The complexity of reasoning with relative directions

© 2014 The Authors and IOS Press. Whether reasoning with relative directions can be performed in NP has been an open problem in qualitative spatial reasoning. Efficient reasoning with relative directions is essential, for example, in rule-compliant agent navigation. In this paper, we prove that reasoning with relative directions is ∃ℝ-complete. As a consequence, reasoning with relative directions is not in NP, unless NP=∃ℝ

Qualitative Process Analysis : Theoretical Requirements and Practical Implementation in Naval Domain

Understanding complex behaviours is an essential component of everyday life, integrated into daily routines as well as specialised research. To handle the increasing amount of data available from (logistic) dynamic scenarios, analysis of the behaviour of agents in a given environment is becoming more automated and thus requires reliable new analytical methods. This thesis seeks to improve analysis of observed data in dynamic scenarios by developing a new model for transforming sparse behavioural observations into realistic explanations of agent behaviours, with the goal of testing that model in a real-world maritime navigation scenario

Qualitative Spatial and Temporal Reasoning based on And/Or Linear Programming An approach to partially grounded qualitative spatial reasoning

Acting intelligently in dynamic environments involves anticipating surrounding processes, for example to foresee a dangerous situation or acceptable social behavior. Knowledge about spatial configurations and how they develop over time enables intelligent robots to safely navigate by reasoning about possible actions. The seamless connection of high-level deliberative processes to perception and action selection remains a challenge though. Moreover, an integration should allow the robot to build awareness of these processes as in reality there will be misunderstandings a robot should be able to respond to. My aim is to verify that actions selected by the robot do not violate navigation or safety regulations and thereby endanger the robot or others. Navigation rules specified qualitatively allow an autonomous agent to consistently combine all rules applicable in a context. Within this thesis, I develop a formal, symbolic representation of right-of-way-rules based on a qualitative spatial representation. This cumulative dissertation consists of 5 peer-reviewed papers and 1 manuscript under review. The contribution of this thesis is an approach to represent navigation patterns based on qualitative spatio-temporal representation and the development of corresponding effective sound reasoning techniques. The approach is based on a spatial logic in the sense of Aiello, Pratt-Hartmann, and van Benthem. This logic has clear spatial and temporal semantics and I demonstrate how it allows various navigation rules and social conventions to be represented. I demonstrate the applicability of the developed method in three different areas, an autonomous robotic system in an industrial setting, an autonomous sailing boat, and a robot that should act politely by adhering to social conventions. In all three settings, the navigation behavior is specified by logic formulas. Temporal reasoning is performed via model checking. An important aspect is that a logic symbol, such as \emph{turn left}, comprises a family of movement behaviors rather than a single pre-specified movement command. This enables to incorporate the current spatial context, the possible changing kinematics of the robotic system, and so on without changing a single formula. Additionally, I show that the developed approach can be integrated into various robotic software architectures. Further, an answer to three long standing questions in the field of qualitative spatial reasoning is presented. Using generalized linear programming as a unifying basis for reasoning, one can jointly reason about relations from different qualitative calculi. Also, concrete entities (fixed points, regions fixed in shape and/or position, etc.) can be mixed with free variables. In addition, a realization of qualitative spatial description can be calculated, i.e., a specific instance/example. All three features are important for applications but cannot be handled by other techniques. I advocate the use of And/Or trees to facilitate efficient reasoning and I show the feasibility of my approach. Last but not least, I investigate a fourth question, how to integrate And/Or trees with linear temporal logic, to enable spatio-temporal reasoning

Training of Crisis Mappers and Map Production from Multi-sensor Data: Vernazza Case Study (Cinque Terre National Park, Italy)

This aim of paper is to presents the development of a multidisciplinary project carried out by the cooperation between Politecnico di Torino and ITHACA (Information Technology for Humanitarian Assistance, Cooperation and Action). The goal of the project was the training in geospatial data acquiring and processing for students attending Architecture and Engineering Courses, in order to start up a team of "volunteer mappers". Indeed, the project is aimed to document the environmental and built heritage subject to disaster; the purpose is to improve the capabilities of the actors involved in the activities connected in geospatial data collection, integration and sharing. The proposed area for testing the training activities is the Cinque Terre National Park, registered in the World Heritage List since 1997. The area was affected by flood on the 25th of October 2011. According to other international experiences, the group is expected to be active after emergencies in order to upgrade maps, using data acquired by typical geomatic methods and techniques such as terrestrial and aerial Lidar, close-range and aerial photogrammetry, topographic and GNSS instruments etc.; or by non conventional systems and instruments such us UAV, mobile mapping etc. The ultimate goal is to implement a WebGIS platform to share all the data collected with local authorities and the Civil Protectio

Sailing:Cognition, Action, Communication

How do humans perceive and think about space, and how can this be represented adequately? For everyday activities such as locating objects or places, route planning, and the like, many insights have been gained over the past few decades, feeding into theories of spatial cognition and frameworks for spatial information science. In this paper, we explore sailing as a more specialized domain that has not yet been considered in this way, but has a lot to offer precisely because of its peculiarities. Sailing involves ways of thinking about space that are not normally required (or even acquired) in everyday life. Movement in this domain is based on a combination of external forces and internal (human) intentions that impose various kinds of directionality, affecting local action as well as global planning. Sailing terminology is spatial to a high extent, and involves a range of concepts that have received little attention in the spatial cognition community. We explore the area by focusing on the core features of cognition, action, and communication, and suggest a range of promising future areas of research in this domain as a showcase of the fascinating flexibility of human spatial cognition

Robust Reasoning for Autonomous Cyber-Physical Systems in Dynamic Environments

Autonomous cyber-physical systems, CPS, in dynamic environments must work impeccably. The cyber-physical systems must handle tasks consistently and trustworthily, i.e., with a robust behavior. Robust systems, in general, require making valid and solid decisions using one or a combination of robust reasoning strategies, algorithms, and robustness analysis. However, in dynamic environments, data can be incomplete, skewed, contradictory, and redundant impacting the reasoning. Basing decisions on these data can lead to inconsistent, irrational, and unreasonable cyber-physical systems' movements, adversely impacting the system’s reliability and integrity. This paper presents the assessment of robust reasoning for autonomous cyber-physical systems in dynamic environments. In this work, robust reasoning is considered as 1) the capability of drawing conclusions with available data by applying classical and non-classical reasoning strategies and algorithms and 2) act and react robustly and safely in dynamic environments by employing robustness analysis to provide options on possible actions and evaluate alternative decisions. The result of the research shows that different common existing strategies, algorithms and analyses can be provided together with a comparison of their applicabilities, benefits, and drawbacks in the context of cyber-physical systems operating in dynamically changing environments. The conclusion is that robust reasoning in cyber-physical systems can handle dynamic environments. Moreover, combining these strategies and algorithms with robustness analysis can support achieving robust behavior in autonomous cyber-physical systems while operating in dynamically changing environments

Multi-agent geo-simulation of crowds and control forces in conflict situations : models, application and analysis

Peu de modèles et de simulations qui décrivent les comportements de foule en situations de conflit impliquant des forces de l’ordre et des armes non-létales (NLW) existent. Ce mémoire présente des modèles d’agents de la foule et des forces de l’ordre ainsi que des NLWs dans des situations de conflit. Des groupes ainsi que leurs interactions et actions collectives sont explicitement modélisés, ce qui repousse les approches de simulation de foule existantes. Les agents sont caractérisés par des profils d’appréciation de l’agressivité et ils peuvent changer leurs comportements en relation avec la Théorie de l’identité sociale. Un logiciel a été développé et les modèles ont été calibrés avec des scénarios réalistes. Il a démontré la faisabilité technique de modèles sociaux aussi complexes pour des foules de centaines d’agents, en plus de générer des données pour évaluer l’efficacité des techniques d’intervention.Few models and simulations that describe crowd behaviour in conflict situations involving control forces and non-lethal weapons (NLW) exist. This thesis presents models for crowd agents, control forces, and NLWs in crowd control situations. Groups as well as their interactions and collective actions are explicitly modelled, which pushes further currently existing crowd simulation approaches. Agents are characterized by appreciation of aggressiveness profiles and they can change their behaviours in relation with the Social Identity theory. A software application was developed and the models were calibrated with realistic scenarios. It demonstrated the technical feasibility of such complex social models for crowds of hundreds of agents, as well generating data to assess the efficiency of intervention techniques

A general cognitive framework for context-aware systems: extensions and applications for high level information fusion approaches

Mención Internacional en el título de doctorContext-aware systems aims at the development of computational systems that process data acquired from different datasources and adapt their behaviour in order to provide the 'right' information, at the 'right' time, in the 'right' place, in the 'right' way to the 'right' person (Fischer, 2012). Traditionally computational research has tried to answer these needs by means of low-level algorithms. In the last years the combination of numeric and symbolic approaches has offered the opportunity to create systems to deal with these issues. However, although the performance of algorithms and the quality of the data directly provided by computers and devices has quickly improved, symbolic models used to represent the resulting knowledge have not yet been adapted to smart environments. This lack of representation does not allow to take advantage of the semantic quality of the information provided by new sensors. This dissertation proposes a set of extensions and applications focused on a cognitive framework for the implementation of context-aware systems based on a general model inspired by the Information Fusion paradigm. This model is stepped in several abstraction levels from low-level raw data to high level scene interpretation whose structure is determined by a set of ontologies. Each ontology level provides a skeleton that includes general concepts and relations to describe entities and their connections. This structure has been designed to promote extensibility and modularity, and might be refined to apply this model in specific domains. This framework combines a priori context knowledge represented with ontologies with real data coming from sensors to support logic-based high-level interpretation of the current situation and to automatically generate feedback recommendations to adjust data acquisition procedures. This work advocates for the introduction of general purpose cognitive layers in order to obtain a closer representation to the human cognition, generate additional knowledge and improve the high-level interpretation. Extensibility and adaptability of the basic ontology levels is demonstrated with the introduction of these traverse semantic layers which are able to be present and represent information at several granularity levels of knowledge using a common formalism. Context-based system must be able to reason about uncertainty. However the reasoning associated to ontologies has been limited to classical description logic mechanisms. This research also tackle the problem of reasoning under uncertainty circumstances through a logic-based paradigm for abductive reasoning: the Belief-Argumentation System. The main contribution of this dissertation is the adaptation of the general architecture and the theoretical proposals to several context-aware application areas such as Ambient Intelligence, Social Signal Processing and surveillance systems. The implementation of prototypes and examples for these areas are explained along this dissertation to progressively illustrate the improvements and extensions in the framework. To initially depict the general model, its components and the basic reasoning mechanisms a video-based Ambient Intelligence application is presented. The advantages and features of the framework extensions through traverse cognitive layers are demonstrated in a Social Signal Processing case for the elaboration of automatic market researches. Finally, the functioning of the system under uncertainty circumstances is illustrated with several examples to support decision makers in the detection of potential threats in common harbor scenarios.Programa Oficial de Doctorado en Ciencia y Tecnología InformáticaPresidente: José Manuel Molina López.- Secretario: Ángel Arroyo.- Vocal: Nayat Sánchez P