Survivable mesh-network design & optimization to support multiple QoP service classes

Every second, vast amounts of data are transferred over communication systems around the world, and as a result, the demands on optical infrastructures are extending beyond the traditional, ring-based architecture. The range of content and services available from the Internet is increasing, and network operations are constantly under pressure to expand their optical networks in order to keep pace with the ever increasing demand for higher speed and more reliable links

Availability Constrained Routing And Wavelength Assignment And Survivability In Optical Wdm Networks

Tez (Doktora) -- İstanbul Teknik Üniversitesi, Fen Bilimleri Enstitüsü, 2009Thesis (PhD) -- İstanbul Technical University, Institute of Science and Technology, 2009Bu çalışmada, optik ağlarda kullanılabilirlik kısıtı altında yol ve dalgaboyu atama konusu farklı sürdürülebilirlik politikaları altında çalışılmış ve elde edilen sonuçlar benzetim aracılığıyla doğrulanarak sunulmuştur. Öncelikle paylaşılan yol koruması altında sınırsız kaynak bulunması durumunda kullanılabilirlik kısıtı altında yol ve dalgaboyu atamaya yönelik planlama amaçlı bağlantı kurma yöntemleri sezgisel ve optimizasyona dayalı olarak önerilmiştir. Sonrasında bu teknikler kısıtlı kaynak altında ve farklılaştırılmış kullanılabilirlik düzeyi gereksinimleri ile gelen bağlantı isteklerinin olması koşulu altında çalışabilecek şekilde adapte edilmiş ve başarımları sınanmıştır. Önerilen tekniklerin literatürde yaygın olarak bilinen bağlantı kurma tekniklerinin başarımını bağlantı düşürme olasılığı ve bağlantı kullanılabilirliği açısından yükselttiği, bunun yanında yedek kaynak tüketim fazlasını da gözeterek kabul edilir bir düzeyde tuttuğu gözlenmiştir. Özellikle optimizasyon tabanlı bağlantı kurma tekniğinin, farklılaştırılmış bağlantı isteklerinin bulunduğu ortamda kaynak tüketimini de düşürdüğü gösterilmiştir. Son olarak da, segmanlı koruma için önceden önerilmiş bir kullanılabilirlik analizine rastlanamadığı için, paylaşılan segmanlı koruma için kullanılabilirlik analizi yöntemi önerilerek benzetim aracılığıyla doğrulanmıştır. Bu analiz kullanılarak da segmanlı koruma altında kullanılabilirliği gözeten yol ve dalgaboyu atama yöntemleri oluşturularak başarımları kaynak kısıtlı ve kaynakça zengin ortamlarda denenerek uygulanabilirlikleri belirlenmiştir.In this study, we have proposed availability aware routing and wavelength assignment schemes for optical networks under different survivability policies. The proposed techniques are evaluated by simulation. First, we have proposed heuristic and optimization driven connection provisioning schemes under shared backup path protection in resource plentiful environment. Then, the proposed schemes are modified to work in resource limited environment where connections arrive with differentiated availability requirements. The proposed techniques are compared to a conventional reliable connection provisioning algorithm. The simulation results show that the proposed techniques lead to lower connection blocking probability and better connection availability. Besides this, it is also shown that the proposed techniques also keep the resource overbuild due to protection in a feasible range. Moreover, the experimental results also show that the optimization driven technique leads to a decreased resource overbuild under resource limited environment for connection arrivals with differentiated availability requirements. The last part of this work deals with shared segment protection. Since there is no specific availability analysis method for shared segment protection, an availability analysis method for this protection scheme is proposed and validated by simulation. Based on this analysis, availability aware connection provisioning schemes are constructed, their performance is evaluated in resource plentiful and resource scarce environments, and the applicability of the schemes are determined in terms of environmental constraints.DoktoraPh

Crosslayer Survivability in Overlay-IP-WDM Networks

As the Internet moves towards a three-layer architecture consisting of overlay networks on top of the IP network layer on top of WDM-based physical networks, incorporating the interaction between and among network layers is crucial for efficient and effective implementation of survivability.This dissertation has four major foci as follows: First, a first-of-its-kind analysis of the impact of overlay network dependency on the lower layer network unveils that backhaul, a link loop that occurs at any two or more lower layers below the layer where traffic is present, could happen. This prompts our proposal of a crosslayer survivable mapping to highlight such challenges and to offer survivability in an efficient backhaul-free way. The results demonstrate that the impact of layer dependency is more severe than initially anticipated making it clear that independent single layer network design is inadequate to assure service guarantees and efficient capacity allocation. Second, a forbidden link matrix is proposed masking part of the network for use in situations where some physical links are reserved exclusively for a designated service, mainly for the context of providing multiple levels of differentiation on the network use and service guarantee. The masking effect is evaluated on metrics using practical approaches in a sample real-world network, showing that both efficiency and practicality can be achieved. Third, matrix-based optimization problem formulations of several crosslayer survivable mappings are presented; examples on the link availability mapping are particularly illustrated. Fourth, survivability strategies for two-layer backbone networks where traffic originates at each layer are investigated. Optimization-based formulations of performing recovery mechanisms at each layer for both layers of traffic are also presented. Numerical results indicate that, in such a wavelength-based optical network, implementing survivability of all traffic at the bottom layer can be a viable solution with significant advantages.This dissertation concludes by identifying a roadmap of potential future work for crosslayer survivability in layered network settings

Efficient shared segment protection in optical networks

This thesis introduces a new shared segment protection scheme that ensures both node and link protection in an efficient manner in terms of cost. Although the segment protection scheme exhibits an interesting compromise between link and path protection schemes and attempts to encompass all their advantages, it has been much less explored than the other protection approaches. The proposed work investigates two different Shared Segment Protection (SSP) schemes: Basic Shared Segment Protection (BSSP) and a new segment protection, called Shared Segment Protection with segment Overlap (SSPO). For both BSSP and SSPO schemes, we propose two novel efficient and scalable ILP formulations, based on a column generation mathematical modeling. SSPO offers more advantages over BSSP as it ensures both node and link protections, in addition to shorter delays. It is not necessarily more expensive while BSSP ensures only link protection. Indeed, depending on the network topology and the traffic instances, it can be shown that neither of the two SSP schemes is dominant in terms of cost. The mathematical models have been solved using column generation techniques. Simulations have been conducted to validate the two segment protection models and to evaluate the performance of the two segment protection schemes under different traffic scenarios. In addition, we have estimated when an additional cost (and how much) is needed in order to ensure node protection

On Integrating Failure Localization with Survivable Design

In this thesis, I proposed a novel framework of all-optical failure restoration which jointly determines network monitoring plane and spare capacity allocation in the presence of either static or dynamic traffic. The proposed framework aims to enable a general shared protection scheme to achieve near optimal capacity efficiency as in Failure Dependent Protection(FDP) while subject to an ultra-fast, all-optical, and deterministic failure restoration process. Simply put, Local Unambiguous Failure Localization(L-UFL) and FDP are the two building blocks for the proposed restoration framework. Under L-UFL, by properly allocating a set of Monitoring Trails (m-trails), a set of nodes can unambiguously identify every possible Shared Risk Link Group (SRLG) failure merely based on its locally collected Loss of Light(LOL) signals. Two heuristics are proposed to solve L-UFL, one of which exclusively deploys Supervisory Lightpaths (S-LPs) while the other jointly considers S-LPs and Working Lightpaths (W-LPs) for suppressing monitoring resource consumption. Thanks to the ``Enhanced Min Wavelength Max Information principle'', an entropy based utility function, m-trail global-sharing and other techniques, the proposed heuristics exhibit satisfactory performance in minimizing the number of m-trails, Wavelength Channel(WL) consumption and the running time of the algorithm. Based on the heuristics for L-UFL, two algorithms, namely MPJD and DJH, are proposed for the novel signaling-free restoration framework to deal with static and dynamic traffic respectively. MPJD is developed to determine the Protection Lightpaths (P-LPs) and m-trails given the pre-computed W-LPs while DJH jointly implements a generic dynamic survivable routing scheme based on FDP with an m-trail deployment scheme. For both algorithms, m-trail deployment is guided by the Necessary Monitoring Requirement (NMR) defined at each node for achieving signaling-free restoration. Extensive simulation is conducted to verify the performance of the proposed heuristics in terms of WL consumption, number of m-trails, monitoring requirement, blocking probability and running time. In conclusion, the proposed restoration framework can achieve all-optical and signaling-free restoration with the help of L-UFL, while maintaining high capacity efficiency as in FDP based survivable routing. The proposed heuristics achieve satisfactory performance as verified by the simulation results

p-Cycle Based Protection in WDM Mesh Networks

Abstract p-Cycle Based Protection in WDM Mesh Networks Honghui Li, Ph.D. Concordia University, 2012 WDM techniques enable single fiber to carry huge amount of data. However, optical WDM networks are prone to failures, and therefore survivability is a very important requirement in the design of optical networks. In the context of network survivability, p-cycle based schemes attracted extensive research interests as they well balance the recovery speed and the capacity efficiency. Towards the design of p-cycle based survivableWDM mesh networks, some issues still need to be addressed. The conventional p-cycle design models and solution methods suffers from scalability issues. Besides, most studies on the design of p-cycle based schemes only cope with single link failures without any concern about single node failures. Moreover, loop backs may exist in the recovery paths along p-cycles, which lead to unnecessary stretching of the recovery path lengths. This thesis investigates the scalable and efficient design of segment p-cycles against single link failures. The optimization models and their solutions rely on large-scale optimization techniques, namely, Column Generation (CG) modeling and solution, where segment pcycle candidates are dynamically generated during the optimization process. To ensure full node protection in the context of link p-cycles, we propose an efficient protection scheme, called node p-cycles, and develop a scalable optimization design model. It is shown that, depending on the network topology, node p-cycles sometimes outperform path p-cycles in iii terms of capacity efficiency. Also, an enhanced segment p-cycle scheme is proposed, entitled segment Np-cycles, for full link and node protection. Again, the CG-based optimization models are developed for the design of segment Np-cycles. Two objectives are considered, minimizing the spare capacity usage and minimizing the CAPEX cost. It is shown that segment Np-cycles can ensure full node protection with marginal extra cost in comparison with segment p-cycles for link protection. Segment Np-cycles provide faster recovery speed than path p-cycles although they are slightly more costly than path p-cycles. Furthermore, we propose the shortcut p-cycle scheme, i.e., p-cycles free of loop backs for full node and link protection, in addition to shortcuts in the protection paths. A CG-based optimization model for the design of shortcut p-cycles is formulated as well. It is shown that, for full node protection, shortcut p-cycles have advantages over path p-cycles with respect to capacity efficiency and recovery speed. We have studied a whole sequence of protection schemes from link p-cycles to path p-cycles, and concluded that the best compromise is the segment Np-cycle scheme for full node protection with respect to capacity efficiency and recovery time. Therefore, this thesis offers to network operators several interesting alternatives to path p-cycles in the design of survivable WDM mesh networks against any single link/node failures

Differentiated quality-of-recovery and quality-of-protection in survivable WDM mesh networks

In the modern telecommunication business, there is a need to provide different Quality-of-Recovery (QoR) and Quality-of-Protection (QoP) classes in order to accommodate as many customers as possible, and to optimize the protection capacity cost. Prevalent protection methods to provide specific QoS related to protection are based on pre-defined shape protection structures (topologies), e.g., p -cycles and p -trees. Although some of these protection patterns are known to provide a good trade-off among the different protection parameters, their shapes can limit their deployment in some specific network conditions, e.g., a constrained link spare capacity budget and traffic distribution. In this thesis, we propose to re-think the design process of protection schemes in survivable WDM networks by adopting a hew design approach where the shapes of the protection structures are decided based on the targeted QoR and QoP guarantees, and not the reverse. We focus on the degree of pre-configuration of the protection topologies, and use fully and partially pre-cross connected p -structures, and dynamically cross connected p -structures. In QoR differentiation, we develop different approaches for pre-configuring the protection capacity in order to strike different balances between the protection cost and the availability requirements in the network; while in the QoP differentiation, we focus on the shaping of the protection structures to provide different grades of protection including single and dual-link failure protection. The new research directions proposed and developed in this thesis are intended to help network operators to effectively support different Quality-of-Recovery and Quality-of-Protection classes. All new ideas have been translated into mathematical models for which we propose practical and efficient design methods in order to optimize the inherent cost to the different designs of protection schemes. Furthermore, we establish a quantitative relation between the degree of pre-configuration of the protection structures and their costs in terms of protection capacity. Our most significant contributions are the design and development of Pre-Configured Protection Structure (p-structure) and Pre-Configured Protection Extended-Tree (p -etree) based schemes. Thanks to the column generation modeling and solution approaches, we propose a new design approach of protection schemes where we deploy just enough protection to provide different quality of recovery and protection classe

Minimizing the Number of Constraints for Shared Backup Path Protection (SBPP) in Shared Risk Link Group (SRLG) Optical Mesh Networks

Path-arc integer linear programming (ILP) models for shared backup path protection (SBPP) in optical mesh networks generally contain many redundant constraints for calculating shared backup capacity. This greatly increases the computational time of the ILP solvers. In this paper, we first identify the sharing relationship between working and backup capacities, which facilitates the development of two novel algorithms for minimizing the number of constraints in ILP models for SBPP in mesh networks. Next, we consider the more realistic case of Shared Risk Link Group (SRLG) networks, where some optical fibers have the same risk of a physical cut due to being bundled in the same conduit. We propose a path-arc ILP model for SBPP in SRLG networks and minimize the number of constraints in this ILP model using the proposed algorithms. Simulation results show a remarkable reduction of around 50% in the number of constraints, which significantly improves the computational complexity of the model

Risk-based Survivable Network Design

Communication networks are part of the critical infrastructure upon which society and the economy depends; therefore it is crucial for communication networks to survive failures and physical attacks to provide critical services. Survivability techniques are deployed to ensure the functionality of communication networks in the face of failures. The basic approach for designing survivable networks is that given a survivability technique (e.g., link protection, or path protection) the network is designed to survive a set of predefined failures (e.g., all single-link failures) with minimum cost. However, a hidden assumption in this design approach is that the sufficient monetary funds are available to protect all predefined failures, which might not be the case in practice as network operators may have a limited budget for improving network survivability. To overcome this limitation, this dissertation proposed a new approach for designing survivable networks, namely; risk-based survivable network design, which integrates risk analysis techniques into an incremental network design procedure with budget constraints. In the risk-based design approach, the basic design problem considered is that given a working network and a fixed budget, how best to allocate the budget for deploying a survivability technique in different parts of the network based on the risk. The term risk measures two related quantities: the likelihood of failure or attack, and the amount of damage caused by the failure or attack. Various designs with different risk-based design objectives are considered, for example, minimizing the expected damage, minimizing the maximum damage, and minimizing a measure of the variability of damage that could occur in the network. In this dissertation, a design methodology for the proposed risk-based survivable network design approach is presented. The design problems are formulated as Integer Programming (InP) models; and in order to scale the solution of models, some greedy heuristic solution algorithms are developed. Numerical results and analysis illustrating different risk-based designs are presented

Supporting differentiated classes of resilience in multilayer networks

Services provided over telecommunications networks typically have different resilience requirements and networks need to be able to support different levels of resilience in an efficient manner. This dissertation investigates the problem of supporting differentiated classes of resilience in multilayer networks, including the most stringent resilience class required by critical services. We incorporate an innovative technique of embedding a subnetwork, termed the spine, with comparatively higher availability values at the physical layer. The spine lays a foundation for differentiation between multiple classes of flows that can be leveraged to achieve both high resilience and differentiation. The aim of this research is mainly to explore, design, and evaluate the proposed spine concept model in multilayer networks. The dissertation has four major parts. First, we explore the spine concept through numerical analysis of simple topologies illustrating the potential benefits and the cost considerations of the spine. We develop heuristics algorithms to find suitable spines for a network based on the structural properties of the network topology. Second, an optimization problem is formulated to determine the spine. The problem encompasses estimates of link availability improvements, associated costs, and a total budget. Third, we propose a crosslayer mapping and spine-aware routing design problem with protection given mainly at the lower layer. The problem is designed to transfer lower layer differentiation capability to the upper layer network and flows. We provide two joint routing-mapping optimization formulations and evaluate their performance in a multilayer scenario. Fourth, the joint routing-mapping problem is redesigned with protection given in the upper network layer instead. This will create two isolated logical networks; one mapped to the spine and the other is mapped freely on the network. Flows are assigned a path or path-pair based on their class of resilience. This approach can provide more routing options yielding different availability levels. The joint routing-mapping design problems are formulated as Integer Linear Programming (ILP) models. The goal is to achieve a wider range of availability values across layers and high availability levels for mission-critical services without the need to use higher order protection configurations. The proposed models are evaluated with extensive numerical results using real network topologies