Multi-sensor data fusion in mobile devices for the identification of Activities of Daily Living

Following the recent advances in technology and the growing use of mobile devices such as smartphones, several solutions may be developed to improve the quality of life of users in the context of Ambient Assisted Living (AAL). Mobile devices have different available sensors, e.g., accelerometer, gyroscope, magnetometer, microphone and Global Positioning System (GPS) receiver, which allow the acquisition of physical and physiological parameters for the recognition of different Activities of Daily Living (ADL) and the environments in which they are performed. The definition of ADL includes a well-known set of tasks, which include basic selfcare tasks, based on the types of skills that people usually learn in early childhood, including feeding, bathing, dressing, grooming, walking, running, jumping, climbing stairs, sleeping, watching TV, working, listening to music, cooking, eating and others. On the context of AAL, some individuals (henceforth called user or users) need particular assistance, either because the user has some sort of impairment, or because the user is old, or simply because users need/want to monitor their lifestyle. The research and development of systems that provide a particular assistance to people is increasing in many areas of application. In particular, in the future, the recognition of ADL will be an important element for the development of a personal digital life coach, providing assistance to different types of users. To support the recognition of ADL, the surrounding environments should be also recognized to increase the reliability of these systems. The main focus of this Thesis is the research on methods for the fusion and classification of the data acquired by the sensors available in off-the-shelf mobile devices in order to recognize ADL in almost real-time, taking into account the large diversity of the capabilities and characteristics of the mobile devices available in the market. In order to achieve this objective, this Thesis started with the review of the existing methods and technologies to define the architecture and modules of the method for the identification of ADL. With this review and based on the knowledge acquired about the sensors available in off-the-shelf mobile devices, a set of tasks that may be reliably identified was defined as a basis for the remaining research and development to be carried out in this Thesis. This review also identified the main stages for the development of a new method for the identification of the ADL using the sensors available in off-the-shelf mobile devices; these stages are data acquisition, data processing, data cleaning, data imputation, feature extraction, data fusion and artificial intelligence. One of the challenges is related to the different types of data acquired from the different sensors, but other challenges were found, including the presence of environmental noise, the positioning of the mobile device during the daily activities, the limited capabilities of the mobile devices and others. Based on the acquired data, the processing was performed, implementing data cleaning and feature extraction methods, in order to define a new framework for the recognition of ADL. The data imputation methods were not applied, because at this stage of the research their implementation does not have influence in the results of the identification of the ADL and environments, as the features are extracted from a set of data acquired during a defined time interval and there are no missing values during this stage. The joint selection of the set of usable sensors and the identifiable set of tasks will then allow the development of a framework that, considering multi-sensor data fusion technologies and context awareness, in coordination with other information available from the user context, such as his/her agenda and the time of the day, will allow to establish a profile of the tasks that the user performs in a regular activity day. The classification method and the algorithm for the fusion of the features for the recognition of ADL and its environments needs to be deployed in a machine with some computational power, while the mobile device that will use the created framework, can perform the identification of the ADL using a much less computational power. Based on the results reported in the literature, the method chosen for the recognition of the ADL is composed by three variants of Artificial Neural Networks (ANN), including simple Multilayer Perceptron (MLP) networks, Feedforward Neural Networks (FNN) with Backpropagation, and Deep Neural Networks (DNN). Data acquisition can be performed with standard methods. After the acquisition, the data must be processed at the data processing stage, which includes data cleaning and feature extraction methods. The data cleaning method used for motion and magnetic sensors is the low pass filter, in order to reduce the noise acquired; but for the acoustic data, the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) was applied to extract the different frequencies. When the data is clean, several features are then extracted based on the types of sensors used, including the mean, standard deviation, variance, maximum value, minimum value and median of raw data acquired from the motion and magnetic sensors; the mean, standard deviation, variance and median of the maximum peaks calculated with the raw data acquired from the motion and magnetic sensors; the five greatest distances between the maximum peaks calculated with the raw data acquired from the motion and magnetic sensors; the mean, standard deviation, variance, median and 26 Mel- Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCC) of the frequencies obtained with FFT based on the raw data acquired from the microphone data; and the distance travelled calculated with the data acquired from the GPS receiver. After the extraction of the features, these will be grouped in different datasets for the application of the ANN methods and to discover the method and dataset that reports better results. The classification stage was incrementally developed, starting with the identification of the most common ADL (i.e., walking, running, going upstairs, going downstairs and standing activities) with motion and magnetic sensors. Next, the environments were identified with acoustic data, i.e., bedroom, bar, classroom, gym, kitchen, living room, hall, street and library. After the environments are recognized, and based on the different sets of sensors commonly available in the mobile devices, the data acquired from the motion and magnetic sensors were combined with the recognized environment in order to differentiate some activities without motion, i.e., sleeping and watching TV. The number of recognized activities in this stage was increased with the use of the distance travelled, extracted from the GPS receiver data, allowing also to recognize the driving activity. After the implementation of the three classification methods with different numbers of iterations, datasets and remaining configurations in a machine with high processing capabilities, the reported results proved that the best method for the recognition of the most common ADL and activities without motion is the DNN method, but the best method for the recognition of environments is the FNN method with Backpropagation. Depending on the number of sensors used, this implementation reports a mean accuracy between 85.89% and 89.51% for the recognition of the most common ADL, equals to 86.50% for the recognition of environments, and equals to 100% for the recognition of activities without motion, reporting an overall accuracy between 85.89% and 92.00%. The last stage of this research work was the implementation of the structured framework for the mobile devices, verifying that the FNN method requires a high processing power for the recognition of environments and the results reported with the mobile application are lower than the results reported with the machine with high processing capabilities used. Thus, the DNN method was also implemented for the recognition of the environments with the mobile devices. Finally, the results reported with the mobile devices show an accuracy between 86.39% and 89.15% for the recognition of the most common ADL, equal to 45.68% for the recognition of environments, and equal to 100% for the recognition of activities without motion, reporting an overall accuracy between 58.02% and 89.15%. Compared with the literature, the results returned by the implemented framework show only a residual improvement. However, the results reported in this research work comprehend the identification of more ADL than the ones described in other studies. The improvement in the recognition of ADL based on the mean of the accuracies is equal to 2.93%, but the maximum number of ADL and environments previously recognized was 13, while the number of ADL and environments recognized with the framework resulting from this research is 16. In conclusion, the framework developed has a mean improvement of 2.93% in the accuracy of the recognition for a larger number of ADL and environments than previously reported. In the future, the achievements reported by this PhD research may be considered as a start point of the development of a personal digital life coach, but the number of ADL and environments recognized by the framework should be increased and the experiments should be performed with different types of devices (i.e., smartphones and smartwatches), and the data imputation and other machine learning methods should be explored in order to attempt to increase the reliability of the framework for the recognition of ADL and its environments.Após os recentes avanços tecnológicos e o crescente uso dos dispositivos móveis, como por exemplo os smartphones, várias soluções podem ser desenvolvidas para melhorar a qualidade de vida dos utilizadores no contexto de Ambientes de Vida Assistida (AVA) ou Ambient Assisted Living (AAL). Os dispositivos móveis integram vários sensores, tais como acelerómetro, giroscópio, magnetómetro, microfone e recetor de Sistema de Posicionamento Global (GPS), que permitem a aquisição de vários parâmetros físicos e fisiológicos para o reconhecimento de diferentes Atividades da Vida Diária (AVD) e os seus ambientes. A definição de AVD inclui um conjunto bem conhecido de tarefas que são tarefas básicas de autocuidado, baseadas nos tipos de habilidades que as pessoas geralmente aprendem na infância. Essas tarefas incluem alimentar-se, tomar banho, vestir-se, fazer os cuidados pessoais, caminhar, correr, pular, subir escadas, dormir, ver televisão, trabalhar, ouvir música, cozinhar, comer, entre outras. No contexto de AVA, alguns indivíduos (comumente chamados de utilizadores) precisam de assistência particular, seja porque o utilizador tem algum tipo de deficiência, seja porque é idoso, ou simplesmente porque o utilizador precisa/quer monitorizar e treinar o seu estilo de vida. A investigação e desenvolvimento de sistemas que fornecem algum tipo de assistência particular está em crescente em muitas áreas de aplicação. Em particular, no futuro, o reconhecimento das AVD é uma parte importante para o desenvolvimento de um assistente pessoal digital, fornecendo uma assistência pessoal de baixo custo aos diferentes tipos de pessoas. pessoas. Para ajudar no reconhecimento das AVD, os ambientes em que estas se desenrolam devem ser reconhecidos para aumentar a fiabilidade destes sistemas. O foco principal desta Tese é o desenvolvimento de métodos para a fusão e classificação dos dados adquiridos a partir dos sensores disponíveis nos dispositivos móveis, para o reconhecimento quase em tempo real das AVD, tendo em consideração a grande diversidade das características dos dispositivos móveis disponíveis no mercado. Para atingir este objetivo, esta Tese iniciou-se com a revisão dos métodos e tecnologias existentes para definir a arquitetura e os módulos do novo método de identificação das AVD. Com esta revisão da literatura e com base no conhecimento adquirido sobre os sensores disponíveis nos dispositivos móveis disponíveis no mercado, um conjunto de tarefas que podem ser identificadas foi definido para as pesquisas e desenvolvimentos desta Tese. Esta revisão também identifica os principais conceitos para o desenvolvimento do novo método de identificação das AVD, utilizando os sensores, são eles: aquisição de dados, processamento de dados, correção de dados, imputação de dados, extração de características, fusão de dados e extração de resultados recorrendo a métodos de inteligência artificial. Um dos desafios está relacionado aos diferentes tipos de dados adquiridos pelos diferentes sensores, mas outros desafios foram encontrados, sendo os mais relevantes o ruído ambiental, o posicionamento do dispositivo durante a realização das atividades diárias, as capacidades limitadas dos dispositivos móveis. As diferentes características das pessoas podem igualmente influenciar a criação dos métodos, escolhendo pessoas com diferentes estilos de vida e características físicas para a aquisição e identificação dos dados adquiridos a partir de sensores. Com base nos dados adquiridos, realizou-se o processamento dos dados, implementando-se métodos de correção dos dados e a extração de características, para iniciar a criação do novo método para o reconhecimento das AVD. Os métodos de imputação de dados foram excluídos da implementação, pois não iriam influenciar os resultados da identificação das AVD e dos ambientes, na medida em que são utilizadas as características extraídas de um conjunto de dados adquiridos durante um intervalo de tempo definido. A seleção dos sensores utilizáveis, bem como das AVD identificáveis, permitirá o desenvolvimento de um método que, considerando o uso de tecnologias para a fusão de dados adquiridos com múltiplos sensores em coordenação com outras informações relativas ao contexto do utilizador, tais como a agenda do utilizador, permitindo estabelecer um perfil de tarefas que o utilizador realiza diariamente. Com base nos resultados obtidos na literatura, o método escolhido para o reconhecimento das AVD são as diferentes variantes das Redes Neuronais Artificiais (RNA), incluindo Multilayer Perceptron (MLP), Feedforward Neural Networks (FNN) with Backpropagation and Deep Neural Networks (DNN). No final, após a criação dos métodos para cada fase do método para o reconhecimento das AVD e ambientes, a implementação sequencial dos diferentes métodos foi realizada num dispositivo móvel para testes adicionais. Após a definição da estrutura do método para o reconhecimento de AVD e ambientes usando dispositivos móveis, verificou-se que a aquisição de dados pode ser realizada com os métodos comuns. Após a aquisição de dados, os mesmos devem ser processados no módulo de processamento de dados, que inclui os métodos de correção de dados e de extração de características. O método de correção de dados utilizado para sensores de movimento e magnéticos é o filtro passa-baixo de modo a reduzir o ruído, mas para os dados acústicos, a Transformada Rápida de Fourier (FFT) foi aplicada para extrair as diferentes frequências. Após a correção dos dados, as diferentes características foram extraídas com base nos tipos de sensores usados, sendo a média, desvio padrão, variância, valor máximo, valor mínimo e mediana de dados adquiridos pelos sensores magnéticos e de movimento, a média, desvio padrão, variância e mediana dos picos máximos calculados com base nos dados adquiridos pelos sensores magnéticos e de movimento, as cinco maiores distâncias entre os picos máximos calculados com os dados adquiridos dos sensores de movimento e magnéticos, a média, desvio padrão, variância e 26 Mel-Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCC) das frequências obtidas com FFT com base nos dados obtidos a partir do microfone, e a distância calculada com os dados adquiridos pelo recetor de GPS. Após a extração das características, as mesmas são agrupadas em diferentes conjuntos de dados para a aplicação dos métodos de RNA de modo a descobrir o método e o conjunto de características que reporta melhores resultados. O módulo de classificação de dados foi incrementalmente desenvolvido, começando com a identificação das AVD comuns com sensores magnéticos e de movimento, i.e., andar, correr, subir escadas, descer escadas e parado. Em seguida, os ambientes são identificados com dados de sensores acústicos, i.e., quarto, bar, sala de aula, ginásio, cozinha, sala de estar, hall, rua e biblioteca. Com base nos ambientes reconhecidos e os restantes sensores disponíveis nos dispositivos móveis, os dados adquiridos dos sensores magnéticos e de movimento foram combinados com o ambiente reconhecido para diferenciar algumas atividades sem movimento (i.e., dormir e ver televisão), onde o número de atividades reconhecidas nesta fase aumenta com a fusão da distância percorrida, extraída a partir dos dados do recetor GPS, permitindo também reconhecer a atividade de conduzir. Após a implementação dos três métodos de classificação com diferentes números de iterações, conjuntos de dados e configurações numa máquina com alta capacidade de processamento, os resultados relatados provaram que o melhor método para o reconhecimento das atividades comuns de AVD e atividades sem movimento é o método DNN, mas o melhor método para o reconhecimento de ambientes é o método FNN with Backpropagation. Dependendo do número de sensores utilizados, esta implementação reporta uma exatidão média entre 85,89% e 89,51% para o reconhecimento das AVD comuns, igual a 86,50% para o reconhecimento de ambientes, e igual a 100% para o reconhecimento de atividades sem movimento, reportando uma exatidão global entre 85,89% e 92,00%. A última etapa desta Tese foi a implementação do método nos dispositivos móveis, verificando que o método FNN requer um alto poder de processamento para o reconhecimento de ambientes e os resultados reportados com estes dispositivos são inferiores aos resultados reportados com a máquina com alta capacidade de processamento utilizada no desenvolvimento do método. Assim, o método DNN foi igualmente implementado para o reconhecimento dos ambientes com os dispositivos móveis. Finalmente, os resultados relatados com os dispositivos móveis reportam uma exatidão entre 86,39% e 89,15% para o reconhecimento das AVD comuns, igual a 45,68% para o reconhecimento de ambientes, e igual a 100% para o reconhecimento de atividades sem movimento, reportando uma exatidão geral entre 58,02% e 89,15%. Com base nos resultados relatados na literatura, os resultados do método desenvolvido mostram uma melhoria residual, mas os resultados desta Tese identificam mais AVD que os demais estudos disponíveis na literatura. A melhoria no reconhecimento das AVD com base na média das exatidões é igual a 2,93%, mas o número máximo de AVD e ambientes reconhecidos pelos estudos disponíveis na literatura é 13, enquanto o número de AVD e ambientes reconhecidos com o método implementado é 16. Assim, o método desenvolvido tem uma melhoria de 2,93% na exatidão do reconhecimento num maior número de AVD e ambientes. Como trabalho futuro, os resultados reportados nesta Tese podem ser considerados um ponto de partida para o desenvolvimento de um assistente digital pessoal, mas o número de ADL e ambientes reconhecidos pelo método deve ser aumentado e as experiências devem ser repetidas com diferentes tipos de dispositivos móveis (i.e., smartphones e smartwatches), e os métodos de imputação e outros métodos de classificação de dados devem ser explorados de modo a tentar aumentar a confiabilidade do método para o reconhecimento das AVD e ambientes

Developing a Home Service Robot Platform for Smart Homes

The purpose of this work is to develop a testbed for a smart home environment integrated with a home service robot (ASH Testbed) as well as to build home service robot platforms. The architecture of ASH Testbed was proposed and implemented based on ROS (Robot Operating System). In addition, two robot platforms, ASCCHomeBots, were developed using an iRobot Create base and a Pioneer base. They are equipped with capabilities such as mapping, autonomous navigation. They are also equipped with the natural human interfaces including hand-gesture recognition using a RGB-D camera, online speech recognition through cloud computing services provided by Google, and local speech recognition based on PocketSphinx. Furthermore, the Pioneer based ASCCHomeBot was developed along with an open audition system. This allows the robot to serve the elderly living alone at home. We successfully implemented the software for this system that realizes robot services and audition services for high level applications such as telepresence video conference, sound source position estimation, multiple source speech recognition, and human assisted sound classification. Our experimental results validated the proposed framework and the effectiveness of the developed robots as well as the proposed testbed.Electrical Engineerin

Advances in Robotics, Automation and Control

The book presents an excellent overview of the recent developments in the different areas of Robotics, Automation and Control. Through its 24 chapters, this book presents topics related to control and robot design; it also introduces new mathematical tools and techniques devoted to improve the system modeling and control. An important point is the use of rational agents and heuristic techniques to cope with the computational complexity required for controlling complex systems. Through this book, we also find navigation and vision algorithms, automatic handwritten comprehension and speech recognition systems that will be included in the next generation of productive systems developed by man

Intelligent Sensors for Human Motion Analysis

The book, "Intelligent Sensors for Human Motion Analysis," contains 17 articles published in the Special Issue of the Sensors journal. These articles deal with many aspects related to the analysis of human movement. New techniques and methods for pose estimation, gait recognition, and fall detection have been proposed and verified. Some of them will trigger further research, and some may become the backbone of commercial systems

16th Sound and Music Computing Conference SMC 2019 (28–31 May 2019, Malaga, Spain)

The 16th Sound and Music Computing Conference (SMC 2019) took place in Malaga, Spain, 28-31 May 2019 and it was organized by the Application of Information and Communication Technologies Research group (ATIC) of the University of Malaga (UMA). The SMC 2019 associated Summer School took place 25-28 May 2019. The First International Day of Women in Inclusive Engineering, Sound and Music Computing Research (WiSMC 2019) took place on 28 May 2019. The SMC 2019 TOPICS OF INTEREST included a wide selection of topics related to acoustics, psychoacoustics, music, technology for music, audio analysis, musicology, sonification, music games, machine learning, serious games, immersive audio, sound synthesis, etc

Unsupervised video indexing on audiovisual characterization of persons

Cette thèse consiste à proposer une méthode de caractérisation non-supervisée des intervenants dans les documents audiovisuels, en exploitant des données liées à leur apparence physique et à leur voix. De manière générale, les méthodes d'identification automatique, que ce soit en vidéo ou en audio, nécessitent une quantité importante de connaissances a priori sur le contenu. Dans ce travail, le but est d'étudier les deux modes de façon corrélée et d'exploiter leur propriété respective de manière collaborative et robuste, afin de produire un résultat fiable aussi indépendant que possible de toute connaissance a priori. Plus particulièrement, nous avons étudié les caractéristiques du flux audio et nous avons proposé plusieurs méthodes pour la segmentation et le regroupement en locuteurs que nous avons évaluées dans le cadre d'une campagne d'évaluation. Ensuite, nous avons mené une étude approfondie sur les descripteurs visuels (visage, costume) qui nous ont servis à proposer de nouvelles approches pour la détection, le suivi et le regroupement des personnes. Enfin, le travail s'est focalisé sur la fusion des données audio et vidéo en proposant une approche basée sur le calcul d'une matrice de cooccurrence qui nous a permis d'établir une association entre l'index audio et l'index vidéo et d'effectuer leur correction. Nous pouvons ainsi produire un modèle audiovisuel dynamique des intervenants.This thesis consists to propose a method for an unsupervised characterization of persons within audiovisual documents, by exploring the data related for their physical appearance and their voice. From a general manner, the automatic recognition methods, either in video or audio, need a huge amount of a priori knowledge about their content. In this work, the goal is to study the two modes in a correlated way and to explore their properties in a collaborative and robust way, in order to produce a reliable result as independent as possible from any a priori knowledge. More particularly, we have studied the characteristics of the audio stream and we have proposed many methods for speaker segmentation and clustering and that we have evaluated in a french competition. Then, we have carried a deep study on visual descriptors (face, clothing) that helped us to propose novel approches for detecting, tracking, and clustering of people within the document. Finally, the work was focused on the audiovisual fusion by proposing a method based on computing the cooccurrence matrix that allowed us to establish an association between audio and video indexes, and to correct them. That will enable us to produce a dynamic audiovisual model for each speaker

Sequential decision making in artificial musical intelligence

Over the past 60 years, artificial intelligence has grown from a largely academic field of research to a ubiquitous array of tools and approaches used in everyday technology. Despite its many recent successes and growing prevalence, certain meaningful facets of computational intelligence have not been as thoroughly explored. Such additional facets cover a wide array of complex mental tasks which humans carry out easily, yet are difficult for computers to mimic. A prime example of a domain in which human intelligence thrives, but machine understanding is still fairly limited, is music. Over the last decade, many researchers have applied computational tools to carry out tasks such as genre identification, music summarization, music database querying, and melodic segmentation. While these are all useful algorithmic solutions, we are still a long way from constructing complete music agents, able to mimic (at least partially) the complexity with which humans approach music. One key aspect which hasn't been sufficiently studied is that of sequential decision making in musical intelligence. This thesis strives to answer the following question: Can a sequential decision making perspective guide us in the creation of better music agents, and social agents in general? And if so, how? More specifically, this thesis focuses on two aspects of musical intelligence: music recommendation and human-agent (and more generally agent-agent) interaction in the context of music. The key contributions of this thesis are the design of better music playlist recommendation algorithms; the design of algorithms for tracking user preferences over time; new approaches for modeling people's behavior in situations that involve music; and the design of agents capable of meaningful interaction with humans and other agents in a setting where music plays a roll (either directly or indirectly). Though motivated primarily by music-related tasks, and focusing largely on people's musical preferences, this thesis also establishes that insights from music-specific case studies can also be applicable in other concrete social domains, such as different types of content recommendation. Showing the generality of insights from musical data in other contexts serves as evidence for the utility of music domains as testbeds for the development of general artificial intelligence techniques. Ultimately, this thesis demonstrates the overall usefulness of taking a sequential decision making approach in settings previously unexplored from this perspectiveComputer Science

Multimodal Video Analysis and Modeling

From recalling long forgotten experiences based on a familiar scent or on a piece of music, to lip reading aided conversation in noisy environments or travel sickness caused by mismatch of the signals from vision and the vestibular system, the human perception manifests countless examples of subtle and effortless joint adoption of the multiple senses provided to us by evolution. Emulating such multisensory (or multimodal, i.e., comprising multiple types of input modes or modalities) processing computationally offers tools for more effective, efficient, or robust accomplishment of many multimedia tasks using evidence from the multiple input modalities. Information from the modalities can also be analyzed for patterns and connections across them, opening up interesting applications not feasible with a single modality, such as prediction of some aspects of one modality based on another. In this dissertation, multimodal analysis techniques are applied to selected video tasks with accompanying modalities. More specifically, all the tasks involve some type of analysis of videos recorded by non-professional videographers using mobile devices.Fusion of information from multiple modalities is applied to recording environment classification from video and audio as well as to sport type classification from a set of multi-device videos, corresponding audio, and recording device motion sensor data. The environment classification combines support vector machine (SVM) classifiers trained on various global visual low-level features with audio event histogram based environment classification using k nearest neighbors (k-NN). Rule-based fusion schemes with genetic algorithm (GA)-optimized modality weights are compared to training a SVM classifier to perform the multimodal fusion. A comprehensive selection of fusion strategies is compared for the task of classifying the sport type of a set of recordings from a common event. These include fusion prior to, simultaneously with, and after classification; various approaches for using modality quality estimates; and fusing soft confidence scores as well as crisp single-class predictions. Additionally, different strategies are examined for aggregating the decisions of single videos to a collective prediction from the set of videos recorded concurrently with multiple devices. In both tasks multimodal analysis shows clear advantage over separate classification of the modalities.Another part of the work investigates cross-modal pattern analysis and audio-based video editing. This study examines the feasibility of automatically timing shot cuts of multi-camera concert recordings according to music-related cutting patterns learnt from professional concert videos. Cut timing is a crucial part of automated creation of multicamera mashups, where shots from multiple recording devices from a common event are alternated with the aim at mimicing a professionally produced video. In the framework, separate statistical models are formed for typical patterns of beat-quantized cuts in short segments, differences in beats between consecutive cuts, and relative deviation of cuts from exact beat times. Based on music meter and audio change point analysis of a new recording, the models can be used for synthesizing cut times. In a user study the proposed framework clearly outperforms a baseline automatic method with comparably advanced audio analysis and wins 48.2 % of comparisons against hand-edited videos