27 research outputs found

    Ecology and emergence: Understanding factors that drive variation in process quality and clinical outcomes in general practice

    Get PDF
    Clinical practice variation (CPV), where differences in healthcare delivery do not reflect differences in patient preferences or clinical need, is considered a hallmark of poor quality care. 'Unwarranted' variation is the focus of mounting policy attention and a growing body of literature, but remains poorly explained and theorised, with ways of determining when variation is warranted only weakly developed. Many assertions around CPV remain under-explored and untested. Much of the literature operates on the assumption that the legitimacy of variation depends on its source or cause, and that variation in processes of care will lead to related variation in outcomes. This doctoral research focuses on two overarching questions relating to CPV in Australian general practice: (1) what is CPV, and how can it be best conceptualised and understood; and (2) what can routinely-collected clinical data tell us about the phenomenon of CPV in general practice? Accordingly, this thesis explores the operationalisation of CPV as a theoretical construct and also examines variation in a series of clinical performance measures for coronary heart disease (CHD) and diabetes. Together, these lines of inquiry constitute a mixed-methods 'sense-making' exercise that seeks an incremental interplay between literature and data, to shed light on the phenomenon of CPV. Data are drawn from a unique dataset of aggregate reporting metrics, using extracted electronic medical record data, among an affiliated group of 36 general practice clinics serving approximately 189,848 patients over a 5-year period. These data are examined descriptively and ultimately analysed using Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) against an empirically derived explanatory framework. Theory development draws on complexity science, especially complex adaptive systems theory, and the disciplines of social epidemiology and health ecology. Results show that a series of discourses have strongly shaped thinking about CPV, converging around a normative 'bad apples' approach to understanding variation. However, CPV may also contribute to healthcare quality in ways that are not well considered, especially in primary care settings. I demonstrate that there may be unconventional but more illuminating ways to conceptualise variation that enable our collective understanding to progress. These include using an ecological framework to conceive CPV as an emergent property of coupled, complex adaptive systems, and employing an equity lens to distinguish between CPV in processes and outcomes of care. In descriptive analyses, I find that variation frequently behaves differently across different measures, with crucial system information contained in the interstices of the data. Contrary to common assumptions, relationships between processes and outcomes of care are not straightforward. Using a framework of factors associated with CPV in general practice management of diabetes and CHD, I confirm that causality is complex and multifactorial, operating at a number of levels. Employing the case-based configurational method of QCA, I show that there may be no single or primary cause for CPV. Instead, clinics can arrive at a particular outcome via multiple independent causal pathways which are themselves multifactorial. These multi-component causes may be defined as much by the interactions between component elements as by individual elements themselves. The same factor may have differential effects within different combinations, or at different scales. These findings suggest that relying on causal explanations to demarcate unwarranted variation may be insufficient. However, both theory and methods require continued development to ensure an adequate understanding of the role and representation of warranted and unwarranted variation in performance measurement systems. Case-based configurational methods such as QCA may have substantial utility in helping to explain and delineate these phenomena

    Proceedings of the 2018 Canadian Society for Mechanical Engineering (CSME) International Congress

    Get PDF
    Published proceedings of the 2018 Canadian Society for Mechanical Engineering (CSME) International Congress, hosted by York University, 27-30 May 2018

    CIRA annual report FY 2015/2016

    Get PDF
    Reporting period April 1, 2015-March 31, 2016

    Sustainable energy for a resilient future: proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Sustainable Energy Technologies

    Get PDF
    Volume I, 898 pages, ISBN 9780853583134 Energy Technologies & Renewables Session 1: Biofuels & Biomass Session 5: Building Energy Systems Session 9: Low-carbon/ Low-energy Technologies Session 13: Biomass Systems Session 16: Solar Energy Session 17: Biomass & Biofuels Session 20: Solar Energy Session 21: Solar Energy Session 22: Solar Energy Session 25: Building Energy Technologies Session 26: Solar Energy Session 29: Low-carbon/ Low-energy Technologies Session 32: Heat Pumps Session 33: Low-carbon/ Low-energy Technologies Session 36: Low-carbon/ Low-energy Technologies Poster Session A Poster Session B Poster Session C Poster Session E Volume II, 644 pages, ISBN 9780853583141 Energy Storage & Conversion Session 2: Heating and Cooling Systems Session 6: Heating and Cooling Systems Session 10: Ventilation and Air Conditioning Session 14: Smart and Responsive Buildings Session 18: Phase Change Materials Session 23: Smart and Responsive Buildings Session 30: Heating and Cooling System Session 34: Carbon Sequestration Poster Session A Poster Session C Poster Session D Policies & Management Session 4: Environmental Issues and the Public Session 8: Energy and Environment Security Session 12: Energy and Environment Policies Poster Session A Poster Session D Volume III, 642 pages, ISBN 9780853583158 Sustainable Cities & Environment Session 3: Sustainable and Resilient Cities Session 7: Energy Demand and Use Optimization Session 11: Energy Efficiency in Buildings Session 15: Green and Sustainable Buildings Session 19: Green Buildings and Materials Session 24: Energy Efficiency in Buildings Session 27: Energy Efficiency in Buildings Session 28: Energy Efficiency in Buildings Session 31: Energy Efficiency in Buildings Session 35: Energy Efficiency in Buildings Poster Session A Poster Session D Poster Session
    corecore