independent (SI) Conformer model and conventional non-Bayesian, point estimate-based adaptation using no speaker data selection. Similar consistent performance improvements were retained after external Transformer and LSTM language model rescoring. In particular, on the 300-hour Switchboard corpus, statistically significant WER reductions of 1.0%, 1.3%, and 1.4% absolute (9.5%, 10.9%, and 11.3% relative) were obtained over the baseline SI Conformer on the NIST Hub5'00, RT02, and RT03 evaluation sets respectively. Similar WER reductions of 2.7% and 3.3% absolute (8.9% and 10.2% relative) were also obtained on the AMI development and evaluation sets.Comment: IEEE/ACM Transactions on Audio, Speech, and Language Processin

Adaptation Algorithms for Neural Network-Based Speech Recognition: An Overview

We present a structured overview of adaptation algorithms for neural network-based speech recognition, considering both hybrid hidden Markov model / neural network systems and end-to-end neural network systems, with a focus on speaker adaptation, domain adaptation, and accent adaptation. The overview characterizes adaptation algorithms as based on embeddings, model parameter adaptation, or data augmentation. We present a meta-analysis of the performance of speech recognition adaptation algorithms, based on relative error rate reductions as reported in the literature.Comment: Submitted to IEEE Open Journal of Signal Processing. 30 pages, 27 figure

On adaptive decision rules and decision parameter adaptation for automatic speech recognition

Recent advances in automatic speech recognition are accomplished by designing a plug-in maximum a posteriori decision rule such that the forms of the acoustic and language model distributions are specified and the parameters of the assumed distributions are estimated from a collection of speech and language training corpora. Maximum-likelihood point estimation is by far the most prevailing training method. However, due to the problems of unknown speech distributions, sparse training data, high spectral and temporal variabilities in speech, and possible mismatch between training and testing conditions, a dynamic training strategy is needed. To cope with the changing speakers and speaking conditions in real operational conditions for high-performance speech recognition, such paradigms incorporate a small amount of speaker and environment specific adaptation data into the training process. Bayesian adaptive learning is an optimal way to combine prior knowledge in an existing collection of general models with a new set of condition-specific adaptation data. In this paper, the mathematical framework for Bayesian adaptation of acoustic and language model parameters is first described. Maximum a posteriori point estimation is then developed for hidden Markov models and a number of useful parameters densities commonly used in automatic speech recognition and natural language processing.published_or_final_versio

Acoustic variability and automatic recognition of children’s speech

International audienc

Confidence Scoring and Speaker Adaptation in Mobile Automatic Speech Recognition Applications

Generally, the user group of a language is remarkably diverse in terms of speaker-specific characteristics such as dialect and speaking style. Hence, quality of spoken content varies notably from one individual to another. This diversity causes problems for Automatic Speech Recognition systems. An Automatic Speech Recognition system should be able to assess the hypothesised results. This can be done by evaluating a confidence measure on the recognition results and comparing the resulting measure to a specified threshold. This threshold value, referred to as confidence score, informs how reliable a particular recognition result is for the given speech. A system should perform optimally irrespective of input speaker characteristics. However, most systems are inflexible and non-adaptive and thus, speaker adaptability can be improved. For achieving these purposes, a solid criterion is required to evaluate the quality of spoken content and the system should be made robust and adaptive towards new speakers as well. This thesis implements a confidence score using posterior probabilities to examine the quality of the output, based on the speech data and corpora provided by Devoca Oy. Furthermore, speaker adaptation algorithms: Maximum Likelihood Linear Regression and Maximum a Posteriori are applied on a GMM-HMM system and their results are compared. Experiments show that Maximum a Posteriori adaptation brings 2% to 25% improvement in word error rates of semi-continuous model and is recommended for use in the commercial product. The results of other methods are also reported. In addition, word graph is suggested as the method for obtaining posterior probabilities. Since it guarantees no such improvement in the results, the confidence score is proposed as an optional feature for the system

Acoustic model selection for recognition of regional accented speech

Accent is cited as an issue for speech recognition systems. Our experiments showed that the ASR word error rate is up to seven times greater for accented speech compared with standard British English. The main objective of this research is to develop Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) techniques that are robust to accent variation. We applied different acoustic modelling techniques to compensate for the effects of regional accents on the ASR performance. For conventional GMM-HMM based ASR systems, we showed that using a small amount of data from a test speaker to choose an accent dependent model using an accent identification system, or building a model using the data from N neighbouring speakers in AID space, will result in superior performance compared to that obtained with unsupervised or supervised speaker adaptation. In addition we showed that using a DNN-HMM rather than a GMM-HMM based acoustic model would improve the recognition accuracy considerably. Even if we apply two stages of accent followed by speaker adaptation to the GMM-HMM baseline system, the GMM-HMM based system will not outperform the baseline DNN-HMM based system. For more contemporary DNN-HMM based ASR systems we investigated how adding different types of accented data to the training set can provide better recognition accuracy on accented speech. Finally, we proposed a new approach for visualisation of the AID feature space. This is helpful in analysing the AID recognition accuracies and analysing AID confusion matrices

Automatic Speech Recognition for Low-resource Languages and Accents Using Multilingual and Crosslingual Information

This thesis explores methods to rapidly bootstrap automatic speech recognition systems for languages, which lack resources for speech and language processing. We focus on finding approaches which allow using data from multiple languages to improve the performance for those languages on different levels, such as feature extraction, acoustic modeling and language modeling. Under application aspects, this thesis also includes research work on non-native and Code-Switching speech

A Study of the Automatic Speech Recognition Process and Speaker Adaptation

This thesis considers the entire automated speech recognition process and presents a standardised approach to LVCSR experimentation with HMMs. It also discusses various approaches to speaker adaptation such as MLLR and multiscale, and presents experimental results for cross­-task speaker adaptation. An analysis of training parameters and data sufficiency for reasonable system performance estimates are also included. It is found that Maximum Likelihood Linear Regression (MLLR) supervised adaptation can result in 6% reduction (absolute) in word error rate given only one minute of adaptation data, as compared with an unadapted model set trained on a different task. The unadapted system performed at 24% WER and the adapted system at 18% WER. This is achieved with only 4 to 7 adaptation classes per speaker, as generated from a regression tree

Automatic Speech Recognition for ageing voices

With ageing, human voices undergo several changes which are typically characterised by increased hoarseness, breathiness, changes in articulatory patterns and slower speaking rate. The focus of this thesis is to understand the impact of ageing on Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) performance and improve the ASR accuracies for older voices. Baseline results on three corpora indicate that the word error rates (WER) for older adults are significantly higher than those of younger adults and the decrease in accuracies is higher for males speakers as compared to females. Acoustic parameters such as jitter and shimmer that measure glottal source disfluencies were found to be significantly higher for older adults. However, the hypothesis that these changes explain the differences in WER for the two age groups is proven incorrect. Experiments with artificial introduction of glottal source disfluencies in speech from younger adults do not display a significant impact on WERs. Changes in fundamental frequency observed quite often in older voices has a marginal impact on ASR accuracies. Analysis of phoneme errors between younger and older speakers shows a pattern of certain phonemes especially lower vowels getting more affected with ageing. These changes however are seen to vary across speakers. Another factor that is strongly associated with ageing voices is a decrease in the rate of speech. Experiments to analyse the impact of slower speaking rate on ASR accuracies indicate that the insertion errors increase while decoding slower speech with models trained on relatively faster speech. We then propose a way to characterise speakers in acoustic space based on speaker adaptation transforms and observe that speakers (especially males) can be segregated with reasonable accuracies based on age. Inspired by this, we look at supervised hierarchical acoustic models based on gender and age. Significant improvements in word accuracies are achieved over the baseline results with such models. The idea is then extended to construct unsupervised hierarchical models which also outperform the baseline models by a good margin. Finally, we hypothesize that the ASR accuracies can be improved by augmenting the adaptation data with speech from acoustically closest speakers. A strategy to select the augmentation speakers is proposed. Experimental results on two corpora indicate that the hypothesis holds true only when the amount of available adaptation is limited to a few seconds. The efficacy of such a speaker selection strategy is analysed for both younger and older adults

Stacked transformations for foreign accented speech recognition

Nowadays, large vocabulary speech recognizers exist that are performing reasonably well for specific conditions and environments. When the conditions change however, performance degrades quickly. For example, when the person to be recognized has a foreign accent the conditions could mismatch with the model, resulting in high error rates. The problem in recognizing foreign accented speech is the lack of sufficient training data. If enough data would be available of the same accent, from numerous different speakers, a well performing accented speech model could be built. Besides the lack of speech data, there are more problems with training a complete new model. It costs a lot of computational resources and storage space to train a new model. If speakers with different accents must be recognized, these costs explode as every accent needs retraining. A common solution for preventing retraining is to adapt (transform) an existing model, such that it better matches the recognition conditions. In this thesis multiple different adaptation transformations are considered. Speaker Transformations are using speech data from the target speaker, Accent Transformations use speech data from different speakers, who have the same accent as the speech that needs to be recognized. Neighbour Transformations are estimated with speech from different speakers that are automatically determined to be similar to the target speaker. Novelty in this work is the stack wise combination of these adaptations. Instead of using a single transformation, multiple transformations are 'stacked together'. Because all adaptations except the speaker specific adaptation can be precomputed, no extra computational costs at recognition time occur compared to normal speaker adaptation and the adaptations that can be precomputed are much more refined as they can use more and better adaptation data. In addition, they need only a very small amount storage space, compared to a retrained model. The effect of Stacked Transformations is that the models have a better fit for the recognition utterances. When compared to no adaptation, improvements up to 30% in Word Error Rate can be achieved. In adaptation with a small number (5) of sentences, improvements up to 15% are gained