Asymmetric Feedback Learning in Online Convex Games

This paper considers online convex games involving multiple agents that aim to minimize their own cost functions using locally available feedback. A common assumption in the study of such games is that the agents are symmetric, meaning that they have access to the same type of information or feedback. Here we lift this assumption, which is often violated in practice, and instead consider asymmetric agents; specifically, we assume some agents have access to first-order gradient feedback and others have access to the zeroth-order oracles (cost function evaluations). We propose an asymmetric feedback learning algorithm that combines the agent feedback mechanisms. We analyze the regret and Nash equilibrium convergence of this algorithm for convex games and strongly monotone games, respectively. Specifically, we show that our algorithm always performs between pure first-order and zeroth-order methods, and can match the performance of these two extremes by adjusting the number of agents with access to zeroth-order oracles. Therefore, our algorithm incorporates the pure first-order and zeroth-order methods as special cases. We provide numerical experiments on an online market problem for both deterministic and risk-averse games to demonstrate the performance of the proposed algorithm.Comment: 16page

Small Errors in Random Zeroth Order Optimization are Imaginary

The vast majority of zeroth order optimization methods try to imitate first order methods via some smooth approximation of the gradient. Here, the smaller the smoothing parameter, the smaller the gradient approximation error. We show that for the majority of zeroth order methods this smoothing parameter can however not be chosen arbitrarily small as numerical cancellation errors will dominate. As such, theoretical and numerical performance could differ significantly. Using classical tools from numerical differentiation we will propose a new smoothed approximation of the gradient that can be integrated into general zeroth order algorithmic frameworks. Since the proposed smoothed approximation does not suffer from cancellation errors, the smoothing parameter (and hence the approximation error) can be made arbitrarily small. Sublinear convergence rates for algorithms based on our smoothed approximation are proved. Numerical experiments are also presented to demonstrate the superiority of algorithms based on the proposed approximation.Comment: New: Figure 3.