Performance and power optimizations in chip multiprocessors for throughput-aware computation

The so-called "power (or power density) wall" has caused core frequency (and single-thread performance) to slow down, giving rise to the era of multi-core/multi-thread processors. For example, the IBM POWER4 processor, released in 2001, incorporated two single-thread cores into the same chip. In 2010, IBM released the POWER7 processor with eight 4-thread cores in the same chip, for a total capacity of 32 execution contexts. The ever increasing number of cores and threads gives rise to new opportunities and challenges for software and hardware architects. At software level, applications can benefit from the abundant number of execution contexts to boost throughput. But this challenges programmers to create highly-parallel applications and operating systems capable of scheduling them correctly. At hardware level, the increasing core and thread count puts pressure on the memory interface, because memory bandwidth grows at a slower pace ---phenomenon known as the "bandwidth (or memory) wall". In addition to memory bandwidth issues, chip power consumption rises due to manufacturers' difficulty to lower operating voltages sufficiently every processor generation. This thesis presents innovations to improve bandwidth and power consumption in chip multiprocessors (CMPs) for throughput-aware computation: a bandwidth-optimized last-level cache (LLC), a bandwidth-optimized vector register file, and a power/performance-aware thread placement heuristic. In contrast to state-of-the-art LLC designs, our organization avoids data replication and, hence, does not require keeping data coherent. Instead, the address space is statically distributed all over the LLC (in a fine-grained interleaving fashion). The absence of data replication increases the cache effective capacity, which results in better hit rates and higher bandwidth compared to a coherent LLC. We use double buffering to hide the extra access latency due to the lack of data replication. The proposed vector register file is composed of thousands of registers and organized as an aggregation of banks. We leverage such organization to attach small special-function "local computation elements" (LCEs) to each bank. This approach ---referred to as the "processor-in-regfile" (PIR) strategy--- overcomes the limited number of register file ports. Because each LCE is a SIMD computation element and all of them can proceed concurrently, the PIR strategy constitutes a highly-parallel super-wide-SIMD device (ideal for throughput-aware computation). Finally, we present a heuristic to reduce chip power consumption by dynamically placing software (application) threads across hardware (physical) threads. The heuristic gathers chip-level power and performance information at runtime to infer characteristics of the applications being executed. For example, if an application's threads share data, the heuristic may decide to place them in fewer cores to favor inter-thread data sharing and communication. In such case, the number of active cores decreases, which is a good opportunity to switch off the unused cores to save power. It is increasingly harder to find bulletproof (micro-)architectural solutions for the bandwidth and power scalability limitations in CMPs. Consequently, we think that architects should attack those problems from different flanks simultaneously, with complementary innovations. This thesis contributes with a battery of solutions to alleviate those problems in the context of throughput-aware computation: 1) proposing a bandwidth-optimized LLC; 2) proposing a bandwidth-optimized register file organization; and 3) proposing a simple technique to improve power-performance efficiency.El excesivo consumo de potencia de los procesadores actuales ha desacelerado el incremento en la frecuencia operativa de los mismos para dar lugar a la era de los procesadores con múltiples núcleos y múltiples hilos de ejecución. Por ejemplo, el procesador POWER7 de IBM, lanzado al mercado en 2010, incorpora ocho núcleos en el mismo chip, con cuatro hilos de ejecución por núcleo. Esto da lugar a nuevas oportunidades y desafíos para los arquitectos de software y hardware. A nivel de software, las aplicaciones pueden beneficiarse del abundante número de núcleos e hilos de ejecución para aumentar el rendimiento. Pero esto obliga a los programadores a crear aplicaciones altamente paralelas y sistemas operativos capaces de planificar correctamente la ejecución de las mismas. A nivel de hardware, el creciente número de núcleos e hilos de ejecución ejerce presión sobre la interfaz de memoria, ya que el ancho de banda de memoria crece a un ritmo más lento. Además de los problemas de ancho de banda de memoria, el consumo de energía del chip se eleva debido a la dificultad de los fabricantes para reducir suficientemente los voltajes de operación entre generaciones de procesadores. Esta tesis presenta innovaciones para mejorar el ancho de banda y consumo de energía en procesadores multinúcleo en el ámbito de la computación orientada a rendimiento ("throughput-aware computation"): una memoria caché de último nivel ("last-level cache" o LLC) optimizada para ancho de banda, un banco de registros vectorial optimizado para ancho de banda, y una heurística para planificar la ejecución de aplicaciones paralelas orientada a mejorar la eficiencia del consumo de potencia y desempeño. En contraste con los diseños de LLC de última generación, nuestra organización evita la duplicación de datos y, por tanto, no requiere de técnicas de coherencia. El espacio de direcciones de memoria se distribuye estáticamente en la LLC con un entrelazado de grano fino. La ausencia de replicación de datos aumenta la capacidad efectiva de la memoria caché, lo que se traduce en mejores tasas de acierto y mayor ancho de banda en comparación con una LLC coherente. Utilizamos la técnica de "doble buffering" para ocultar la latencia adicional necesaria para acceder a datos remotos. El banco de registros vectorial propuesto se compone de miles de registros y se organiza como una agregación de bancos. Incorporamos a cada banco una pequeña unidad de cómputo de propósito especial ("local computation element" o LCE). Este enfoque ---que llamamos "computación en banco de registros"--- permite superar el número limitado de puertos en el banco de registros. Debido a que cada LCE es una unidad de cómputo con soporte SIMD ("single instruction, multiple data") y todas ellas pueden proceder de forma concurrente, la estrategia de "computación en banco de registros" constituye un dispositivo SIMD altamente paralelo. Por último, presentamos una heurística para planificar la ejecución de aplicaciones paralelas orientada a reducir el consumo de energía del chip, colocando dinámicamente los hilos de ejecución a nivel de software entre los hilos de ejecución a nivel de hardware. La heurística obtiene, en tiempo de ejecución, información de consumo de potencia y desempeño del chip para inferir las características de las aplicaciones. Por ejemplo, si los hilos de ejecución a nivel de software comparten datos significativamente, la heurística puede decidir colocarlos en un menor número de núcleos para favorecer el intercambio de datos entre ellos. En tal caso, los núcleos no utilizados se pueden apagar para ahorrar energía. Cada vez es más difícil encontrar soluciones de arquitectura "a prueba de balas" para resolver las limitaciones de escalabilidad de los procesadores actuales. En consecuencia, creemos que los arquitectos deben atacar dichos problemas desde diferentes flancos simultáneamente, con innovaciones complementarias

Castell: a heterogeneous cmp architecture scalable to hundreds of processors

Technology improvements and power constrains have taken multicore architectures to dominate microprocessor designs over uniprocessors. At the same time, accelerator based architectures have shown that heterogeneous multicores are very efficient and can provide high throughput for parallel applications, but with a high-programming effort. We propose Castell a scalable chip multiprocessor architecture that can be programmed as uniprocessors, and provides the high throughput of accelerator-based architectures. Castell relies on task-based programming models that simplify software development. These models use a runtime system that dynamically finds, schedules, and adds hardware-specific features to parallel tasks. One of these features is DMA transfers to overlap computation and data movement, which is known as double buffering. This feature allows applications on Castell to tolerate large memory latencies and lets us design the memory system focusing on memory bandwidth. In addition to provide programmability and the design of the memory system, we have used a hierarchical NoC and added a synchronization module. The NoC design distributes memory traffic efficiently to allow the architecture to scale. The synchronization module is a consequence of the large performance degradation of application for large synchronization latencies. Castell is mainly an architecture framework that enables the definition of domain-specific implementations, fine-tuned to a particular problem or application. So far, Castell has been successfully used to propose heterogeneous multicore architectures for scientific kernels, video decoding (using H.264), and protein sequence alignment (using Smith-Waterman and clustalW). It has also been used to explore a number of architecture optimizations such as enhanced DMA controllers, and architecture support for task-based programming models. ii

An analyzable memory controller for hard real-time CMPs

Multicore processors (CMPs) represent a good solution to provide the performance required by current and future hard real-time systems. However, it is difficult to compute a tight WCET estimation for CMPs due to interferences that tasks suffer when accessing shared hardware resources.We propose an analyzable JEDEC-compliant DDRx SDRAM memory controller (AMC) for hard real-time CMPs, that reduces the impact of memory interferences caused by other tasks on WCET estimation, providing a predictable memory access time and allowing the computation of tight WCET estimations.Peer ReviewedPostprint (published version

Cache Equalizer: A Cache Pressure Aware Block Placement Scheme for Large-Scale Chip Multiprocessors

This paper describes Cache Equalizer (CE), a novel distributed cache management scheme for large scale chip multiprocessors (CMPs). Our work is motivated by large asymmetry in cache sets usages. CE decouples the physical locations of cache blocks from their addresses for the sake of reducing misses caused by destructive interferences. Temporal pressure at the on-chip last-level cache, is continuously collected at a group (comprised of cache sets) granularity, and periodically recorded at the memory controller to guide the placement process. An incoming block is consequently placed at a cache group that exhibits the minimum pressure. CE provides Quality of Service (QoS) by robustly offering better performance than the baseline shared NUCA cache. Simulation results using a full-system simulator demonstrate that CE outperforms shared NUCA caches by an average of 15.5% and by as much as 28.5% for the benchmark programs we examined. Furthermore, evaluations manifested the outperformance of CE versus related CMP cache designs

Multicore architecture optimizations for HPC applications

From single-core CPUs to detachable compute accelerators, supercomputers made a tremendous progress by using available transistors on chip and specializing hardware for a given type of computation. Today, compute nodes used in HPC employ multi-core CPUs tailored for serial execution and multiple accelerators (many-core devices or GPUs) for throughput computing. However, designing next-generation HPC system requires not only the performance improvement but also better energy efficiency. Current trend of reaching exascale level of computation asks for at least an order of magnitude increase in both of these metrics. This thesis explores HPC-specific optimizations in order to make better utilization of the available transistors and to improve performance by transparently executing parallel code across multiple GPU accelerators. First, we analyze several HPC benchmark suites, compare them against typical desktop applications, and identify the differences which advocate for proper core tailoring. Moreover, within the HPC applications, we evaluate serial and parallel code sections separately, resulting in an Asymmetric Chip Multiprocessor (ACMP) design with one core optimized for single-thread performance and many lean cores for parallel execution. Our results presented here suggests downsizing of core front-end structures providing an HPC-tailored lean core which saves 16% of the core area and 7% of power, without performance loss. Further improving an ACMP design, we identify that multiple lean cores run the same code during parallel regions. This motivated us to evaluate the idea where lean cores share the I-cache with the intent of benefiting from mutual prefetching, without increasing the average access latency. Our exploration of the multiple parameters finds the sweet spot on a wide interconnect to access the shared I-cache and the inclusion of a few line buffers to provide the required bandwidth and latency to sustain performance. The projections presented in this thesis show additional 11% area savings with a 5% energy reduction at no performance cost. These area and power savings might be attractive for many-core accelerators either for increasing the performance per area and power unit, or adding additional cores and thus improving the performance for the same hardware budget. Finally, in this thesis we study the effects of future NUMA accelerators comprised of multiple GPU devices. Reaching the limits of a single-GPU die size, next-generation GPU compute accelerators will likely embrace multi-socket designs increasing the core count and memory bandwidth. However, maintaining the UMA behavior of a single-GPU in multi-GPU systems without code rewriting stands as a challenge. We investigate multi-socket NUMA GPU designs and show that significant changes are needed to both the GPU interconnect and cache architectures to achieve performance scalability. We show that application phase effects can be exploited allowing GPU sockets to dynamically optimize their individual interconnect and cache policies, minimizing the impact of NUMA effects. Our NUMA-aware GPU outperforms a single GPU by 1.5×, 2.3×, and 3.2× while achieving 89%, 84%, and 76% of theoretical application scalability in 2, 4, and 8 sockets designs respectively. Implementable today, NUMA-aware multi-socket GPUs may be a promising candidate for performance scaling of future compute nodes used in HPC.Empezando por CPUs de un solo procesador, y pasando por aceleradores discretos, los supercomputadores han avanzado enormemente utilizando todos los transistores disponibles en el chip, y especializando los diseños para cada tipo de cálculo. Actualmente, los nodos de cálculo de un sistema de Computación de Altas Prestaciones (CAP) utilizan CPUs de múltiples procesadores, optimizados para el cálculo serial de instrucciones, y múltiples aceleradores (aceleradores gráficos, o many-core), optimizados para el cálculo paralelo. El diseño de un sistema CAP de nueva generación requiere no solo mejorar el rendimiento de cálculo, sino también mejorar la eficiencia energética. La siguiente generación de sistemas requiere mejorar un orden de magnitud en ambas métricas simultáneamente. Esta tesis doctoral explora optimizaciones específicas para sistemas CAP para hacer un mejor uso de los transistores, y para mejorar las prestaciones de forma transparente ejecutando las aplicaciones en múltiples aceleradores en paralelo. Primero, analizamos varios conjuntos de aplicaciones CAP, y las comparamos con aplicaciones para servidores y escritorio, identificando las principales diferencias que nos indican cómo ajustar la arquitectura para CAP. En las aplicaciones CAP, también analizamos la parte secuencial del código y la parte paralela de forma separada, . El resultado de este análisis nos lleva a proponer una arquitectura multiprocesador asimétrica (ACMP) , con un procesador optimizado para el código secuencial, y múltiples procesadores, más pequeños, optimizados para el procesamiento paralelo. Nuestros resultados muestran que reducir el tamaño de las estructuras del front-end (fetch, y predicción de saltos) en los procesadores paralelos nos proporciona un 16% extra de área en el chip, y una reducción de consumo del 7%. Como mejora a nuestra arquitectura ACMP, proponemos explotar el hecho de que todos los procesadores paralelos ejecutan el mismo código al mismo tiempo. Evaluamos una propuesta en que los procesadores paralelos comparten la caché de instrucciones, con la intención de que uno de ellos precargue las instrucciones para los demás procesadores (prefetching), sin aumentar la latencia media de acceso. Nuestra exploración de los distintos parámetros determina que el punto óptimo requiere una interconexión de alto ancho de banda para acceder a la caché compartida, y el uso de unos pocos line buffers para mantener el ancho de banda y la latencia necesarios. Nuestras proyecciones muestran un ahorro adicional del 11% en área y el 5% en energía, sin impacto en el rendimiento. Estos ahorros de área y energía permiten a un multiprocesador incrementar la eficiencia energética, o aumentar el rendimiento añadiendo procesador adicionales. Por último, estudiamos el efecto de usar múltiples aceleradores (GPU) en una arquitectura con tiempo de acceso a memoria no uniforme (NUMA). Una vez alcanzado el límite de número de transistores y tamaño máximo por chip, la siguiente generación de aceleradores deberá utilizar múltiples chips para aumentar el número de procesadores y el ancho de banda de acceso a memoria. Sin embargo, es muy difícil mantener la ilusión de un tiempo de acceso a memoria uniforme en un sistema multi-GPU sin reescribir el código de la aplicación. Nuestra investigación sobre sistemas multi-GPU muestra retos significativos en el diseño de la interconexión entre las GPU y la jerarquía de memorias cache. Nuestros resultados muestran que se puede explotar el comportamiento en fases de las aplicaciones para optimizar la configuración de la interconexión y las cachés de forma dinámica, minimizando el impacto de la arquitectura NUMA. Nuestro diseño mejora el rendimiento de un sistema con una única GPU en 1.5x, 2.3x y 3.2x (el 89%, 84%, y 76% del máximo teórico) usando 2, 4, y 8 GPUs en paralelo. Siendo su implementación posible hoy en dia, los nodos de cálculo con múltiples aceleradores son una alternativa atractiva para futuros sistemas CAP.Postprint (published version

Multicore architecture optimizations for HPC applications

From single-core CPUs to detachable compute accelerators, supercomputers made a tremendous progress by using available transistors on chip and specializing hardware for a given type of computation. Today, compute nodes used in HPC employ multi-core CPUs tailored for serial execution and multiple accelerators (many-core devices or GPUs) for throughput computing. However, designing next-generation HPC system requires not only the performance improvement but also better energy efficiency. Current trend of reaching exascale level of computation asks for at least an order of magnitude increase in both of these metrics. This thesis explores HPC-specific optimizations in order to make better utilization of the available transistors and to improve performance by transparently executing parallel code across multiple GPU accelerators. First, we analyze several HPC benchmark suites, compare them against typical desktop applications, and identify the differences which advocate for proper core tailoring. Moreover, within the HPC applications, we evaluate serial and parallel code sections separately, resulting in an Asymmetric Chip Multiprocessor (ACMP) design with one core optimized for single-thread performance and many lean cores for parallel execution. Our results presented here suggests downsizing of core front-end structures providing an HPC-tailored lean core which saves 16% of the core area and 7% of power, without performance loss. Further improving an ACMP design, we identify that multiple lean cores run the same code during parallel regions. This motivated us to evaluate the idea where lean cores share the I-cache with the intent of benefiting from mutual prefetching, without increasing the average access latency. Our exploration of the multiple parameters finds the sweet spot on a wide interconnect to access the shared I-cache and the inclusion of a few line buffers to provide the required bandwidth and latency to sustain performance. The projections presented in this thesis show additional 11% area savings with a 5% energy reduction at no performance cost. These area and power savings might be attractive for many-core accelerators either for increasing the performance per area and power unit, or adding additional cores and thus improving the performance for the same hardware budget. Finally, in this thesis we study the effects of future NUMA accelerators comprised of multiple GPU devices. Reaching the limits of a single-GPU die size, next-generation GPU compute accelerators will likely embrace multi-socket designs increasing the core count and memory bandwidth. However, maintaining the UMA behavior of a single-GPU in multi-GPU systems without code rewriting stands as a challenge. We investigate multi-socket NUMA GPU designs and show that significant changes are needed to both the GPU interconnect and cache architectures to achieve performance scalability. We show that application phase effects can be exploited allowing GPU sockets to dynamically optimize their individual interconnect and cache policies, minimizing the impact of NUMA effects. Our NUMA-aware GPU outperforms a single GPU by 1.5×, 2.3×, and 3.2× while achieving 89%, 84%, and 76% of theoretical application scalability in 2, 4, and 8 sockets designs respectively. Implementable today, NUMA-aware multi-socket GPUs may be a promising candidate for performance scaling of future compute nodes used in HPC.Empezando por CPUs de un solo procesador, y pasando por aceleradores discretos, los supercomputadores han avanzado enormemente utilizando todos los transistores disponibles en el chip, y especializando los diseños para cada tipo de cálculo. Actualmente, los nodos de cálculo de un sistema de Computación de Altas Prestaciones (CAP) utilizan CPUs de múltiples procesadores, optimizados para el cálculo serial de instrucciones, y múltiples aceleradores (aceleradores gráficos, o many-core), optimizados para el cálculo paralelo. El diseño de un sistema CAP de nueva generación requiere no solo mejorar el rendimiento de cálculo, sino también mejorar la eficiencia energética. La siguiente generación de sistemas requiere mejorar un orden de magnitud en ambas métricas simultáneamente. Esta tesis doctoral explora optimizaciones específicas para sistemas CAP para hacer un mejor uso de los transistores, y para mejorar las prestaciones de forma transparente ejecutando las aplicaciones en múltiples aceleradores en paralelo. Primero, analizamos varios conjuntos de aplicaciones CAP, y las comparamos con aplicaciones para servidores y escritorio, identificando las principales diferencias que nos indican cómo ajustar la arquitectura para CAP. En las aplicaciones CAP, también analizamos la parte secuencial del código y la parte paralela de forma separada, . El resultado de este análisis nos lleva a proponer una arquitectura multiprocesador asimétrica (ACMP) , con un procesador optimizado para el código secuencial, y múltiples procesadores, más pequeños, optimizados para el procesamiento paralelo. Nuestros resultados muestran que reducir el tamaño de las estructuras del front-end (fetch, y predicción de saltos) en los procesadores paralelos nos proporciona un 16% extra de área en el chip, y una reducción de consumo del 7%. Como mejora a nuestra arquitectura ACMP, proponemos explotar el hecho de que todos los procesadores paralelos ejecutan el mismo código al mismo tiempo. Evaluamos una propuesta en que los procesadores paralelos comparten la caché de instrucciones, con la intención de que uno de ellos precargue las instrucciones para los demás procesadores (prefetching), sin aumentar la latencia media de acceso. Nuestra exploración de los distintos parámetros determina que el punto óptimo requiere una interconexión de alto ancho de banda para acceder a la caché compartida, y el uso de unos pocos line buffers para mantener el ancho de banda y la latencia necesarios. Nuestras proyecciones muestran un ahorro adicional del 11% en área y el 5% en energía, sin impacto en el rendimiento. Estos ahorros de área y energía permiten a un multiprocesador incrementar la eficiencia energética, o aumentar el rendimiento añadiendo procesador adicionales. Por último, estudiamos el efecto de usar múltiples aceleradores (GPU) en una arquitectura con tiempo de acceso a memoria no uniforme (NUMA). Una vez alcanzado el límite de número de transistores y tamaño máximo por chip, la siguiente generación de aceleradores deberá utilizar múltiples chips para aumentar el número de procesadores y el ancho de banda de acceso a memoria. Sin embargo, es muy difícil mantener la ilusión de un tiempo de acceso a memoria uniforme en un sistema multi-GPU sin reescribir el código de la aplicación. Nuestra investigación sobre sistemas multi-GPU muestra retos significativos en el diseño de la interconexión entre las GPU y la jerarquía de memorias cache. Nuestros resultados muestran que se puede explotar el comportamiento en fases de las aplicaciones para optimizar la configuración de la interconexión y las cachés de forma dinámica, minimizando el impacto de la arquitectura NUMA. Nuestro diseño mejora el rendimiento de un sistema con una única GPU en 1.5x, 2.3x y 3.2x (el 89%, 84%, y 76% del máximo teórico) usando 2, 4, y 8 GPUs en paralelo. Siendo su implementación posible hoy en dia, los nodos de cálculo con múltiples aceleradores son una alternativa atractiva para futuros sistemas CAP

Reuse Distance Analysis for Large-Scale Chip Multiprocessors

Multicore Reuse Distance (RD) analysis is a powerful tool that can potentially provide a parallel program's detailed memory behavior. Concurrent Reuse Distance (CRD) and Private-stack Reuse Distance (PRD) measure RD across thread-interleaved memory reference streams, addressing shared and private caches. Sensitivity to memory interleaving makes CRD and PRD profiles architecture dependent, preventing them from analyzing different processor configurations. However such instability is minimal when all threads exhibit similar data-locality patterns. For loop-based parallel programs, interleaving threads are symmetric. CRD and PRD profiles are stable across cache size scaling, and exhibit predictable coherent movement across core count scaling. Hence, multicore RD analysis can provide accurate analysis for different processor configurations. Due to the prevalence of parallel loops, RD analysis will be valuable to multicore designers. This dissertation uses RD analysis to analyze multicore cache performance for loop-based parallel programs. First, we study the impacts of core count scaling and problem size scaling on CRD and PRD profiles. Two application parameters with architectural implications are identified: Ccore and Cshare. Core count scaling only impacts cache performance significantly below Ccore in shared caches, and Cshare is the capacity at which shared caches begin to outperform private caches in terms of data locality. Then, we develop techniques, in particular employing reference groups, to predict the coherent movement of CRD and PRD profiles due to scaling, and achieve accuracy of 80%-96%. After comparing our prediction techniques against profile sampling, we find that the prediction achieves higher speedup and accuracy, especially when the design space is large. Moreover, we evaluate the accuracy of using CRD and PRD profile predictions to estimate multicore cache performance, especially MPKI. When combined with the existing problem scaling prediction, our techniques can predict shared LLC (private L2 cache) MPKI to within 12% (14%) of simulation across 1,728 (1,440) configurations using only 36 measured CRD (PRD) profiles. Lastly, we propose a new framework based on RD analysis to optimize multicore cache hierarchies. Our study not only reveals several new insights, but it also demonstrates that RD analysis can help computer architects improve multicore designs

Scaling Distributed Cache Hierarchies through Computation and Data Co-Scheduling

Cache hierarchies are increasingly non-uniform, so for systems to scale efficiently, data must be close to the threads that use it. Moreover, cache capacity is limited and contended among threads, introducing complex capacity/latency tradeoffs. Prior NUCA schemes have focused on managing data to reduce access latency, but have ignored thread placement; and applying prior NUMA thread placement schemes to NUCA is inefficient, as capacity, not bandwidth, is the main constraint. We present CDCS, a technique to jointly place threads and data in multicores with distributed shared caches. We develop novel monitoring hardware that enables fine-grained space allocation on large caches, and data movement support to allow frequent full-chip reconfigurations. On a 64-core system, CDCS outperforms an S-NUCA LLC by 46% on average (up to 76%) in weighted speedup and saves 36% of system energy. CDCS also outperforms state-of-the-art NUCA schemes under different thread scheduling policies.National Science Foundation (U.S.) (Grant CCF-1318384)Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science (Jacobs Presidential Fellowship)United States. Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (PERFECT Contract HR0011-13-2-0005

Design tradeoffs for simplicity and efficient verification in the Execution Migration Machine

As transistor technology continues to scale, the architecture community has experienced exponential growth in design complexity and significantly increasing implementation and verification costs. Moreover, Moore's law has led to a ubiquitous trend of an increasing number of cores on a single chip. Often, these large-core-count chips provide a shared memory abstraction via directories and coherence protocols, which have become notoriously error-prone and difficult to verify because of subtle data races and state space explosion. Although a very simple hardware shared memory implementation can be achieved by simply not allowing ad-hoc data replication and relying on remote accesses for remotely cached data (i.e., requiring no directories or coherence protocols), such remote-access-based directoryless architectures cannot take advantage of any data locality, and therefore suffer in both performance and energy. Our recently taped-out 110-core shared-memory processor, the Execution Migration Machine (EM[superscript 2]), establishes a new design point. On the one hand, EM[superscript 2] supports shared memory but does not automatically replicate data, and thus preserves the simplicity of directoryless architectures. On the other hand, it significantly improves performance and energy over remote-access-only designs by exploiting data locality at remote cores via fast hardware-level thread migration. In this paper, we describe the design choices made in the EM[superscript 2] chip as well as our choice of design methodology, and discuss how they combine to achieve design simplicity and verification efficiency. Even though EM[superscript 2] is a fairly large design-110 cores using a total of 357 million transistors-the entire chip design and implementation process (RTL, verification, physical design, tapeout) took only 18 man-months

Reactive NUCA: Near-Optimal Block Placement and Replication in Distributed Caches

Increases in on-chip communication delay and the large working sets of server and scientific workloads complicate the design of the on-chip last- level cache for multicore processors. The large working sets favor a shared cache design that maximizes the aggregate cache capacity and minimizes off-chip memory requests. At the same time, the growing on-chip communication delay favors core-private caches that replicate data to minimize delays on global wires. Recent hybrid proposals offer lower average latency than conventional designs, but they address the placement requirements of only a subset of the data accessed by the application, require complex lookup and coherence mechanisms that increase latency, or fail to scale to high core counts. In this work, we observe that the cache access patterns of a range of server and scientific workloads can be classified into distinct classes, where each class is amenable to different block placement policies. Based on this observation, we propose Reactive NUCA (R- NUCA), a distributed cache design which reacts to the class of each cache access and places blocks at the appropriate location in the cache. R-NUCA cooperates with the operating system to support intelligent placement, migration, and replication without the overhead of an explicit coherence mechanism for the on-chip last-level cache. In a range of server, scientific, and multi-programmed workloads, R-NUCA matches the performance of the best cache design for each workload, improving performance by 14% on average over competing designs and by 32% at best, while achieving performance within 5% of an ideal cache design