Understanding and Optimizing Flash-based Key-value Systems in Data Centers

Flash-based key-value systems are widely deployed in today’s data centers for providing high-speed data processing services. These systems deploy flash-friendly data structures, such as slab and Log Structured Merge(LSM) tree, on flash-based Solid State Drives(SSDs) and provide efficient solutions in caching and storage scenarios. With the rapid evolution of data centers, there appear plenty of challenges and opportunities for future optimizations. In this dissertation, we focus on understanding and optimizing flash-based key-value systems from the perspective of workloads, software, and hardware as data centers evolve. We first propose an on-line compression scheme, called SlimCache, considering the unique characteristics of key-value workloads, to virtually enlarge the cache space, increase the hit ratio, and improve the cache performance. Furthermore, to appropriately configure increasingly complex modern key-value data systems, which can have more than 50 parameters with additional hardware and system settings, we quantitatively study and compare five multi-objective optimization methods for auto-tuning the performance of an LSM-tree based key-value store in terms of throughput, the 99th percentile tail latency, convergence time, real-time system throughput, and the iteration process, etc. Last but not least, we conduct an in-depth, comprehensive measurement work on flash-optimized key-value stores with recently emerging 3D XPoint SSDs. We reveal several unexpected bottlenecks in the current key-value store design and present three exemplary case studies to showcase the efficacy of removing these bottlenecks with simple methods on 3D XPoint SSDs. Our experimental results show that our proposed solutions significantly outperform traditional methods. Our study also contributes to providing system implications for auto-tuning the key-value system on flash-based SSDs and optimizing it on revolutionary 3D XPoint based SSDs

Designing systems for emerging memory technologies

Emerging memory technologies open new challenges in system software: diversity and large capacity. Non-volatile memory (NVM) technologies will have excellent performance, byte- addressability, and large capacity, blurring the line between traditional volatile DRAM and non-volatile storage. NVM diverges from DRAM in significant ways, like limited write bandwidth. It is likely that future storage market will be diversified, having DRAM, NVM, SSD, and hard disk. Unfortunately, current file systems, built on top of old design ideas, cannot provide an efficient way to take advantage of the different storage media. Strata is a cross-media file system, fundamentally redesigning file systems to leverage different strengths of storage technologies while compensating their weaknesses. Modern applications such as large-scale machine learning and graph analytics want to load huge datasets into memory for fast computation. For these workloads, merely adding more RAM to a machine reaches a point of diminishing returns for performance because their poor spatial locality causes them to suffer high virtual to physical memory translation costs. NVM will make this problem worse because it provides cheaper cost-per-capacity than DRAM. Ingens, a efficient memory management system, addresses the shortcomings in modern operating systems and hypervisors that underlies these excessive address translation overheads and redesign huge page memory systems to make huge page widely used in practice.Computer Science

Extending Memory Capacity in Consumer Devices with Emerging Non-Volatile Memory: An Experimental Study

The number and diversity of consumer devices are growing rapidly, alongside their target applications' memory consumption. Unfortunately, DRAM scalability is becoming a limiting factor to the available memory capacity in consumer devices. As a potential solution, manufacturers have introduced emerging non-volatile memories (NVMs) into the market, which can be used to increase the memory capacity of consumer devices by augmenting or replacing DRAM. Since entirely replacing DRAM with NVM in consumer devices imposes large system integration and design challenges, recent works propose extending the total main memory space available to applications by using NVM as swap space for DRAM. However, no prior work analyzes the implications of enabling a real NVM-based swap space in real consumer devices. In this work, we provide the first analysis of the impact of extending the main memory space of consumer devices using off-the-shelf NVMs. We extensively examine system performance and energy consumption when the NVM device is used as swap space for DRAM main memory to effectively extend the main memory capacity. For our analyses, we equip real web-based Chromebook computers with the Intel Optane SSD, which is a state-of-the-art low-latency NVM-based SSD device. We compare the performance and energy consumption of interactive workloads running on our Chromebook with NVM-based swap space, where the Intel Optane SSD capacity is used as swap space to extend main memory capacity, against two state-of-the-art systems: (i) a baseline system with double the amount of DRAM than the system with the NVM-based swap space; and (ii) a system where the Intel Optane SSD is naively replaced with a state-of-the-art (yet slower) off-the-shelf NAND-flash-based SSD, which we use as a swap space of equivalent size as the NVM-based swap space

Improving Data Management and Data Movement Efficiency in Hybrid Storage Systems

University of Minnesota Ph.D. dissertation.July 2017. Major: Computer Science. Advisor: David Du. 1 computer file (PDF); ix, 116 pages.In the big data era, large volumes of data being continuously generated drive the emergence of high performance large capacity storage systems. To reduce the total cost of ownership, storage systems are built in a more composite way with many different types of emerging storage technologies/devices including Storage Class Memory (SCM), Solid State Drives (SSD), Shingle Magnetic Recording (SMR), Hard Disk Drives (HDD), and even across off-premise cloud storage. To make better utilization of each type of storage, industries have provided multi-tier storage through dynamically placing hot data in the faster tiers and cold data in the slower tiers. Data movement happens between devices on one single device and as well as between devices connected via various networks. Toward improving data management and data movement efficiency in such hybrid storage systems, this work makes the following contributions: To bridge the giant semantic gap between applications and modern storage systems, passing a piece of tiny and useful information (I/O access hints) from upper layers to the block storage layer may greatly improve application performance or ease data management in heterogeneous storage systems. We present and develop a generic and flexible framework, called HintStor, to execute and evaluate various I/O access hints on heterogeneous storage systems with minor modifications to the kernel and applications. The design of HintStor contains a new application/user level interface, a file system plugin and a block storage data manager. With HintStor, storage systems composed of various storage devices can perform pre-devised data placement, space reallocation and data migration polices assisted by the added access hints. Each storage device/technology has its own unique price-performance tradeoffs and idiosyncrasies with respect to workload characteristics they prefer to support. To explore the internal access patterns and thus efficiently place data on storage systems with fully connected (i.e., data can move from one device to any other device instead of moving tier by tier) differential pools (each pool consists of storage devices of a particular type), we propose a chunk-level storage-aware workload analyzer framework, simplified as ChewAnalyzer. With ChewAnalzyer, the storage manager can adequately distribute and move the data chunks across different storage pools. To reduce the duplicate content transferred between local storage devices and devices in remote data centers, an inline Network Redundancy Elimination (NRE) process with Content-Defined Chunking (CDC) policy can obtain a higher Redundancy Elimination (RE) ratio but may suffer from a considerably higher computational requirement than fixed-size chunking. We build an inline NRE appliance which incorporates an improved FPGA based scheme to speed up CDC processing. To efficiently utilize the hardware resources, the whole NRE process is handled by a Virtualized NRE (VNRE) controller. The uniqueness of this VNRE that we developed lies in its ability to exploit the redundancy patterns of different TCP flows and customize the chunking process to achieve a higher RE ratio

Customized Interfaces for Modern Storage Devices

In the past decade, we have seen two major evolutions on storage technologies: flash storage and non-volatile memory. These storage technologies are both vastly different in their properties and implementations than the disk-based storage devices that current soft- ware stacks and applications have been built for and optimized over several decades. The second major trend that the industry has been witnessing is new classes of applications that are moving away from the conventional ACID (SQL) database access to storage. The resulting new class of NoSQL and in-memory storage applications consume storage using entirely new application programmer interfaces than their predecessors. The most significant outcome given these trends is that there is a great mismatch in terms of both application access interfaces and implementations of storage stacks when consuming these new technologies. In this work, we study the unique, intrinsic properties of current and next-generation storage technologies and propose new interfaces that allow application developers to get the most out of these storage technologies without having to become storage experts them- selves. We first build a new type of NoSQL key-value (KV) store that is FTL-aware rather than flash optimized. Our novel FTL cooperative design for KV store proofed to simplify development and outperformed state of the art KV stores, while reducing write amplification. Next, to address the growing relevance of byte-addressable persistent memory, we build a new type of KV store that is customized and optimized for persistent memory. The resulting KV store illustrates how to program persistent effectively while exposing a simpler interface and performing better than more general solutions. As the final component of the thesis, we build a generic, native storage solution for byte-addressable persistent memory. This new solution provides the most generic interface to applications, allow- ing applications to store and manipulate arbitrarily structured data with strong durability and consistency properties. With this new solution, existing applications as well as new “green field” applications will get to experience native performance and interfaces that are customized for the next storage technology evolution

Evaluating TLB (Translation Lookaside Buffer) Performance Overhead for NVM (non-volatile Memory) Hybrid System

As the non-volatile memory (NVM) technology offers near-DRAM performance and near-disk capacity, NVM has emerged as a new storage class. Conventional file systems, designed for hard disk drives or solid-state drives, need to be re-examined or even re-designed for NVM storage. For example, new file systems such as NOVA, HMFS, HMVFS and Ext4-DAX, have been developed and implemented to fully leverage NVM’s characteristics, such as fast fine-grained access. This thesis research uses a variety of I/O workloads to evaluate the performance overhead of the TLB (translation lookaside buffer) in various file systems on emulated NVM storage systems, in which NVM resides on the memory bus. As NVM’s capacity becomes much greater than DRAM and applications’ footprints continue to increase rapidly, the number of TLB entries scales up with the same pace, leading to a significant amount of TLB misses. The goal of this research is to gain insights into file system optimizations on storage-class memory. Experimental results show that NVM based file systems can have 50% more TLB overhead compare to with conventional file systems, under the same file operations. Profiling based on performance counters show that TLB-friendly journaling/logging should be taken into consideration into future file system design

A differentiated proposal of three dimension i/o performance characterization model focusing on storage environments

The I/O bottleneck remains a central issue in high-performance environments. Cloud computing, high-performance computing (HPC) and big data environments share many underneath difficulties to deliver data at a desirable time rate requested by high-performance applications. This increases the possibility of creating bottlenecks throughout the application feeding process by bottom hardware devices located in the storage system layer. In the last years, many researchers have been proposed solutions to improve the I/O architecture considering different approaches. Some of them take advantage of hardware devices while others focus on a sophisticated software approach. However, due to the complexity of dealing with high-performance environments, creating solutions to improve I/O performance in both software and hardware is challenging and gives researchers many opportunities. Classifying these improvements in different dimensions allows researchers to understand how these improvements have been built over the years and how it progresses. In addition, it also allows future efforts to be directed to research topics that have developed at a lower rate, balancing the general development process. This research present a three-dimension characterization model for classifying research works on I/O performance improvements for large scale storage computing facilities. This classification model can also be used as a guideline framework to summarize researches providing an overview of the actual scenario. We also used the proposed model to perform a systematic literature mapping that covered ten years of research on I/O performance improvements in storage environments. This study classified hundreds of distinct researches identifying which were the hardware, software, and storage systems that received more attention over the years, which were the most researches proposals elements and where these elements were evaluated. In order to justify the importance of this model and the development of solutions that targets I/O performance improvements, we evaluated a subset of these improvements using a a real and complete experimentation environment, the Grid5000. Analysis over different scenarios using a synthetic I/O benchmark demonstrates how the throughput and latency parameters behaves when performing different I/O operations using distinct storage technologies and approaches.O gargalo de E/S continua sendo um problema central em ambientes de alto desempenho. Os ambientes de computação em nuvem, computação de alto desempenho (HPC) e big data compartilham muitas dificuldades para fornecer dados em uma taxa de tempo desejável solicitada por aplicações de alto desempenho. Isso aumenta a possibilidade de criar gargalos em todo o processo de alimentação de aplicativos pelos dispositivos de hardware inferiores localizados na camada do sistema de armazenamento. Nos últimos anos, muitos pesquisadores propuseram soluções para melhorar a arquitetura de E/S considerando diferentes abordagens. Alguns deles aproveitam os dispositivos de hardware, enquanto outros se concentram em uma abordagem sofisticada de software. No entanto, devido à complexidade de lidar com ambientes de alto desempenho, criar soluções para melhorar o desempenho de E/S em software e hardware é um desafio e oferece aos pesquisadores muitas oportunidades. A classificação dessas melhorias em diferentes dimensões permite que os pesquisadores entendam como essas melhorias foram construídas ao longo dos anos e como elas progridem. Além disso, também permite que futuros esforços sejam direcionados para tópicos de pesquisa que se desenvolveram em menor proporção, equilibrando o processo geral de desenvolvimento. Esta pesquisa apresenta um modelo de caracterização tridimensional para classificar trabalhos de pesquisa sobre melhorias de desempenho de E/S para instalações de computação de armazenamento em larga escala. Esse modelo de classificação também pode ser usado como uma estrutura de diretrizes para resumir as pesquisas, fornecendo uma visão geral do cenário real. Também usamos o modelo proposto para realizar um mapeamento sistemático da literatura que abrangeu dez anos de pesquisa sobre melhorias no desempenho de E/S em ambientes de armazenamento. Este estudo classificou centenas de pesquisas distintas, identificando quais eram os dispositivos de hardware, software e sistemas de armazenamento que receberam mais atenção ao longo dos anos, quais foram os elementos de proposta mais pesquisados e onde esses elementos foram avaliados. Para justificar a importância desse modelo e o desenvolvimento de soluções que visam melhorias no desempenho de E/S, avaliamos um subconjunto dessas melhorias usando um ambiente de experimentação real e completo, o Grid5000. Análises em cenários diferentes usando um benchmark de E/S sintética demonstra como os parâmetros de vazão e latência se comportam ao executar diferentes operações de E/S usando tecnologias e abordagens distintas de armazenamento

Modern computing: Vision and challenges

Over the past six decades, the computing systems field has experienced significant transformations, profoundly impacting society with transformational developments, such as the Internet and the commodification of computing. Underpinned by technological advancements, computer systems, far from being static, have been continuously evolving and adapting to cover multifaceted societal niches. This has led to new paradigms such as cloud, fog, edge computing, and the Internet of Things (IoT), which offer fresh economic and creative opportunities. Nevertheless, this rapid change poses complex research challenges, especially in maximizing potential and enhancing functionality. As such, to maintain an economical level of performance that meets ever-tighter requirements, one must understand the drivers of new model emergence and expansion, and how contemporary challenges differ from past ones. To that end, this article investigates and assesses the factors influencing the evolution of computing systems, covering established systems and architectures as well as newer developments, such as serverless computing, quantum computing, and on-device AI on edge devices. Trends emerge when one traces technological trajectory, which includes the rapid obsolescence of frameworks due to business and technical constraints, a move towards specialized systems and models, and varying approaches to centralized and decentralized control. This comprehensive review of modern computing systems looks ahead to the future of research in the field, highlighting key challenges and emerging trends, and underscoring their importance in cost-effectively driving technological progress

Exploiting intrinsic flash properties to enhance modern storage systems

The longstanding goals of storage system design have been to provide simple abstractions for applications to efficiently access data while ensuring the data durability and security on a hardware device. The traditional storage system, which was designed for slow hard disk drive with little parallelism, does not fit for the new storage technologies such as the faster flash memory with high internal parallelism. The gap between the storage system software and flash device causes both resource inefficiency and sub-optimal performance. This dissertation focuses on the rethinking of the storage system design for flash memory with a holistic approach from the system level to the device level and revisits several critical aspects of the storage system design including the storage performance, performance isolation, energy-efficiency, and data security. The traditional storage system lacks full performance isolation between applications sharing the device because it does not make the software aware of the underlying flash properties and constraints. This dissertation proposes FlashBlox, a storage virtualization system that utilizes flash parallelism to provide hardware isolation between applications by assigning them on dedicated chips. FlashBlox reduces the tail latency of storage operations dramatically compared with the existing software-based isolation techniques while achieving uniform lifetime for the flash device. As the underlying flash device latency is reduced significantly compared to the conventional hard disk drive, the storage software overhead has become the major bottleneck. This dissertation presents FlashMap, a holistic flash-based storage stack that combines memory, storage and device-level indirections into a unified layer. By combining these layers, FlashMap reduces critical-path latency for accessing data in the flash device and improves DRAM caching efficiency significantly for flash management. The traditional storage software incurs energy-intensive storage operations due to the need for maintaining data durability and security for personal data, which has become a significant challenge for resource-constrained devices such as mobiles and wearables. This dissertation proposes WearDrive, a fast and energy-efficient storage system for wearables. WearDrive treats the battery-backed DRAM as non-volatile memory to store personal data and trades the connected phone’s battery for the wearable’s by performing large and energy-intensive tasks on the phone while performing small and energy-efficient tasks locally using battery-backed DRAM. WearDrive improves wearable’s battery life significantly with negligible impact to the phone’s battery life. The storage software which has been developed for decades is still vulnerable to malware attacks. For example, the encryption ransomware which is a malicious software that stealthily encrypts user files and demands a ransom to provide access to these files. Prior solutions such as ransomware detection and data backups have been proposed to defend against encryption ransomware. Unfortunately, by the time the ransomware is detected, some files already undergo encryption and the user is still required to pay a ransom to access those files. Furthermore, ransomware variants can obtain kernel privilege to terminate or destroy these software-based defense systems. This dissertation presents FlashGuard, a ransomware-tolerant SSD which has a firmware-level recovery system that allows effective data recovery from encryption ransomware. FlashGuard leverages the intrinsic flash properties to defend against the encryption ransomware and adds minimal overhead to regular storage operations.Ph.D