333 research outputs found
Cyclic proof systems for modal fixpoint logics
This thesis is about cyclic and ill-founded proof systems for modal fixpoint logics, with and without explicit fixpoint quantifiers.Cyclic and ill-founded proof-theory allow proofs with infinite branches or paths, as long as they satisfy some correctness conditions ensuring the validity of the conclusion. In this dissertation we design a few cyclic and ill-founded systems: a cyclic one for the weak Grzegorczyk modal logic K4Grz, based on our explanation of the phenomenon of cyclic companionship; and ill-founded and cyclic ones for the full computation tree logic CTL* and the intuitionistic linear-time temporal logic iLTL. All systems are cut-free, and the cyclic ones for K4Grz and iLTL have fully finitary correctness conditions.Lastly, we use a cyclic system for the modal mu-calculus to obtain a proof of the uniform interpolation property for the logic which differs from the original, automata-based one
Fragments and frame classes:Towards a uniform proof theory for modal fixed point logics
This thesis studies the proof theory of modal fixed point logics. In particular, we construct proof systems for various fragments of the modal mu-calculus, interpreted over various classes of frames. With an emphasis on uniform constructions and general results, we aim to bring the relatively underdeveloped proof theory of modal fixed point logics closer to the well-established proof theory of basic modal logic. We employ two main approaches. First, we seek to generalise existing methods for basic modal logic to accommodate fragments of the modal mu-calculus. We use this approach for obtaining Hilbert-style proof systems. Secondly, we adapt existing proof systems for the modal mu-calculus to various classes of frames. This approach yields proof systems which are non-well-founded, or cyclic.The thesis starts with an introduction and some mathematical preliminaries. In Chapter 3 we give hypersequent calculi for modal logic with the master modality, building on work by Ori Lahav. This is followed by an Intermezzo, where we present an abstract framework for cyclic proofs, in which we give sufficient conditions for establishing the bounded proof property. In Chapter 4 we generalise existing work on Hilbert-style proof systems for PDL to the level of the continuous modal mu-calculus. Chapter 5 contains a novel cyclic proof system for the alternation-free two-way modal mu-calculus. Finally, in Chapter 6, we present a cyclic proof system for Guarded Kleene Algebra with Tests and take a first step towards using it to establish the completeness of an algebraic counterpart
Views from a peak:Generalisations and descriptive set theory
This dissertation has two major threads, one is mathematical, namely descriptive set theory, the other is philosophical, namely generalisation in mathematics. Descriptive set theory is the study of the behaviour of definable subsets of a given structure such as the real numbers. In the core mathematical chapters, we provide mathematical results connecting descriptive set theory and generalised descriptive set theory. Using these, we give a philosophical account of the motivations for, and the nature of, generalisation in mathematics.In Chapter 3, we stratify set theories based on this descriptive complexity. The axiom of countable choice for reals is one of the most basic fragments of the axiom of choice needed in many parts of mathematics. Descriptive choice principles are a further stratification of this fragment by the descriptive complexity of the sets. We provide a separation technique for descriptive choice principles based on Jensen forcing. Our results generalise a theorem by Kanovei.Chapter 4 gives the essentials of a generalised real analysis, that is a real analysis on generalisations of the real numbers to higher infinities. This builds on work by Galeotti and his coauthors. We generalise classical theorems of real analysis to certain sets of functions, strengthening continuity, and disprove other classical theorems. We also show that a certain cardinal property, the tree property, is equivalent to the Extreme Value Theorem for a set of functions which generalize the continuous functions.The question of Chapter 5 is whether a robust notion of infinite sums can be developed on generalisations of the real numbers to higher infinities. We state some incompatibility results, which suggest not. We analyse several candidate notions of infinite sum, both from the literature and more novel, and show which of the expected properties of a notion of sum they fail.In Chapter 6, we study the descriptive set theory arising from a generalization of topology, κ-topology, which is used in the previous two chapters. We show that the theory is quite different from that of the standard (full) topology. Differences include a collapsing Borel hierarchy, a lack of universal or complete sets, Lebesgue’s ‘great mistake’ holds (projections do not increase complexity), a strict hierarchy of notions of analyticity, and a failure of Suslin’s theorem.Lastly, in Chapter 7, we give a philosophical account of the nature of generalisation in mathematics, and describe the methodological reasons that mathematicians generalise. In so doing, we distinguish generalisation from other processes of change in mathematics, such as abstraction and domain expansion. We suggest a semantic account of generalisation, where two pieces of mathematics constitute a generalisation if they have a certain relation of content, along with an increased level of generality
Essential Hereditary Undecidability
In this paper we study \emph{essential hereditary undecidability}. Theories
with this property are a convenient tool to prove undecidability of other
theories. The paper develops the basic facts concerning essentially hereditary
undecidability and provides salient examples, like a construction of \ehu\
theories due to Hanf and an example of a rather natural essentially
hereditarily undecidable theory strictly below {\sf R}. We discuss the
(non-)interaction of essential hereditary undecidability with recursive boolean
isomorphism.
We develop a reduction relation \emph{essential tolerance}, or, in the
converse direction, \emph{lax interpretability} that interacts in a good way
with essential hereditary undecidability.
We introduce the class of -friendly theories and show that
-friendliness is sufficient but not necessary for essential
hereditary undecidability.
Finally, we adapt an argument due to Pakhomov, Murwanashyaka and Visser to
show that there is no interpretability minimal essentially
hereditarilyundecidable theory
Indeterminacy and the law of the excluded middle
This thesis is an investigation into indeterminacy in the foundations of mathematics and its possible consequences for the applicability of the law of the excluded middle (LEM). It characterises different ways in which the natural numbers as well as the sets may be understood to be indeterminate, and asks in what sense this would cease to support applicability of LEM to reasoning with them. The first part of the thesis reviews the indeterminacy phenomena on which the argument is based and argues for a distinction between two notions of indeterminacy: a) indeterminacy as applied to domains and b) indefiniteness as applied to concepts. It then addresses possible attempts to secure determinacy in both cases. The second part of the thesis discusses the advantages that an argument from indeterminacy has over traditional intuitionistic arguments against LEM, and it provides the framework in which conditions for the applicability of LEM can be explicated in the setting of indeterminacy. The final part of the thesis then applies these findings to concrete cases of indeterminacy. With respect to indeterminacy of domains, I note some problems for establishing a rejection of LEM based on the indeterminacy of the height of the set theoretic hierarchy. I show that a coherent argument can be made for the rejection of LEM based on the indeterminacy of its width, and assess its philosophical commitments. A final chapter addresses the notion of indefiniteness of our concepts of set and number and asks how this might affect the applicability of LEM
On Notions of Provability
In this thesis, we study notions of provability, i.e. formulas B(x,y) such that a formula
ϕ is provable in T if, and only if, there is m ∈ N such that T ⊢ B(⌜ϕ⌝,m) (m plays the
role of a parameter); the usual notion of provability, k-step provability (also known as
k-provability), s-symbols provability are examples of notions of provability.
We develop general results concerning notions of provability, but we also study in
detail concrete notions. We present partial results concerning the decidability of kprovability
for Peano Arithmetic (PA), and we study important problems concerning
k-provability, such as Kreisel’s Conjecture and Montagna’s Problem:
(∀n ∈ N.T ⊢k steps ϕ(n)) =⇒ T ⊢ ∀x.ϕ(x), [Kreisel’s Conjecture]
and
Does PA ⊢k steps PrPA(⌜ϕ⌝)→ϕ imply PA ⊢k steps ϕ? [Montagna’s Problem]
Incompleteness, Undefinability of Truth, and Recursion are different entities that
share important features; we study this in detail and we trace these entities to common
results.
We present numeral forms of completeness and consistency, numeral completeness
and numeral consistency, respectively; numeral completeness guarantees that, whenever
a Σb
1(S12
)-formula ϕ(⃗x ) is such that ⃗Q
⃗x .ϕ(⃗x ) is true (where ⃗Q
is any array of quantifiers),
then this very fact can be proved inside S12
, more precisely S12
⊢ ⃗Q
⃗x .Prτ (⌜ϕ(
•⃗
x )⌝). We
examine these two results from a mathematical point of view by presenting the minimal
conditions to state them and by finding consequences of them, and from a philosophical
point of view by relating them to Hilbert’s Program.
The derivability condition “provability implies provable provability” is one of the main
derivability conditions used to derive the Second Incompleteness Theorem and is known
to be very sensitive to the underlying theory one has at hand. We create a weak theory
G2 to study this condition; this is a theory for the complexity class FLINSPACE. We also
relate properties of G2 to equality between computational classes.O tema desta tese são noções de demonstração; estas últimas são fórmulas B(x,y) tais que
uma fórmula ϕ é demonstrável em T se, e só se, existe m ∈ N tal que T ⊢ B(⌜ϕ⌝,m) (m
desempenha o papel de um parâmetro). A noção usual de demonstração, demonstração
em k-linhas (demonstração-k), demonstração em s-símbolos são exemplos de noções de
demonstração.
Desenvolvemos resultados gerais sobre noções de demonstração, mas também estudamos
exemplos concretos. Damos a conhecer resultados parciais sobre a decidibilidade da
demonstração-k para a Aritmética de Peano (PA), e estudamos dois problemas conhecidos
desta área, a Conjectura de Kreisel e o Problema de Montagna:
(∀n ∈ N.T ⊢k steps ϕ(n)) =⇒ T ⊢ ∀x.ϕ(x), [Conjectura de Kreisel]
e
PA ⊢k steps PrPA(⌜ϕ⌝)→ϕ implica PA ⊢k steps ϕ? [Problema de Montagna]
A Incompletude, a Incapacidade de Definir Verdade, e Recursão são entidades que
têm em comum características relevantes; nós estudamos estas entidades em detalhe e
apresentamos resultados que são simultaneamente responsáveis pelas mesmas.
Além disso, apresentamos formas numerais de completude e consistência, a completude
numeral e a consistência numeral, respectivamente; a completude numeral assegura
que, quando uma fórmula-Σb
1(S12) ϕ(⃗x ) é tal que ⃗Q
⃗x .ϕ(⃗x ) é verdadeira, então este facto
pode ser verificado dentro de S12, mais precisamente S12
⊢ ⃗Q
⃗x .Prτ (⌜ϕ(
•⃗
x )⌝). Este dois resultados
são analisados de um ponto de vista matemático onde apresentamos as condições
mínimas para os demonstrar e apresentamos consequências dos mesmos, e de um ponto
de vista filosófico, onde relacionamos os mesmos com o Programa de Hilbert.
A condição de derivabilidade “demonstração implica demonstrabilidade da demonstração”
é uma das condições usadas para derivar o Segundo Teorema da Incompletude e
sabemos ser muito sensível à teoria de base escolhida. Nós criámos uma teoria fraca G2
para estudar esta condição; esta é uma teoria para a classe de complexidade FLINSPACE.
Também relacionámos propriedades de G2 com igualdades entre classes de complexidade
computacional
- …