An investigation of the utility of monaural sound source separation via nonnegative matrix factorization applied to acoustic echo and reverberation mitigation for hands-free telephony

In this thesis we investigate the applicability and utility of Monaural Sound Source Separation (MSSS) via Nonnegative Matrix Factorization (NMF) for various problems related to audio for hands-free telephony. We first investigate MSSS via NMF as an alternative acoustic echo reduction approach to existing approaches such as Acoustic Echo Cancellation (AEC). To this end, we present the single-channel acoustic echo problem as an MSSS problem, in which the objective is to extract the users signal from a mixture also containing acoustic echo and noise. To perform separation, NMF is used to decompose the near-end microphone signal onto the union of two nonnegative bases in the magnitude Short Time Fourier Transform domain. One of these bases is for the spectral energy of the acoustic echo signal, and is formed from the in- coming far-end user’s speech, while the other basis is for the spectral energy of the near-end speaker, and is trained with speech data a priori. In comparison to AEC, the speaker extraction approach obviates Double-Talk Detection (DTD), and is demonstrated to attain its maximal echo mitigation performance immediately upon initiation and to maintain that performance during and after room changes for similar computational requirements. Speaker extraction is also shown to introduce distortion of the near-end speech signal during double-talk, which is quantified by means of a speech distortion measure and compared to that of AEC. Subsequently, we address Double-Talk Detection (DTD) for block-based AEC algorithms. We propose a novel block-based DTD algorithm that uses the available signals and the estimate of the echo signal that is produced by NMF-based speaker extraction to compute a suitably normalized correlation-based decision variable, which is compared to a fixed threshold to decide on doubletalk. Using a standard evaluation technique, the proposed algorithm is shown to have comparable detection performance to an existing conventional block-based DTD algorithm. It is also demonstrated to inherit the room change insensitivity of speaker extraction, with the proposed DTD algorithm generating minimal false doubletalk indications upon initiation and in response to room changes in comparison to the existing conventional DTD. We also show that this property allows its paired AEC to converge at a rate close to the optimum. Another focus of this thesis is the problem of inverting a single measurement of a non- minimum phase Room Impulse Response (RIR). We describe the process by which percep- tually detrimental all-pass phase distortion arises in reverberant speech filtered by the inverse of the minimum phase component of the RIR; in short, such distortion arises from inverting the magnitude response of the high-Q maximum phase zeros of the RIR. We then propose two novel partial inversion schemes that precisely mitigate this distortion. One of these schemes employs NMF-based MSSS to separate the all-pass phase distortion from the target speech in the magnitude STFT domain, while the other approach modifies the inverse minimum phase filter such that the magnitude response of the maximum phase zeros of the RIR is not fully compensated. Subjective listening tests reveal that the proposed schemes generally produce better quality output speech than a comparable inversion technique

An investigation of the utility of monaural sound source separation via nonnegative matrix factorization applied to acoustic echo and reverberation mitigation for hands-free telephony

In this thesis we investigate the applicability and utility of Monaural Sound Source Separation (MSSS) via Nonnegative Matrix Factorization (NMF) for various problems related to audio for hands-free telephony. We first investigate MSSS via NMF as an alternative acoustic echo reduction approach to existing approaches such as Acoustic Echo Cancellation (AEC). To this end, we present the single-channel acoustic echo problem as an MSSS problem, in which the objective is to extract the users signal from a mixture also containing acoustic echo and noise. To perform separation, NMF is used to decompose the near-end microphone signal onto the union of two nonnegative bases in the magnitude Short Time Fourier Transform domain. One of these bases is for the spectral energy of the acoustic echo signal, and is formed from the in- coming far-end user’s speech, while the other basis is for the spectral energy of the near-end speaker, and is trained with speech data a priori. In comparison to AEC, the speaker extraction approach obviates Double-Talk Detection (DTD), and is demonstrated to attain its maximal echo mitigation performance immediately upon initiation and to maintain that performance during and after room changes for similar computational requirements. Speaker extraction is also shown to introduce distortion of the near-end speech signal during double-talk, which is quantified by means of a speech distortion measure and compared to that of AEC. Subsequently, we address Double-Talk Detection (DTD) for block-based AEC algorithms. We propose a novel block-based DTD algorithm that uses the available signals and the estimate of the echo signal that is produced by NMF-based speaker extraction to compute a suitably normalized correlation-based decision variable, which is compared to a fixed threshold to decide on doubletalk. Using a standard evaluation technique, the proposed algorithm is shown to have comparable detection performance to an existing conventional block-based DTD algorithm. It is also demonstrated to inherit the room change insensitivity of speaker extraction, with the proposed DTD algorithm generating minimal false doubletalk indications upon initiation and in response to room changes in comparison to the existing conventional DTD. We also show that this property allows its paired AEC to converge at a rate close to the optimum. Another focus of this thesis is the problem of inverting a single measurement of a non- minimum phase Room Impulse Response (RIR). We describe the process by which percep- tually detrimental all-pass phase distortion arises in reverberant speech filtered by the inverse of the minimum phase component of the RIR; in short, such distortion arises from inverting the magnitude response of the high-Q maximum phase zeros of the RIR. We then propose two novel partial inversion schemes that precisely mitigate this distortion. One of these schemes employs NMF-based MSSS to separate the all-pass phase distortion from the target speech in the magnitude STFT domain, while the other approach modifies the inverse minimum phase filter such that the magnitude response of the maximum phase zeros of the RIR is not fully compensated. Subjective listening tests reveal that the proposed schemes generally produce better quality output speech than a comparable inversion technique

Learning-Based Reference-Free Speech Quality Assessment for Normal Hearing and Hearing Impaired Applications

Accurate speech quality measures are highly attractive and beneficial in the design, fine-tuning, and benchmarking of speech processing algorithms, devices, and communication systems. Switching from narrowband telecommunication to wideband telephony is a change within the telecommunication industry which provides users with better speech quality experience but introduces a number of challenges in speech processing. Noise is the most common distortion on audio signals and as a result there have been a lot of studies on developing high performance noise reduction algorithms. Assistive hearing devices are designed to decrease communication difficulties for people with loss of hearing. As the algorithms within these devices become more advanced, it becomes increasingly crucial to develop accurate and robust quality metrics to assess their performance. Objective speech quality measurements are more attractive compared to subjective assessments as they are cost-effective and subjective variability is eliminated. Although there has been extensive research on objective speech quality evaluation for narrowband speech, those methods are unsuitable for wideband telephony. In the case of hearing-impaired applications, objective quality assessment is challenging as it has to be capable of distinguishing between desired modifications which make signals audible and undesired artifacts. In this thesis a model is proposed that allows extracting two sets of features from the distorted signal only. This approach which is called reference-free (nonintrusive) assessment is attractive as it does not need access to the reference signal. Although this benefit makes nonintrusive assessments suitable for real-time applications, more features need to be extracted and smartly combined to provide comparable accuracy as intrusive metrics. Two feature vectors are proposed to extract information from distorted signals and their performance is examined in three studies. In the first study, both feature vectors are trained on various portions of a noise reduction database for normal hearing applications. In the second study, the same investigation is performed on two sets of databases acquired through several hearing aids. Third study examined the generalizability of the proposed metrics on benchmarking four wireless remote microphones in a variety of environmental conditions. Machine learning techniques are deployed for training the models in the three studies. The studies show that one of the feature sets is robust when trained on different portions of the data from different databases and it also provides good quality prediction accuracy for both normal hearing and hearing-impaired applications

A non-linear polynomial approximation filter for robust speaker verification

Bibliography: leaves 101-109

Replay detection in voice biometrics: an investigation of adaptive and non-adaptive front-ends

Among various physiological and behavioural traits, speech has gained popularity as an effective mode of biometric authentication. Even though they are gaining popularity, automatic speaker verification systems are vulnerable to malicious attacks, known as spoofing attacks. Among various types of spoofing attacks, replay attack poses the biggest threat due to its simplicity and effectiveness. This thesis investigates the importance of 1) improving front-end feature extraction via novel feature extraction techniques and 2) enhancing spectral components via adaptive front-end frameworks to improve replay attack detection. This thesis initially focuses on AM-FM modelling techniques and their use in replay attack detection. A novel method to extract the sub-band frequency modulation (FM) component using the spectral centroid of a signal is proposed, and its use as a potential acoustic feature is also discussed. Frequency Domain Linear Prediction (FDLP) is explored as a method to obtain the temporal envelope of a speech signal. The temporal envelope carries amplitude modulation (AM) information of speech resonances. Several features are extracted from the temporal envelope and the FDLP residual signal. These features are then evaluated for replay attack detection and shown to have significant capability in discriminating genuine and spoofed signals. Fusion of AM and FM-based features has shown that AM and FM carry complementary information that helps distinguish replayed signals from genuine ones. The importance of frequency band allocation when creating filter banks is studied as well to further advance the understanding of front-ends for replay attack detection. Mechanisms inspired by the human auditory system that makes the human ear an excellent spectrum analyser have been investigated and integrated into front-ends. Spatial differentiation, a mechanism that provides additional sharpening to auditory filters is one of them that is used in this work to improve the selectivity of the sub-band decomposition filters. Two features are extracted using the improved filter bank front-end: spectral envelope centroid magnitude (SECM) and spectral envelope centroid frequency (SECF). These are used to establish the positive effect of spatial differentiation on discriminating spoofed signals. Level-dependent filter tuning, which allows the ear to handle a large dynamic range, is integrated into the filter bank to further improve the front-end. This mechanism converts the filter bank into an adaptive one where the selectivity of the filters is varied based on the input signal energy. Experimental results show that this leads to improved spoofing detection performance. Finally, deep neural network (DNN) mechanisms are integrated into sub-band feature extraction to develop an adaptive front-end that adjusts its characteristics based on the sub-band signals. A DNN-based controller that takes sub-band FM components as input, is developed to adaptively control the selectivity and sensitivity of a parallel filter bank to enhance the artifacts that differentiate a replayed signal from a genuine signal. This work illustrates gradient-based optimization of a DNN-based controller using the feedback from a spoofing detection back-end classifier, thus training it to reduce spoofing detection error. The proposed framework has displayed a superior ability in identifying high-quality replayed signals compared to conventional non-adaptive frameworks. All techniques proposed in this thesis have been evaluated on well-established databases on replay attack detection and compared with state-of-the-art baseline systems

Model-Based Speech Enhancement

Abstract A method of speech enhancement is developed that reconstructs clean speech from a set of acoustic features using a harmonic plus noise model of speech. This is a significant departure from traditional filtering-based methods of speech enhancement. A major challenge with this approach is to estimate accurately the acoustic features (voicing, fundamental frequency, spectral envelope and phase) from noisy speech. This is achieved using maximum a-posteriori (MAP) estimation methods that operate on the noisy speech. In each case a prior model of the relationship between the noisy speech features and the estimated acoustic feature is required. These models are approximated using speaker-independent GMMs of the clean speech features that are adapted to speaker-dependent models using MAP adaptation and for noise using the Unscented Transform. Objective results are presented to optimise the proposed system and a set of subjective tests compare the approach with traditional enhancement methods. Threeway listening tests examining signal quality, background noise intrusiveness and overall quality show the proposed system to be highly robust to noise, performing significantly better than conventional methods of enhancement in terms of background noise intrusiveness. However, the proposed method is shown to reduce signal quality, with overall quality measured to be roughly equivalent to that of the Wiener filter

Joint Training Methods for Tandem and Hybrid Speech Recognition Systems using Deep Neural Networks

Hidden Markov models (HMMs) have been the mainstream acoustic modelling approach for state-of-the-art automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems over the past few decades. Recently, due to the rapid development of deep learning technologies, deep neural networks (DNNs) have become an essential part of nearly all kinds of ASR approaches. Among HMM-based ASR approaches, DNNs are most commonly used to extract features (tandem system configuration) or to directly produce HMM output probabilities (hybrid system configuration). Although DNN tandem and hybrid systems have been shown to have superior performance to traditional ASR systems without any DNN models, there are still issues with such systems. First, some of the DNN settings, such as the choice of the context-dependent (CD) output targets set and hidden activation functions, are usually determined independently from the DNN training process. Second, different ASR modules are separately optimised based on different criteria following a greedy build strategy. For instance, for tandem systems, the features are often extracted by a DNN trained to classify individual speech frames while acoustic models are built upon such features according to a sequence level criterion. These issues mean that the best performance is not theoretically guaranteed. This thesis focuses on alleviating both issues using joint training methods. In DNN acoustic model joint training, the decision tree HMM state tying approach is extended to cluster DNN-HMM states. Based on this method, an alternative CD-DNN training procedure without relying on any additional system is proposed, which can produce DNN acoustic models comparable in word error rate (WER) with those trained by the conventional procedure. Meanwhile, the most common hidden activation functions, the sigmoid and rectified linear unit (ReLU), are parameterised to enable automatic learning of function forms. Experiments using conversational telephone speech (CTS) Mandarin data result in an average of 3.4% and 2.2% relative character error rate (CER) reduction with sigmoid and ReLU parameterisations. Such parameterised functions can also be applied to speaker adaptation tasks. At the ASR system level, DNN acoustic model and corresponding speaker dependent (SD) input feature transforms are jointly learned through minimum phone error (MPE) training as an example of hybrid system joint training, which outperforms the conventional hybrid system speaker adaptive training (SAT) method. MPE based speaker independent (SI) tandem system joint training is also studied. Experiments on multi-genre broadcast (MGB) English data show that this method gives a reduction in tandem system WER of 11.8% (relative), and the resulting tandem systems are comparable to MPE hybrid systems in both WER and the number of parameters. In addition, all approaches in this thesis have been implemented using the hidden Markov model toolkit (HTK) and the related source code has been or will be made publicly available with either recent or future HTK releases, to increase the reproducibility of the work presented in this thesis.Cambridge International Scholarship, Cambridge Overseas Trust Research funding, EPSRC Natural Speech Technology Project Research funding, DARPA BOLT Program Research funding, iARPA Babel Progra

Robust speech recognition with spectrogram factorisation

Communication by speech is intrinsic for humans. Since the breakthrough of mobile devices and wireless communication, digital transmission of speech has become ubiquitous. Similarly distribution and storage of audio and video data has increased rapidly. However, despite being technically capable to record and process audio signals, only a fraction of digital systems and services are actually able to work with spoken input, that is, to operate on the lexical content of speech. One persistent obstacle for practical deployment of automatic speech recognition systems is inadequate robustness against noise and other interferences, which regularly corrupt signals recorded in real-world environments. Speech and diverse noises are both complex signals, which are not trivially separable. Despite decades of research and a multitude of different approaches, the problem has not been solved to a sufficient extent. Especially the mathematically ill-posed problem of separating multiple sources from a single-channel input requires advanced models and algorithms to be solvable. One promising path is using a composite model of long-context atoms to represent a mixture of non-stationary sources based on their spectro-temporal behaviour. Algorithms derived from the family of non-negative matrix factorisations have been applied to such problems to separate and recognise individual sources like speech. This thesis describes a set of tools developed for non-negative modelling of audio spectrograms, especially involving speech and real-world noise sources. An overview is provided to the complete framework starting from model and feature definitions, advancing to factorisation algorithms, and finally describing different routes for separation, enhancement, and recognition tasks. Current issues and their potential solutions are discussed both theoretically and from a practical point of view. The included publications describe factorisation-based recognition systems, which have been evaluated on publicly available speech corpora in order to determine the efficiency of various separation and recognition algorithms. Several variants and system combinations that have been proposed in literature are also discussed. The work covers a broad span of factorisation-based system components, which together aim at providing a practically viable solution to robust processing and recognition of speech in everyday situations