Optimal Binary Search Trees with Near Minimal Height

Suppose we have n keys, n access probabilities for the keys, and n+1 access probabilities for the gaps between the keys. Let h_min(n) be the minimal height of a binary search tree for n keys. We consider the problem to construct an optimal binary search tree with near minimal height, i.e.\ with height h <= h_min(n) + Delta for some fixed Delta. It is shown, that for any fixed Delta optimal binary search trees with near minimal height can be constructed in time O(n^2). This is as fast as in the unrestricted case. So far, the best known algorithms for the construction of height-restricted optimal binary search trees have running time O(L n^2), whereby L is the maximal permitted height. Compared to these algorithms our algorithm is at least faster by a factor of log n, because L is lower bounded by log n

Subtree weight ratios for optimal binary search trees

For an optimal binary search tree T with a subtree S(d) at a distance d from the root of T, we study the ratio of the weight of S(d) to the weight of T. The maximum possible value, which we call ρ(d), of the ratio of weights, is found to have an upper bound of 2/F_d+3 where F_i is the ith Fibonacci number. For d = 1, 2, 3, and 4, the bound is shown to be tight. For larger d, the Fibonacci bound gives ρ(d) = O(ϕ^d) where ϕ ~ .61803 is the golden ratio. By giving a particular set of optimal trees, we prove ρ(d) = Ω((.58578 ... )^d), and believe a similar proof follows for ρ(d) = Ω((.60179 ... )^d). If we include frequencies for unsuccessful searches in the optimal binary search trees, the Fibonacci bound is found to be tight

Bicriteria Network Design Problems

We study a general class of bicriteria network design problems. A generic problem in this class is as follows: Given an undirected graph and two minimization objectives (under different cost functions), with a budget specified on the first, find a <subgraph \from a given subgraph-class that minimizes the second objective subject to the budget on the first. We consider three different criteria - the total edge cost, the diameter and the maximum degree of the network. Here, we present the first polynomial-time approximation algorithms for a large class of bicriteria network design problems for the above mentioned criteria. The following general types of results are presented. First, we develop a framework for bicriteria problems and their approximations. Second, when the two criteria are the same %(note that the cost functions continue to be different) we present a ``black box'' parametric search technique. This black box takes in as input an (approximation) algorithm for the unicriterion situation and generates an approximation algorithm for the bicriteria case with only a constant factor loss in the performance guarantee. Third, when the two criteria are the diameter and the total edge costs we use a cluster-based approach to devise a approximation algorithms --- the solutions output violate both the criteria by a logarithmic factor. Finally, for the class of treewidth-bounded graphs, we provide pseudopolynomial-time algorithms for a number of bicriteria problems using dynamic programming. We show how these pseudopolynomial-time algorithms can be converted to fully polynomial-time approximation schemes using a scaling technique.Comment: 24 pages 1 figur

Optimal Hierarchical Layouts for Cache-Oblivious Search Trees

This paper proposes a general framework for generating cache-oblivious layouts for binary search trees. A cache-oblivious layout attempts to minimize cache misses on any hierarchical memory, independent of the number of memory levels and attributes at each level such as cache size, line size, and replacement policy. Recursively partitioning a tree into contiguous subtrees and prescribing an ordering amongst the subtrees, Hierarchical Layouts generalize many commonly used layouts for trees such as in-order, pre-order and breadth-first. They also generalize the various flavors of the van Emde Boas layout, which have previously been used as cache-oblivious layouts. Hierarchical Layouts thus unify all previous attempts at deriving layouts for search trees. The paper then derives a new locality measure (the Weighted Edge Product) that mimics the probability of cache misses at multiple levels, and shows that layouts that reduce this measure perform better. We analyze the various degrees of freedom in the construction of Hierarchical Layouts, and investigate the relative effect of each of these decisions in the construction of cache-oblivious layouts. Optimizing the Weighted Edge Product for complete binary search trees, we introduce the MinWEP layout, and show that it outperforms previously used cache-oblivious layouts by almost 20%.Comment: Extended version with proofs added to the appendi