A Survey of Techniques for Architecting TLBs

“Translation lookaside buffer” (TLB) caches virtual to physical address translation information and is used in systems ranging from embedded devices to high-end servers. Since TLB is accessed very frequently and a TLB miss is extremely costly, prudent management of TLB is important for improving performance and energy efficiency of processors. In this paper, we present a survey of techniques for architecting and managing TLBs. We characterize the techniques across several dimensions to highlight their similarities and distinctions. We believe that this paper will be useful for chip designers, computer architects and system engineers

TLB-Based Temporality-Aware Classification in CMPs with Multilevel TLBs

"© 2017 IEEE. Personal use of this material is permitted. Permissíon from IEEE must be obtained for all other uses, in any current or future media, including reprinting/republishing this material for advertisíng or promotional purposes, creating new collective works, for resale or redistribution to servers or lists, or reuse of any copyrighted component of this work in other works."[EN] Recent proposals are based on classifying memory accesses into private or shared in order to process private accesses more efficiently and reduce coherence overhead. The classification mechanisms previously proposed are either not able to adapt to the dynamic sharing behavior of the applications or require frequent broadcast messages. Additionally, most of these classification approaches assume single-level translation lookaside buffers (TLBs). However, deeper and more efficient TLB hierarchies, such as the ones implemented in current commodity processors, have not been appropriately explored. This paper analyzes accurate classification mechanisms in multilevel TLB hierarchies. In particular, we propose an efficient data classification strategy for systems with distributed shared last-level TLBs. Our approach classifies data accounting for temporal private accesses and constrains TLB-related traffic by issuing unicast messages on first-level TLB misses. When our classification is employed to deactivate coherence for private data in directory-based protocols, it improves the directory efficiency and, consequently, reduces coherence traffic to merely 53.0%, on average. Additionally, it avoids some of the overheads of previous classification approaches for purely private TLBs, improving average execution time by nearly 9% for large-scale systems.This work has been jointly supported by the MINECO and European Commission (FEDER funds) under the project TIN2015-66972-C5-1-R and TIN2015-66972-C5-3-R and the Fundacion Seneca-Agencia de Ciencia y Tecnologia de la Region de Murcia under the project Jovenes Lideres en Investigacion 18956/JLI/13.Esteve Garcia, A.; Ros Bardisa, A.; Gómez Requena, ME.; Robles Martínez, A.; Duato Marín, JF. (2017). TLB-Based Temporality-Aware Classification in CMPs with Multilevel TLBs. IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed Systems. 28(8):2401-2413. https://doi.org/10.1109/TPDS.2017.2658576S2401241328

Software-Oriented Data Access Characterization for Chip Multiprocessor Architecture Optimizations

The integration of an increasing amount of on-chip hardware in Chip-Multiprocessors (CMPs) poses a challenge of efficiently utilizing the on-chip resources to maximize performance. Prior research proposals largely rely on additional hardware support to achieve desirable tradeoffs. However, these purely hardware-oriented mechanisms typically result in more generic but less efficient approaches. A new trend is designing adaptive systems by exploiting and leveraging application-level information. In this work a wide range of applications are analyzed and remarkable data access behaviors/patterns are recognized to be useful for architectural and system optimizations. In particular, this dissertation work introduces software-based techniques that can be used to extract data access characteristics for cross-layer optimizations on performance and scalability. The collected information is utilized to guide cache data placement, network configuration, coherence operations, address translation, memory configuration, etc. In particular, an approach is proposed to classify data blocks into different categories to optimize an on-chip coherent cache organization. For applications with compile-time deterministic data access localities, a compiler technique is proposed to determine data partitions that guide the last level cache data placement and communication patterns for network configuration. A page-level data classification is also demonstrated to improve address translation performance. The successful utilization of data access characteristics on traditional CMP architectures demonstrates that the proposed approach is promising and generic and can be potentially applied to future CMP architectures with emerging technologies such as the Spin-transfer torque RAM (STT-RAM)

Victima: Drastically Increasing Address Translation Reach by Leveraging Underutilized Cache Resources

Address translation is a performance bottleneck in data-intensive workloads due to large datasets and irregular access patterns that lead to frequent high-latency page table walks (PTWs). PTWs can be reduced by using (i) large hardware TLBs or (ii) large software-managed TLBs. Unfortunately, both solutions have significant drawbacks: increased access latency, power and area (for hardware TLBs), and costly memory accesses, the need for large contiguous memory blocks, and complex OS modifications (for software-managed TLBs). We present Victima, a new software-transparent mechanism that drastically increases the translation reach of the processor by leveraging the underutilized resources of the cache hierarchy. The key idea of Victima is to repurpose L2 cache blocks to store clusters of TLB entries, thereby providing an additional low-latency and high-capacity component that backs up the last-level TLB and thus reduces PTWs. Victima has two main components. First, a PTW cost predictor (PTW-CP) identifies costly-to-translate addresses based on the frequency and cost of the PTWs they lead to. Second, a TLB-aware cache replacement policy prioritizes keeping TLB entries in the cache hierarchy by considering (i) the translation pressure (e.g., last-level TLB miss rate) and (ii) the reuse characteristics of the TLB entries. Our evaluation results show that in native (virtualized) execution environments Victima improves average end-to-end application performance by 7.4% (28.7%) over the baseline four-level radix-tree-based page table design and by 6.2% (20.1%) over a state-of-the-art software-managed TLB, across 11 diverse data-intensive workloads. Victima (i) is effective in both native and virtualized environments, (ii) is completely transparent to application and system software, and (iii) incurs very small area and power overheads on a modern high-end CPU.Comment: To appear in 56th IEEE/ACM International Symposium on Microarchitecture (MICRO), 202

Morrigan: A composite instruction TLB prefetcher

The effort to reduce address translation overheads has typically targeted data accesses since they constitute the overwhelming portion of the second-level TLB (STLB) misses in desktop and HPC applications. The address translation cost of instruction accesses has been relatively neglected due to historically small instruction footprints. However, state-of-the-art datacenter and server applications feature massive instruction footprints owing to deep software stacks, resulting in high STLB miss rates for instruction accesses. This paper demonstrates that instruction address translation is a performance bottleneck in server workloads. In response, we propose Morrigan, a microarchitectural instruction STLB prefetcher whose design is based on new insights regarding instruction STLB misses. At the core of Morrigan there is an ensemble of table-based Markov prefetchers that build and store variable length Markov chains out of the instruction STLB miss stream. Morrigan further employs a sequential prefetcher and a scheme that exploits page table locality to maximize miss coverage. An important contribution of the work is showing that access frequency is more important than access recency when choosing replacement candidates. Based on this insight, Morrigan introduces a new replacement policy that identifies victims in the Markov prefetchers using a frequency stack while adapting to phase-change behavior. On a set of 45 industrial server workloads, Morrigan eliminates 69% of the memory references in demand page walks triggered by instruction STLB misses and improves geometric mean performance by 7.6%.This work is partially supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Technology through the PID2019-107255GB project, the Generalitat de Catalunya (contract 2017-SGR-1414), the NSF grant CCF-1912617, the Semiconductor Research Corporation grant 2936.001, and generous gifts from Intel Labs. Georgios Vavouliotis has been supported by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness and the European Social Fund under the FPI fellowship No. PRE2018-087046. Marc Casas has been supported by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness under the Ramon y Cajal fellowship No. RYC-2017-23269.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

Morrigan: A Composite Instruction TLB Prefetcher

The effort to reduce address translation overheads has typically targeted data accesses since they constitute the overwhelming portion of the second-level TLB (STLB) misses in desktop and HPC applications. The address translation cost of instruction accesses has been relatively neglected due to historically small instruction footprints. However, state-of-the-art datacenter and server applications feature massive instruction footprints owing to deep software stacks, resulting in high STLB miss rates for instruction accesses. This paper demonstrates that instruction address translation is a performance bottleneck in server workloads. In response, we propose Morrigan, a microarchitectural instruction STLB prefetcher whose design is based on new insights regarding instruction STLB misses. At the core of Morrigan there is an ensemble of table-based Markov prefetchers that build and store variable length Markov chains out of the instruction STLB miss stream. Morrigan further employs a sequential prefetcher and a scheme that exploits page table locality to maximize miss coverage. An important contribution of the work is showing that access frequency is more important than access recency when choosing replacement candidates. Based on this insight, Morrigan introduces a new replacement policy that identifies victims in the Markov prefetchers using a frequency stack while adapting to phase-change behavior. On a set of 45 industrial server workloads, Morrigan eliminates 69% of the memory references in demand page walks triggered by instruction STLB misses and improves geometric mean performance by 7.6%.This work is partially supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Technology through the PID2019-107255GB project, the Generalitat de Catalunya (contract 2017-SGR-1414), the NSF grant CCF-1912617, the Semiconductor Research Corporation grant 2936.001, and generous gifts from Intel Labs. Georgios Vavouliotis has been supported by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness and the European Social Fund under the FPI fellowship No. PRE2018-087046. Marc Casas has been supported by the Spanish Ministry of Economy, Industry and Competitiveness under the Ramon y Cajal fellowship No. RYC-2017-23269.Peer ReviewedPostprint (author's final draft

TokenTLB+CUP: A Token-Based Page Classification with Cooperative Usage Prediction

[EN] Discerning the private or shared condition of the data accessed by the applications is an increasingly decisive approach to achieving efficiency and scalability in multi- and many-core systems. Since most memory accesses in both sequential and parallel applications are either private (accessed only by one core) or read-only (not written) data, devoting the full cost of coherence to every memory access results in sub-optimal performance and limits the scalability and efficiency of the multiprocessor. This paper introduces TokenTLB, a TLB-based page classification approach based on exchange and count of tokens. Token counting on TLBs is a natural and efficient way for classifying memory pages, and it does not require the use of complex and undesirable persistent requests or arbitration. In addition, classification is extended with Cooperative Usage Predictor (CUP), a token-based system-wide page usage predictor retrieved through TLB cooperation, in order to perform a classification unaffected by TLB size. Through cycle-accurate simulation we observed that TokenTLB spends 43.6% of cycles as private per page on average, and CUP further increases the time spent as private by 22.0%. CUP avoids 4 out of 5 TLB invalidations when compared to state-of-the-art predictors, thus proving far better prediction accuracy and making usage prediction an attractive mechanism for the first time.This work has been jointly supported by the MINECO and European Commission (FEDER funds) under the project TIN2015-66972-C5-1-R and TIN2015-66972-C5-3-R and the Fundacion Seneca-Agencia de Ciencia y Tecnologia de la Region de Murcia under the project Jovenes Lideres en Investigacion 18956/JLI/13.Esteve Garcia, A.; Ros Bardisa, A.; Robles Martínez, A.; Gómez Requena, ME. (2018). TokenTLB+CUP: A Token-Based Page Classification with Cooperative Usage Prediction. IEEE Transactions on Parallel and Distributed Systems. 29(5):1188-1201. https://doi.org/10.1109/TPDS.2017.2782808S1188120129

Doctor of Philosophy

dissertationIn recent years, a number of trends have started to emerge, both in microprocessor and application characteristics. As per Moore's law, the number of cores on chip will keep doubling every 18-24 months. International Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors (ITRS) reports that wires will continue to scale poorly, exacerbating the cost of on-chip communication. Cores will have to navigate an on-chip network to access data that may be scattered across many cache banks. The number of pins on the package, and hence available off-chip bandwidth, will at best increase at sublinear rate and at worst, stagnate. A number of disruptive memory technologies, e.g., phase change memory (PCM) have begun to emerge and will be integrated into the memory hierarchy sooner than later, leading to non-uniform memory access (NUMA) hierarchies. This will make the cost of accessing main memory even higher. In previous years, most of the focus has been on deciding the memory hierarchy level where data must be placed (L1 or L2 caches, main memory, disk, etc.). However, in modern and future generations, each level is getting bigger and its design is being subjected to a number of constraints (wire delays, power budget, etc.). It is becoming very important to make an intelligent decision about where data must be placed within a level. For example, in a large non-uniform access cache (NUCA), we must figure out the optimal bank. Similarly, in a multi-dual inline memory module (DIMM) non uniform memory access (NUMA) main memory, we must figure out the DIMM that is the optimal home for every data page. Studies have indicated that heterogeneous main memory hierarchies that incorporate multiple memory technologies are on the horizon. We must develop solutions for data management that take heterogeneity into account. For these memory organizations, we must again identify the appropriate home for data. In this dissertation, we attempt to verify the following thesis statement: "Can low-complexity hardware and OS mechanisms manage data placement within each memory hierarchy level to optimize metrics such as performance and/or throughput?" In this dissertation we argue for a hardware-software codesign approach to tackle the above mentioned problems at different levels of the memory hierarchy. The proposed methods utilize techniques like page coloring and shadow addresses and are able to handle a large number of problems ranging from managing wire-delays in large, shared NUCA caches to distributing shared capacity among different cores. We then examine data-placement issues in NUMA main memory for a many-core processor with a moderate number of on-chip memory controllers. Using codesign approaches, we achieve efficient data placement by modifying the operating system's (OS) page allocation algorithm for a wide variety of main memory architectures