Constrained word alignment models for statistical machine translation

Word alignment is a fundamental and crucial component in Statistical Machine Translation (SMT) systems. Despite the enormous progress made in the past two decades, this task remains an active research topic simply because the quality of word alignment is still far from optimal. Most state-of-the-art word alignment models are grounded on statistical learning theory treating word alignment as a general sequence alignment problem, where many linguistically motivated insights are not incorporated. In this thesis, we propose new word alignment models with linguistically motivated constraints in a bid to improve the quality of word alignment for Phrase-Based SMT systems (PB-SMT). We start the exploration with an investigation into segmentation constraints for word alignment by proposing a novel algorithm, namely word packing, which is motivated by the fact that one concept expressed by one word in one language can frequently surface as a compound or collocation in another language. Our algorithm takes advantage of the interaction between segmentation and alignment, starting with some segmentation for both the source and target language and updating the segmentation with respect to the word alignment results using state-of-the-art word alignment models; thereafter a refined word alignment can be obtained based on the updated segmentation. In this process, the updated segmentation acts as a hard constraint on the word alignment models and reduces the complexity of the alignment models by generating more 1-to-1 correspondences through word packing. Experimental results show that this algorithm can lead to statistically significant improvements over the state-of-the-art word alignment models. Given that word packing imposes "hard" segmentation constraints on the word aligner, which is prone to introducing noise, we propose two new word alignment models using syntactic dependencies as soft constraints. The first model is a syntactically enhanced discriminative word alignment model, where we use a set of feature functions to express the syntactic dependency information encoded in both source and target languages. One the one hand, this model enjoys great flexibility in its capacity to incorporate multiple features; on the other hand, this model is designed to facilitate model tuning for different objective functions. Experimental results show that using syntactic constraints can improve the performance of the discriminative word alignment model, which also leads to better PB-SMT performance compared to using state-of-the-art word alignment models. The second model is a syntactically constrained generative word alignment model, where we add in a syntactic coherence model over the target phrases in the context of HMM word-to-phrase alignment. The advantages of our model are that (i) the addition of the syntactic coherence model preserves the efficient parameter estimation procedures; and (ii) the flexibility of the model can be increased so that it can be tuned according to different objective functions. Experimental results show that tuning this model properly leads to a significant gain in MT performance over the state-of-the-art

A Survey of Word Reordering in Statistical Machine Translation: Computational Models and Language Phenomena

Word reordering is one of the most difficult aspects of statistical machine translation (SMT), and an important factor of its quality and efficiency. Despite the vast amount of research published to date, the interest of the community in this problem has not decreased, and no single method appears to be strongly dominant across language pairs. Instead, the choice of the optimal approach for a new translation task still seems to be mostly driven by empirical trials. To orientate the reader in this vast and complex research area, we present a comprehensive survey of word reordering viewed as a statistical modeling challenge and as a natural language phenomenon. The survey describes in detail how word reordering is modeled within different string-based and tree-based SMT frameworks and as a stand-alone task, including systematic overviews of the literature in advanced reordering modeling. We then question why some approaches are more successful than others in different language pairs. We argue that, besides measuring the amount of reordering, it is important to understand which kinds of reordering occur in a given language pair. To this end, we conduct a qualitative analysis of word reordering phenomena in a diverse sample of language pairs, based on a large collection of linguistic knowledge. Empirical results in the SMT literature are shown to support the hypothesis that a few linguistic facts can be very useful to anticipate the reordering characteristics of a language pair and to select the SMT framework that best suits them.Comment: 44 pages, to appear in Computational Linguistic

Parallel Treebanks in Phrase-Based Statistical Machine Translation

Given much recent discussion and the shift in focus of the field, it is becoming apparent that the incorporation of syntax is the way forward for the current state-of-the-art in machine translation (MT). Parallel treebanks are a relatively recent innovation and appear to be ideal candidates for MT training material. However, until recently there has been no other means to build them than by hand. In this paper, we describe how we make use of new tools to automatically build a large parallel treebank and extract a set of linguistically motivated phrase pairs from it. We show that adding these phrase pairs to the translation model of a baseline phrase-based statistical MT (PBSMT) system leads to significant improvements in translation quality. We describe further experiments on incorporating parallel treebank information into PBSMT, such as word alignments. We investigate the conditions under which the incorporation of parallel treebank data performs optimally. Finally, we discuss the potential of parallel treebanks in other paradigms of MT

Using percolated dependencies for phrase extraction in SMT

Statistical Machine Translation (SMT) systems rely heavily on the quality of the phrase pairs induced from large amounts of training data. Apart from the widely used method of heuristic learning of n-gram phrase translations from word alignments, there are numerous methods for extracting these phrase pairs. One such class of approaches uses translation information encoded in parallel treebanks to extract phrase pairs. Work to date has demonstrated the usefulness of translation models induced from both constituency structure trees and dependency structure trees. Both syntactic annotations rely on the existence of natural language parsers for both the source and target languages. We depart from the norm by directly obtaining dependency parses from constituency structures using head percolation tables. The paper investigates the use of aligned chunks induced from percolated dependencies in French–English SMT and contrasts it with the aforementioned extracted phrases. We observe that adding phrase pairs from any other method improves translation performance over the baseline n-gram-based system, percolated dependencies are a good substitute for parsed dependencies, and that supplementing with our novel head percolation-induced chunks shows a general trend toward improving all system types across two data sets up to a 5.26% relative increase in BLEU

A Joint Phrasal and Dependency Model for Paraphrase Alignment

Monolingual alignment is frequently required for natural language tasks that involve similar or comparable sentences. We present a new model for monolingual alignment in which the score of an alignment decomposes over both the set of aligned phrases as well as a set of aligned dependency arcs. Optimal alignments under this scoring function are decoded using integer linear programming while model parameters are learned using standard structured prediction approaches. We evaluate our joint aligner on the Edinburgh paraphrase corpus and show significant gains over a Meteor baseline and a state-of-the-art phrase-based aligner

Getting Past the Language Gap: Innovations in Machine Translation

In this chapter, we will be reviewing state of the art machine translation systems, and will discuss innovative methods for machine translation, highlighting the most promising techniques and applications. Machine translation (MT) has benefited from a revitalization in the last 10 years or so, after a period of relatively slow activity. In 2005 the field received a jumpstart when a powerful complete experimental package for building MT systems from scratch became freely available as a result of the unified efforts of the MOSES international consortium. Around the same time, hierarchical methods had been introduced by Chinese researchers, which allowed the introduction and use of syntactic information in translation modeling. Furthermore, the advances in the related field of computational linguistics, making off-the-shelf taggers and parsers readily available, helped give MT an additional boost. Yet there is still more progress to be made. For example, MT will be enhanced greatly when both syntax and semantics are on board: this still presents a major challenge though many advanced research groups are currently pursuing ways to meet this challenge head-on. The next generation of MT will consist of a collection of hybrid systems. It also augurs well for the mobile environment, as we look forward to more advanced and improved technologies that enable the working of Speech-To-Speech machine translation on hand-held devices, i.e. speech recognition and speech synthesis. We review all of these developments and point out in the final section some of the most promising research avenues for the future of MT

Resourcing machine translation with parallel treebanks

The benefits of syntax-based approaches to data-driven machine translation (MT) are clear: given the right model, a combination of hierarchical structure, constituent labels and morphological information can be exploited to produce more fluent, grammatical translation output. This has been demonstrated by the recent shift in research focus towards such linguistically motivated approaches. However, one issue facing developers of such models that is not encountered in the development of state-of-the-art string-based statistical MT (SMT) systems is the lack of available syntactically annotated training data for many languages. In this thesis, we propose a solution to the problem of limited resources for syntax-based MT by introducing a novel sub-sentential alignment algorithm for the induction of translational equivalence links between pairs of phrase structure trees. This algorithm, which operates on a language pair-independent basis, allows for the automatic generation of large-scale parallel treebanks which are useful not only for machine translation, but also across a variety of natural language processing tasks. We demonstrate the viability of our automatically generated parallel treebanks by means of a thorough evaluation process during which they are compared to a manually annotated gold standard parallel treebank both intrinsically and in an MT task. Following this, we hypothesise that these parallel treebanks are not only useful in syntax-based MT, but also have the potential to be exploited in other paradigms of MT. To this end, we carry out a large number of experiments across a variety of data sets and language pairs, in which we exploit the information encoded within the parallel treebanks in various components of phrase-based statistical MT systems. We demonstrate that improvements in translation accuracy can be achieved by enhancing SMT phrase tables with linguistically motivated phrase pairs extracted from a parallel treebank, while showing that a number of other features in SMT can also be supplemented with varying degrees of effectiveness. Finally, we examine ways in which synchronous grammars extracted from parallel treebanks can improve the quality of translation output, focussing on real translation examples from a syntax-based MT system

The Roles of Language Models and Hierarchical Models in Neural Sequence-to-Sequence Prediction

With the advent of deep learning, research in many areas of machine learning is converging towards the same set of methods and models. For example, long short-term memory networks are not only popular for various tasks in natural language processing (NLP) such as speech recognition, machine translation, handwriting recognition, syntactic parsing, etc., but they are also applicable to seemingly unrelated fields such as robot control, time series prediction, and bioinformatics. Recent advances in contextual word embeddings like BERT boast with achieving state-of-the-art results on 11 NLP tasks with the same model. Before deep learning, a speech recognizer and a syntactic parser used to have little in common as systems were much more tailored towards the task at hand. At the core of this development is the tendency to view each task as yet another data mapping problem, neglecting the particular characteristics and (soft) requirements tasks often have in practice. This often goes along with a sharp break of deep learning methods with previous research in the specific area. This work can be understood as an antithesis to this paradigm. We show how traditional symbolic statistical machine translation models can still improve neural machine translation (NMT) while reducing the risk for common pathologies of NMT such as hallucinations and neologisms. Other external symbolic models such as spell checkers and morphology databases help neural grammatical error correction. We also focus on language models that often do not play a role in vanilla end-to-end approaches and apply them in different ways to word reordering, grammatical error correction, low-resource NMT, and document-level NMT. Finally, we demonstrate the benefit of hierarchical models in sequence-to-sequence prediction. Hand-engineered covering grammars are effective in preventing catastrophic errors in neural text normalization systems. Our operation sequence model for interpretable NMT represents translation as a series of actions that modify the translation state, and can also be seen as derivation in a formal grammar.EPSRC grant EP/L027623/1 EPSRC Tier-2 capital grant EP/P020259/

The Circle of Meaning: From Translation to Paraphrasing and Back

The preservation of meaning between inputs and outputs is perhaps the most ambitious and, often, the most elusive goal of systems that attempt to process natural language. Nowhere is this goal of more obvious importance than for the tasks of machine translation and paraphrase generation. Preserving meaning between the input and the output is paramount for both, the monolingual vs bilingual distinction notwithstanding. In this thesis, I present a novel, symbiotic relationship between these two tasks that I term the "circle of meaning''. Today's statistical machine translation (SMT) systems require high quality human translations for parameter tuning, in addition to large bi-texts for learning the translation units. This parameter tuning usually involves generating translations at different points in the parameter space and obtaining feedback against human-authored reference translations as to how good the translations. This feedback then dictates what point in the parameter space should be explored next. To measure this feedback, it is generally considered wise to have multiple (usually 4) reference translations to avoid unfair penalization of translation hypotheses which could easily happen given the large number of ways in which a sentence can be translated from one language to another. However, this reliance on multiple reference translations creates a problem since they are labor intensive and expensive to obtain. Therefore, most current MT datasets only contain a single reference. This leads to the problem of reference sparsity---the primary open problem that I address in this dissertation---one that has a serious effect on the SMT parameter tuning process. Bannard and Callison-Burch (2005) were the first to provide a practical connection between phrase-based statistical machine translation and paraphrase generation. However, their technique is restricted to generating phrasal paraphrases. I build upon their approach and augment a phrasal paraphrase extractor into a sentential paraphraser with extremely broad coverage. The novelty in this augmentation lies in the further strengthening of the connection between statistical machine translation and paraphrase generation; whereas Bannard and Callison-Burch only relied on SMT machinery to extract phrasal paraphrase rules and stopped there, I take it a few steps further and build a full English-to-English SMT system. This system can, as expected, ``translate'' any English input sentence into a new English sentence with the same degree of meaning preservation that exists in a bilingual SMT system. In fact, being a state-of-the-art SMT system, it is able to generate n-best "translations" for any given input sentence. This sentential paraphraser, built almost entirely from existing SMT machinery, represents the first 180 degrees of the circle of meaning. To complete the circle, I describe a novel connection in the other direction. I claim that the sentential paraphraser, once built in this fashion, can provide a solution to the reference sparsity problem and, hence, be used to improve the performance a bilingual SMT system. I discuss two different instantiations of the sentential paraphraser and show several results that provide empirical validation for this connection