The Impact of Dynamics in Protein Assembly

Predicting the assembly of multiple proteins into specific complexes is critical to understanding their biological function in an organism, and thus the design of drugs to address their malfunction. Consequently, a significant body of research and development focuses on methods for elucidating protein quaternary structure. In silico techniques are used to propose models that decode experimental data, and independently as a structure prediction tool. These computational methods often consider proteins as rigid structures, yet proteins are inherently flexible molecules, with both local side-chain motion and larger conformational dynamics governing their behaviour. This treatment is particularly problematic for any protein docking engine, where even a simple rearrangement of the side-chain and backbone atoms at the interface of binding partners complicates the successful determination of the correct docked pose. Herein, we present a means of representing protein surface, electrostatics and local dynamics within a single volumetric descriptor, before applying it to a series of physical and biophysical problems to validate it as representative of a protein. We leverage this representation in a protein-protein docking context and demonstrate that its application bypasses the need to compensate for, and predict, specific side-chain packing at the interface of binding partners for both water-soluble and lipid-soluble protein complexes. We find little detriment in the quality of returned predictions with increased flexibility, placing our protein docking approach as highly competitive versus comparative methods. We then explore the role of larger, conformational dynamics in protein quaternary structure prediction, by exploiting large-scale Molecular Dynamics simulations of the SARS-CoV-2 spike glycoprotein to elucidate possible high-order spike-ACE2 oligomeric states. Our results indicate a possible novel path to therapeutics following the COVID-19 pandemic. Overall, we find that the structure of a protein alone is inadequate in understanding its function through its possible binding modes. Therefore, we must also consider the impact of dynamics in protein assembly

Classification of Protein-Binding Sites Using a Spherical Convolutional Neural Network

The analysis and comparison of protein-binding sites aid various applications in the drug discovery process, e.g., hit finding, drug repurposing, and polypharmacology. Classification of binding sites has been a hot topic for the past 30 years, and many different methods have been published. The rapid development of machine learning computational algorithms, coupled with the large volume of publicly available protein–ligand 3D structures, makes it possible to apply deep learning techniques in binding site comparison. Our method uses a cutting-edge spherical convolutional neural network based on the DeepSphere architecture to learn global representations of protein-binding sites. The model was trained on TOUGH-C1 and TOUGH-M1 data and validated with the ProSPECCTs datasets. Our results show that our model can (1) perform well in protein-binding site similarity and classification tasks and (2) learn and separate the physicochemical properties of binding sites. Lastly, we tested the model on a set of kinases, where the results show that it is able to cluster the different kinase subfamilies effectively. This example demonstrates the method’s promise for lead hopping within or outside a protein target, directly based on binding site information

Improving the resolution of interaction maps: A middleground between high-resolution complexes and genome-wide interactomes

Protein-protein interactions are ubiquitous in Biology and therefore central to understand living organisms. In recent years, large-scale studies have been undertaken to describe, at least partially, protein-protein interaction maps or interactomes for a number of relevant organisms including human. Although the analysis of interaction networks is proving useful, current interactomes provide a blurry and granular picture of the molecular machinery, i.e. unless the structure of the protein complex is known the molecular details of the interaction are missing and sometime is even not possible to know if the interaction between the proteins is direct, i.e. physical interaction or part of functional, not necessary, direct association. Unfortunately, the determination of the structure of protein complexes cannot keep pace with the discovery of new protein-protein interactions resulting in a large, and increasing, gap between the number of complexes that are thought to exist and the number for which 3D structures are available. The aim of the thesis was to tackle this problem by implementing computational approaches to derive structural models of protein complexes and thus reduce this existing gap. Over the course of the thesis, a novel modelling algorithm to predict the structure of protein complexes, V-D2OCK, was implemented. This new algorithm combines structure-based prediction of protein binding sites by means of a novel algorithm developed over the course of the thesis: VORFFIP and M-VORFFIP, data-driven docking and energy minimization. This algorithm was used to improve the coverage and structural content of the human interactome compiled from different sources of interactomic data to ensure the most comprehensive interactome. Finally, the human interactome and structural models were compiled in a database, V-D2OCK DB, that offers an easy and user-friendly access to the human interactome including a bespoken graphical molecular viewer to facilitate the analysis of the structural models of protein complexes. Furthermore, new organisms, in addition to human, were included providing a useful resource for the study of all known interactomes

Computational Approaches to Drug Profiling and Drug-Protein Interactions

Despite substantial increases in R&D spending within the pharmaceutical industry, denovo drug design has become a time-consuming endeavour. High attrition rates led to a long period of stagnation in drug approvals. Due to the extreme costs associated with introducing a drug to the market, locating and understanding the reasons for clinical failure is key to future productivity. As part of this PhD, three main contributions were made in this respect. First, the web platform, LigNFam enables users to interactively explore similarity relationships between ‘drug like’ molecules and the proteins they bind. Secondly, two deep-learning-based binding site comparison tools were developed, competing with the state-of-the-art over benchmark datasets. The models have the ability to predict offtarget interactions and potential candidates for target-based drug repurposing. Finally, the open-source ScaffoldGraph software was presented for the analysis of hierarchical scaffold relationships and has already been used in multiple projects, including integration into a virtual screening pipeline to increase the tractability of ultra-large screening experiments. Together, and with existing tools, the contributions made will aid in the understanding of drug-protein relationships, particularly in the fields of off-target prediction and drug repurposing, helping to design better drugs faster

Bioinformatics

This book is divided into different research areas relevant in Bioinformatics such as biological networks, next generation sequencing, high performance computing, molecular modeling, structural bioinformatics, molecular modeling and intelligent data analysis. Each book section introduces the basic concepts and then explains its application to problems of great relevance, so both novice and expert readers can benefit from the information and research works presented here

Quality assessment of docked protein interfaces using 3D convolution

2021 Spring.Includes bibliographical references.Proteins play a vital role in most biological processes, most of which occur through interactions between proteins. When proteins interact they form a complex, whose functionality is different from the individual proteins in the complex. Therefore understanding protein interactions and their interfaces is an important problem. Experimental methods for this task are expensive and time consuming, which has led to the development of docking methods for predicting the structures of protein complexes. These methods produce a large number of potential solutions, and the energy functions used in these methods are not good enough to find solutions that are close to the native state of the complex. Deep learning and its ability to model complex problems has opened up the opportunity to model protein complexes and learn from scratch how to rank docking solutions. As a part of this work, we have developed a 3D convolutional network approach that uses raw atomic densities to address this problem. Our method achieves performance which is on par with state-of-art methods. We have evaluated our model on docked protein structures simulated from four docking tools namely ZDOCK, HADDOCK, FRODOCK and ClusPro on targets from Docking Benchmark Data version 5 (DBD5)

Leveraging Structural Flexibility to Predict Protein Function

Proteins are essentially versatile and flexible molecules and understanding protein function plays a fundamental role in understanding biological systems. Protein structure comparisons are widely used for revealing protein function. However,with rigidity or partial rigidity assumption, most existing comparison methods do not consider conformational flexibility in protein structures. To address this issue, this thesis seeks to develop algorithms for flexible structure comparisons to predict one specific aspect of protein function, binding specificity. Given conformational samples as flexibility representation, we focus on two predictive problems related to specificity: aggregate prediction and individual prediction.For aggregate prediction, we have designed FAVA (Flexible Aggregate Volumetric Analysis). FAVA is the first conformationally general method to compare proteins with identical folds but different specificities. FAVA is able to correctly categorize members of protein superfamilies and to identify influential amino acids that cause different specificities. A second method PEAP (Point-based Ensemble for Aggregate Prediction) employs ensemble clustering techniques from many base clustering to predict binding specificity. This method incorporates structural motions of functional substructures and is capable of mitigating prediction errors.For individual prediction, the first method is an atomic point representation for representing flexibilities in the binding cavity. This representation is able to predict binding specificity on each protein conformation with high accuracy, and it is the first to analyze maps of binding cavity conformations that describe proteins with different specificities. Our second method introduces a volumetric lattice representation. This representation localizes solvent-accessible shape of the binding cavity by computing cavity volume in each user-defined space. It proves to be more informative than point-based representations. Last but not least, we discuss a structure-independent representation. This representation builds a lattice model on protein electrostatic isopotentials. This is the first known method to predict binding specificity explicitly from the perspective of electrostatic fields.The methods presented in this thesis incorporate the variety of protein conformations into the analysis of protein ligand binding, and provide more views on flexible structure comparisons and structure-based function annotation of molecular design

Constrained optimization applied to multiscale integrative modeling

Multiscale integrative modeling stands at the intersection between experimental and computational techniques to predict the atomistic structures of important macromolecules. In the integrative modeling process, the experimental information is often integrated with energy potential and macromolecular substructures in order to derive realistic structural models. This heterogeneous information is often combined into a global objective function that quantifies the quality of the structural models and that is minimized through optimization. In order to balance the contribution of the relative terms concurring to the global function, weight constants are assigned to each term through a computationally demanding process. In order to alleviate this common issue, we suggest to switch from the traditional paradigm of using a single unconstrained global objective function to a constrained optimization scheme. The work presented in this thesis describes the different applications and methods associated with the development of a general constrained optimization protocol for multiscale integrative modeling. The initial implementation concerned the prediction of symmetric macromolecular assemblies throught the incorporation of a recent efficient constrained optimizer nicknamed mViE (memetic Viability Evolution) to our integrative modeling protocol power (parallel optimization workbench to enhance resolution). We tested this new approach through rigorous comparisons against other state-of-the-art integrative modeling methods on a benchmark set of solved symmetric macromolecular assemblies. In this process, we validated the robustness of the constrained optimization method by obtaining native-like structural models. This constrained optimization protocol was then applied to predict the structure of the elusive human Huntingtin protein. Due to the fact that little structural information was available when the project was initiated, we integrated information from secondary structure prediction and low-resolution experiments, in the form of cryo-electron microscopy maps and crosslinking mass spectrometry data, in order to derive a structural model of Huntingtin. The structure resulting from such integrative modeling approach was used to derive dynamic information about Huntingtin protein. At a finer level of resolution, the constrained optimization protocol was then applied to dock small molecules inside the binding site of protein targets. We converted the classical molecular docking problem from an unconstrained single objective optimization to a constrained one by extracting local and global constraints from pre-computed energy grids. The new approach was tested and validated on standard ligand-receptor benchmark sets widely used by the molecular docking community, and showed comparable results to state-of-the-art molecular docking programs. Altogether, the work presented in this thesis proposed improvements in the field of multiscale integrative modeling which are reflected both in the quality of the models returned by the new constrained optimization protocol and in the simpler way of treating the uncorrelated terms concurring to the global scoring scheme to estimate the quality of the models

Theoretical and computational modeling of rna-ligand interactions

Ribonucleic acid (RNA) is a polymeric nucleic acid that plays a variety of critical roles in gene expression and regulation at the level of transcription and translation. Recently, there has been an enormous interest in the development of therapeutic strategies that target RNA molecules. Instead of modifying the product of gene expression, i.e., proteins, RNAtargeted therapeutics aims to modulate the relevant key RNA elements in the disease-related cellular pathways. Such approaches have two significant advantages. First, diseases with related proteins that are difficult or unable to be drugged become druggable by targeting the corresponding messenger RNAs (mRNAs) that encode the amino acid sequences. Second, besides coding mRNAs, the vast majority of the human genome sequences are transcribed to noncoding RNAs (ncRNAs), which serve as enzymatic, structural, and regulatory elements in cellular pathways of most human diseases. Targeting noncoding RNAs would open up remarkable new opportunities for disease treatment. The first step in modeling the RNA-drug interaction is to understand the 3D structure of the given RNA target. With current theoretical models, accurate prediction of 3D structures for large RNAs from sequence remains computationally infeasible. One of the major challenges comes from the flexibility in the RNA molecule, especially in loop/junction regions, and the resulting rugged energy landscape. However, structure probing techniques, such as the “selective 20-hydroxyl acylation analyzed by primer extension” (SHAPE) experiment, enable the quantitative detection of the relative flexibility and hence structure information of RNA structural elements. Therefore, one may incorporate the SHAPE data into RNA 3D structure prediction. In the first project, we investigate the feasibility of using a machine-learning-based approach to predict the SHAPE reactivity from the 3D RNA structure and compare the machine-learning result to that of a physics-based model. In the second project, in order to provide a user-friendly tool for RNA biologists, we developed a fully automated web interface, “SHAPE predictoR” (SHAPER) for predicting SHAPE profile from any given 3D RNA structure. In a cellular environment, various factors, such as metal ions and small molecules, interact with an RNA molecule to modulate RNA cellular activity. RNA is a highly charged polymer with each backbone phosphate group carrying one unit of negative (electronic) charge. In order to fold into a compact functional tertiary structure, it requires metal ions to reduce Coulombic repulsive electrostatic forces by neutralizing the backbone charges. In particular, Mg2+ ion is essential for the folding and stability of RNA tertiary structures. In the third project, we introduce a machine-learning-based model, the “Magnesium convolutional neural network” (MgNet) model, to predict Mg2+ binding site for a given 3D RNA structure, and show the use of the model in investigating the important coordinating RNA atoms and identifying novel Mg2+ binding motifs. Besides Mg2+ ions, small molecules, such as drug molecules, can also bind to an RNA to modulate its activities. Motivated by the tremendous potential of RNA-targeted drug discovery, in the fourth project, we develop a novel approach to predicting RNA-small molecule binding. Specifically, we develop a statistical potential-based scoring/ranking method (SPRank) to identify the native binding mode of the small molecule from a pool of decoys and estimate the binding affinity for the given RNA-small molecule complex. The results tested on a widely used data set suggest that SPRank can achieve (moderately) better performance than the current state-of-art models