Precedence-constrained scheduling problems parameterized by partial order width

Negatively answering a question posed by Mnich and Wiese (Math. Program. 154(1-2):533-562), we show that P2|prec,$p_j{\in}\{1,2\}$|$C_{\max}$, the problem of finding a non-preemptive minimum-makespan schedule for precedence-constrained jobs of lengths 1 and 2 on two parallel identical machines, is W[2]-hard parameterized by the width of the partial order giving the precedence constraints. To this end, we show that Shuffle Product, the problem of deciding whether a given word can be obtained by interleaving the letters of $k$ other given words, is W[2]-hard parameterized by $k$, thus additionally answering a question posed by Rizzi and Vialette (CSR 2013). Finally, refining a geometric algorithm due to Servakh (Diskretn. Anal. Issled. Oper. 7(1):75-82), we show that the more general Resource-Constrained Project Scheduling problem is fixed-parameter tractable parameterized by the partial order width combined with the maximum allowed difference between the earliest possible and factual starting time of a job.Comment: 14 pages plus appendi

On the relationships between linear extensions and multiprocessor scheduling.

Scheduling is a classical field with many challenging problems and interesting results. A scheduling problem emerges wherever there is a choice as to the order in which a number of tasks can be performed and/or the assignment of the tasks to the available resources for processing . In this thesis, we focus on a version of the scheduling problem that deals with scheduling precedence constrained tasks onto the multi processors of a given distributed system with the goal of minimizing the schedule time. This scheduling problem has been proven to be NP-hard even when several restrictions are applied. This implies that an optimal and efficient solution for solving the problem is not likely to exist. Therefore, researchers in this field have been focusing their attention on solving very special versions of the problem or developing fast heuristics for solving the problem in general. In this work, we propose a new approach for developing a scheduling heuristic that is based on a theoretical foundation. Since precedence constrained tasks can be modeled by a partially ordered set, known results from the field of partial orders can be used to solve the scheduling problem. In particular, we look into another scheduling problem, known as the jump number problem in partially ordered sets, to provide a helpful tool in developing a new scheduling heuristic. Given a partially ordered set there exist several efficient, and optimal, algorithms for finding a linear extension of the tasks with the maximum number of unrelated consecutive tasks. Since the order of tasks in such a linear extension explore the independence relations among the tasks, we propose to use this order in a priority-based scheduling algorithm. We then study the relationship between the characteristic of the linear extension and the length of the scheduling algorithm and one of the frequently used algorithms will be conducted. Randomly generated partial orders that represent precedence constrained tasks will be used to test the developed algorithms and measure their performance

Resource-constrained project scheduling.

Abstract: Resource-constrained project scheduling involves the scheduling of project activities subject to precedence and resource constraints in order to meet the objective(s) in the best possible way. The area covers a wide variety of problem types. The objective of this paper is to provide a survey of what we believe are important recent in the area . Our main focus will be on the recent progress made in and the encouraging computational experience gained with the use of optimal solution procedures for the basic resource-constrained project scheduling problem (RCPSP) and important extensions. The RCPSP involves the scheduling of a project its duration subject to zero-lag finish-start precedence constraints of the PERT/CPM type and constant availability constraints on the required set of renewable resources. We discuss recent striking advances in dealing with this problem using a new depth-first branch-and-bound procedure, elaborating on the effective and efficient branching scheme, bounding calculations and dominance rules, and discuss the potential of using truncated branch-and-bound. We derive a set of conclusions from the research on optimal solution procedures for the basis RCPSP and subsequently illustrate how effective and efficient branching rules and several of the strong dominance and bounding arguments can be extended to a rich and realistic variety of related problems. The preemptive resource-constrained project scheduling problem (PRCPSP) relaxes the nonpreemption condition of the RCPSP, thus allowing activities to be interrupted at integer points in time and resumed later without additional penalty cost. The generalized resource-constrained project scheduling (GRCPSP) extends the RCPSP to the case of precedence diagramming type of precedence constraints (minimal finish-start, start-start, start-finish, finish-finish precedence relations), activity ready times, deadlines and variable resource availability's. The resource-constrained project scheduling problem with generalized precedence relations (RCPSP-GPR) allows for start-start, finish-start and finish-finish constraints with minimal and maximal time lags. The MAX-NPV problem aims at scheduling project activities in order to maximize the net present value of the project in the absence of resource constraints. The resource-constrained project scheduling problem with discounted cash flows (RCPSP-DC) aims at the same non-regular objective in the presence of resource constraints. The resource availability cost problem (RACP) aims at determining the cheapest resource availability amounts for which a feasible solution exists that does not violate the project deadline. In the discrete time/cost trade-off problem (DTCTP) the duration of an activity is a discrete, non-increasing function of the amount of a single nonrenewable resource committed to it. In the discrete time/resource trade-off problem (DTRTP) the duration of an activity is a discrete, non-increasing function of the amount of a single renewable resource. Each activity must then be scheduled in one of its possible execution modes. In addition to time/resource trade-offs, the multi-mode project scheduling problem (MRCPSP) allows for resource/resource trade-offs and constraints on renewable, nonrenewable and doubly-constrained resources. We report on recent computational results and end with overall conclusions and suggestions for future research.Scheduling; Optimal;

Algorithms for scheduling projects with generalized precedence relations.

Project scheduling under the assumption of renewable resource constraints and generalized precedence relations, i.e. arbitrary minimal and maximal time lags between the starting and completion times of the activities of the project, constitutes an important and challenging problem. Over the past few years considerable progress has been made in the use of exact solution procedure for this problem type and its variants. We review the fundamental logic and report new computational experience with a branch-and-bound procedure for optimally solving resource-constrained project scheduling problems with generalized precedence relations of the precedence diagramming type, i.e. start-start, start-finish, finish-start and finish-finish relations with minimal time lags for minimizing the project makespan. Subsequently, we review and report new results for several branch-and -bound procedures for the case of generalized precedence relations, including both minimal and maximal time lags, and demonstrate how the solution methodology can be expected to cope with other regular and nonregular objective functions such a smaximizing the net present value of a project.Networks; Problems; Scheduling; Algorithms; Functions; Net present value;

How the structure of precedence constraints may change the complexity class of scheduling problems

This survey aims at demonstrating that the structure of precedence constraints plays a tremendous role on the complexity of scheduling problems. Indeed many problems can be NP-hard when considering general precedence constraints, while they become polynomially solvable for particular precedence constraints. We also show that there still are many very exciting challenges in this research area

An optimal procedure for the resource-constrained project scheduling problem with discounted cash flows and generalized precedence relations.

In this paper, we study the resource-constrained project scheduling problem (RCPSP) with discounted cash flows and generalized precedence relations (further denoted as RCPSPDC-GPR). The RCPSPDC-GPR extends the RCPSP to (a) arbitrary minimal and maximal time lags between the starting and completion times of activities and (b) the non-regular objective function of maximizing the net present value of the project with positive and/or negative cash flows associated with the activities.). To the best of our knowledge, the literature on the RCPSPDC-GPR is completely void. We present a depth-first branch-and-bound algorithm in which the nodes in the search tree represent the original project network extended with extra precedence relations which resolve a number of resource conflicts. These conflicts are resolved using the concept of a minimal delaying mode (De Reyck and Herroelen, 1996b). An upper bound on the project net present value as well as several dominance rules are used to fathom large portions of the search tree. Extensive computational experience on a randomly generated benchmark problem set is obtained.Scheduling; Optimal; Discounted cash flow; Cash flow;

An optimal procedure for the unconstrained max-NPV project scheduling problem with generalized precedence relations.

The unconstrained max-npv project scheduling problem involves the scheduling of the activities of a project in order to maximize its net present value. Assume a project represented in activity-on-mode (AoN) notation, in which the activities have a known duration and are subject to technological precedence constraints. Throughout each activity, a series of cash outflows and receipts may occur, which allows for the computation of a terminal cash flow value (positive or negative) upon the completion. The project is to be scheduled against a fixed deadline in the absence of resource constraints. Several procedures have been presented in the literature to cope with this problem. In this paper, we describe how one of the most efficient optimal procedures can be adapted to cope with generalized precedence relations, which introduce arbitrary minimal and maximal time lags between the start and completion of activities. The procedure has been programmed in Microsoft° Visual ++ 2.0 under Windows NT for use on a personal computer. Extensive computational results are reported.Scheduling; Optimal;

Time-constrained project scheduling

We study the Time-Constrained Project Scheduling Problem (TCPSP), in which the scheduling of activities is subject to strict deadlines. To be able to meet these deadlines, it is possible to work in overtime or hire additional capacity in regular time or overtime. For this problem, we develop a two stage heuristic. The key of our approach lies in the first stage in which we construct partial schedules with a randomized sampling technique. In these partial schedules, jobs may be scheduled for a shorter duration than required. The second stage uses an ILP formulation of the problem to turn a partial schedule into a feasible schedule, and to perform a neighbourhood search. The developed heuristic is quite flexible and, therefore, suitable for practice. We present experimental results on modified RCPSP benchmark instances. The two stage heuristic solves many instances to optimality, and if we substantially decrease the deadline, the rise in cost is only small