Algorithm Development and VLSI Implementation of Energy Efficient Decoders of Polar Codes

With its low error-floor performance, polar codes attract significant attention as the potential standard error correction code (ECC) for future communication and data storage. However, the VLSI implementation complexity of polar codes decoders is largely influenced by its nature of in-series decoding. This dissertation is dedicated to presenting optimal decoder architectures for polar codes. This dissertation addresses several structural properties of polar codes and key properties of decoding algorithms that are not dealt with in the prior researches. The underlying concept of the proposed architectures is a paradigm that simplifies and schedules the computations such that hardware is simplified, latency is minimized and bandwidth is maximized. In pursuit of the above, throughput centric successive cancellation (TCSC) and overlapping path list successive cancellation (OPLSC) VLSI architectures and express journey BP (XJBP) decoders for the polar codes are presented. An arbitrary polar code can be decomposed by a set of shorter polar codes with special characteristics, those shorter polar codes are referred to as constituent polar codes. By exploiting the homogeneousness between decoding processes of different constituent polar codes, TCSC reduces the decoding latency of the SC decoder by 60% for codes with length n = 1024. The error correction performance of SC decoding is inferior to that of list successive cancellation decoding. The LSC decoding algorithm delivers the most reliable decoding results; however, it consumes most hardware resources and decoding cycles. Instead of using multiple instances of decoding cores in the LSC decoders, a single SC decoder is used in the OPLSC architecture. The computations of each path in the LSC are arranged to occupy the decoder hardware stages serially in a streamlined fashion. This yields a significant reduction of hardware complexity. The OPLSC decoder has achieved about 1.4 times hardware efficiency improvement compared with traditional LSC decoders. The hardware efficient VLSI architectures for TCSC and OPLSC polar codes decoders are also introduced. Decoders based on SC or LSC algorithms suffer from high latency and limited throughput due to their serial decoding natures. An alternative approach to decode the polar codes is belief propagation (BP) based algorithm. In BP algorithm, a graph is set up to guide the beliefs propagated and refined, which is usually referred to as factor graph. BP decoding algorithm allows decoding in parallel to achieve much higher throughput. XJBP decoder facilitates belief propagation by utilizing the specific constituent codes that exist in the conventional factor graph, which results in an express journey (XJ) decoder. Compared with the conventional BP decoding algorithm for polar codes, the proposed decoder reduces the computational complexity by about 40.6%. This enables an energy-efficient hardware implementation. To further explore the hardware consumption of the proposed XJBP decoder, the computations scheduling is modeled and analyzed in this dissertation. With discussions on different hardware scenarios, the optimal scheduling plans are developed. A novel memory-distributed micro-architecture of the XJBP decoder is proposed and analyzed to solve the potential memory access problems of the proposed scheduling strategy. The register-transfer level (RTL) models of the XJBP decoder are set up for comparisons with other state-of-the-art BP decoders. The results show that the power efficiency of BP decoders is improved by about 3 times

Low-Latency Successive-Cancellation List Decoders for Polar Codes with Multi-bit Decision

Polar codes, as the first provable capacity-achieving error-correcting codes, have received much attention in recent years. However, the decoding performance of polar codes with traditional successive-cancellation (SC) algorithm cannot match that of the low-density parity-check (LDPC) or turbo codes. Because SC list (SCL) decoding algorithm can significantly improve the error-correcting performance of polar codes, design of SCL decoders is important for polar codes to be deployed in practical applications. However, because the prior latency reduction approaches for SC decoders are not applicable for SCL decoders, these list decoders suffer from the long latency bottleneck. In this paper, we propose a multi-bit-decision approach that can significantly reduce latency of SCL decoders. First, we present a reformulated SCL algorithm that can perform intermediate decoding of 2 bits together. The proposed approach, referred as 2-bit reformulated SCL (2b-rSCL) algorithm, can reduce the latency of SCL decoder from (3n-2) to (2n-2) clock cycles without any performance loss. Then, we extend the idea of 2-bit-decision to general case, and propose a general decoding scheme that can perform intermediate decoding of any 2K bits simultaneously. This general approach, referred as 2K-bit reformulated SCL (2Kb-rSCL) algorithm, can reduce the overall decoding latency to as short as n/2K-2-2 cycles. Furthermore, based on the proposed algorithms, VLSI architectures for 2b-rSCL and 4b-rSCL decoders are synthesized. Compared with a prior SCL decoder, the proposed (1024, 512) 2b-rSCL and 4b-rSCL decoders can achieve 21% and 60% reduction in latency, 1.66 times and 2.77 times increase in coded throughput with list size 2, and 2.11 times and 3.23 times increase in coded throughput with list size 4, respectively.Comment: submitted to IEEE TVLSI in Feb 2014, accepted in Sep. 201

High Performance Decoder Architectures for Error Correction Codes

Due to the rapid development of the information industry, modern communication and storage systems require much higher data rates and reliability to server various demanding applications. However, these systems suffer from noises from the practical channels. Various error correction codes (ECCs), such as Reed-Solomon (RS) codes, convolutional codes, turbo codes, Low-Density Parity-Check (LDPC) codes and so on, have been adopted in lots of current standards. With the increasing data rate, the research of more advanced ECCs and the corresponding efficient decoders will never stop.Binary LDPC codes have been adopted in lots of modern communication and storage applications due their superior error performance and efficient hardware decoder implementations. Non-binary LDPC (NB-LDPC) codes are an important extension of traditional binary LDPC codes. Compared with its binary counterpart, NB-LDPC codes show better error performance under short to moderate block lengths and higher order modulations. Moreover, NB-LDPC codes have lower error floor than binary LDPC codes. In spite of the excellent error performance, it is hard for current communication and storage systems to adopt NB-LDPC codes due to complex decoding algorithms and decoder architectures. In terms of hardware implementation, current NB-LDPC decoders need much larger area and achieve much lower data throughput.Besides the recently proposed NB-LDPC codes, polar codes, discovered by Ar{\i}kan, appear as a very promising candidate for future communication and storage systems. Polar codes are considered as a major breakthrough in recent coding theory society. Polar codes are proved to be capacity achieving codes over binary input symmetric memoryless channels. Besides, polar codes can be decoded by the successive cancelation (SC) algorithm with of complexity of $\mathcal{O}(N\log_2 N)$, where $N$ is the block length. The main sticking point of polar codes to date is that their error performance under short to moderate block lengths is inferior compared with LDPC codes or turbo codes. The list decoding technique can be used to improve the error performance of SC algorithms at the cost higher computational and memory complexities. Besides, the hardware implementation of current SC based decoders suffer from long decoding latency which is unsuitable for modern high speed communications.ECCs also find their applications in improving the reliability of network coding. Random linear network coding is an efficient technique for disseminating information in networks, but it is highly susceptible to errors. K\ {o}tter-Kschischang (KK) codes and Mahdavifar-Vardy (MV) codes are two important families of subspace codes that provide error control in noncoherent random linear network coding. List decoding has been used to decode MV codes beyond half distance. Existing hardware implementations of the rank metric decoder for KK codes suffer from limited throughput, long latency and high area complexity. The interpolation-based list decoding algorithm for MV codes still has high computational complexity, and its feasibility for hardware implementations has not been investigated.In this exam, we present efficient decoding algorithms and hardware decoder architectures for NB-LDPC codes, polar codes, KK and MV codes. For NB-LDPC codes, an efficient shuffled decoder architecture is presented to reduce the number of average iterations and improve the throughput. Besides, a fully parallel decoder architecture for NB-LDPC codes with short or moderate block lengths is also presented. Our fully parallel decoder architecture achieves much higher throughput and area efficiency compared with the state-of-art NB-LDPC decoders. For polar codes, a memory efficient list decoder architecture is first presented. Based on our reduced latency list decoding algorithm for polar codes, a high throughput list decoder architecture is also presented. At last, we present efficient decoder architectures for both KK and MV codes

A Compact Low-Latency Systematic Successive Cancellation Polar Decoder for Visible Light Communication Systems

Channel polarization and Polar code are widely considered as major breakthroughs in coding theory because they have shown promising features for future wireless standards. The main drawbacks of Polar code are high-latency in decoding hardware, and unimpressive error-correction performance in case limited code-length is implemented. These two disadvantages limit implementation of Polar code in low-throughput wireless communication systems. In this paper, we propose a low-complexity low-latency hardware architecture for the soft-decision compact (16,11) Systematic Successive Cancellation Polar Decoder (S-SCD). Experimental results has shown that the latency of the proposed S-SCD improves 3.75 times and 2.75 times compared with conventional and 2b-SC architectures. Besides, it has also shown a better BER/FER performance compared with RS(15,11) code, which is applied widely in current VLC-based systems.Comment: IEICE Technical Report, Vol.117, Issue 44, pp.3-

A Complexity Reduction Method for Successive Cancellation List Decoding

This brief introduces a hardware complexity reduction method for successive cancellation list (SCL) decoders. Specifically, we propose to use a sorting scheme so that L paths with smallest path metrics are also sorted according to their path indexes for path pruning. We prove that such sorting scheme reduces the input number of multiplexers in any hardware implementation of SCL decoding from L to (L/2+1) without any changes in the decoding latency. We also propose sorter architectures for the proposed sorting method. Field programmable gate array (FPGA) implementations show that the proposed method achieves significant gain in hardware consumptions of SCL decoder implementations, especially for large list sizes and block lengths.Comment: 6 pages, 3 figures, 6 table

On Error-Correction Performance and Implementation of Polar Code List Decoders for 5G

Polar codes are a class of capacity achieving error correcting codes that has been recently selected for the next generation of wireless communication standards (5G). Polar code decoding algorithms have evolved in various directions, striking different balances between error-correction performance, speed and complexity. Successive-cancellation list (SCL) and its incarnations constitute a powerful, well-studied set of algorithms, in constant improvement. At the same time, different implementation approaches provide a wide range of area occupations and latency results. 5G puts a focus on improved error-correction performance, high throughput and low power consumption: a comprehensive study considering all these metrics is currently lacking in literature. In this work, we evaluate SCL-based decoding algorithms in terms of error-correction performance and compare them to low-density parity-check (LDPC) codes. Moreover, we consider various decoder implementations, for both polar and LDPC codes, and compare their area occupation and power and energy consumption when targeting short code lengths and rates. Our work shows that among SCL-based decoders, the partitioned SCL (PSCL) provides the lowest area occupation and power consumption, whereas fast simplified SCL (Fast-SSCL) yields the lowest energy consumption. Compared to LDPC decoder architectures, different SCL implementations occupy up to 17.1x less area, dissipate up to 7.35x less power, and up to 26x less energy.Comment: Accepted in 55th Annual Allerton Conference on Communication, Control, and Computin

Fast and Flexible Successive-Cancellation List Decoders for Polar Codes

Polar codes have gained significant amount of attention during the past few years and have been selected as a coding scheme for the next generation of mobile broadband standard. Among decoding schemes, successive-cancellation list (SCL) decoding provides a reasonable trade-off between the error-correction performance and hardware implementation complexity when used to decode polar codes, at the cost of limited throughput. The simplified SCL (SSCL) and its extension SSCL-SPC increase the speed of decoding by removing redundant calculations when encountering particular information and frozen bit patterns (rate one and single parity check codes), while keeping the error-correction performance unaltered. In this paper, we improve SSCL and SSCL-SPC by proving that the list size imposes a specific number of bit estimations required to decode rate one and single parity check codes. Thus, the number of estimations can be limited while guaranteeing exactly the same error-correction performance as if all bits of the code were estimated. We call the new decoding algorithms Fast-SSCL and Fast-SSCL-SPC. Moreover, we show that the number of bit estimations in a practical application can be tuned to achieve desirable speed, while keeping the error-correction performance almost unchanged. Hardware architectures implementing both algorithms are then described and implemented: it is shown that our design can achieve 1.86 Gb/s throughput, higher than the best state-of-the-art decoders.Comment: IEEE Transactions on Signal Processin

High Throughput Polar Decoding Using Two-Staged Adaptive Successive Cancellation List Decoding

Polar codes are the first class of capacity-achieving forward error correction (FEC) codes. They have been selected as one of the coding schemes for the 5G communication systems due to their excellent error correction performance when successive cancellation list (SCL) decoding with cyclic redundancy check (CRC) is used. A large list size is necessary for SCL decoding to achieve a low error rate. However, it impedes SCL decoding from achieving a high throughput as the computational complexity is very high when a large list size is used. In this paper, we propose a two-staged adaptive SCL (TA-SCL) decoding scheme and the corresponding hardware architecture to accelerate SCL decoding with a large list size. Constant system latency and data rate are supported by TA-SCL decoding. To analyse the decoding performance of TA-SCL, an accurate mathematical model based on Markov Chain is derived, which can be used to determine the parameters for practical designs. A VLSI architecture implementing TA-SCL decoding is then proposed. The proposed architecture is implemented using UMC 90nm technology. Experimental results show that TA-SCL can achieve throughputs of 3.00 and 2.35 Gbps when the list sizes are 8 and 32, respectively, which are nearly 3 times as that of the state-ofthe-art SCL decoding architectures, with negligible performance degradation on a wide signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) range and small hardware overhead.Comment: 12 pages, 12 figures, 7 tables, Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems I: Regular Paper

Reduced-Latency SC Polar Decoder Architectures

Polar codes have become one of the most favorable capacity achieving error correction codes (ECC) along with their simple encoding method. However, among the very few prior successive cancellation (SC) polar decoder designs, the required long code length makes the decoding latency high. In this paper, conventional decoding algorithm is transformed with look-ahead techniques. This reduces the decoding latency by 50%. With pipelining and parallel processing schemes, a parallel SC polar decoder is proposed. Sub-structure sharing approach is employed to design the merged processing element (PE). Moreover, inspired by the real FFT architecture, this paper presents a novel input generating circuit (ICG) block that can generate additional input signals for merged PEs on-the-fly. Gate-level analysis has demonstrated that the proposed design shows advantages of 50% decoding latency and twice throughput over the conventional one with similar hardware cost

Symbol-Decision Successive Cancellation List Decoder for Polar Codes

Polar codes are of great interests because they provably achieve the capacity of both discrete and continuous memoryless channels while having an explicit construction. Most existing decoding algorithms of polar codes are based on bit-wise hard or soft decisions. In this paper, we propose symbol-decision successive cancellation (SC) and successive cancellation list (SCL) decoders for polar codes, which use symbol-wise hard or soft decisions for higher throughput or better error performance. First, we propose to use a recursive channel combination to calculate symbol-wise channel transition probabilities, which lead to symbol decisions. Our proposed recursive channel combination also has a lower complexity than simply combining bit-wise channel transition probabilities. The similarity between our proposed method and Arikan's channel transformations also helps to share hardware resources between calculating bit- and symbol-wise channel transition probabilities. Second, a two-stage list pruning network is proposed to provide a trade-off between the error performance and the complexity of the symbol-decision SCL decoder. Third, since memory is a significant part of SCL decoders, we propose a pre-computation memory-saving technique to reduce memory requirement of an SCL decoder. Finally, to evaluate the throughput advantage of our symbol-decision decoders, we design an architecture based on a semi-parallel successive cancellation list decoder. In this architecture, different symbol sizes, sorting implementations, and message scheduling schemes are considered. Our synthesis results show that in terms of area efficiency, our symbol-decision SCL decoders outperform both bit- and symbol-decision SCL decoders.Comment: 13 pages, 17 figure