Security in network games

Attacks on the Internet are characterized by several alarming trends: 1) increases in frequency; 2) increases in speed; and 3) increases in severity. Modern computer worms simply propagate too quickly for human detection. Since attacks are now occurring at a speed which prevents direct human intervention, there is a need to develop automated defenses. Since the financial, social and political stakes are so high, we need defenses which are provably good against worst case attacks and are not too costly to deploy. In this dissertation we present two approaches to tackle these problems. For the first part of the dissertation we consider a game between an alert and a worm over a large network. We show, for this game, that it is possible to design an algorithm for the alerts that can prevent any worm from infecting more than a vanishingly small fraction of the nodes with high probability. Critical to our result is designing a communication network for spreading the alerts that has high expansion. The expansion of the network is related to the gap between the 1st and 2nd eigenvalues of the adjacency matrix. Intuitively high expansion ensures redundant connectivity. We also present results simulating our algorithm on networks of size up to $2^{25}$. In the second part of this dissertation we consider the virus inoculation game which models the selfish behavior of the nodes involved. We present a technique for this game which makes it possible to achieve the \u27windfall of malice\u27 even without the actual presence of malicious players. We also show the limitations of this technique for congestion games that are known to have a windfall of malice

Automatic Malware Detection

The problem of automatic malware detection presents challenges for antivirus vendors. Since the manual investigation is not possible due to the massive number of samples being submitted every day, automatic malware classication is necessary. Our work is focused on an automatic malware detection framework based on machine learning algorithms. We proposed several static malware detection systems for the Windows operating system to achieve the primary goal of distinguishing between malware and benign software. We also considered the more practical goal of detecting as much malware as possible while maintaining a suciently low false positive rate. We proposed several malware detection systems using various machine learning techniques, such as ensemble classier, recurrent neural network, and distance metric learning. We designed architectures of the proposed detection systems, which are automatic in the sense that extraction of features, preprocessing, training, and evaluating the detection model can be automated. However, antivirus program relies on more complex system that consists of many components where several of them depends on malware analysts and researchers. Malware authors adapt their malicious programs frequently in order to bypass antivirus programs that are regularly updated. Our proposed detection systems are not automatic in the sense that they are not able to automatically adapt to detect the newest malware. However, we can partly solve this problem by running our proposed systems again if the training set contains the newest malware. Our work relied on static analysis only. In this thesis, we discuss advantages and drawbacks in comparison to dynamic analysis. Static analysis still plays an important role, and it is used as one component of a complex detection system.The problem of automatic malware detection presents challenges for antivirus vendors. Since the manual investigation is not possible due to the massive number of samples being submitted every day, automatic malware classication is necessary. Our work is focused on an automatic malware detection framework based on machine learning algorithms. We proposed several static malware detection systems for the Windows operating system to achieve the primary goal of distinguishing between malware and benign software. We also considered the more practical goal of detecting as much malware as possible while maintaining a suciently low false positive rate. We proposed several malware detection systems using various machine learning techniques, such as ensemble classier, recurrent neural network, and distance metric learning. We designed architectures of the proposed detection systems, which are automatic in the sense that extraction of features, preprocessing, training, and evaluating the detection model can be automated. However, antivirus program relies on more complex system that consists of many components where several of them depends on malware analysts and researchers. Malware authors adapt their malicious programs frequently in order to bypass antivirus programs that are regularly updated. Our proposed detection systems are not automatic in the sense that they are not able to automatically adapt to detect the newest malware. However, we can partly solve this problem by running our proposed systems again if the training set contains the newest malware. Our work relied on static analysis only. In this thesis, we discuss advantages and drawbacks in comparison to dynamic analysis. Static analysis still plays an important role, and it is used as one component of a complex detection system

Intelligent Malware Detection Using File-to-file Relations and Enhancing its Security against Adversarial Attacks

With computing devices and the Internet being indispensable in people\u27s everyday life, malware has posed serious threats to their security, making its detection of utmost concern. To protect legitimate users from the evolving malware attacks, machine learning-based systems have been successfully deployed and offer unparalleled flexibility in automatic malware detection. In most of these systems, resting on the analysis of different content-based features either statically or dynamically extracted from the file samples, various kinds of classifiers are constructed to detect malware. However, besides content-based features, file-to-file relations, such as file co-existence, can provide valuable information in malware detection and make evasion harder. To better understand the properties of file-to-file relations, we construct the file co-existence graph. Resting on the constructed graph, we investigate the semantic relatedness among files, and leverage graph inference, active learning and graph representation learning for malware detection. Comprehensive experimental results on the real sample collections from Comodo Cloud Security Center demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed learning paradigms. As machine learning-based detection systems become more widely deployed, the incentive for defeating them increases. Therefore, we go further insight into the arms race between adversarial malware attack and defense, and aim to enhance the security of machine learning-based malware detection systems. In particular, we first explore the adversarial attacks under different scenarios (i.e., different levels of knowledge the attackers might have about the targeted learning system), and define a general attack strategy to thoroughly assess the adversarial behaviors. Then, considering different skills and capabilities of the attackers, we propose the corresponding secure-learning paradigms to counter the adversarial attacks and enhance the security of the learning systems while not compromising the detection accuracy. We conduct a series of comprehensive experimental studies based on the real sample collections from Comodo Cloud Security Center and the promising results demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed secure-learning models, which can be readily applied to other detection tasks

Machine Learning and other Computational-Intelligence Techniques for Security Applications

L'abstract è presente nell'allegato / the abstract is in the attachmen

Mustererkennungsbasierte Verteidgung gegen gezielte Angriffe

The speed at which everything and everyone is being connected considerably outstrips the rate at which effective security mechanisms are introduced to protect them. This has created an opportunity for resourceful threat actors which have specialized in conducting low-volume persistent attacks through sophisticated techniques that are tailored to specific valuable targets. Consequently, traditional approaches are rendered ineffective against targeted attacks, creating an acute need for innovative defense mechanisms. This thesis aims at supporting the security practitioner in bridging this gap by introducing a holistic strategy against targeted attacks that addresses key challenges encountered during the phases of detection, analysis and response. The structure of this thesis is therefore aligned to these three phases, with each one of its central chapters taking on a particular problem and proposing a solution built on a strong foundation on pattern recognition and machine learning. In particular, we propose a detection approach that, in the absence of additional authentication mechanisms, allows to identify spear-phishing emails without relying on their content. Next, we introduce an analysis approach for malware triage based on the structural characterization of malicious code. Finally, we introduce MANTIS, an open-source platform for authoring, sharing and collecting threat intelligence, whose data model is based on an innovative unified representation for threat intelligence standards based on attributed graphs. As a whole, these ideas open new avenues for research on defense mechanisms and represent an attempt to counteract the imbalance between resourceful actors and society at large.In unserer heutigen Welt sind alle und alles miteinander vernetzt. Dies bietet mächtigen Angreifern die Möglichkeit, komplexe Verfahren zu entwickeln, die auf spezifische Ziele angepasst sind. Traditionelle Ansätze zur Bekämpfung solcher Angriffe werden damit ineffektiv, was die Entwicklung innovativer Methoden unabdingbar macht. Die vorliegende Dissertation verfolgt das Ziel, den Sicherheitsanalysten durch eine umfassende Strategie gegen gezielte Angriffe zu unterstützen. Diese Strategie beschäftigt sich mit den hauptsächlichen Herausforderungen in den drei Phasen der Erkennung und Analyse von sowie der Reaktion auf gezielte Angriffe. Der Aufbau dieser Arbeit orientiert sich daher an den genannten drei Phasen. In jedem Kapitel wird ein Problem aufgegriffen und eine entsprechende Lösung vorgeschlagen, die stark auf maschinellem Lernen und Mustererkennung basiert. Insbesondere schlagen wir einen Ansatz vor, der eine Identifizierung von Spear-Phishing-Emails ermöglicht, ohne ihren Inhalt zu betrachten. Anschliessend stellen wir einen Analyseansatz für Malware Triage vor, der auf der strukturierten Darstellung von Code basiert. Zum Schluss stellen wir MANTIS vor, eine Open-Source-Plattform für Authoring, Verteilung und Sammlung von Threat Intelligence, deren Datenmodell auf einer innovativen konsolidierten Graphen-Darstellung für Threat Intelligence Stardards basiert. Wir evaluieren unsere Ansätze in verschiedenen Experimenten, die ihren potentiellen Nutzen in echten Szenarien beweisen. Insgesamt bereiten diese Ideen neue Wege für die Forschung zu Abwehrmechanismen und erstreben, das Ungleichgewicht zwischen mächtigen Angreifern und der Gesellschaft zu minimieren

A Survey on Malware Detection with Graph Representation Learning

Malware detection has become a major concern due to the increasing number and complexity of malware. Traditional detection methods based on signatures and heuristics are used for malware detection, but unfortunately, they suffer from poor generalization to unknown attacks and can be easily circumvented using obfuscation techniques. In recent years, Machine Learning (ML) and notably Deep Learning (DL) achieved impressive results in malware detection by learning useful representations from data and have become a solution preferred over traditional methods. More recently, the application of such techniques on graph-structured data has achieved state-of-the-art performance in various domains and demonstrates promising results in learning more robust representations from malware. Yet, no literature review focusing on graph-based deep learning for malware detection exists. In this survey, we provide an in-depth literature review to summarize and unify existing works under the common approaches and architectures. We notably demonstrate that Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) reach competitive results in learning robust embeddings from malware represented as expressive graph structures, leading to an efficient detection by downstream classifiers. This paper also reviews adversarial attacks that are utilized to fool graph-based detection methods. Challenges and future research directions are discussed at the end of the paper.Comment: Preprint, submitted to ACM Computing Surveys on March 2023. For any suggestions or improvements, please contact me directly by e-mai

Attacks against intrusion detection networks: evasion, reverse engineering and optimal countermeasures

Intrusion Detection Networks (IDNs) constitute a primary element in current cyberdefense systems. IDNs are composed of different nodes distributed among a network infrastructure, performing functions such as local detection --mostly by Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) --, information sharing with other nodes in the IDN, and aggregation and correlation of data from different sources. Overall, they are able to detect distributed attacks taking place at large scale or in different parts of the network simultaneously. IDNs have become themselves target of advanced cyberattacks aimed at bypassing the security barrier they offer and thus gaining control of the protected system. In order to guarantee the security and privacy of the systems being protected and the IDN itself, it is required to design resilient architectures for IDNs capable of maintaining a minimum level of functionality even when certain IDN nodes are bypassed, compromised, or rendered unusable. Research in this field has traditionally focused on designing robust detection algorithms for IDS. However, almost no attention has been paid to analyzing the security of the overall IDN and designing robust architectures for them. This Thesis provides various contributions in the research of resilient IDNs grouped into two main blocks. The first two contributions analyze the security of current proposals for IDS nodes against specific attacks, while the third and fourth contributions provide mechanisms to design IDN architectures that remain resilient in the presence of adversaries. In the first contribution, we propose evasion and reverse engineering attacks to anomaly detectors that use classification algorithms at the core of the detection engine. These algorithms have been widely studied in the anomaly detection field, as they generally are claimed to be both effective and efficient. However, such anomaly detectors do not consider potential behaviors incurred by adversaries to decrease the effectiveness and efficiency of the detection process. We demonstrate that using well-known classification algorithms for intrusion detection is vulnerable to reverse engineering and evasion attacks, which makes these algorithms inappropriate for real systems. The second contribution discusses the security of randomization as a countermeasure to evasion attacks against anomaly detectors. Recent works have proposed the use of secret (random) information to hide the detection surface, thus making evasion harder for an adversary. We propose a reverse engineering attack using a query-response analysis showing that randomization does not provide such security. We demonstrate our attack on Anagram, a popular application-layer anomaly detector based on randomized n-gram analysis. We show how an adversary can _rst discover the secret information used by the detector by querying it with carefully constructed payloads and then use this information to evade the detector. The difficulties found to properly address the security of nodes in an IDN motivate our research to protect cyberdefense systems globally, assuming the possibility of attacks against some nodes and devising ways of allocating countermeasures optimally. In order to do so, it is essential to model both IDN nodes and adversarial capabilities. In the third contribution of this Thesis, we provide a conceptual model for IDNs viewed as a network of nodes whose connections and internal components determine the architecture and functionality of the global defense network. Such a model is based on the analysis and abstraction of a number of existing proposals for IDNs. Furthermore, we also develop an adversarial model for IDNs that builds on classical attack capabilities for communication networks and allow to specify complex attacks against IDN nodes. Finally, the fourth contribution of this Thesis presents DEFIDNET, a framework to assess the vulnerabilities of IDNs, the threats to which they are exposed, and optimal countermeasures to minimize risk considering possible economic and operational constraints. The framework uses the system and adversarial models developed earlier in this Thesis, together with a risk rating procedure that evaluates the propagation of attacks against particular nodes throughout the entire IDN and estimates the impacts of such actions according to different attack strategies. This assessment is then used to search for countermeasures that are both optimal in terms of involved cost and amount of mitigated risk. This is done using multi-objective optimization algorithms, thus offering the analyst sets of solutions that could be applied in different operational scenarios. -------------------------------------------------------------Las Redes de Detección de Intrusiones (IDNs, por sus siglas en inglés) constituyen un elemento primordial de los actuales sistemas de ciberdefensa. Una IDN está compuesta por diferentes nodos distribuidos a lo largo de una infraestructura de red que realizan funciones de detección de ataques --fundamentalmente a través de Sistemas de Detección de Intrusiones, o IDS--, intercambio de información con otros nodos de la IDN, y agregación y correlación de eventos procedentes de distintas fuentes. En conjunto, una IDN es capaz de detectar ataques distribuidos y de gran escala que se manifiestan en diferentes partes de la red simultáneamente. Las IDNs se han convertido en objeto de ataques avanzados cuyo fin es evadir las funciones de seguridad que ofrecen y ganar así control sobre los sistemas protegidos. Con objeto de garantizar la seguridad y privacidad de la infraestructura de red y de la IDN, es necesario diseñar arquitecturas resilientes para IDNs que sean capaces de mantener un nivel mínimo de funcionalidad incluso cuando ciertos nodos son evadidos, comprometidos o inutilizados. La investigación en este campo se ha centrado tradicionalmente en el diseño de algoritmos de detección robustos para IDS. Sin embargo, la seguridad global de la IDN ha recibido considerablemente menos atención, lo que ha resultado en una carencia de principios de diseño para arquitecturas de IDN resilientes. Esta Tesis Doctoral proporciona varias contribuciones en la investigación de IDN resilientes. La investigación aquí presentada se agrupa en dos grandes bloques. Por un lado, las dos primeras contribuciones proporcionan técnicas de análisis de la seguridad de nodos IDS contra ataques deliberados. Por otro lado, las contribuciones tres y cuatro presentan mecanismos de diseño de arquitecturas IDS robustas frente a adversarios. En la primera contribución se proponen ataques de evasión e ingeniería inversa sobre detectores de anomalíaas que utilizan algoritmos de clasificación en el motor de detección. Estos algoritmos han sido ampliamente estudiados en el campo de la detección de anomalías y son generalmente considerados efectivos y eficientes. A pesar de esto, los detectores de anomalías no consideran el papel que un adversario puede desempeñar si persigue activamente decrementar la efectividad o la eficiencia del proceso de detección. En esta Tesis se demuestra que el uso de algoritmos de clasificación simples para la detección de anomalías es, en general, vulnerable a ataques de ingeniería inversa y evasión, lo que convierte a estos algoritmos en inapropiados para sistemas reales. La segunda contribución analiza la seguridad de la aleatorización como contramedida frente a los ataques de evasión contra detectores de anomalías. Esta contramedida ha sido propuesta recientemente como mecanismo de ocultación de la superficie de decisión, lo que supuestamente dificulta la tarea del adversario. En esta Tesis se propone un ataque de ingeniería inversa basado en un análisis consulta-respuesta que demuestra que, en general, la aleatorización no proporciona un nivel de seguridad sustancialmente superior. El ataque se demuestra contra Anagram, un detector de anomalías muy popular basado en el análisis de n-gramas que opera en la capa de aplicación. El ataque permite a un adversario descubrir la información secreta utilizada durante la aleatorización mediante la construcción de paquetes cuidadosamente diseñados. Tras la finalización de este proceso, el adversario se encuentra en disposición de lanzar un ataque de evasión. Los trabajos descritos anteriormente motivan la investigación de técnicas que permitan proteger sistemas de ciberdefensa tales como una IDN incluso cuando la seguridad de algunos de sus nodos se ve comprometida, así como soluciones para la asignación óptima de contramedidas. Para ello, resulta esencial disponer de modelos tanto de los nodos de una IDN como de las capacidades del adversario. En la tercera contribución de esta Tesis se proporcionan modelos conceptuales para ambos elementos. El modelo de sistema permite representar una IDN como una red de nodos cuyas conexiones y componentes internos determinan la arquitectura y funcionalidad de la red global de defensa. Este modelo se basa en el análisis y abstracción de diferentes arquitecturas para IDNs propuestas en los últimos años. Asimismo, se desarrolla un modelo de adversario para IDNs basado en las capacidades clásicas de un atacante en redes de comunicaciones que permite especificar ataques complejos contra nodos de una IDN. Finalmente, la cuarta y última contribución de esta Tesis Doctoral describe DEFIDNET, un marco que permite evaluar las vulnerabilidades de una IDN, las amenazas a las que están expuestas y las contramedidas que permiten minimizar el riesgo de manera óptima considerando restricciones de naturaleza económica u operacional. DEFIDNET se basa en los modelos de sistema y adversario desarrollados anteriormente en esta Tesis, junto con un procedimiento de evaluación de riesgos que permite calcular la propagación a lo largo de la IDN de ataques contra nodos individuales y estimar el impacto de acuerdo a diversas estrategias de ataque. El resultado del análisis de riesgos es utilizado para determinar contramedidas óptimas tanto en términos de coste involucrado como de cantidad de riesgo mitigado. Este proceso hace uso de algoritmos de optimización multiobjetivo y ofrece al analista varios conjuntos de soluciones que podrían aplicarse en distintos escenarios operacionales.Programa en Ciencia y Tecnología InformáticaPresidente: Andrés Marín López; Vocal: Sevil Sen; Secretario: David Camacho Fernánde

Understanding and Detecting Malicious Cyber Infrastructures

Malware (e.g., trojans, bots, and spyware) is still a pervasive threat on the Internet. It is able to infect computer systems to further launch a variety of malicious activities such as sending spam, stealing sensitive information and launching distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) attacks. In order to continue malevolent activities without being detected and to improve the efficiency of malicious activities, cyber-criminals tend to build malicious cyber infrastructures to communicate with their malware and to exploit benign users. In these infrastructures, multiple servers are set to be efficient and anonymous in (i) malware distribution (using redirectors and exploit servers), (ii) control (using C&C servers), (iii) monetization (using payment servers), and (iv) robustness against server takedowns (using multiple backups for each type of server). The most straightforward way to counteract the malware threat is to detect malware directly on infected hosts. However, it is difficult since packing and obfuscation techniques are frequently used by malware to evade state-of-the-art anti-virus tools. Therefore, an alternate solution is to detect and disrupt the malicious cyber infrastructures used by malware. In this dissertation, we take an important step in this direction and focus on identifying malicious servers behind those malicious cyber infrastructures. We present a comprehensive inferring framework to infer servers involved in malicious cyber infrastructure based on the three roles of those servers: compromised server, malicious server accessed through redirection and malicious server accessed through directly connecting. We characterize these three roles from four novel perspectives and demonstrate our detection technologies in four systems: PoisonAmplifier, SMASH, VisHunter and NeighbourWatcher. PoisonAmplifier focuses on compromised servers. It explores the fact that cybercriminals tend to use compromised servers to trick benign users during the attacking process. Therefore, it is designed to proactively find more compromised servers. SMASH focuses on malicious servers accessed through directly connecting. It explores the fact that multiple backups are usually used in malicious cyber infrastructures to avoid server takedowns. Therefore, it leverages the correlation among malicious servers to infer a group of malicious servers. VisHunter focuses on the redirections from compromised servers to malicious servers. It explores the fact that cybercriminals usually conceal their core malicious servers. Therefore, it is designed to detect those “invisible” malicious servers. NeighbourWatcher focuses on all general malicious servers promoted by spammers. It explores the observation that spammers intend to promote some servers (e.g., phishing servers) on the special websites (e.g., forum and wikis) to trick benign users and to improve the reputation of their malicious servers. In short, we build a comprehensive inferring framework to identify servers involved in malicious cyber infrastructures from four novel perspectives and implement different inference techniques in different systems that complement each other. Our inferring framework has been evaluated in live networks and/or real-world network traces. The evaluation results show that it can accurately detect malicious servers involved in malicious cyber infrastructures with a very low false positive rate. We found the three roles of malicious servers we proposed can characterize most of servers involved in malicious cyber infrastructures, and the four principles we developed for the detection are invariable across different malicious cyber infrastructures. We believe our experience and lessons are of great benefit to the future malicious cyber infrastructure study and detection

On Collaborative Intrusion Detection

Cyber-attacks have nowadays become more frightening than ever before. The growing dependency of our society on networked systems aggravates these threats; from interconnected corporate networks and Industrial Control Systems (ICSs) to smart households, the attack surface for the adversaries is increasing. At the same time, it is becoming evident that the utilization of classic fields of security research alone, e.g., cryptography, or the usage of isolated traditional defense mechanisms, e.g., firewalls and Intrusion Detection Systems ( IDSs ), is not enough to cope with the imminent security challenges. To move beyond monolithic approaches and concepts that follow a “cat and mouse” paradigm between the defender and the attacker, cyber-security research requires novel schemes. One such promis- ing approach is collaborative intrusion detection. Driven by the lessons learned from cyber-security research over the years, the aforesaid notion attempts to connect two instinctive questions: “if we acknowledge the fact that no security mechanism can detect all attacks, can we beneficially combine multiple approaches to operate together?” and “as the adversaries increasingly collaborate (e.g., Distributed Denial of Service (DDoS) attacks from whichever larger botnets) to achieve their goals, can the defenders beneficially collude too?”. Collabora- tive intrusion detection attempts to address the emerging security challenges by providing methods for IDSs and other security mech- anisms (e.g., firewalls and honeypots) to combine their knowledge towards generating a more holistic view of the monitored network. This thesis improves the state of the art in collaborative intrusion detection in several areas. In particular, the dissertation proposes methods for the detection of complex attacks and the generation of the corresponding intrusion detection signatures. Moreover, a novel approach for the generation of alert datasets is given, which can assist researchers in evaluating intrusion detection algorithms and systems. Furthermore, a method for the construction of communities of collab- orative monitoring sensors is given, along with a domain-awareness approach that incorporates an efficient data correlation mechanism. With regard to attacks and countermeasures, a detailed methodology is presented that is focusing on sensor-disclosure attacks in the con- text of collaborative intrusion detection. The scientific contributions can be structured into the following categories: Alert data generation: This thesis deals with the topic of alert data generation in a twofold manner: first it presents novel approaches for detecting complex attacks towards generating alert signatures for IDSs ; second a method for the synthetic generation of alert data is pro- posed. In particular, a novel security mechanism for mobile devices is proposed that is able to support users in assessing the security status of their networks. The system can detect sophisticated attacks and generate signatures to be utilized by IDSs . The dissertation also touches the topic of synthetic, yet realistic, dataset generation for the evaluation of intrusion detection algorithms and systems; it proposes a novel dynamic dataset generation concept that overcomes the short- comings of the related work. Collaborative intrusion detection: As a first step, the the- sis proposes a novel taxonomy for collaborative intrusion detection ac- companied with building blocks for Collaborative IDSs ( CIDSs ). More- over, the dissertation deals with the topics of (alert) data correlation and aggregation in the context of CIDSs . For this, a number of novel methods are proposed that aim at improving the clustering of mon- itoring sensors that exhibit similar traffic patterns. Furthermore, a novel alert correlation approach is presented that can minimize the messaging overhead of a CIDS. Attacks on CIDSs: It is common for research on cyber-defense to switch its perspective, taking on the viewpoint of attackers, trying to anticipate their remedies against novel defense approaches. The the- sis follows such an approach by focusing on a certain class of attacks on CIDSs that aim at identifying the network location of the monitor- ing sensors. In particular, the state of the art is advanced by proposing a novel scheme for the improvement of such attacks. Furthermore, the dissertation proposes novel mitigation techniques to overcome both the state of art and the proposed improved attacks. Evaluation: All the proposals and methods introduced in the dis- sertation were evaluated qualitatively, quantitatively and empirically. A comprehensive study of the state of the art in collaborative intru- sion detection was conducted via a qualitative approach, identifying research gaps and surveying the related work. To study the effective- ness of the proposed algorithms and systems extensive simulations were utilized. Moreover, the applicability and usability of some of the contributions in the area of alert data generation was additionally supported via Proof of Concepts (PoCs) and prototypes. The majority of the contributions were published in peer-reviewed journal articles, in book chapters, and in the proceedings of interna- tional conferences and workshops