Chronos: Failure-Aware Scheduling in Shared Hadoop Clusters

International audienceHadoop emerged as the de facto state-of-the-art system for MapReduce-based data analytics. The reliability of Hadoop systems depends in part on how well they handle failures. Currently, Hadoop handles machine failures by re-executing all the tasks of the failed machines (i.e., executing recovery tasks). Unfortunately, this elegant solution is entirely entrusted to the core of Hadoop and hidden from Hadoop schedulers. The unawareness of failures therefore may prevent Hadoop schedulers from operating correctly towards meeting their objectives (e.g., fairness, job priority) and can significantly impact the performance of MapReduce applications. This paper presents Chronos, a failure-aware scheduling strategy that enables an early yet smart action for fast failure recovery while still operating within a specific scheduler objective. Upon failure detection, rather than waiting an uncertain amount of time to get resources for recovery tasks, Chronos leverages a lightweight preemption technique to carefully allocate these resources. In addition, Chronos considers data locality when scheduling recovery tasks to further improve the performance. We demonstrate the utility of Chronos by combining it with Fifo and Fair schedulers. The experimental results show that Chronos recovers to a correct scheduling behavior within a couple of seconds only and reduces the job completion times by up to 55% compared to state-of-the-art schedulers

Enabling Fast Failure Recovery in Shared Hadoop Clusters: Towards Failure-Aware Scheduling

International audienceHadoop emerged as the de facto state-of-the-art system for MapReduce-based data analytics. The reliability of Hadoop systems depends in part on how well they handle failures. Currently, Hadoop handles machine failures by re-executing all the tasks of the failed machines (i.e., executing recovery tasks). Unfortunately, this elegant solution is entirely entrusted to the core of Hadoop and hidden from Hadoop schedulers. The unawareness of failures therefore may prevent Hadoop schedulers from operating correctly towards meeting their objectives (e.g., fairness, job priority) and can significantly impact the performance of MapReduce applications. This paper presents Chronos, a failure-aware scheduling strategy that enables an early yet smart action for fast failure recovery while still operating within a specific scheduler objective. Upon failure detection, rather than waiting an uncertain amount of time to get resources for recovery tasks, Chronos leverages a lightweight preemption technique to carefully allocate these resources. In addition, Chronos considers data locality when scheduling recovery tasks to further improve the performance. We demonstrate the utility of Chronos by combining it with Fifo and Fair schedulers. The experimental results show that Chronos recovers to a correct scheduling behavior within a couple of seconds only and reduces the job completion times by up to 55% compared to state-of-the-art schedulers

Hopper: Decentralized Speculation-aware Cluster Scheduling at Scale

As clusters continue to grow in size and complexity, providing scalable and predictable performance is an increasingly important challenge. A crucial roadblock to achieving predictable performance is stragglers, i.e., tasks that take significantly longer than expected to run. At this point, speculative execution has been widely adopted to mitigate the impact of stragglers. However, speculation mechanisms are designed and operated independently of job scheduling when, in fact, scheduling a speculative copy of a task has a direct impact on the resources available for other jobs. In this work, we present Hopper, a job scheduler that is speculation-aware, i.e., that integrates the tradeoffs associated with speculation into job scheduling decisions. We implement both centralized and decentralized prototypes of the Hopper scheduler and show that 50% (66%) improvements over state-of-the-art centralized (decentralized) schedulers and speculation strategies can be achieved through the coordination of scheduling and speculation

A Platform for Scalable Low-Latency Analytics using MapReduce

Today, the ability to process big data has become crucial to the information needs of many enterprise businesses, scientific applications, and governments. Recently, there have been increasing needs of processing data that is not only big but also fast . Here fast data refers to high-speed real-time and near real-time data streams, such as Twitter feeds, search query streams, click streams, impressions, and system logs. To handle both historical data and real-time data, many companies have to maintain multiple systems. However, recent real-world case studies show that maintaining multiple systems cause not only code duplication, but also intensive manual work to partition the analytics workloads and determine which data is processed by which system. These issues point to the need for a general, unified data processing framework to support analytical queries with different latency requirements. This thesis takes a further step towards building a general, unified system for big and fast data analytics. In order to build such a system, I propose to build on existing solutions on data parallelism and extend them with two new features: incremental processing and stream processing with latency constraints. This thesis starts with Hadoop, the most popular open-source MapReduce implementation, which provides proven scalability based on data parallelism. I answer the following questions: (1) Is Hadoop able to support incremental processing? (2) What are the necessary architecture changes in order to support incremental processing? (3) What are the additional design features needed to support stream processing with latency constraints? The thesis includes three parts that answer each of the questions. The first part of the thesis validates whether the existing MapReduce implementations can support incremental processing. Incremental processing means that computation is performed as soon as the relevant data becomes available. My extensive benchmark study of Hadoop-based MapReduce systems shows that the widely-used sort-merge implementation for partitioning and parallel processing poses a fundamental barrier to incremental computation. I further propose a cost model, and optimize the Hadoop system configuration based on the model. The benchmark results over the optimized system verify that the barrier to incremental computation is intrinsic, and cannot be removed by tuning system parameters. In the second part of the thesis, I employ various purely hash-based techniques to enable fast in-memory incremental processing in MapReduce, and frequent key based techniques to extend such processing to workloads that require memory more than available. I evaluate my Hadoop-based prototype equipped with all proposed techniques. The results show that the hash techniques allow the reduce progress to keep up with the map progress with up to 3 orders of magnitude reduction of internal disk spills, and enable results to be returned early. The third part of the thesis aims to support stream processing with latency constraints based on the incremental processing platform resulted from the second part. I perform a benchmark study to understand the sources of latency. I then propose a number of necessary architecture changes to support stream processing, and augment the platform with new latency-aware model-driven resource planning and latency-aware runtime scheduling techniques to meet user-specified latency constraints while maximizing throughput. Experiments using real-world workloads show that the techniques reduce the latency from tens or hundreds of seconds to sub-second, with 2x-5x increase in throughput. The new platform offers 1-2 orders of magnitude improvements over Storm, a commercial-grade distributed stream system, and Spark Streaming, a state-of-the-art academic prototype, when considering both latency and throughput

Data-Driven Intelligent Scheduling For Long Running Workloads In Large-Scale Datacenters

Cloud computing is becoming a fundamental facility of society today. Large-scale public or private cloud datacenters spreading millions of servers, as a warehouse-scale computer, are supporting most business of Fortune-500 companies and serving billions of users around the world. Unfortunately, modern industry-wide average datacenter utilization is as low as 6% to 12%. Low utilization not only negatively impacts operational and capital components of cost efficiency, but also becomes the scaling bottleneck due to the limits of electricity delivered by nearby utility. It is critical and challenge to improve multi-resource efficiency for global datacenters. Additionally, with the great commercial success of diverse big data analytics services, enterprise datacenters are evolving to host heterogeneous computation workloads including online web services, batch processing, machine learning, streaming computing, interactive query and graph computation on shared clusters. Most of them are long-running workloads that leverage long-lived containers to execute tasks. We concluded datacenter resource scheduling works over last 15 years. Most previous works are designed to maximize the cluster efficiency for short-lived tasks in batch processing system like Hadoop. They are not suitable for modern long-running workloads of Microservices, Spark, Flink, Pregel, Storm or Tensorflow like systems. It is urgent to develop new effective scheduling and resource allocation approaches to improve efficiency in large-scale enterprise datacenters. In the dissertation, we are the first of works to define and identify the problems, challenges and scenarios of scheduling and resource management for diverse long-running workloads in modern datacenter. They rely on predictive scheduling techniques to perform reservation, auto-scaling, migration or rescheduling. It forces us to pursue and explore more intelligent scheduling techniques by adequate predictive knowledges. We innovatively specify what is intelligent scheduling, what abilities are necessary towards intelligent scheduling, how to leverage intelligent scheduling to transfer NP-hard online scheduling problems to resolvable offline scheduling issues. We designed and implemented an intelligent cloud datacenter scheduler, which automatically performs resource-to-performance modeling, predictive optimal reservation estimation, QoS (interference)-aware predictive scheduling to maximize resource efficiency of multi-dimensions (CPU, Memory, Network, Disk I/O), and strictly guarantee service level agreements (SLA) for long-running workloads. Finally, we introduced a large-scale co-location techniques of executing long-running and other workloads on the shared global datacenter infrastructure of Alibaba Group. It effectively improves cluster utilization from 10% to averagely 50%. It is far more complicated beyond scheduling that involves technique evolutions of IDC, network, physical datacenter topology, storage, server hardwares, operating systems and containerization. We demonstrate its effectiveness by analysis of newest Alibaba public cluster trace in 2017. We are the first of works to reveal the global view of scenarios, challenges and status in Alibaba large-scale global datacenters by data demonstration, including big promotion events like Double 11 . Data-driven intelligent scheduling methodologies and effective infrastructure co-location techniques are critical and necessary to pursue maximized multi-resource efficiency in modern large-scale datacenter, especially for long-running workloads

Workload Interleaving with Performance Guarantees in Data Centers

In the era of global, large scale data centers residing in clouds, many applications and users share the same pool of resources for the purposes of reducing energy and operating costs, and of improving availability and reliability. Along with the above benefits, resource sharing also introduces performance challenges: when multiple workloads access the same resources concurrently, contention may occur and introduce delays in the performance of individual workloads. Providing performance isolation to individual workloads needs effective management methodologies. The challenges of deriving effective management methodologies lie in finding accurate, robust, compact metrics and models to drive algorithms that can meet different performance objectives while achieving efficient utilization of resources. This dissertation proposes a set of methodologies aiming at solving the challenging performance isolation problem in workload interleaving in data centers, focusing on both storage components and computing components. at the storage node level, we focus on methodologies for better interleaving user traffic with background workloads, such as tasks for improving reliability, availability, and power savings. More specifically, a scheduling policy for background workload based on the statistical characteristics of the system busy periods and a methodology that quantitatively estimates the performance impact of power savings are developed. at the storage cluster level, we consider methodologies on how to efficiently conduct work consolidation and schedule asynchronous updates without violating user performance targets. More specifically, we develop a framework that can estimate beforehand the benefits and overheads of each option in order to automate the process of reaching intelligent consolidation decisions while achieving faster eventual consistency. at the computing node level, we focus on improving workload interleaving at off-the-shelf servers as they are the basic building blocks of large-scale data centers. We develop priority scheduling middleware that employs different policies to schedule background tasks based on the instantaneous resource requirements of the high priority applications running on the server node. Finally, at the computing cluster level, we investigate popular computing frameworks for large-scale data intensive distributed processing, such as MapReduce and its Hadoop implementation. We develop a new Hadoop scheduler called DyScale to exploit capabilities offered by heterogeneous cores in order to achieve a variety of performance objectives

Scheduling and resource allocation for clouds: novel algorithms, state space collapse and decay of tails

Scheduling and resource allocation in cloud systems is of fundamental importance to system efficiency. The focus of this thesis is to study the fundamental limits of the scheduling and resource allocation problems in clouds, and design provably high-performance algorithms. In the first part, we consider data-centric scheduling. Data-intensive applications are posing increasingly significant challenges to scheduling in today's computing clusters. The presence of data induces an extremely heterogeneous cluster where processing speed depends on the task-server pair. The situation is further complicated by ever-changing technologies of networking, memory, and software architecture. As a result, a suboptimal scheduling algorithm causes unnecessary delay in job completion and wastes system capacity. We propose a versatile model featuring a multi-class parallel-server system that readily incorporates different characteristics of a variety of systems. The model has been studied by Harrison, Williams and Stolyar, respectively. However, delay optimality in heavy traffic with unknown arrival rate vectors has remained an open problem. We propose novel algorithms that achieve delay optimality with unknown arrival rates. This enables the application of proposed algorithms to data-centric clusters. New proof techniques are required including construction of an ideal load decomposition. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed algorithms, we implement a Hadoop MapReduce scheduler and show that it achieves more than 10 times improvement over existing schedulers. The second part studies the resource allocation problem for clouds that provide infrastructure as a service, in the form of virtual machines (VMs). Consolidation of multiple VMs on a single physical machine (PM) has been advocated for improving system utilization. VMs placed on the same PM are subject to resource "packing constraint," leading to stochastic dynamic bin packing models for the real-time assignment of VMs to PMs in a data center. Due to finite-sized pools of servers, incoming requests might not be fulfilled immediately and such requests are typically rejected. Hence a meaningful metric in practice is the blocking probability for arriving VM requests. We analyze the power-of-d-choices algorithm, a well-known stateless randomized routing policy with low scheduling overhead. We establish an explicit upper bound on the equilibrium blocking probability, and further demonstrate that the blocking probability exhibits distinct behaviors in different load regions: doubly-exponential decay in the heavy-traffic regime and exponential decay in the critically loaded regime