Community Detection and Improved Detectability in Multiplex Networks

We investigate the widely encountered problem of detecting communities in multiplex networks, such as social networks, with an unknown arbitrary heterogeneous structure. To improve detectability, we propose a generative model that leverages the multiplicity of a single community in multiple layers, with no prior assumption on the relation of communities among different layers. Our model relies on a novel idea of incorporating a large set of generic localized community label constraints across the layers, in conjunction with the celebrated Stochastic Block Model (SBM) in each layer. Accordingly, we build a probabilistic graphical model over the entire multiplex network by treating the constraints as Bayesian priors. We mathematically prove that these constraints/priors promote existence of identical communities across layers without introducing further correlation between individual communities. The constraints are further tailored to render a sparse graphical model and the numerically efficient Belief Propagation algorithm is subsequently employed. We further demonstrate by numerical experiments that in the presence of consistent communities between different layers, consistent communities are matched, and the detectability is improved over a single layer. We compare our model with a "correlated model" which exploits the prior knowledge of community correlation between layers. Similar detectability improvement is obtained under such a correlation, even though our model relies on much milder assumptions than the correlated model. Our model even shows a better detection performance over a certain correlation and signal to noise ratio (SNR) range. In the absence of community correlation, the correlation model naturally fails, while ours maintains its performance

Ground truth? Concept-based communities versus the external classification of physics manuscripts

Community detection techniques are widely used to infer hidden structures within interconnected systems. Despite demonstrating high accuracy on benchmarks, they reproduce the external classification for many real-world systems with a significant level of discrepancy. A widely accepted reason behind such outcome is the unavoidable loss of non-topological information (such as node attributes) encountered when the original complex system is represented as a network. In this article we emphasize that the observed discrepancies may also be caused by a different reason: the external classification itself. For this end we use scientific publication data which i) exhibit a well defined modular structure and ii) hold an expert-made classification of research articles. Having represented the articles and the extracted scientific concepts both as a bipartite network and as its unipartite projection, we applied modularity optimization to uncover the inner thematic structure. The resulting clusters are shown to partly reflect the author-made classification, although some significant discrepancies are observed. A detailed analysis of these discrepancies shows that they carry essential information about the system, mainly related to the use of similar techniques and methods across different (sub)disciplines, that is otherwise omitted when only the external classification is considered.Comment: 15 pages, 2 figure