Evaluation and analysis of hybrid intelligent pattern recognition techniques for speaker identification

This thesis was submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy and awarded by Brunel University.The rapid momentum of the technology progress in the recent years has led to a tremendous rise in the use of biometric authentication systems. The objective of this research is to investigate the problem of identifying a speaker from its voice regardless of the content (i.e. text-independent), and to design efficient methods of combining face and voice in producing a robust authentication system. A novel approach towards speaker identification is developed using wavelet analysis, and multiple neural networks including Probabilistic Neural Network (PNN), General Regressive Neural Network (GRNN)and Radial Basis Function-Neural Network (RBF NN) with the AND voting scheme. This approach is tested on GRID and VidTIMIT cor-pora and comprehensive test results have been validated with state- of-the-art approaches. The system was found to be competitive and it improved the recognition rate by 15% as compared to the classical Mel-frequency Cepstral Coe±cients (MFCC), and reduced the recognition time by 40% compared to Back Propagation Neural Network (BPNN), Gaussian Mixture Models (GMM) and Principal Component Analysis (PCA). Another novel approach using vowel formant analysis is implemented using Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA). Vowel formant based speaker identification is best suitable for real-time implementation and requires only a few bytes of information to be stored for each speaker, making it both storage and time efficient. Tested on GRID and Vid-TIMIT, the proposed scheme was found to be 85.05% accurate when Linear Predictive Coding (LPC) is used to extract the vowel formants, which is much higher than the accuracy of BPNN and GMM. Since the proposed scheme does not require any training time other than creating a small database of vowel formants, it is faster as well. Furthermore, an increasing number of speakers makes it di±cult for BPNN and GMM to sustain their accuracy, but the proposed score-based methodology stays almost linear. Finally, a novel audio-visual fusion based identification system is implemented using GMM and MFCC for speaker identi¯cation and PCA for face recognition. The results of speaker identification and face recognition are fused at different levels, namely the feature, score and decision levels. Both the score-level and decision-level (with OR voting) fusions were shown to outperform the feature-level fusion in terms of accuracy and error resilience. The result is in line with the distinct nature of the two modalities which lose themselves when combined at the feature-level. The GRID and VidTIMIT test results validate that the proposed scheme is one of the best candidates for the fusion of face and voice due to its low computational time and high recognition accuracy

Acoustic Approaches to Gender and Accent Identification

There has been considerable research on the problems of speaker and language recognition from samples of speech. A less researched problem is that of accent recognition. Although this is a similar problem to language identification, di�erent accents of a language exhibit more fine-grained di�erences between classes than languages. This presents a tougher problem for traditional classification techniques. In this thesis, we propose and evaluate a number of techniques for gender and accent classification. These techniques are novel modifications and extensions to state of the art algorithms, and they result in enhanced performance on gender and accent recognition. The first part of the thesis focuses on the problem of gender identification, and presents a technique that gives improved performance in situations where training and test conditions are mismatched. The bulk of this thesis is concerned with the application of the i-Vector technique to accent identification, which is the most successful approach to acoustic classification to have emerged in recent years. We show that it is possible to achieve high accuracy accent identification without reliance on transcriptions and without utilising phoneme recognition algorithms. The thesis describes various stages in the development of i-Vector based accent classification that improve the standard approaches usually applied for speaker or language identification, which are insu�cient. We demonstrate that very good accent identification performance is possible with acoustic methods by considering di�erent i-Vector projections, frontend parameters, i-Vector configuration parameters, and an optimised fusion of the resulting i-Vector classifiers we can obtain from the same data. We claim to have achieved the best accent identification performance on the test corpus for acoustic methods, with up to 90% identification rate. This performance is even better than previously reported acoustic-phonotactic based systems on the same corpus, and is very close to performance obtained via transcription based accent identification. Finally, we demonstrate that the utilization of our techniques for speech recognition purposes leads to considerably lower word error rates. Keywords: Accent Identification, Gender Identification, Speaker Identification, Gaussian Mixture Model, Support Vector Machine, i-Vector, Factor Analysis, Feature Extraction, British English, Prosody, Speech Recognition

Robust text independent closed set speaker identification systems and their evaluation

PhD ThesisThis thesis focuses upon text independent closed set speaker identi cation. The contributions relate to evaluation studies in the presence of various types of noise and handset e ects. Extensive evaluations are performed on four databases. The rst contribution is in the context of the use of the Gaussian Mixture Model-Universal Background Model (GMM-UBM) with original speech recordings from only the TIMIT database. Four main simulations for Speaker Identi cation Accuracy (SIA) are presented including di erent fusion strategies: Late fusion (score based), early fusion (feature based) and early-late fusion (combination of feature and score based), late fusion using concatenated static and dynamic features (features with temporal derivatives such as rst order derivative delta and second order derivative delta-delta features, namely acceleration features), and nally fusion of statistically independent normalized scores. The second contribution is again based on the GMM-UBM approach. Comprehensive evaluations of the e ect of Additive White Gaussian Noise (AWGN), and Non-Stationary Noise (NSN) (with and without a G.712 type handset) upon identi cation performance are undertaken. In particular, three NSN types with varying Signal to Noise Ratios (SNRs) were tested corresponding to: street tra c, a bus interior and a crowded talking environment. The performance evaluation also considered the e ect of late fusion techniques based on score fusion, namely mean, maximum, and linear weighted sum fusion. The databases employed were: TIMIT, SITW, and NIST 2008; and 120 speakers were selected from each database to yield 3,600 speech utterances. The third contribution is based on the use of the I-vector, four combinations of I-vectors with 100 and 200 dimensions were employed. Then, various fusion techniques using maximum, mean, weighted sum and cumulative fusion with the same I-vector dimension were used to improve the SIA. Similarly, both interleaving and concatenated I-vector fusion were exploited to produce 200 and 400 I-vector dimensions. The system was evaluated with four di erent databases using 120 speakers from each database. TIMIT, SITW and NIST 2008 databases were evaluated for various types of NSN namely, street-tra c NSN, bus-interior NSN and crowd talking NSN; and the G.712 type handset at 16 kHz was also applied. As recommendations from the study in terms of the GMM-UBM approach, mean fusion is found to yield overall best performance in terms of the SIA with noisy speech, whereas linear weighted sum fusion is overall best for original database recordings. However, in the I-vector approach the best SIA was obtained from the weighted sum and the concatenated fusion.Ministry of Higher Education and Scienti c Research (MoHESR), and the Iraqi Cultural Attach e, Al-Mustansiriya University, Al-Mustansiriya University College of Engineering in Iraq for supporting my PhD scholarship

Open-set Speaker Identification

This study is motivated by the growing need for effective extraction of intelligence and evidence from audio recordings in the fight against crime, a need made ever more apparent with the recent expansion of criminal and terrorist organisations. The main focus is to enhance open-set speaker identification process within the speaker identification systems, which are affected by noisy audio data obtained under uncontrolled environments such as in the street, in restaurants or other places of businesses. Consequently, two investigations are initially carried out including the effects of environmental noise on the accuracy of open-set speaker recognition, which thoroughly cover relevant conditions in the considered application areas, such as variable training data length, background noise and real world noise, and the effects of short and varied duration reference data in open-set speaker recognition. The investigations led to a novel method termed “vowel boosting” to enhance the reliability in speaker identification when operating with varied duration speech data under uncontrolled conditions. Vowels naturally contain more speaker specific information. Therefore, by emphasising this natural phenomenon in speech data, it enables better identification performance. The traditional state-of-the-art GMM-UBMs and i-vectors are used to evaluate “vowel boosting”. The proposed approach boosts the impact of the vowels on the speaker scores, which improves the recognition accuracy for the specific case of open-set identification with short and varied duration of speech material

Dealing with linguistic mismatches for automatic speech recognition

Recent breakthroughs in automatic speech recognition (ASR) have resulted in a word error rate (WER) on par with human transcribers on the English Switchboard benchmark. However, dealing with linguistic mismatches between the training and testing data is still a significant challenge that remains unsolved. Under the monolingual environment, it is well-known that the performance of ASR systems degrades significantly when presented with the speech from speakers with different accents, dialects, and speaking styles than those encountered during system training. Under the multi-lingual environment, ASR systems trained on a source language achieve even worse performance when tested on another target language because of mismatches in terms of the number of phonemes, lexical ambiguity, and power of phonotactic constraints provided by phone-level n-grams. In order to address the issues of linguistic mismatches for current ASR systems, my dissertation investigates both knowledge-gnostic and knowledge-agnostic solutions. In the first part, classic theories relevant to acoustics and articulatory phonetics that present capability of being transferred across a dialect continuum from local dialects to another standardized language are re-visited. Experiments demonstrate the potentials that acoustic correlates in the vicinity of landmarks could help to build a bridge for dealing with mismatches across difference local or global varieties in a dialect continuum. In the second part, we design an end-to-end acoustic modeling approach based on connectionist temporal classification loss and propose to link the training of acoustics and accent altogether in a manner similar to the learning process in human speech perception. This joint model not only performed well on ASR with multiple accents but also boosted accuracies of accent identification task in comparison to separately-trained models

PHONOTACTIC AND ACOUSTIC LANGUAGE RECOGNITION

Práce pojednává o fonotaktickém a akustickém přístupu pro automatické rozpoznávání jazyka. První část práce pojednává o fonotaktickém přístupu založeném na výskytu fonémových sekvenci v řeči. Nejdříve je prezentován popis vývoje fonémového rozpoznávače jako techniky pro přepis řeči do sekvence smysluplných symbolů. Hlavní důraz je kladen na dobré natrénování fonémového rozpoznávače a kombinaci výsledků z několika fonémových rozpoznávačů trénovaných na různých jazycích (Paralelní fonémové rozpoznávání následované jazykovými modely (PPRLM)). Práce také pojednává o nové technice anti-modely v PPRLM a studuje použití fonémových grafů místo nejlepšího přepisu. Na závěr práce jsou porovnány dva přístupy modelování výstupu fonémového rozpoznávače -- standardní n-gramové jazykové modely a binární rozhodovací stromy. Hlavní přínos v akustickém přístupu je diskriminativní modelování cílových modelů jazyků a první experimenty s kombinací diskriminativního trénování a na příznacích, kde byl odstraněn vliv kanálu. Práce dále zkoumá různé druhy technik fúzi akustického a fonotaktického přístupu. Všechny experimenty jsou provedeny na standardních datech z NIST evaluaci konané v letech 2003, 2005 a 2007, takže jsou přímo porovnatelné s výsledky ostatních skupin zabývajících se automatickým rozpoznáváním jazyka. S fúzí uvedených technik jsme posunuli state-of-the-art výsledky a dosáhli vynikajících výsledků ve dvou NIST evaluacích.This thesis deals with phonotactic and acoustic techniques for automatic language recognition (LRE). The first part of the thesis deals with the phonotactic language recognition based on co-occurrences of phone sequences in speech. A thorough study of phone recognition as tokenization technique for LRE is done, with focus on the amounts of training data for phone recognizer and on the combination of phone recognizers trained on several language (Parallel Phone Recognition followed by Language Model - PPRLM). The thesis also deals with novel technique of anti-models in PPRLM and investigates into using phone lattices instead of strings. The work on phonotactic approach is concluded by a comparison of classical n-gram modeling techniques and binary decision trees. The acoustic LRE was addressed too, with the main focus on discriminative techniques for training target language acoustic models and on initial (but successful) experiments with removing channel dependencies. We have also investigated into the fusion of phonotactic and acoustic approaches. All experiments were performed on standard data from NIST 2003, 2005 and 2007 evaluations so that the results are directly comparable to other laboratories in the LRE community. With the above mentioned techniques, the fused systems defined the state-of-the-art in the LRE field and reached excellent results in NIST evaluations.

Robust speaker identification against computer aided voice impersonation

Speaker Identification (SID) systems offer good performance in the case of noise free speech and most of the on-going research aims at improving their reliability in noisy environments. In ideal operating conditions very low identification error rates can be achieved. The low error rates suggest that SID systems can be used in real-life applications as an extra layer of security along with existing secure layers. They can, for instance, be used alongside a Personal Identification Number (PIN) or passwords. SID systems can also be used by law enforcements agencies as a detection system to track wanted people over voice communications networks. In this thesis, the performance of 'the existing SID systems against impersonation attacks is analysed and strategies to counteract them are discussed. A voice impersonation system is developed using Gaussian Mixture Modelling (GMM) utilizing Line Spectral Frequencies (LSF) as the features representing the spectral parameters of the source-target pair. Voice conversion systems based on probabilistic approaches suffer from the problem of over smoothing of the converted spectrum. A hybrid scheme using Linear Multivariate Regression and GMM, together with posterior probability smoothing is proposed to reduce over smoothing and alleviate the discontinuities in the converted speech. The converted voices are used to intrude a closed-set SID system in the scenarios of identity disguise and targeted speaker impersonation. The results of the intrusion suggest that in their present form the SID systems are vulnerable to deliberate voice conversion attacks. For impostors to transform their voices, a large volume of speech data is required, which may not be easily accessible. In the context of improving the performance of SID against deliberate impersonation attacks, the use of multiple classifiers is explored. Linear Prediction (LP) residual of the speech signal is also analysed for speaker-specific excitation information. A speaker identification system based on multiple classifier system, using features to describe the vocal tract and the LP residual is targeted by the impersonation system. The identification results provide an improvement in rejecting impostor claims when presented with converted voices. It is hoped that the findings in this thesis, can lead to the development of speaker identification systems which are better equipped to deal with the problem with deliberate voice impersonation.EThOS - Electronic Theses Online ServiceGBUnited Kingdo

Speech Recognition

Chapters in the first part of the book cover all the essential speech processing techniques for building robust, automatic speech recognition systems: the representation for speech signals and the methods for speech-features extraction, acoustic and language modeling, efficient algorithms for searching the hypothesis space, and multimodal approaches to speech recognition. The last part of the book is devoted to other speech processing applications that can use the information from automatic speech recognition for speaker identification and tracking, for prosody modeling in emotion-detection systems and in other speech processing applications that are able to operate in real-world environments, like mobile communication services and smart homes