Energy-maximising moment-based constrained optimal control of ocean wave energy farms

Successful commercialisation of wave energy technology inherently incorporates the concept of an array of wave energy converters (WECs). These devices, which constantly interact via hydrodynamic effects, require optimised control that can guarantee maximum energy extraction from incoming ocean waves while ensuring, at the same time, that any physical limitations associated with device and actuator systems are being consistently respected. This paper presents a moment-based energy-maximising optimal control framework for WECs arrays subject to state and input constraints. The authors develop a framework under which the objective function (and system variables) can be mapped to a finite-dimensional tractable quadratic program (QP), which can be efficiently solved using state-of-the-art solvers. Moreover, the authors show that this QP is always concave, i.e. existence and uniqueness of a globally optimal solution is guaranteed under this moment-based framework. The performance of the proposed strategy is demonstrated through a case study, where (state and input constrained) energy-maximisation for a WEC farm composed of CorPower-like WEC devices is considered

Empowering wave energy with control technology: Possibilities and pitfalls

With an increasing focus on climate action and energy security, an appropriate mix of renewable energy technologies is imperative. Despite having considerable global potential, wave energy has still not reached a state of maturity or economic competitiveness to have made an impact. Challenges include the high capital and operational costs associated with deployment in the harsh ocean environment, so it is imperative that the full energy harnessing capacity of wave energy devices, and arrays of devices in farms, is realised. To this end, control technology has an important role to play in maximising power capture, while ensuring that physical system constraints are respected, and control actions do not adversely affect device lifetime. Within the gamut of control technology, a variety of tools can be brought to bear on the wave energy control problem, including various control strategies (optimal, robust, nonlinear, etc.), data-based model identification, estimation, and forecasting. However, the wave energy problem displays a number of unique features which challenge the traditional application of these techniques, while also presenting a number of control ‘paradoxes’. This review articulates the important control-related characteristics of the wave energy control problem, provides a survey of currently applied control and control-related techniques, and gives some perspectives on the outstanding challenges and future possibilities. The emerging area of control co-design, which is especially relevant to the relatively immature area of wave energy system design, is also covered

Optimal control of wave energy converters

Wave Energy Converters (WECs) are devices designed to absorb energy from ocean waves. The particular type of Wave Energy Converter (WEC) considered in this thesis is an oscillating body; energy conversion is carried out by means of a structure immersed in water which oscillates under forces exerted by waves. This thesis addresses the control of oscillating body WECs and the objective of the control system is to optimise the motion of the devices that maximises the energy absorption. In particular, this thesis presents the formulation of the optimal control problem for WECs in the framework of direct transcription methods, known as spectral and pseudospectral optimal control. Direct transcription methods transform continuous time optimal control problems into Non Linear Programming (NLP) problems, for which the literature (and the market) offer a large number of standard algorithms (and software packages). It is shown, in this thesis, that direct transcription gives the possibility of formulating complex control problems where realistic scenarios can be taken into account, such as physical limitations and nonlinearities in the behaviour of the devices. Additionally, by means of spectral and pseudospectral methods, it is possible to find an approximation of the optimal solution directly from sampled frequency and impulse response models of the radiation forces, obviating the need for finite order approximate models. By implementing a spectral method, convexity of the NLP problem, associated with the optimal control problem for a single body WEC described by a linear model, is demonstrated analytically. The solution to a nonlinear optimal control problem is approximated by means of pseudospectral optimal control. In the nonlinear case, simulation results show a significant difference in the optimal behaviour of the device, both in the motion and in the energy absorption, when the quadratic term describing the viscous forces are dominant, compared to the linear case. This thesis also considers the comparison of two control strategies for arrays of WECs. A Global Control strategy computes the optimal motion by taking into account the complete model of the array and it provides the global optimum for the absorbed energy. In contrast, an Independent Control strategy implements a control system on each device which is independent from all the other devices. The final part of the thesis illustrates an approach for the study of the effects of constraints on the total absorbed energy. The procedure allows the feasibility of the constrained energy maximisation problem to be studied, and it provides an intuitive framework for the design of WECs relating to the power take-off operating envelope, thanks to the geometrical interpretation of the functions describing both the total absorbed energy and the constraints

OPTIMIZATION AND CONTROL OF ARRAYS OF WAVE ENERGY CONVERTERS

Wave Energy Converter Array is a practical approach to harvest ocean wave energy. To leverage the potential of the WEC array in terms of energy extraction, it is essential to have a properly designed array configuration and control system. This thesis explores the optimal configuration of Wave Energy Converters (WECs) arrays and their optimal control. The optimization of the WEC array allows both dimensions of individual WECs as well as the array layout to varying. In the first optimization problem, cylindrical buoys are assumed in the array where their radii and drafts are optimization parameters. Genetic Algorithms are used for optimization. Three case studies are investigated of different array sizes: 3, 5, and 7 devices in the array. Two types of controls are assumed; the first is the standard impedance matching control while the second is a derivative control. The numerical test cases demonstrate that a higher q-factor is achieved when optimizing the buoys dimensions simultaneously with the array layout. In the conducted test cases, it is shown that optimizing the array layout can increase the q-factor on average by 39.21% when using optimal control, and increase it on average by a factor of 8.87% when using a derivative control. Arrays of wave energy converters (WECs) usually have large spacing between members of the array to avoid negative hydrodynamic interaction between members in the array. Errors in estimating the spacing between members may result in a significant degradation in the performance of the array in terms of the total harvested energy, due to destructive hydrodynamic interaction between members of the array. In this thesis, a hybrid design of wave energy converter arrays, that contains two types of WECs, the heaving buoys, and the floating flap-type devices, is investigated and compared against traditional WEC arrays of heaving buoys. The resulting q-factor is less sensitive to deviations in the spacing from the design layout. This hybrid array, hence, enables more WECs in the same ocean area. The two types of arrays are tested using 40 layouts that have different separation distances ranging from small to large. With the hybrid configuration, the array achieved a variance of the q-factor as low as 0.006. The traditional array has a variance of 0.024 which is four times larger. The optimization is conducted on the hybrid array with both layout and dimension as design variables. The optimal control algorithm for the WEC array is developed using the optimality condition. Devices in the array are assumed to be identical heaving buoys. The optimization objective is to maximize energy extraction at each time step. Both regular and irregular waves are used to excite the array. The unconstrained optimal control problem is solved with saturation on the control force. The solutions show that good wave estimations and sufficient accuracy of the radiation sub-system are the keys to the desired WEC array performance

Optimal control of wave energy converters

Wave Energy Converters (WECs) are devices designed to absorb energy from ocean waves. The particular type of Wave Energy Converter (WEC) considered in this thesis is an oscillating body; energy conversion is carried out by means of a structure immersed in water which oscillates under forces exerted by waves. This thesis addresses the control of oscillating body WECs and the objective of the control system is to optimise the motion of the devices that maximises the energy absorption. In particular, this thesis presents the formulation of the optimal control problem for WECs in the framework of direct transcription methods, known as spectral and pseudospectral optimal control. Direct transcription methods transform continuous time optimal control problems into Non Linear Programming (NLP) problems, for which the literature (and the market) offer a large number of standard algorithms (and software packages). It is shown, in this thesis, that direct transcription gives the possibility of formulating complex control problems where realistic scenarios can be taken into account, such as physical limitations and nonlinearities in the behaviour of the devices. Additionally, by means of spectral and pseudospectral methods, it is possible to find an approximation of the optimal solution directly from sampled frequency and impulse response models of the radiation forces, obviating the need for finite order approximate models. By implementing a spectral method, convexity of the NLP problem, associated with the optimal control problem for a single body WEC described by a linear model, is demonstrated analytically. The solution to a nonlinear optimal control problem is approximated by means of pseudospectral optimal control. In the nonlinear case, simulation results show a significant difference in the optimal behaviour of the device, both in the motion and in the energy absorption, when the quadratic term describing the viscous forces are dominant, compared to the linear case. This thesis also considers the comparison of two control strategies for arrays of WECs. A Global Control strategy computes the optimal motion by taking into account the complete model of the array and it provides the global optimum for the absorbed energy. In contrast, an Independent Control strategy implements a control system on each device which is independent from all the other devices. The final part of the thesis illustrates an approach for the study of the effects of constraints on the total absorbed energy. The procedure allows the feasibility of the constrained energy maximisation problem to be studied, and it provides an intuitive framework for the design of WECs relating to the power take-off operating envelope, thanks to the geometrical interpretation of the functions describing both the total absorbed energy and the constraints

Optimal Control of Wave Energy Converters

In this dissertation, we address the optimal control of the Wave Energy Converters. The Wave Energy Converters introduced in this study can be categorized as the single body heaving device, the single body pitching device, the single body three degrees of freedoms device, and the Wave Energy Converters array. Different types of Wave Energy Converters are modeled mathematically, and different optimal controls are developed for them. The objective of the optimal controllers is to maximize the energy extraction with and without the motion and control constraints. The development of the unconstrained control is first introduced which includes the implementation of the Singular Arc control and the Simple Model Control. The constrained optimal control is then introduced which contains the Shape-based approach, Pseudospectral control, the Linear Quadratic Gaussian optimal control, and the Collective Control. The wave estimation is also discussed since it is required by the controllers. Several estimators are implemented, such as the Kalman Filter, the Extended Kalman Filter, and the Kalman-Consensus Filter. They can be applied for estimating the system states and the wave excitation force/wave excitation force field. Last, the controllers are validated with the Discrete Displacement Hydraulic system which is the Power Take-off unit of the Wave Energy Converter. The simulation results show that the proposed optimal controllers can maximize the energy absorption when the wave estimation is accurate. The performance of the unconstrained controllers is close to the theoretical maximum (Complex Conjugate Control). Furthermore, the energy extraction is optimized and the constraints are satisfied by applying the constrained controllers. However, when the proposed controllers are further validated with the hydraulic system, they extract less energy than a simple Proportional-derivative control. This indicates the dynamics of the Power take-off unit needs to be considered in designing the control to obtain the robustness

Modelling and Optimization of Wave Energy Converters

Wave energy offers a promising renewable energy source. This guide presents numerical modelling and optimisation methods for the development of wave energy converter technologies, from principles to applications. It covers oscillating water column technologies, theoretical wave power absorption, heaving point absorbers in single and multi-mode degrees of freedom, and the relatively hitherto unexplored topic of wave energy harvesting farms. It can be used as a specialist student textbook as well as a reference book for the design of wave energy harvesting systems, across a broad range of disciplines, including renewable energy, marine engineering, infrastructure engineering, hydrodynamics, ocean science, and mechatronics engineering. The Open Access version of this book, available at https://www.routledge.com/ has been made available under a Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives 4.0 license

Optimization and Energy Maximizing Control Systems for Wave Energy Converters

The book, “Optimization and Energy Maximizing Control Systems for Wave Energy Converters”, presents eleven contributions on the latest scientific advancements of 2020-2021 in wave energy technology optimization and control, including holistic techno-economic optimization, inclusion of nonlinear effects, and real-time implementations of estimation and control algorithms

Control, forecasting and optimisation for wave energy conversion

This paper presents an overview of the motivation, background to and state-of- the-art in energy maximising control of wave energy devices. The underpinning mathematical modelling is described and the control fundamentals established. Two example control schemes are presented, along with some algorithms for wave forecasting, which can be a necessary requirement, due to the non-causal nature of some optimal control strategies. One of the control schemes is extended to show how cooperative control of devices in a wave farm can be beneficial. The paper also includes perspectives on the interaction between control and the broader objectives of optimal wave energy device geometry and full techno-economic optimisation of wave energy converters