Cache Related Pre-emption Delays in Embedded Real-Time Systems

Real-time systems are subject to stringent deadlines which make their temporal behaviour just as important as their functional behaviour. In multi-tasking real-time systems, the execution time of each task must be determined, and then combined together with information about the scheduling policy to ensure that there are enough resources to schedule all of the tasks. This is usually achieved by performing timing analysis on the individual tasks, and then schedulability analysis on the system as a whole. In systems with cache, multiple tasks can share this common resource which can lead to cache-related pre-emption delays (CRPD) being introduced. CRPD is the additional cost incurred from resuming a pre-empted task that no longer has the instructions or data it was using in cache, because the pre-empting task(s) evicted them from cache. It is therefore important to be able to account for CRPD when performing schedulability analysis. This thesis focuses on the effects of CRPD on a single processor system, further expanding our understanding of CRPD and ability to analyse and optimise for it. We present new CRPD analysis for Earliest Deadline First (EDF) scheduling that significantly outperforms existing analysis, and then perform the first comparison between Fixed Priority (FP) and EDF accounting for CRPD. In this comparison, we explore the effects of CRPD across a wide range of system and taskset parameters. We introduce a new task layout optimisation technique that maximises system schedulability via reduced CRPD. Finally, we extend CRPD analysis to hierarchical systems, allowing the effects of cache when scheduling multiple independent applications on a single processor to be analysed

On the effectiveness of cache partitioning in hard real-time systems

In hard real-time systems, cache partitioning is often suggested as a means of increasing the predictability of caches in pre-emptively scheduled systems: when a task is assigned its own cache partition, inter-task cache eviction is avoided, and timing verification is reduced to the standard worst-case execution time analysis used in non-pre-emptive systems. The downside of cache partitioning is the potential increase in execution times. In this paper, we evaluate cache partitioning for hard real-time systems in terms of overall schedulability. To this end, we examine the sensitivity of (i) task execution times and (ii) pre-emption costs to the size of the cache partition allocated and present a cache partitioning algorithm that is optimal with respect to taskset schedulability. We also devise an alternative algorithm which primarily optimises schedulability but also minimises processor utilization. We evaluate the performance of cache partitioning compared to state-of-the-art pre-emption cost analysis based on benchmark code and on a large number of synthetic tasksets with both fixed priority and EDF scheduling. This allows us to derive general conclusions about the usability of cache partitioning and identify taskset and system parameters that influence the relative effectiveness of cache partitioning. We also examine the improvement in processor utilization obtained using an alternative cache partitioning algorithm, and the tradeoff in terms of increased analysis time

Fixed priority scheduling with pre-emption thresholds and cache-related pre-emption delays: integrated analysis and evaluation

Commercial off-the-shelf programmable platforms for real-time systems typically contain a cache to bridge the gap between the processor speed and main memory speed. Because cache-related pre-emption delays (CRPD) can have a significant influence on the computation times of tasks, CRPD have been integrated in the response time analysis for fixed-priority pre-emptive scheduling (FPPS). This paper presents CRPD aware response-time analysis of sporadic tasks with arbitrary deadlines for fixed-priority pre-emption threshold scheduling (FPTS), generalizing earlier work. The analysis is complemented by an optimal (pre-emption) threshold assignment algorithm, assuming the priorities of tasks are given. We further improve upon these results by presenting an algorithm that searches for a layout of tasks in memory that makes a task set schedulable. The paper includes an extensive comparative evaluation of the schedulability ratios of FPPS and FPTS, taking CRPD into account. The practical relevance of our work stems from FPTS support in AUTOSAR, a standardized development model for the automotive industry

An extensible framework for multicore response time analysis

In this paper, we introduce a multicore response time analysis (MRTA) framework, which decouples response time analysis from a reliance on context independent WCET values. Instead, the analysis formulates response times directly from the demands placed on different hardware resources. The MRTA framework is extensible to different multicore architectures, with a variety of arbitration policies for the common interconnects, and different types and arrangements of local memory. We instantiate the framework for single level local data and instruction memories (cache or scratchpads), for a variety of memory bus arbitration policies, including: Round-Robin, FIFO, Fixed-Priority, Processor-Priority, and TDMA, and account for DRAM refreshes. The MRTA framework provides a general approach to timing verification for multicore systems that is parametric in the hardware configuration and so can be used at the architectural design stage to compare the guaranteed levels of real-time performance that can be obtained with different hardware configurations. We use the framework in this way to evaluate the performance of multicore systems with a variety of different architectural components and policies. These results are then used to compose a predictable architecture, which is compared against a reference architecture designed for good average-case behaviour. This comparison shows that the predictable architecture has substantially better guaranteed real-time performance, with the precision of the analysis verified using cycle-accurate simulation

Response-time analysis for fixed-priority systems with a write-back cache

This paper introduces analyses of write-back caches integrated into response-time analysis for fixed-priority preemptive and non-preemptive scheduling. For each scheduling paradigm, we derive four different approaches to computing the additional costs incurred due to write backs. We show the dominance relationships between these different approaches and note how they can be combined to form a single state-of-the-art approach in each case. The evaluation explores the relative performance of the different methods using a set of benchmarks, as well as making comparisons with no cache and a write-through cache. We also explore the effect of write buffers used to hide the latency of write-through caches. We show that depending upon the depth of the buffer used and the policies employed, such buffers can result in domino effects. Our evaluation shows that even ignoring domino effects, a substantial write buffer is needed to match the guaranteed performance of write-back caches

A WCET-aware cache coloring technique for reducing interference in real-time systems

International audienceThe time predictability of a system is the condition to give safe and precise bounds on the worst-case execution time of real-time functionalities which are running on it. Commercial off-the-shelf(COTS) processors are increasingly used in embedded systems and contain shared cache memory. This component has a hard predictable behavior because its state depends on the execution history of the systems. To increase the predictability of COTS component we use cache coloring, a technique widely used to partition cache memory. Our main contribution is a WCET aware heuristic which partition task according to the needs of each task. Our experiments are made with CPLEX an ILP solver with random tasks set generated running on preemptive system scheduled with earliest deadline first(EDF)