Solving the waste collection problem from a multiobjective perspective: New methodologies and case studies

Fecha de lectura Tesis Doctoral: 19 de marzo de 2018.Economía Aplicada ( Matemáticas) Resumen tesis: El tratamiento de residuos es un tema de estudio por parte de las administraciones locales a nivel mundial. Distintos factores han de tenerse en cuenta para realizar un servicio eficiente. En este trabajo se desarrolla una herramienta para analizar y resolver el problema de la recogida de residuos sólidos en Málaga. Tras un análisis exhaustivo de los datos, se aborda el problema real como un problema de rutas multiobjetivo con capacidad limitada. Para los problemas multiobjetivo, no suele existir una única solución óptima, sino un conjunto de soluciones eficientes de Pareto. Las características del problema hacen inviable su resolución de forma exacta, por lo que se aplican distintas estrategias metaheurísticas para obtener una buena aproximación. En particular, se combinan las técnicas de GRASP, Path Relinking y Variable Neighborhood Search, que son adaptadas a la perspectiva multicriterio. Se trata de una aproximación en dos fases: una primera aproximación de la frontera eficiente se genera mediante un GRASP multiobjetivo. Tres son los métodos propuestos para la primera aproximación, dos de ellos derivados de la publicación de Martí et al. (2015) y el último se apoya en la función escalarizada de logro de Wierzbicki (Wierzbicki, 1980) para distintas combinaciones de pesos. A continuación, esta aproximación es mejorada con una versión de Path Relinking o Variable Neighborhood Search, con un punto de referencia diseñado para problemas multiobjetivo. Una vez generada la aproximación de la frontera eficiente, el proceso de obtención de la solución que más se adecúa a las preferencias de los gestores se basa en el desarrollo de un método interactivo sin trade – off, derivado de la filosofía NAUTILUS (Miettinen et al. 2010). Para evitar gastos de cómputo extensos, esta metodología se apoya en una pre - computación de los elementos de la frontera eficiente

Toward an estimation of nadir objective vector using a hybrid of evolutionary and local search approaches

A nadir objective vector is constructed from the worst Pareto-optimal objective values in a multiobjective optimization problem and is an important entity to compute because of its significance in estimating the range of objective values in the Pareto-optimal front and also in executing a number of interactive multiobjective optimization techniques. Along with the ideal objective vector, it is also needed for the purpose of normalizing different objectives, so as to facilitate a comparison and agglomeration of the objectives. However, the task of estimating the nadir objective vector necessitates information about the complete Pareto-optimal front and has been reported to be a difficult task, and importantly an unsolved and open research issue. In this paper, we propose certain modifications to an existing evolutionary multiobjective optimization procedure to focus its search toward the extreme objective values and combine it with a reference-point based local search approach to constitute a couple of hybrid procedures for a reliable estimation of the nadir objective vector. With up to 20-objective optimization test problems and on a three-objective engineering design optimization problem, one of the proposed procedures is found to be capable of finding the nadir objective vector reliably. The study clearly shows the significance of an evolutionary computing based search procedure in assisting to solve an age-old important task in the field of multiobjective optimization

A hybrid integrated multi-objective optimization procedure for estimating nadir point

A nadir point is constructed by the worst objective values of the solutions of the entire Pareto-optimal set. Along with the ideal point, the nadir point provides the range of objective values within which all Pareto-optimal solutions must lie. Thus, a nadir point is an important point to researchers and practitioners interested in multi-objective optimization. Besides, if the nadir point can be computed relatively quickly, it can be used to normalize objectives in many multi-criterion decision making tasks. Importantly, estimating the nadir point is a challenging and unsolved computing problem in case of more than two objectives. In this paper, we revise a previously proposed serial application of an EMO and a local search method and suggest an integrated approach for finding the nadir point. A local search procedure based on the solution of a bi-level achievement scalarizing function is employed to extreme solutions in stabilized populations in an EMO procedure. Simulation results on a number of problems demonstrate the viability and working of the proposed procedure

Understanding Complexity in Multiobjective Optimization

This report documents the program and outcomes of the Dagstuhl Seminar 15031 Understanding Complexity in Multiobjective Optimization. This seminar carried on the series of four previous Dagstuhl Seminars (04461, 06501, 09041 and 12041) that were focused on Multiobjective Optimization, and strengthening the links between the Evolutionary Multiobjective Optimization (EMO) and Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) communities. The purpose of the seminar was to bring together researchers from the two communities to take part in a wide-ranging discussion about the different sources and impacts of complexity in multiobjective optimization. The outcome was a clarified viewpoint of complexity in the various facets of multiobjective optimization, leading to several research initiatives with innovative approaches for coping with complexity

Initialization of a Multi-objective Evolutionary Algorithms Knowledge Acquisition System for Renewable Energy Power Plants

pp. 185-204The design of Renewable Energy Power Plants (REPPs) is crucial not only for the investments' performance and attractiveness measures, but also for the maximization of resource (source) usage (e.g. sun, water, and wind) and the minimization of raw materials (e.g. aluminum: Al, cadmium: Cd, iron: Fe, silicon: Si, and tellurium: Te) consumption. Hence, several appropriate and satisfactory Multi-objective Problems (MOPs) are mandatory during the REPPs' design phases. MOPs related tasks can only be managed by very well organized knowledge acquisition on all REPPs' design equations and models. The proposed MOPs need to be solved with one or more multiobjective algorithm, such as Multi-objective Evolutionary Algorithms (MOEAs). In this respect, the first aim of this research study is to start gathering knowledge on the REPPs' MOPs. The second aim of this study is to gather detailed information about all MOEAs and available free software tools for their development. The main contribution of this research is the initialization of a proposed multi-objective evolutionary algorithm knowledge acquisition system for renewable energy power plants (MOEAs-KAS-FREPPs) (research and development loopwise process: develop, train, validate, improve, test, improve, operate, and improve). As a simple representative example of this knowledge acquisition system research with two selective and elective proposed standard objectives (as test objectives) and eight selective and elective proposed standard constraints (as test constraints) are generated and applied as a standardized MOP for a virtual small hydropower plant design and investment. The maximization of energy generation (MWh) and the minimization of initial investment cost (million €) are achieved by the Multi-objective Genetic Algorithm (MOGA), the Niched Sharing Genetic Algorithm/Non-dominated Sorting Genetic Algorithm (NSGA-I), and the NSGA-II algorithms in the Scilab 6.0.0 as only three standardized MOEAs amongst all proposed standardized MOEAs on two desktop computer configurations (Windows 10 Home 1709 64 bits, Intel i5-7200 CPU @ 2.7 GHz, 8.00 GB RAM with internet connection and Windows 10 Pro, Intel(R) Core(TM) i5 CPU 650 @ 3.20 GHz, 6,00 GB RAM with internet connection). The algorithm run-times (computation time) of the current applications vary between 20.64 and 59.98 seconds.S

Application of multiobjective optimization concepts in inverse radiotherapy planning

Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT) belongs to the most advanced techniques in cancer treatment. Due to the large number of degrees of freedom the inverse problem of IMRT is formulated as a scalar optimization problem. The conventional scalarization approach of the objective function represents an a priori trade-off between the planning goals and can lead to time consuming planning process. New multiobjective approaches try to overcome the difficulties by a precalculation of a set of Pareto optimal treatment plans from which the planner can subsequently choose the best suited plan. In this work we evaluate a new multiobjective treatment planning system. We investigate three different generalized equivalent uniform dose (gEUD) based modeling approaches and study the sensitivities of the corresponding model parameters. Quality measures for entire Pareto optimal databases are developed and applied to clincal cases. In retrospective planning studies we show that the new system is compatible with a clinical reference treatment planning system and that the total planning time for prostate cases can be significantly reduced. In the last part we develop a method to detect the imperative trade-offs in a plan database and apply techniques from linear as well as non-linear dimensionality reduction. They allow meaningful visualizations of high dimensional Pareto fronts and an insight into the underlying trade-offs between the planning goals

A Hybrid Integrated Multi-Objective Optimization Procedure for Estimating Nadir Point

Abstract. A nadir point is constructed by the worst objective values of the solutions of the entire Pareto-optimal set. Along with the ideal point, the nadir point provides the range of objective values within which all Pareto-optimal solutions must lie. Thus, a nadir point is an important point to researchers and practitioners interested in multi-objective optimization. Besides, if the nadir point can be computed relatively quickly, it can be used to normalize objectives in many multi-criterion decision making tasks. Importantly, estimating the nadir point is a challenging and unsolved computing problem in case of more than two objectives. In this paper, we revise a previously proposed serial application of an EMO and a local search method and suggest an integrated approach for finding the nadir point. A local search procedure based on the solution of a bi-level achievement scalarizing function is employed to extreme solutions in stabilized populations in an EMO procedure. Simulation results on a number of problems demonstrate the viability and working of the proposed procedure