Vector coprocessor sharing techniques for multicores: performance and energy gains

Vector Processors (VPs) created the breakthroughs needed for the emergence of computational science many years ago. All commercial computing architectures on the market today contain some form of vector or SIMD processing. Many high-performance and embedded applications, often dealing with streams of data, cannot efficiently utilize dedicated vector processors for various reasons: limited percentage of sustained vector code due to substantial flow control; inherent small parallelism or the frequent involvement of operating system tasks; varying vector length across applications or within a single application; data dependencies within short sequences of instructions, a problem further exacerbated without loop unrolling or other compiler optimization techniques. Additionally, existing rigid SIMD architectures cannot tolerate efficiently dynamic application environments with many cores that may require the runtime adjustment of assigned vector resources in order to operate at desired energy/performance levels. To simultaneously alleviate these drawbacks of rigid lane-based VP architectures, while also releasing on-chip real estate for other important design choices, the first part of this research proposes three architectural contexts for the implementation of a shared vector coprocessor in multicore processors. Sharing an expensive resource among multiple cores increases the efficiency of the functional units and the overall system throughput. The second part of the dissertation regards the evaluation and characterization of the three proposed shared vector architectures from the performance and power perspectives on an FPGA (Field-Programmable Gate Array) prototype. The third part of this work introduces performance and power estimation models based on observations deduced from the experimental results. The results show the opportunity to adaptively adjust the number of vector lanes assigned to individual cores or processing threads in order to minimize various energy-performance metrics on modern vector- capable multicore processors that run applications with dynamic workloads. Therefore, the fourth part of this research focuses on the development of a fine-to-coarse grain power management technique and a relevant adaptive hardware/software infrastructure which dynamically adjusts the assigned VP resources (number of vector lanes) in order to minimize the energy consumption for applications with dynamic workloads. In order to remove the inherent limitations imposed by FPGA technologies, the fifth part of this work consists of implementing an ASIC (Application Specific Integrated Circuit) version of the shared VP towards precise performance-energy studies involving high- performance vector processing in multicore environments

Distributed Time-Predictable Memory Interconnect for Multi-Core Architectures

Multi-core architectures are increasingly adopted in emerging real-time applications where execution time is required to be bounded in the worst case (i.e., time predictability) and low. Memory access latency is the main part forming the overall execution time. A promising approach towards time predictability is to employ distributed memory interconnects, either locally arbitrated interconnects or globally arbitrated interconnects, with arbitration schemes, and the pipelined tree-based structure can break the critical path of multiplexing into short steps with small logic size. It scales to a large number of processors that high clock frequency can be synthesised. This research explores timing behaviour of multi-core architectures with shared distributed memory interconnects and improves distributed time-predictable memory interconnects for multi-core architectures. The contributions are mainly threefold. First, the generic analytical flow is proposed for time-predictable behaviour of memory accesses across multi-core architectures with locally arbitrated interconnects. It guarantees time predictability and safely bound the worst case without exact memory access profiles. Second, the root queue modification with the root queue management is proposed for multi-core architectures with locally arbitrated interconnects that variation of memory access latency is reduced and timing behaviour analysis is facilitated. Third, Meshed Bluetree is proposed as the distributed time-predictable multi-memory interconnect, enabling multiple processors to simultaneously access multiple memory modules

Massive Data-Centric Parallelism in the Chiplet Era

Traditionally, massively parallel applications are executed on distributed systems, where computing nodes are distant enough that the parallelization schemes must minimize communication and synchronization to achieve scalability. Mapping communication-intensive workloads to distributed systems requires complicated problem partitioning and dataset pre-processing. With the current AI-driven trend of having thousands of interconnected processors per chip, there is an opportunity to re-think these communication-bottlenecked workloads. This bottleneck often arises from data structure traversals, which cause irregular memory accesses and poor cache locality. Recent works have introduced task-based parallelization schemes to accelerate graph traversal and other sparse workloads. Data structure traversals are split into tasks and pipelined across processing units (PUs). Dalorex demonstrated the highest scalability (up to thousands of PUs on a single chip) by having the entire dataset on-chip, scattered across PUs, and executing the tasks at the PU where the data is local. However, it also raised questions on how to scale to larger datasets when all the memory is on chip, and at what cost. To address these challenges, we propose a scalable architecture composed of a grid of Data-Centric Reconfigurable Array (DCRA) chiplets. Package-time reconfiguration enables creating chip products that optimize for different target metrics, such as time-to-solution, energy, or cost, while software reconfigurations avoid network saturation when scaling to millions of PUs across many chip packages. We evaluate six applications and four datasets, with several configurations and memory technologies, to provide a detailed analysis of the performance, power, and cost of data-local execution at scale. Our parallelization of Breadth-First-Search with RMAT-26 across a million PUs reaches 3323 GTEPS

Efficient runtime placement management for high performance and reliability in COTS FPGAs

Designing high-performance, fault-tolerant multisensory electronic systems for hostile environments such as nuclear plants and outer space within the constraints of cost, power and flexibility is challenging. Issues such as ionizing radiation, extreme temperature and ageing can lead to faults in the electronics of these systems. In addition, the remote nature of these environments demands a level of flexibility and autonomy in their operations. The standard practice of using specially hardened electronic devices for such systems is not only very expensive but also has limited flexibility. This thesis proposes novel techniques that promote the use of Commercial Off-The- Shelf (COTS) reconfigurable devices to meet the challenges of high-performance systems for hostile environments. Reconfigurable hardware such as Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGA) have a unique combination of flexibility and high performance. The flexibility offered through features such as dynamic partial reconfiguration (DPR) can be harnessed not only to achieve cost-effective designs as a smaller area can be used to execute multiple tasks, but also to improve the reliability of a system as a circuit on one portion of the device can be physically relocated to another portion in the case of fault occurrence. However, to harness these potentials for high performance and reliability in a cost-effective manner, novel runtime management tools are required. Most runtime support tools for reconfigurable devices are based on ideal models which do not adequately consider the limitations of realistic FPGAs, in particular modern FPGAs which are increasingly heterogeneous. Specifically, these tools lack efficient mechanisms for ensuring a high utilization of FPGA resources, including the FPGA area and the configuration port and clocking resources, in a reliable manner. To ensure high utilization of reconfigurable device area, placement management is a key aspect of these tools. This thesis presents novel techniques for the management of hardware task placement on COTS reconfigurable devices for high performance and reliability. To this end, it addresses design-time issues that affect efficient hardware task placement, with a focus on reliability. It also presents techniques to maximize the utilization of the FPGA area in runtime, including techniques to minimize fragmentation. Fragmentation leads to the creation of unusable areas due to dynamic placement of tasks and the heterogeneity of the resources on the chip. Moreover, this thesis also presents an efficient task reuse mechanism to improve the availability of the internal configuration infrastructure of the FPGA for critical responsibilities like error mitigation. The task reuse scheme, unlike previous approaches, also improves the utilization of the chip area by offering defragmentation. Task relocation, which involves changing the physical location of circuits is a technique for error mitigation and high performance. Hence, this thesis also provides a functionality-based relocation mechanism for improving the number of locations to which tasks can be relocated on heterogeneous FPGAs. As tasks are relocated, clock networks need to be routed to them. As such, a reliability-aware technique of clock network routing to tasks after placement is also proposed. Finally, this thesis offers a prototype implementation and characterization of a placement management system (PMS) which is an integration of the aforementioned techniques. The performance of most of the proposed techniques are tested using data processing tasks of a NASA JPL spectrometer application. The results show that the proposed techniques have potentials to improve the reliability and performance of applications in hostile environment compared to state-of-the-art techniques. The task optimization technique presented leads to better capacity to circumvent permanent faults on COTS FPGAs compared to state-of-the-art approaches (48.6% more errors were circumvented for the JPL spectrometer application). The proposed task reuse scheme leads to approximately 29% saving in the amount of configuration time. This frees up the internal configuration interface for more error mitigation operations. In addition, the proposed PMS has a worst-case latency of less than 50% of that of state-of- the-art runtime placement systems, while maintaining the same level of placement quality and resource overhead

Synthesis Techniques for Semi-Custom Dynamically Reconfigurable Superscalar Processors

The accelerated adoption of reconfigurable computing foreshadows a computational paradigm shift, aimed at fulfilling the need of customizable yet high-performance flexible hardware. Reconfigurable computing fulfills this need by allowing the physical resources of a chip to be adapted to the computational requirements of a specific program, thus achieving higher levels of computing performance. This dissertation evaluates the area requirements for reconfigurable processing, an important yet often disregarded assessment for partial reconfiguration. Common reconfigurable computing approaches today attempt to create custom circuitry in static co-processor accelerators. We instead focused on a new approach that synthesized semi-custom general-purpose processor cores. Each superscalar processor core's execution units can be customized for a particular application, yet the processor retains its standard microprocessor interface. We analyzed the area consumption for these computational components by studying the synthesis requirements of different processor configurations. This area/performance assessment aids designers when constraining processing elements in a fixed-size area slot, a requirement for modern partial reconfiguration approaches. Our results provide a more deterministic evaluation of performance density, hence making the area cost analysis less ambiguous when optimizing dynamic systems for coarse-grained parallelism. The results obtained showed that even though performance density decreases with processor complexity, the additional area still provides a positive contribution to the aggregate parallel processing performance. This evaluation of parallel execution density contributes to ongoing efforts in the field of reconfigurable computing by providing a baseline for area/performance trade-offs for partial reconfiguration and multi-processor systems

Real-Time Trace Decoding and Monitoring for Safety and Security in Embedded Systems

Integrated circuits and systems can be found almost everywhere in today’s world. As their use increases, they need to be made safer and more perfor mant to meet current demands in processing power. FPGA integrated SoCs can provide the ideal trade-off between performance, adaptability, and energy usage. One of today’s vital challenges lies in updating existing fault tolerance techniques for these new systems while utilizing all available processing capa bilities, such as multi-core and heterogeneous processing units. Control-flow monitoring is one of the primary mechanisms described for error detection at the software architectural level for the highest grade of hazard level clas sifications (e.g., ASIL D) described in industry safety standards ISO-26262. Control-flow errors are also known to compose the majority of detected errors for ICs and embedded systems in safety-critical and risk-susceptible environ ments [5]. Software-based monitoring methods remain the most popular [6–8]. However, recent studies show that the overheads they impose make actual reliability gains negligible [9, 10]. This work proposes and demonstrates a new control flow checking method implemented in FPGA for multi-core embedded systems called control-flow trace checker (CFTC). CFTC uses existing trace and debug subsystems of modern processors to rebuild their execution states. It can iden tify any errors in real-time by comparing executed states to a set of permitted state transitions determined statically. This novel implementation weighs hardware resource trade-offs to target mul tiple independent tasks in multi-core embedded applications, as well as single core systems. The proposed system is entirely implemented in hardware and isolated from all monitored software components, requiring 2.4% of the target FPGA platform resources to protect an execution unit in its entirety. There fore, it avoids undesired overheads and maintains deterministic error detection latencies, which guarantees reliability improvements without impairing the target software system. Finally, CFTC is evaluated under different software i Resumo fault-injection scenarios, achieving detection rates of 100% of all control-flow errors to wrong destinations and 98% of all injected faults to program binaries. All detection times are further analyzed and precisely described by a model based on the monitor’s resources and speed and the software application’s control-flow structure and binary characteristics.Circuitos integrados estão presentes em quase todos sistemas complexos do mundo moderno. Conforme sua frequência de uso aumenta, eles precisam se tornar mais seguros e performantes para conseguir atender as novas demandas em potência de processamento. Sistemas em Chip integrados com FPGAs conseguem prover o balanço perfeito entre desempenho, adaptabilidade, e uso de energia. Um dos maiores desafios agora é a necessidade de atualizar técnicas de tolerância à falhas para estes novos sistemas, aproveitando os novos avanços em capacidade de processamento. Monitoramento de fluxo de controle é um dos principais mecanismos para a detecção de erros em nível de software para sistemas classificados como de alto risco (e.g. ASIL D), descrito em padrões de segurança como o ISO-26262. Estes erros são conhecidos por compor a maioria dos erros detectados em sistemas integrados [5]. Embora métodos de monitoramento baseados em software continuem sendo os mais populares [6–8], estudos recentes mostram que seus custos adicionais, em termos de performance e área, diminuem consideravelmente seus ganhos reais em confiabilidade [9, 10]. Propomos aqui um novo método de monitora mento de fluxo de controle implementado em FPGA para sistemas embarcados multi-core. Este método usa subsistemas de trace e execução de código para reconstruir o estado atual do processador, identificando erros através de com parações entre diferentes estados de execução da CPU. Propomos uma implementação que considera trade-offs no uso de recuros de sistema para monitorar múltiplas tarefas independetes. Nossa abordagem suporta o monitoramento de sistemas simples e também de sistemas multi-core multitarefa. Por fim, nossa técnica é totalmente implementada em hardware, evitando o uso de unidades de processamento de software que possa adicionar custos indesejáveis à aplicação em perda de confiabilidade. Propomos, assim, um mecanismo de verificação de fluxo de controle, escalável e extensível, para proteção de sistemas embarcados críticos e multi-core

Real-time trace decoding and monitoring for safety and security in embedded systems

Integrated circuits and systems can be found almost everywhere in today’s world. As their use increases, they need to be made safer and more perfor mant to meet current demands in processing power. FPGA integrated SoCs can provide the ideal trade-off between performance, adaptability, and energy usage. One of today’s vital challenges lies in updating existing fault tolerance techniques for these new systems while utilizing all available processing capa bilities, such as multi-core and heterogeneous processing units. Control-flow monitoring is one of the primary mechanisms described for error detection at the software architectural level for the highest grade of hazard level clas sifications (e.g., ASIL D) described in industry safety standards ISO-26262. Control-flow errors are also known to compose the majority of detected errors for ICs and embedded systems in safety-critical and risk-susceptible environ ments [5]. Software-based monitoring methods remain the most popular [6–8]. However, recent studies show that the overheads they impose make actual reliability gains negligible [9, 10]. This work proposes and demonstrates a new control flow checking method implemented in FPGA for multi-core embedded systems called control-flow trace checker (CFTC). CFTC uses existing trace and debug subsystems of modern processors to rebuild their execution states. It can iden tify any errors in real-time by comparing executed states to a set of permitted state transitions determined statically. This novel implementation weighs hardware resource trade-offs to target mul tiple independent tasks in multi-core embedded applications, as well as single core systems. The proposed system is entirely implemented in hardware and isolated from all monitored software components, requiring 2.4% of the target FPGA platform resources to protect an execution unit in its entirety. There fore, it avoids undesired overheads and maintains deterministic error detection latencies, which guarantees reliability improvements without impairing the target software system. Finally, CFTC is evaluated under different software i Resumo fault-injection scenarios, achieving detection rates of 100% of all control-flow errors to wrong destinations and 98% of all injected faults to program binaries. All detection times are further analyzed and precisely described by a model based on the monitor’s resources and speed and the software application’s control-flow structure and binary characteristics.Circuitos integrados estão presentes em quase todos sistemas complexos do mundo moderno. Conforme sua frequência de uso aumenta, eles precisam se tornar mais seguros e performantes para conseguir atender as novas demandas em potência de processamento. Sistemas em Chip integrados com FPGAs conseguem prover o balanço perfeito entre desempenho, adaptabilidade, e uso de energia. Um dos maiores desafios agora é a necessidade de atualizar técnicas de tolerância à falhas para estes novos sistemas, aproveitando os novos avanços em capacidade de processamento. Monitoramento de fluxo de controle é um dos principais mecanismos para a detecção de erros em nível de software para sistemas classificados como de alto risco (e.g. ASIL D), descrito em padrões de segurança como o ISO-26262. Estes erros são conhecidos por compor a maioria dos erros detectados em sistemas integrados [5]. Embora métodos de monitoramento baseados em software continuem sendo os mais populares [6–8], estudos recentes mostram que seus custos adicionais, em termos de performance e área, diminuem consideravelmente seus ganhos reais em confiabilidade [9, 10]. Propomos aqui um novo método de monitora mento de fluxo de controle implementado em FPGA para sistemas embarcados multi-core. Este método usa subsistemas de trace e execução de código para reconstruir o estado atual do processador, identificando erros através de com parações entre diferentes estados de execução da CPU. Propomos uma implementação que considera trade-offs no uso de recuros de sistema para monitorar múltiplas tarefas independetes. Nossa abordagem suporta o monitoramento de sistemas simples e também de sistemas multi-core multitarefa. Por fim, nossa técnica é totalmente implementada em hardware, evitando o uso de unidades de processamento de software que possa adicionar custos indesejáveis à aplicação em perda de confiabilidade. Propomos, assim, um mecanismo de verificação de fluxo de controle, escalável e extensível, para proteção de sistemas embarcados críticos e multi-core