Measuring the impact of game controllers on player experience in FPS games

An increasing amount of games is released on multiple platforms, and game designers face the challenge of integrating different interaction paradigms for console and PC users while keeping the core mechanics of a game. However, little research has addressed the influence of game controls on player experience. In this paper, we examine the impact of mouse and keyboard versus gamepad control in first-person shooters using the PC and PlayStation 3 versions of Battlefield: Bad Company 2. We conducted a study with 45 participants to compare player experience and game usability issues of participants who had previously played similar games on one of the respective gaming systems, while also exploring the effects of players being forced to switch to an unfamiliar platform. The results show that players switching to a new platform experience more usability issues and consider themselves more challenged, but report an equally positive overall experience as players on their comfort platform. © 2011 ACM

Is movement better? Comparing sedentary and motion-based game controls for older adults

Providing cognitive and physical stimulation for older adults is critical for their well-being. Video games offer the opportunity of engaging seniors, and research has shown a variety of positive effects of motion-based video games for older adults. However, little is known about the suitability of motion-based game controls for older adults and how their use is affected by age-related changes. In this paper, we present a study evaluating sedentary and motion-based game controls with a focus on differences between younger and older adults. Our results show that older adults can apply motion-based game controls efficiently, and that they enjoy motion-based interaction. We present design implications based on our study, and demonstrate how our findings can be applied both to motion-based game design and to general interaction design for older adults. Copyright held by authors

It’s not the model that doesn’t fit, it’s the controller! The role of cognitive skills in understanding the links between natural mapping, performance, and enjoyment of console video games

This study examines differences in performance, frustration, and game ratings of individuals playing first person shooter video games using two different controllers (motion controller and a traditional, pushbutton controller) in a within-subjects, randomized order design. Structural equation modeling was used to demonstrate that cognitive skills such as mental rotation ability and eye/hand coordination predicted performance for both controllers, but the motion control was significantly more frustrating. Moreover, increased performance was only related to game ratings for the traditional controller input. We interpret these data as evidence that, contrary to the assumption that motion controlled interfaces are more naturally mapped than traditional push-button controllers, the traditional controller was more naturally mapped as an interface for gameplay

Removing the HUD: The Impact of Non-Diegetic Game Elements and Expertise on Player Involvement

Previous research has shown that player involvement can be influenced by a range of factors, from the controllers used to the perceived level of challenge provided by the game. However, little attention has been paid to the influence of the game interface. Game interfaces consist of both diegetic (that can be viewed by the player-character, e.g. the game world) and non-diegetic components (that are only viewed by the player, e.g. the heads-up display). In this paper we examine two versions of a first-person shooter game to investigate how immersion is influenced through interacting with a diegetic and non-diegetic interface. Our findings suggest that the removal of non-diegetic elements, such as the heads-up display, is able to influence immersion in expert players through increasing their cognitive involvement and sense of control. We argue that these results illustrate the importance of considering the role of expertise in relation to how particular design choices will influence the player experience

Psychomotor Skill Measurement of Video Game Players

Psychomotor skills are a combination of innate abilities as well as skills developed because of repeated actions. Researchers have dedicated many studies to understand the extent to which past videogame play contributes to psychomotor skills and fine motor control dexterity. However, not all gamers are created equal. With today\u27s proliferation of platforms, many people are gamers who never pick up a controller. Grouping all gamers together forms dangerous confounds when trying to generalize across a population as diverse as today\u27s gamers. The current study aims to study a population comprised only of gamers to see if there are significant differences in their psychomotor skills. A psychomotor skills test has been developed, which is designed to simulate proven physical tests, with the express purpose of exposing differences between gamers. After filling out an extensive survey of gaming habits, participants completed the psychomotor skills test. Participants were then grouped by measured psychomotor ability and a selection of high and low performing gamers completed four tutorial exercises on the dV-Trainer by Mimic Technologies, a validated robotic laparoscopic training device. The study shows that the number of hours reported per week using analog controllers is correlated with the psychomotor score as measured by the newly developed simulation. In particular, the Purdue Pegboard and Finger Tapping simulation software is the best discriminator among members of the gamer population

Stumbling into Virtual Worlds. How Resolution Affects Users’ Immersion in Virtual Reality and Implications for Virtual Reality in Therapeutic Applications

Studies of how users experience Virtual Reality (VR) have thus far failed to address the extent to which rendering resolution and rendering frame rate affect users’ sense of immersion in VR, including applications of VR involving simulators, treatments for psychological and mental disorders, explorations of new and nonexistent structures, and ways to better understand the human body in medical applications. This study investigated if rendering resolution affected users’ sense of immersion in VR. This was conducted by comparing the responses of two groups, relative to two measures of participant immersion: (a) participant’s sense of presence and (b) participant’s sense of embodiment. The treatment levels were (a) low 512 pixels per inch (ppi) and (b) high 2048 ppi rendering resolution. One potential moderating variable, game type, varied over three levels: narrative, objective, and situational. The participants were randomly assigned to a treatment level account for previous VR experience, neither participants nor the research observer knew the treatment level. Measurements were collected after each game via an Immersion tendency Questionnaire after each game. For each dependent measure, sample descriptive statistics—mean (M) and inter-quartile range (IQR) with a conventional significance level of 0.05—were evaluated to conclude the results. Data indicated that the rendering resolution did not affect user immersion, but the game type did affect immersion and the situational game type was determined to be significantly more immersive than the other game types

The Harder the Battle, the More We Talk: The Effects of Perceived Risk of Player Death on Social Presence and Enjoyment in Mobile Fps Game

Even though the relationship between presence and game enjoyment has been explored, there are unsolved theoretical questions regarding the degree to which social presence may be generated in games. Drawing on (social) presence theory, this study investigated the effects of the perceived risk of player death on game enjoyment. Specifically, the current study examined whether there is a relationship between the perceived risk of player death and communication between players; if this communication will serve as a trigger for a social presence; and if social presence will increase game enjoyment. Results from a self-report survey (N = 128) indicated that the perceived risk of player death has no direct relationship with game enjoyment. However, this result unfolds in a different way when social presence is activated. The results of path analysis showed that the higher the players\u27 perceived risk of death, the more players communicate with teammates. Moreover, communication positively influenced players\u27 social presence, and social presence was positively associated with game enjoyment. The study\u27s theoretical findings were discussed regarding the concept of social presence. The appropriate challenge level and user experience in mobile first-person shooting (FPS) games were discussed as practical implications

Gaze-directed gameplay in first person computer games

The use of eye tracking systems in computer games is still at an early stage. Commercial eye trackers and researches have been focusing in gaze-oriented gameplay as an alternative to traditional input devices. This dissertation proposes to investigate the advantages and disadvantages of the use of these systems in computer games. For it, instead of using eye tracking as a simple direct control input, it is proposed to use it in order to control the attention of the player’s avatar (e.g., if the player notices an obstacle in the way, the avatar will notice it too and avoid it) and the game’s procedural content generation (e.g., spawn obstacles in the opposite side of the screen to where the player’s attention is focused). To demonstrate the value of this proposal, it was developed and is herein presented the first-person shooter "Zombie Runner". Tests showed that the implementation meets the stipulated technical requirements and that, although it still needs improvements in terms of precision and robustness, eye tracking technology can be successfully used to to make the player experience more immersive and challenging.A utilização de sistemas de rastreamento ocular em jogos de computador ainda se encontra numa fase embrionária. Aparelhos de rastreamento ocular comerciais e pesquisas na área têm-se focado em jogabilidade à base da atenção visual como uma alternativa a métodos de entrada tradicionais. Esta dissertação propõe-se a investigar as vantages e desvantagens do uso destes sistemas em jogos de computador. Para isso, invés de se usar rastreamento ocular apenas como um método directo de entrada, é proposto usá-lo para controlar a atenção do personagem do jogo (e.g., se o jogador reparar num obstáculo, a personagem também repara e desvia-se do mesmo) assim como afectar a geração procedimental do jogo (e.g., gerar obstáculos no lado oposto ao qual o jogador tem a sua atenção focada). Para demonstrar o valor desta proposta, foi desenvolvido e aqui apresentado o jogo de tiros em primeira pessoa "Zombie Runner". Os testes demonstraram que a implementação cumpre os requisitos técnicos estipulados e que, apesar de ainda carecer de melhorias em termos de precisão e robustez, a tecnologia para rastreamento ocular pode ser utilizada com sucesso para tornar a experiência do jogador mais imersiva e desafiante