Application of MFBD Algorithms to Image Reconstruction Under Anisoplanatic Conditions

All optical systems that operate in or through the atmosphere suffer from turbulence induced image blur. Both military and civilian surveillance, gun-sighting, and target identification systems are interested in terrestrial imaging over very long horizontal paths, but atmospheric turbulence can blur the resulting images beyond usefulness. My dissertation explores the performance of a multi-frame-blind-deconvolution technique applied under anisoplanatic conditions for both Gaussian and Poisson noise model assumptions. The technique is evaluated for use in reconstructing images of scenes corrupted by turbulence in long horizontal-path imaging scenarios and compared to other speckle imaging techniques. Performance is evaluated via the reconstruction of a common object from three sets of simulated turbulence degraded imagery representing low, moderate and severe turbulence conditions. Each set consisted of 1000 simulated, turbulence degraded images. The MSE performance of the estimator is evaluated as a function of the number of images, and the number of Zernike polynomial terms used to characterize the point spread function. I will compare the mean-square-error (MSE) performance of speckle imaging methods and a maximum-likelihood, multi-frame blind deconvolution (MFBD) method applied to long-path horizontal imaging scenarios. Both methods are used to reconstruct a scene from simulated imagery featuring anisoplanatic turbulence induced aberrations. This comparison is performed over three sets of 1000 simulated images each for low, moderate and severe turbulence-induced image degradation. The comparison shows that speckle-imaging techniques reduce the MSE 46 percent, 42 percent and 47 percent on average for low, moderate, and severe cases, respectively using 15 input frames under daytime conditions and moderate frame rates. Similarly, the MFBD method provides, 40 percent, 29 percent, and 36 percent improvements in MSE on average under the same conditions. The comparison is repeated under low light conditions (less than 100 photons per pixel) where improvements of 39 percent, 29 percent and 27 percent are available using speckle imaging methods and 25 input frames and 38 percent, 34 percent and 33 percent respectively for the MFBD method and 150 input frames. The MFBD estimator is applied to three sets of field data and the results presented. Finally, a combined Bispectrum-MFBD Hybrid estimator is proposed and investigated. This technique consistently provides a lower MSE and smaller variance in the estimate under all three simulated turbulence conditions

Polarimeter Blind Deconvolution Using Image Diversity

This research presents an algorithm that improves the ability to view objects using an electro-optical imaging system with at least one polarization sensitive channel in addition to the primary channel. An innovative algorithm for detection and estimation of the defocus aberration present in an image is also developed. Using a known defocus aberration, an iterative polarimeter deconvolution algorithm is developed using a generalized expectation-maximization (GEM) model. The polarimeter deconvolution algorithm is extended to an iterative polarimeter multiframe blind deconvolution (PMFBD) algorithm with an unknown aberration. Using both simulated and laboratory images, the results of the new PMFBD algorithm clearly outperforms an RL-based MFBD algorithm. The convergence rate is significantly faster with better fidelity of reproduction of the targets. Clearly, leveraging polarization data in electro-optical imaging systems has the potential to significantly improve the ability to resolve objects and, thus, improve Space Situation Awareness

Inverse problems in astronomical and general imaging

The resolution and the quality of an imaged object are limited by four contributing factors. Firstly, the primary resolution limit of a system is imposed by the aperture of an instrument due to the effects of diffraction. Secondly, the finite sampling frequency, the finite measurement time and the mechanical limitations of the equipment also affect the resolution of the images captured. Thirdly, the images are corrupted by noise, a process inherent to all imaging systems. Finally, a turbulent imaging medium introduces random degradations to the signals before they are measured. In astronomical imaging, it is the atmosphere which distorts the wavefronts of the objects, severely limiting the resolution of the images captured by ground-based telescopes. These four factors affect all real imaging systems to varying degrees. All the limitations imposed on an imaging system result in the need to deduce or reconstruct the underlying object distribution from the distorted measured data. This class of problems is called inverse problems. The key to the success of solving an inverse problem is the correct modelling of the physical processes which give rise to the corresponding forward problem. However, the physical processes have an infinite amount of information, but only a finite number of parameters can be used in the model. Information loss is therefore inevitable. As a result, the solution to many inverse problems requires additional information or prior knowledge. The application of prior information to inverse problems is a recurrent theme throughout this thesis. An inverse problem that has been an active research area for many years is interpolation, and there exist numerous techniques for solving this problem. However, many of these techniques neither account for the sampling process of the instrument nor include prior information in the reconstruction. These factors are taken into account in the proposed optimal Bayesian interpolator. The process of interpolation is also examined from the point of view of superresolution, as these processes can be viewed as being complementary. Since the principal effect of atmospheric turbulence on an incoming wavefront is a phase distortion, most of the inverse problem techniques devised for this seek to either estimate or compensate for this phase component. These techniques are classified into computer post-processing methods, adaptive optics (AO) and hybrid techniques. Blind deconvolution is a post-processing technique which uses the speckle images to estimate both the object distribution and the point spread function (PSF), the latter of which is directly related to the phase. The most successful approaches are based on characterising the PSF as the aberrations over the aperture. Since the PSF is also dependent on the atmosphere, it is possible to constrain the solution using the statistics of the atmosphere. An investigation shows the feasibility of this approach. Bispectrum is also a post-processing method which reconstructs the spectrum of the object. The key component for phase preservation is the property of phase closure, and its application as prior information for blind deconvolution is examined. Blind deconvolution techniques utilise only information in the image channel to estimate the phase which is difficult. An alternative method for phase estimation is from a Shack-Hartmann (SH) wavefront sensing channel. However, since phase information is present in both the wavefront sensing and the image channels simultaneously, both of these approaches suffer from the problem that phase information from only one channel is used. An improved estimate of the phase is achieved by a combination of these methods, ensuring that the phase estimation is made jointly from the data in both the image and the wavefront sensing measurements. This formulation, posed as a blind deconvolution framework, is investigated in this thesis. An additional advantage of this approach is that since speckle images are imaged in a narrowband, while wavefront sensing images are captured by a charge-coupled device (CCD) camera at all wavelengths, the splitting of the light does not compromise the light level for either channel. This provides a further incentive for using simultaneous data sets. The effectiveness of using Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensing data for phase estimation relies on the accuracy of locating the data spots. The commonly used method which calculates the centre of gravity of the image is in fact prone to noise and is suboptimal. An improved method for spot location based on blind deconvolution is demonstrated. Ground-based adaptive optics (AO) technologies aim to correct for atmospheric turbulence in real time. Although much success has been achieved, the space- and time-varying nature of the atmosphere renders the accurate measurement of atmospheric properties difficult. It is therefore usual to perform additional post-processing on the AO data. As a result, some of the techniques developed in this thesis are applicable to adaptive optics. One of the methods which utilise elements of both adaptive optics and post-processing is the hybrid technique of deconvolution from wavefront sensing (DWFS). Here, both the speckle images and the SH wavefront sensing data are used. The original proposal of DWFS is simple to implement but suffers from the problem where the magnitude of the object spectrum cannot be reconstructed accurately. The solution proposed for overcoming this is to use an additional set of reference star measurements. This however does not completely remove the original problem; in addition it introduces other difficulties associated with reference star measurements such as anisoplanatism and reduction of valuable observing time. In this thesis a parameterised solution is examined which removes the need for a reference star, as well as offering a potential to overcome the problem of estimating the magnitude of the object

Blind image deconvolution: nonstationary Bayesian approaches to restoring blurred photos

High quality digital images have become pervasive in modern scientific and everyday life — in areas from photography to astronomy, CCTV, microscopy, and medical imaging. However there are always limits to the quality of these images due to uncertainty and imprecision in the measurement systems. Modern signal processing methods offer the promise of overcoming some of these problems by postprocessing these blurred and noisy images. In this thesis, novel methods using nonstationary statistical models are developed for the removal of blurs from out of focus and other types of degraded photographic images. The work tackles the fundamental problem blind image deconvolution (BID); its goal is to restore a sharp image from a blurred observation when the blur itself is completely unknown. This is a “doubly illposed” problem — extreme lack of information must be countered by strong prior constraints about sensible types of solution. In this work, the hierarchical Bayesian methodology is used as a robust and versatile framework to impart the required prior knowledge. The thesis is arranged in two parts. In the first part, the BID problem is reviewed, along with techniques and models for its solution. Observation models are developed, with an emphasis on photographic restoration, concluding with a discussion of how these are reduced to the common linear spatially-invariant (LSI) convolutional model. Classical methods for the solution of illposed problems are summarised to provide a foundation for the main theoretical ideas that will be used under the Bayesian framework. This is followed by an indepth review and discussion of the various prior image and blur models appearing in the literature, and then their applications to solving the problem with both Bayesian and nonBayesian techniques. The second part covers novel restoration methods, making use of the theory presented in Part I. Firstly, two new nonstationary image models are presented. The first models local variance in the image, and the second extends this with locally adaptive noncausal autoregressive (AR) texture estimation and local mean components. These models allow for recovery of image details including edges and texture, whilst preserving smooth regions. Most existing methods do not model the boundary conditions correctly for deblurring of natural photographs, and a Chapter is devoted to exploring Bayesian solutions to this topic. Due to the complexity of the models used and the problem itself, there are many challenges which must be overcome for tractable inference. Using the new models, three different inference strategies are investigated: firstly using the Bayesian maximum marginalised a posteriori (MMAP) method with deterministic optimisation; proceeding with the stochastic methods of variational Bayesian (VB) distribution approximation, and simulation of the posterior distribution using the Gibbs sampler. Of these, we find the Gibbs sampler to be the most effective way to deal with a variety of different types of unknown blurs. Along the way, details are given of the numerical strategies developed to give accurate results and to accelerate performance. Finally, the thesis demonstrates state of the art results in blind restoration of synthetic and real degraded images, such as recovering details in out of focus photographs