Radiation Hardened by Design Methodologies for Soft-Error Mitigated Digital Architectures

abstract: Digital architectures for data encryption, processing, clock synthesis, data transfer, etc. are susceptible to radiation induced soft errors due to charge collection in complementary metal oxide semiconductor (CMOS) integrated circuits (ICs). Radiation hardening by design (RHBD) techniques such as double modular redundancy (DMR) and triple modular redundancy (TMR) are used for error detection and correction respectively in such architectures. Multiple node charge collection (MNCC) causes domain crossing errors (DCE) which can render the redundancy ineffectual. This dissertation describes techniques to ensure DCE mitigation with statistical confidence for various designs. Both sequential and combinatorial logic are separated using these custom and computer aided design (CAD) methodologies. Radiation vulnerability and design overhead are studied on VLSI sub-systems including an advanced encryption standard (AES) which is DCE mitigated using module level coarse separation on a 90-nm process with 99.999% DCE mitigation. A radiation hardened microprocessor (HERMES2) is implemented in both 90-nm and 55-nm technologies with an interleaved separation methodology with 99.99% DCE mitigation while achieving 4.9% increased cell density, 28.5 % reduced routing and 5.6% reduced power dissipation over the module fences implementation. A DMR register-file (RF) is implemented in 55 nm process and used in the HERMES2 microprocessor. The RF array custom design and the decoders APR designed are explored with a focus on design cycle time. Quality of results (QOR) is studied from power, performance, area and reliability (PPAR) perspective to ascertain the improvement over other design techniques. A radiation hardened all-digital multiplying pulsed digital delay line (DDL) is designed for double data rate (DDR2/3) applications for data eye centering during high speed off-chip data transfer. The effect of noise, radiation particle strikes and statistical variation on the designed DDL are studied in detail. The design achieves the best in class 22.4 ps peak-to-peak jitter, 100-850 MHz range at 14 pJ/cycle energy consumption. Vulnerability of the non-hardened design is characterized and portions of the redundant DDL are separated in custom and auto-place and route (APR). Thus, a range of designs for mission critical applications are implemented using methodologies proposed in this work and their potential PPAR benefits explored in detail.Dissertation/ThesisDoctoral Dissertation Electrical Engineering 201

Clock Tree Power Optimization of Three Dimensional VLSI System with Network

Abstract:The proposed method is based on minimum-cost maximum-flow formulation to globally determine the tree topology, which maintains load balance and considers the wirelength between pulse generators and pulsed latches. Experimental results indicate that the proposed migration approach can improve the power consumption by 12% and 13% with 7% and 70% skew improvements on average compared with the most recent paper on the industrial circuits and ISPD-2010 benchmarks, respectively. Minimizing the size of a clock tree is known as an effective approach to reduce power dissipation in modern circuit designs. However, most existing power-aware clock-tree minimization algorithms optimize power on the basis of flip-flops alone, which may result in limited power savings. To achieve a power and timing tradeoff, this paper investigates the pulsed-latch utilization in a clock tree for further power savings. This is the first paper to propose a migration approach to efficiently construct a clock tree with both pulsed-latches and flip-flops

Redundant Skewed Clocking of Pulse-Clocked Latches for Low Power Soft-Error Mitigation

abstract: An integrated methodology combining redundant clock tree synthesis and pulse clocked latches mitigates both single event upsets (SEU) and single event transients (SET) with reduced power consumption. This methodology helps to change the hardness of the design on the fly. This approach, with minimal additional overhead circuitry, has the ability to work in three different modes of operation depending on the speed, hardness and power consumption required by design. This was designed on 90nm low-standby power (LSP) process and utilized commercial CAD tools for testing. Spatial separation of critical nodes in the physical design of this approach mitigates multi-node charge collection (MNCC) upsets. An advanced encryption system implemented with the proposed design, compared to a previous design with non-redundant clock trees and local delay generation. The proposed approach reduces energy per operation up to 18% over an improved version of the prior approach, with negligible area impact. It can save up to 2/3rd of the power consumption and reach maximum possible frequency, when used in non-redundant mode of operation.Dissertation/ThesisMasters Thesis Electrical Engineering 201

비용 효율적인 클럭 및 파워 게이팅 설계 방법론

학위논문(박사)--서울대학교 대학원 :공과대학 전기·정보공학부,2020. 2. 김태환.저전력 설계는 최신 시스템-온-칩 (SoCs) 설계에서 매우 중요한 요소 중의 하나이다. 본 논문에서는 동적 및 정적 전력 소비를 감소시키기 위한 저전력 설계 방법론에 대해 논한다. 구체적으로 비용 효율적인 저전력 설계를 위하여 두 가지 새로운 기술을 제안한다. 우선 본 논문에서는 동적 전력 소비를 줄일 수 있는 새로운 클럭 게이팅 방법을 제안한다. 기존 플립-플랍 입력 데이터 토글 기반 클럭 게이팅은 가장 널리 사용되는 클럭 게이팅 기법 중의 하나이다. 하지만 이 방법은 더 많은 플립-플랍에 대해 적용할수록 클럭 게이팅에 필요한 부가 회로가 급격히 증가한다는 근본적인 한계를 지니고 있다. 이러한 한계를 극복하기 위하여 본 논문에서는 다음과 같이 새로운 클럭 게이팅 방법을 제안한다. 첫 번째로 기존 입력 데이터 토글 기반 클럭 게이팅 방법에 필요한 회로 자원을 분석하여 해당 방법의 비효율성을 보이고, 기존 방법에서 사용되는 입력 데이터 토글 검출에 필수적이지만 고비용의 XOR 게이트를 완벽히 제거한 플립-플랍 상태 기반 클럭 게이팅'이라는 새로운 클럭 게이팅 방법을 제안한다. 두 번째로 제안된 XOR 게이트가 필요 없는 클럭 게이팅 방법을 위한 부가 회로를 제시하며, 다양한 타이밍 분석을 통하여 해당 회로가 안정적으로 적용될 수 있음을 보인다. 세 번째로 회로의 플립-플랍 상태 프로파일에 기반하여, 제안된 클럭 게이팅 기법을 기존 클럭 게이팅 기법과 완벽하게 통합할 수 있는 클럭 게이팅 방법론을 제안한다. 여러 벤치마크 회로에 대한 실험 결과는 기존 입력 데이터 토글 기반 클럭 게이팅 방법이 전력 소비 절감 기회를 놓치는 반면 본 논문에서 제안된 방법은 모든 타이밍 제약 조건을 만족하면서 전력 소비 감소에 매우 효과적임을 보여준다. 다음으로 정적 전력 소비를 줄이기 위한 방안으로, 본 논문에서는 기존 파워 게이트 회로의 상태 보존용 저장 공간 할당 방법들이 지니고 있는 두 가지 중요한 한계들을 해결할 수 있는 방법을 제안한다. 중요한 한계들이란 첫 번째로 다중-비트 상태 보존 플립-플랍의 무분별한 사용으로 인한 긴 웨이크업 지연 시간이며, 두 번째로 멀티플렉서 되먹임 루프가 있는 상태 보존 플립-플랍의 최적화 불가능성이다. 기존 방법들에서는 상태 보존을 위한 저장 공간을 최소화하기 위해 긴 웨이크업 지연 시간이 필수적이었다. 그리고 되먹임 루프가 있는 플립-플랍은 최적화할 수 없는 대상으로 다루어졌다. 그러나 일반적으로 하드웨어 기술 언어(HDL)로부터 생성되는 되먹임 루프를 지닌 플립-플랍은 무시할 수 있을 정도로 적은 양이 아니다. 첫 번째 한계를 해결하기 위한 방법으로 본 논문에서는 최대 2 비트의 다중-비트 상태 보존 플립-플랍을 사용하여 웨이크업 지연 시간을 두 클럭 사이클로 제한하면서도 상태 보존을 위한 저장 공간을 효율적으로 절약할 수 있음을 보인다. 그리고 두 번째 한계를 극복하기 위해서 되먹임 루프를 지닌 플립-플랍이 포함된 두 플립-플랍 쌍의 상태를 복원할 수 있는 2단 상태 보존 제어 방안을 제안한다. 또한 주어진 회로에서 충돌없이 동시에 존재할 수 있는 플립-플랍 쌍을 최대로 추출하기 위해 독립 집합 문제(independent set problem)기반의 연산법도 제안한다. 벤치마크 회로에 대한 실험 결과는 본 논문에서 제안된 방법이 웨이크업 지연 시간을 두 클럭 사이클로 제한하면서도 상태 보존에 필요한 저장 공간과 파워를 감소시키는데 매우 효과적임을 보여준다.Low power design is of great importance in modern system-on-chips (SoCs). This dissertation studies on low power design methodologies for saving dynamic and static power consumption. Precisely, we unveil two novel techniques of cost effective low power design. Firstly, we propose a novel clock gating method for reducing the dynamic power consumption. Flip-flop's input data toggling based clock gating is one of the most commonly used clock gating methods, in which one critical and inherent limitation is the sharp increase of gating logic as more flip-flops are involved in gating. In this dissertation, we propose a new clock gating method to overcome this limitation. Specifically, (1) we analyze the resources of gating logic in the input data toggling based clock gating, from which an ineffectiveness in resource utilization is observed and we propose a new clock gating technique called flip-flop state driven clock gating which completely eliminates the essential and expensive component of XOR gates for detecting input toggling of flip-flops; (2) we provide the supporting logic circuitry of our proposed XOR-free clock gating, confirming its safe applicability through a comprehensive timing analysis; (3) we propose, based on the flip-flops' state profile, a clock gating methodology that seamlessly combines our flip-flop state based clock gating with the toggling based clock gating. Through experiments with benchmark circuits, it is confirmed that our clock gating method is very effective in reducing power, which otherwise the toggling based clock gating shall miss the power saving opportunity, while meeting all timing constraints. Secondly, for reducing the static power consumption, we solve two critical limitations of the conventional approaches to the allocation of state retention storage for power gated circuits. Those are (1) the long wakeup delay caused by the senseless use of multi-bit retention flip-flops (MBRFFs) and (2) the inability to optimize retention flip-flops for the flip-flops with mux-feedback loop. It should be noted that the conventional approaches have regarded the long wakeup delay as an inevitable consequence of maximizing the reduction of total storage size for state retention while they have treated the flip-flops with mux-feedback loop (called self-loop flip-flop) as nonoptimizable component, but practically, the self-loop flip-flops synthesized from hardware description language (HDL) code are not far from a small amount and thus, can in no way be negligible. More precisely, for solving (1), we show that the use of MBRFFs with up to two bits, consequently, constraining the wakeup delay to no more than two clock cycles, is enough to maintain the high reduction of total retention storage and for solving (2), we devise a 2-phase retention control mechanism for a pair of flip-flops, one of which has self-loop, by which just a single retention bit can be used to restore state of the two flip-flops, and propose an independent set based algorithm for maximally extracting the non-conflict pairs from circuits. Through experiments with benchmark circuits, it is shown that our proposed method is very effective against reducing the state retention storage and the power consumption compared with the existing best MBRFF allocation while the wakeup delay is strictly limited to two clock cycles.1 INTRODUCTION 1 1.1 Clock Gating 1 1.2 Power Gating and State Retention 3 1.3 Multi-bit Retention Registers 4 1.4 Contributions of This Dissertation 6 2 FLIP-FLOP STATE DRIVEN CLOCK GATING: CONCEPT, DESIGN, AND METHODOLOGY 9 2.1 Motivations 9 2.1.1 Toggling based Clock Gating 9 2.1.2 Area and Power by Clock Gating 10 2.2 The Proposed Clock Gating 13 2.2.1 Concept of Flip-flop State Driven Clock Gating 13 2.2.2 Design of Gating Logic Circuitry 17 2.2.3 Integrated Clock Gating Methodology 22 2.2.4 Cost Formulation 23 2.3 Experiments 25 2.3.1 Experimental Setup 25 2.3.2 Experimental Results 26 3 ALGORITHM AND DESIGN OPTIMIZATION OF ALLOCATING MULTI-BIT RETENTION FLIP-FLOPS FOR POWER GATED CIRCUITS 32 3.1 Motivations 32 3.1.1 Flip-flops with Mux-feedback Loop 32 3.1.2 Impact of Wakeup Delay 37 3.2 The Proposed Allocation Algorithm 39 3.3 Design of Multi-Bit Retention Flip-Flop and Multi-Bit Extension 48 3.3.1 Multi-Bit Retention Flip-Flop 48 3.3.2 Multi-Bit Flip-Flop Extension 52 3.4 Experiments 54 3.4.1 Experimental Setup 54 3.4.2 Experimental Results 57 4 CONCLUSIONS 65 4.1 Flip-flop State Driven Clock Gating: Concept, Design, and Methodology 65 4.2 Algorithm and Design Optimization of Allocating Multi-bit Retention Flip-flops for Power Gated Circuits 66 Abstract (In Korean) 71Docto

Power efficient resilient microarchitectures for PVT variability mitigation

Nowadays, the high power density and the process, voltage, and temperature variations became the most critical issues that limit the performance of the digital integrated circuits because of the continuous scaling of the fabrication technology. Dynamic voltage and frequency scaling technique is used to reduce the power consumption while different time relaxation techniques and error recovery microarchitectures are used to tolerate the process, voltage, and temperature variations. These techniques reduce the throughput by scaling down the frequency or flushing and restarting the errant pipeline. This thesis presents a novel resilient microarchitecture which is called ERSUT-based resilient microarchitecture to tolerate the induced delays generated by the voltage scaling or the process, voltage, and temperature variations. The resilient microarchitecture detects and recovers the induced errors without flushing the pipeline and without scaling down the operating frequency. An ERSUT-based resilient 16 × 16 bit MAC unit, implemented using Global Foundries 65 nm technology and ARM standard cells library, is introduced as a case study with 18.26% area overhead and up to 1.5x speedup. At the typical conditions, the maximum frequency of the conventional MAC unit is about 375 MHz while the resilient MAC unit operates correctly at a frequency up to 565 MHz. In case of variations, the resilient MAC unit tolerates induced delays up to 50% of the clock period while keeping its throughput equal to the conventional MAC unit’s maximum throughput. At 375 MHz, the resilient MAC unit is able to scale down the supply voltage from 1.2 V to 1.0 V saving about 29% of the power consumed by the conventional MAC unit. A double-edge-triggered microarchitecture is also introduced to reduce the power consumption extremely by reducing the frequency of the clock tree to the half while preserving the same maximum throughput. This microarchitecture is applied to different ISCAS’89 benchmark circuits in addition to the 16x16 bit MAC unit and the average power reduction of all these circuits is 63.58% while the average area overhead is 31.02%. All these circuits are designed using Global Foundries 65nm technology and ARM standard cells library. Towards the full automation of the ERSUT-based resilient microarchitecture, an ERSUT-based algorithm is introduced in C++ to accelerate the design process of the ERSUT-based microarchitecture. The developed algorithm reduces the design-time efforts dramatically and allows the ERSUT-based microarchitecture to be adopted by larger industrial designs. Depending on the ERSUT-based algorithm, a validation study about applying the ERSUT-based microarchitecture on the MAC unit and different ISCAS’89 benchmark circuits with different complexity weights is introduced. This study shows that 72% of these circuits tolerates more than 14% of their clock periods and 54.5% of these circuits tolerates more than 20% while 27% of these circuits tolerates more than 30%. Consequently, the validation study proves that the ERSUT-based resilient microarchitecture is a valid applicable solution for different circuits with different complexity weights

DLWUC: Distance and Load Weight Updated Clustering-Based Clock Distribution for SOC Architecture

High-clock skew variations and degradation of driving ability of buffers lead to an additional power dissipation in Clock Distribution Network (CDN) that increases the dimensionality of buffers and coordination among flip-flops. The manual threshold level to predict the Region of Interest (ROI) is not applicable in clustering process due to the complexities of excessive wire length and critical delay. This paper proposes the Distance and Load Weight Updated Clustering (DLWUC) to determine the suitable position of logical components. Initially, the DLWUC utilizes the Hybrid Weighted Distance (HWD) to estimate the distance and construct the distance matrix. The weight value extracted from the sorted distance matrix facilitates the projection of buffers. The updated weight value serves as the base for clustering with labeled outputs. The placement of buffer at the suitable place from load weight updated clustering provides the necessary trade-off between clock provision and load balance. The DLWUC discussed in this paper reduces the size of buffers, skew, power and latency compared to the existing topologies

Energy and performance models for clocked and asynchronous communication

Journal ArticleParameterized first-order models for throughput, energy, and bandwidth are presented in this paper. Models are developed for many common pipeline methodologies, including clocked flopped, clocked time-borrowing latch protocols, asynchronous two-cycle, four-cycle, delay-insensitive, and source synchronous. The paper focuses on communication costs which have the potential to throttle design performance as scaling continues. The models can also be applied to logic. The equations share common parameters to allow apples-to-apples comparisons against different design targets and pipeline methodologies. By applying the parameters to various design targets, one can determine when unclocked communication is superior at the physical level to clocked communication in terms of energy for a given bandwidth. Comparisons between protocols at fixed targets also allow designers to understand tradeoffs between implementations that have a varying degree of timing assumptions and design requirements

Bascules à impulsion robustes en technologie 28nm FDSOI pour circuits numériques basse consommation à très large gamme de tension d'alimentation

The explosion market of the mobile application and the paradigm of the Internet of Things lead to a huge demand for energy-efficient systems. To overcome the limit of Moore's law due to bulk technology, a new transistor technology has appeared recently in industrial process: the fully-depleted silicon on insulator, or FDSOI.In modern ASIC designs, a large portion of the total power consumption is due to the leaves of the clock tree: the flip-flops. Therefore, the appropriate flip-flop architecture is a major choice to reach the speed and energy constraints of mobile and ultra-low power applications. After a thorough overview of the literature, the explicit pulse-triggered flip-flop topology is pointed out as a very interesting flip-flop architecture for high-speed and low-power systems. However, it is today only used in high-performances circuits mainly because of its poor robustness at ultra-low voltage.In this work, explicit pulse-triggered flip-flops architecture design is developed and studied in order to improve their robustness and their energy-efficiency. A large comparison of resettable and scannable latch architecture is performed in the energy-delay domain by modifying the sizing of the transistors, both at nominal and ultra-low voltage. Then, it is shown that the back biasing technique allowed by the FDSOI technology provides better energy and delay performances than the sizing methodology. As the pulse generator is the main cause of functional failure, we proposed a new architecture which provides both a good robustness at ultra-low voltage and an energy efficiency. A selected topology of explicit pulse-triggered flip-flop was implemented in a 16x32b register file which exhibits better speed, energy consumption and area performances than a version with master-slave flip-flops, mainly thanks to the sharing of the pulse generator over several latches.Avec l'explosion du marché des applications portables et le paradigme de l'Internet des objets, la demande pour les circuits à très haute efficacité énergétique ne cesse de croître. Afin de repousser les limites de la loi de Moore, une nouvelle technologie est apparue très récemment dans les procédés industriels afin de remplacer la technologie en substrat massif ; elle est nommée fully-depleted silicon on insulator ou FDSOI. Dans les circuits numériques synchrones modernes, une grande portion de la consommation totale du circuit provient de l'arbre d'horloge, et en particulier son extrémité : les bascules. Dès lors, l'architecture adéquate de bascules est un choix crucial pour atteindre les contraintes de vitesse et d'énergie des applications basse-consommation. Après un large aperçu de l'état de l'art, les bascules à impulsion explicite sont reconnues les plus prometteuses pour les systèmes demandant une haute performance et une basse consommation. Cependant, cette architecture est pour l'instant fortement utilisée dans les circuits à haute performance et pratiquement absente des circuits à basse tension d'alimentation, principalement à cause de sa faible robustesse face aux variations.Dans ce travail, la conception d'architecture de bascule à impulsion explicite est étudiée dans le but d'améliorer la robustesse et l'efficacité énergétique. Un large panel d'architectures de bascule, avec les fonctions reset et scan, a été comparé dans le domaine énergie-délais, à haute et basse tension d'alimentation, grâce à une méthodologie de dimensionnement des transistors. Il a été montré que la technique dite de « back bias », l'un des principaux avantages de la technologie FDSOI, permettait des meilleures performances en énergie et délais que la méthodologie de dimensionnement. Ensuite, comme le générateur d'impulsion est la principale raison de dysfonctionnement, nous avons proposé une nouvelle architecture qui permet un très bon compromis entre robustesse à faible tension et consommation énergétique. Une topologie de bascule à impulsion explicite a été choisie pour être implémentée dans un banc de registres et, comparé aux bascules maître-esclave, elle présente une plus grande vitesse, une plus faible consommation énergétique et une plus petite surface