Multiple choice allocations with small maximum loads

The idea of using multiple choices to improve allocation schemes is now well understood and is often illustrated by the following example. Suppose $n$ balls are allocated to $n$ bins with each ball choosing a bin independently and uniformly at random. The \emph{maximum load}, or the number of balls in the most loaded bin, will then be approximately $\log n \over \log \log n$ with high probability. Suppose now the balls are allocated sequentially by placing a ball in the least loaded bin among the $k\ge 2$ bins chosen independently and uniformly at random. Azar, Broder, Karlin, and Upfal showed that in this scenario, the maximum load drops to ${\log \log n \over \log k} +\Theta(1)$, with high probability, which is an exponential improvement over the previous case. In this thesis we investigate multiple choice allocations from a slightly different perspective. Instead of minimizing the maximum load, we fix the bin capacities and focus on maximizing the number of balls that can be allocated without overloading any bin. In the process that we consider we have $m=\lfloor cn \rfloor$ balls and $n$ bins. Each ball chooses $k$ bins independently and uniformly at random. \emph{Is it possible to assign each ball to one of its choices such that the no bin receives more than $\ell$ balls?} For all $k\ge 3$ and $\ell\ge 2$ we give a critical value, $c_{k,\ell}^*$, such that when $cc_{k,\ell}^*$ this is not the case. In case such an allocation exists, \emph{how quickly can we find it?} Previous work on total allocation time for case $k\ge 3$ and $\ell=1$ has analyzed a \emph{breadth first strategy} which is shown to be linear only in expectation. We give a simple and efficient algorithm which we also call \emph{local search allocation}(LSA) to find an allocation for all $k\ge 3$ and $\ell=1$. Provided the number of balls are below (but arbitrarily close to) the theoretical achievable load threshold, we give a \emph{linear} bound for the total allocation time that holds with high probability. We demonstrate, through simulations, an order of magnitude improvement for total and maximum allocation times when compared to the state of the art method. Our results find applications in many areas including hashing, load balancing, data management, orientability of random hypergraphs and maximum matchings in a special class of bipartite graphs.Die Idee, mehrere Wahlmöglichkeiten zu benutzen, um Zuordnungsschemas zu verbessern, ist mittlerweile gut verstanden und wird oft mit Hilfe des folgenden Beispiels illustriert: Man nehme an, dass n Kugeln auf n Behälter verteilt werden und jede Kugel unabhängig und gleichverteilt per Zufall ihren Behälter wählt. Die maximale Auslastung, bzw. die Anzahl an Kugeln im meist befüllten Behälter, wird dann mit hoher Wahrscheinlichkeit schätzungsweise $\log n \over \log \log n$ sein. Alternativ können die Kugeln sequenziell zugeordnet werden, indem jede Kugel k ≥ 2 Behälter unabhängig und gleichverteilt zufällig auswählt und in dem am wenigsten befüllten dieser k Behälter platziert wird. Azar, Broder, Karlin, and Upfal haben gezeigt, dass in diesem Szenario die maximale Auslastung mit hoher Wahrscheinlichkeit auf ${\log \log n \over \log k} +\Theta(1)$ sinkt, was eine exponentielle Verbesserung des vorhergehenden Falls darstellt. In dieser Doktorarbeit untersuchen wir solche Zuteilungschemas von einem etwas anderen Standpunkt. Statt die maximale Last zu minimieren, fixieren wir die Kapazitäten der Behälter und konzentrieren uns auf die Maximierung der Anzahl der Kugeln, die ohne Überlastung eines Behälters zugeteilt werden können. In dem von uns betrachteten Prozess haben wir m = bcnc Kugeln und n Behälter. Jede Kugel wählt unabhängig und gleichverteilt zufällig k Behälter. Ist es möglich, jeder Kugel einen Behälter ihrer Wahl zuzuordnen, so dass kein Behälter mehr als Kugeln erhält? Für alle k ≥ 3 und ≥ 2 geben wir einen kritischen Wert $c _{k,\ell}^*$, an sodass für c c {k,\ell}^*$nicht. Im Falle, dass solch eine Zuordnung existiert, stellt sich die Frage, wie schnell diese gefunden werden kann. Die bisher durchgeführten Arbeiten zur Gesamtzuordnungszeit im Falle k ≥ 3 and$\ell = 1$haben eine Breitensuchstrategie analysiert, welche nur im Erwartungswert linear ist. Wir präsentieren einen einfachen und effizienten Algorithmus, welchen wir local search allocation (LSA) nennen und der Zuteilungen für alle k ≥ 3 und$\ell = 1$ findet. Sofern die Anzahl der Kugeln unter (aber beliebig nahe an) der theoretisch erreichbaren Lastschwelle ist, zeigen wir eine lineare Schranke für die Gesamtzuordnungszeit, die mit hoher Wahrscheinlichkeit gilt. Anhand von Simulationen demonstrieren wir eine Verbesserung der Gesamt- und Maximalzuordnungszeiten um eine Größenordnung im Vergleich zu anderen aktuellen Methoden. Unsere Ergebnisse finden Anwendung in vielen Bereichen einschließlich Hashing, Lastbalancierung, Datenmanagement, Orientierbarkeit von zufälligen Hypergraphen und maximale Paarungen in einer speziellen Klasse von bipartiten Graphen

Balanced Allocations and Double Hashing

Double hashing has recently found more common usage in schemes that use multiple hash functions. In double hashing, for an item $x$, one generates two hash values $f(x)$ and $g(x)$, and then uses combinations $(f(x) +k g(x)) \bmod n$ for $k=0,1,2,...$ to generate multiple hash values from the initial two. We first perform an empirical study showing that, surprisingly, the performance difference between double hashing and fully random hashing appears negligible in the standard balanced allocation paradigm, where each item is placed in the least loaded of $d$ choices, as well as several related variants. We then provide theoretical results that explain the behavior of double hashing in this context.Comment: Further updated, small improvements/typos fixe

Traffic-Driven Spectrum Allocation in Heterogeneous Networks

Next generation cellular networks will be heterogeneous with dense deployment of small cells in order to deliver high data rate per unit area. Traffic variations are more pronounced in a small cell, which in turn lead to more dynamic interference to other cells. It is crucial to adapt radio resource management to traffic conditions in such a heterogeneous network (HetNet). This paper studies the optimization of spectrum allocation in HetNets on a relatively slow timescale based on average traffic and channel conditions (typically over seconds or minutes). Specifically, in a cluster with $n$ base transceiver stations (BTSs), the optimal partition of the spectrum into $2^n$ segments is determined, corresponding to all possible spectrum reuse patterns in the downlink. Each BTS's traffic is modeled using a queue with Poisson arrivals, the service rate of which is a linear function of the combined bandwidth of all assigned spectrum segments. With the system average packet sojourn time as the objective, a convex optimization problem is first formulated, where it is shown that the optimal allocation divides the spectrum into at most $n$ segments. A second, refined model is then proposed to address queue interactions due to interference, where the corresponding optimal allocation problem admits an efficient suboptimal solution. Both allocation schemes attain the entire throughput region of a given network. Simulation results show the two schemes perform similarly in the heavy-traffic regime, in which case they significantly outperform both the orthogonal allocation and the full-frequency-reuse allocation. The refined allocation shows the best performance under all traffic conditions.Comment: 13 pages, 11 figures, accepted for publication by JSAC-HC

Probabilistic game approaches for network cost allocation

In a restructured power market, the network cost is to be allocated between multiple players utilizing the system in varying capacities. Cooperative game approaches based on Shapley value and Nucleolus provide stable models for embedded cost allocation of power networks. Varying network usage necessitates the introduction of probabilistic approaches to cooperative games. This paper proposes a variety of probabilistic cooperative game approaches. These have variably been modeled based upon the probability of existence of players, the probability of existence of coalitions, and the probability of players joining a particular coalition along with their joining in a particular sequence. Application of these approaches to power networks reflects the system usage in a more justified way. Consistent and stable results qualify the application of probabilistic cooperative game approaches for cost allocation of power networks.Cooperative games, embedded cost allocation, probabilistic games, transmission pricing

Parallel Balanced Allocations: The Heavily Loaded Case

We study parallel algorithms for the classical balls-into-bins problem, in which $m$ balls acting in parallel as separate agents are placed into $n$ bins. Algorithms operate in synchronous rounds, in each of which balls and bins exchange messages once. The goal is to minimize the maximal load over all bins using a small number of rounds and few messages. While the case of $m=n$ balls has been extensively studied, little is known about the heavily loaded case. In this work, we consider parallel algorithms for this somewhat neglected regime of $m\gg n$. The naive solution of allocating each ball to a bin chosen uniformly and independently at random results in maximal load $m/n+\Theta(\sqrt{m/n\cdot \log n})$ (for $m\geq n \log n$) w.h.p. In contrast, for the sequential setting Berenbrink et al (SIAM J. Comput 2006) showed that letting each ball join the least loaded bin of two randomly selected bins reduces the maximal load to $m/n+O(\log\log m)$ w.h.p. To date, no parallel variant of such a result is known. We present a simple parallel threshold algorithm that obtains a maximal load of $m/n+O(1)$ w.h.p. within $O(\log\log (m/n)+\log^* n)$ rounds. The algorithm is symmetric (balls and bins all "look the same"), and balls send $O(1)$ messages in expectation per round. The additive term of $O(\log^* n)$ in the complexity is known to be tight for such algorithms (Lenzen and Wattenhofer Distributed Computing 2016). We also prove that our analysis is tight, i.e., algorithms of the type we provide must run for $\Omega(\min\{\log\log (m/n),n\})$ rounds w.h.p. Finally, we give a simple asymmetric algorithm (i.e., balls are aware of a common labeling of the bins) that achieves a maximal load of $m/n + O(1)$ in a constant number of rounds w.h.p. Again, balls send only a single message per round, and bins receive $(1+o(1))m/n+O(\log n)$ messages w.h.p

The densest subgraph problem in sparse random graphs

We determine the asymptotic behavior of the maximum subgraph density of large random graphs with a prescribed degree sequence. The result applies in particular to the Erd\H{o}s-R\'{e}nyi model, where it settles a conjecture of Hajek [IEEE Trans. Inform. Theory 36 (1990) 1398-1414]. Our proof consists in extending the notion of balanced loads from finite graphs to their local weak limits, using unimodularity. This is a new illustration of the objective method described by Aldous and Steele [In Probability on Discrete Structures (2004) 1-72 Springer].Comment: Published at http://dx.doi.org/10.1214/14-AAP1091 in the Annals of Applied Probability (http://www.imstat.org/aap/) by the Institute of Mathematical Statistics (http://www.imstat.org