96 research outputs found
Challenges for Efficient Query Evaluation on Structured Probabilistic Data
Query answering over probabilistic data is an important task but is generally
intractable. However, a new approach for this problem has recently been
proposed, based on structural decompositions of input databases, following,
e.g., tree decompositions. This paper presents a vision for a database
management system for probabilistic data built following this structural
approach. We review our existing and ongoing work on this topic and highlight
many theoretical and practical challenges that remain to be addressed.Comment: 9 pages, 1 figure, 23 references. Accepted for publication at SUM
201
Structurally Tractable Uncertain Data
Many data management applications must deal with data which is uncertain,
incomplete, or noisy. However, on existing uncertain data representations, we
cannot tractably perform the important query evaluation tasks of determining
query possibility, certainty, or probability: these problems are hard on
arbitrary uncertain input instances. We thus ask whether we could restrict the
structure of uncertain data so as to guarantee the tractability of exact query
evaluation. We present our tractability results for tree and tree-like
uncertain data, and a vision for probabilistic rule reasoning. We also study
uncertainty about order, proposing a suitable representation, and study
uncertain data conditioned by additional observations.Comment: 11 pages, 1 figure, 1 table. To appear in SIGMOD/PODS PhD Symposium
201
Tractability through Exchangeability: A New Perspective on Efficient Probabilistic Inference
Exchangeability is a central notion in statistics and probability theory. The
assumption that an infinite sequence of data points is exchangeable is at the
core of Bayesian statistics. However, finite exchangeability as a statistical
property that renders probabilistic inference tractable is less
well-understood. We develop a theory of finite exchangeability and its relation
to tractable probabilistic inference. The theory is complementary to that of
independence and conditional independence. We show that tractable inference in
probabilistic models with high treewidth and millions of variables can be
understood using the notion of finite (partial) exchangeability. We also show
that existing lifted inference algorithms implicitly utilize a combination of
conditional independence and partial exchangeability.Comment: In Proceedings of the 28th AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligenc
On the Complexity of Existential Positive Queries
We systematically investigate the complexity of model checking the
existential positive fragment of first-order logic. In particular, for a set of
existential positive sentences, we consider model checking where the sentence
is restricted to fall into the set; a natural question is then to classify
which sentence sets are tractable and which are intractable. With respect to
fixed-parameter tractability, we give a general theorem that reduces this
classification question to the corresponding question for primitive positive
logic, for a variety of representations of structures. This general theorem
allows us to deduce that an existential positive sentence set having bounded
arity is fixed-parameter tractable if and only if each sentence is equivalent
to one in bounded-variable logic. We then use the lens of classical complexity
to study these fixed-parameter tractable sentence sets. We show that such a set
can be NP-complete, and consider the length needed by a translation from
sentences in such a set to bounded-variable logic; we prove superpolynomial
lower bounds on this length using the theory of compilability, obtaining an
interesting type of formula size lower bound. Overall, the tools, concepts, and
results of this article set the stage for the future consideration of the
complexity of model checking on more expressive logics
Provenance Circuits for Trees and Treelike Instances (Extended Version)
Query evaluation in monadic second-order logic (MSO) is tractable on trees
and treelike instances, even though it is hard for arbitrary instances. This
tractability result has been extended to several tasks related to query
evaluation, such as counting query results [3] or performing query evaluation
on probabilistic trees [10]. These are two examples of the more general problem
of computing augmented query output, that is referred to as provenance. This
article presents a provenance framework for trees and treelike instances, by
describing a linear-time construction of a circuit provenance representation
for MSO queries. We show how this provenance can be connected to the usual
definitions of semiring provenance on relational instances [20], even though we
compute it in an unusual way, using tree automata; we do so via intrinsic
definitions of provenance for general semirings, independent of the operational
details of query evaluation. We show applications of this provenance to capture
existing counting and probabilistic results on trees and treelike instances,
and give novel consequences for probability evaluation.Comment: 48 pages. Presented at ICALP'1
An Experimental Study of the Treewidth of Real-World Graph Data
Treewidth is a parameter that measures how tree-like a relational instance is, and whether it can reasonably be decomposed into a tree. Many computation tasks are known to be tractable on databases of small treewidth, but computing the treewidth of a given instance is intractable. This article is the first large-scale experimental study of treewidth and tree decompositions of real-world database instances (25 datasets from 8 different domains, with sizes ranging from a few thousand to a few million vertices). The goal is to determine which data, if any, can benefit of the wealth of algorithms for databases of small treewidth. For each dataset, we obtain upper and lower bound estimations of their treewidth, and study the properties of their tree decompositions. We show in particular that, even when treewidth is high, using partial tree decompositions can result in data structures that can assist algorithms
On the complexity of Existential Positive Queries
We systematically investigate the complexity of model checking the existential positive fragment of first-order logic. In particular, for a set of existential positive sentences, we consider model checking where the sentence is restricted to fall into the set; a natural question is then to classify which sentence sets are tractable and which are intractable. With respect to fixed-parameter tractability, we give a general theorem that reduces this classification question to the corresponding question for primitive positive logic, for a variety of representations of structures. This general theorem allows us to deduce that an existential positive sentence set having bounded arity is fixed-parameter tractable if and only if each sentence is equivalent to one in bounded-variable logic. We then use the lens of classical complexity to study these fixed-parameter tractable sentence sets. We show that such a set can be NP-complete, and consider the length needed by a translation from sentences in such a set to bounded-variable logic; we prove superpolynomial lower bounds on this length using the theory of compilability, obtaining an interesting type of formula size lower bound. Overall, the tools, concepts, and results of this article set the stage for the future consideration of the complexity of model checking on more expressive logics
On the Complexity and Approximation of Binary Evidence in Lifted Inference
Lifted inference algorithms exploit symmetries in probabilistic models to
speed up inference. They show impressive performance when calculating
unconditional probabilities in relational models, but often resort to
non-lifted inference when computing conditional probabilities. The reason is
that conditioning on evidence breaks many of the model's symmetries, which can
preempt standard lifting techniques. Recent theoretical results show, for
example, that conditioning on evidence which corresponds to binary relations is
#P-hard, suggesting that no lifting is to be expected in the worst case. In
this paper, we balance this negative result by identifying the Boolean rank of
the evidence as a key parameter for characterizing the complexity of
conditioning in lifted inference. In particular, we show that conditioning on
binary evidence with bounded Boolean rank is efficient. This opens up the
possibility of approximating evidence by a low-rank Boolean matrix
factorization, which we investigate both theoretically and empirically.Comment: To appear in Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems 26
(NIPS), Lake Tahoe, USA, December 201
- …