Step 0: An Idea for Automatic OCL Benchmark Generation

Model Driven Engineering (MDE) is an important software development paradigm. Within this paradigm, models and constraints are essential components for expressing specifications of a software artefact. Object Constraint Language (OCL), a specification language that allows users to freely express constraints over different model features. However, one major issue is that the lack of OCL benchmarks makes difficult to evaluate existing and newly created OCL tools. In this paper, we present our initial idea about automatic OCL benchmark generation. The purpose of this paper is to show a developing idea rather than presenting a more formal and complete approach. Our idea is to use an OCL metamodel to sketch abstract syntax trees for OCL expressions, and solve generated typing constraints to produce the concrete OCL expressions. We illustrate this idea by using an example, discuss our work-in-progress and outline challenges to be tackled in the future

Recent Developments in OCL and Textual Modelling

The panel session of the 16th OCL workshop featured a lightning talk session for discussing recent developments and open questions in the area of OCL and textual modelling. During this session, the OCL community discussed, stimulated through short presentations by OCL experts, tool support, potential future extensions, and suggested initiatives to make the textual modelling community even more successful. This collaborative paper, to which each OCL expert contributed one section, summarises the discussions as well as describes the recent developments and open questions presented in the lightning talks

UML Consistency Rules:a Case Study with Open-Source UML Models

UML models are standard artifacts used by software engineers for designing software. As software is designed, different UML diagram types (e.g., class diagrams and sequence diagrams) are produced by software designers. Since the various UML diagram types describe different aspects of a software system, they are not independent but strongly depend on each other, hence they must be consistent. Inconsistencies cause faults in the final software systems. It is, therefore, paramount that they get detected, analyzed, and fixed. Consistency rules are a useful tool proposed in the literature to detect inconsistencies. They categorize constraints that help in identifying inconsistencies when violated. This case study aims at collecting and analyzing UML models with OCL consistency rules proposed in the literature and at promoting the development of a reference benchmark that can be reused by the (FM-)research community. We collected 33 UML consistency rules and 206 different UML diagrams contained in 34 open-source UML models presented in the literature. We propose an FM-based encoding of the consistency rules in OCL. This encoding allows analyzing whether the consistency rules are satisfied or violated within the 34 UML models. To assess the proposed benchmark, we analyzed how the UML models, consistency rules, diagram types contained in the benchmark help in assessing the consistency of UML models, and the consistency of diagrams across the different software development phases. Our results show that the considered UML models and consistency rules allowed identifying 2731 inconsistencies and that those inconsistencies refer to different software development phases. We concluded that the considered UML models and consistency rules could be considered as an initial benchmark that can be further extended by the research community

Traduciendo OCL como lenguaje de consultas y restricciones

Tesis inédita de la Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Facultad de Informática, Departamento de Sistemas Informáticos y Computación, leída el 30-06-2017Esta tesis doctoral debe gran parte de su motivación inicial y enfoque final a la discusión muy animada y perspicaz que tuvo lugar durante el seminario “Automated Reasoning on Conceptual Schemas” en Dagstuhl (19-24 Mayo, 2013) [18], en el cual tuvimos la fortuna de participar.Incluso antes de asistir al seminario, sobre la base de nuestra propia experiencia aplicando la metodología de desarrollo dirigida por modelos en el proyecto Action GUI [1],ya estábamos convencidos de la veracidad y la importancia de tres declaraciones claves contenidas en la presentación del mismo, que resumen muy bien las motivaciones finales de esta tesis:“La calidad de un sistema de información se determina en gran medida a principios del ciclo de desarrollo, es decir, durante la especificación de los requisitos y el modelado conceptual, ya que los errores introducidos en estas etapas suelen ser mucho más costosos de corregir que los errores cometidos durante el diseño o la implementación.”“Por lo tanto, es deseable prevenir, detectar y corregir errores tan pronto como sea posible en el proceso de desarrollo evaluando la corrección de los esquemas conceptuales construidos.”“La alta expresividad de los esquemas conceptuales requiere adoptar técnicas de razonamiento automatizadas para apoyar al diseñador en esta importante tarea.”...This doctoral dissertation owes a great deal of its initial motivation and final focusto the very lively and insightful discussion that took place during the Dagstuhl Seminar“Automated Reasoning on Conceptual Schemas” (19-24 May, 2013) [18], which we havethe fortune to participate in.Even before attending the seminar, based on our own experience applying the modeldrivendevelopment methodology within the ActionGUI project [1], we were already convincedof the truthfulness and importance of three key statements contained in the seminar’spresentation, which summarize very well this dissertation’s ultimate motivations:“The quality of an information system is largely determined early in the developmentcycle, i.e., during requirements specification and conceptual modeling, since errorsintroduced at these stages are usually much more expensive to correct than errorsmade during design or implementation.”“Thus, it is desirable to prevent, detect, and correct errors as early as possible in thedevelopment process by assessing the correctness of the conceptual schemas built.”“The high expressivity of conceptual schemas requires to adopt automated reasoningtechniques to support the designer in this important task.”..Depto. de Sistemas Informáticos y ComputaciónFac. de InformáticaTRUEunpu

A Query-based Approach for Verifying UML Class Diagrams with OCL Invariants.

Verifying whether a UML class diagram is consistent involves finding valid instances that provably meet its constraints defined in Object Constraint Language (OCL). Recent studies have shown that many existing tools and techniques not only can find valid instances but also pinpoint the conflicts among the OCL constraints. However, they do not scale well and are often unable to locate the conflicts when the number of OCL constraints significantly increases. In this paper, we present a novel approach that is capable of verifying UML class diagrams with a large number of OCL constraints. Our approach has two distinct features: (1) it provides a query language that allows users to choose parts of a UML class diagram to be verified. (2) a new algorithm that can handle an extreme size of OCL invariants via concurrent verification. We have implemented a new automated tool called: QMaxUSE. The evaluation results suggest that QMaxUSE has the potential to be adapted by industry and offers up to 30x efficiency improvement in verifying UML class diagrams with a large number of OCL constraints

A formal approach to finding inconsistencies in a metamodel

Checking the consistency of a metamodel involves finding a valid metamodel instance that provably meets the set of constraints that are defined over the metamodel. These constraints are often specified in Object Constraint Language. Often, a metamodel is inconsistent due to conflicts among the constraints. Existing approaches and tools are typically incapable of pinpointing the conflicting constraints, and this makes it difficult for users to debug and fix their metamodels. In this paper, we present a formal approach for locating conflicting constraints in inconsistent metamodels. Our approach has four distinct features: (1) users can rank individual metamodel features using their own domain-specific knowledge, (2) we transform these ranked features to a weighted maximum satisfiability modulo theories problem and solve it to compute the set of maximum achievable features, (3) we pinpoint the conflicting constraints by solving the set cover problem using a novel algorithm, and (4) we have implemented our approach into a fully automated tool called MaxUSE. Our evaluation results, using our assembled set of benchmarks, demonstrate the scalability of our work and that it is capable of efficiently finding conflicting constraints

Ontology-Based Verification of UML Class/OCL Model

Software models describe structures, relationships and features of the software. Modern software development methodologies such as MDE (Model Driven Engineering) use models as core elements. In MDE, the code is automatically generated from the model and model errors can implicitly shift into the code, which are difficult to find and fix. Model verification is a promising solution to this problem. However, coverage of all facets of model verification is a painful job and existing formal/semi-formal verification methods are greatly inspired by mathematics and difficult to understand by the software practitioners. This work considers particularly UML Class/OCL (Unified Modeling Language Class/Object Constraint Language) model and presents an ontology-based verification method. In the proposed method, a class diagram is transformed into ontology specified in OWL (Web Ontology Language) and constraints into SPARQL NAF (Negation as Failure) queries. This work tries to demonstrate that the proposed approach can efficiently cover all aspects of UML Class/OCL model verification

An eclipse plug-in for metamodel driven measurement

In this dissertation, we present a new plug-in for the Eclipse integrated development environ-ment that calculates software quality metrics using a metamodel driven approach to software measurement. Metamodel driven measurement is a technique that surged with the popularization of object-oriented systems and model-driven approaches to software design. It involves of in-stantiating software designs according to a language metamodel and calculating metrics with formalized queries over the obtained data. Our objectives consisted of creating a new Eclipse plug-in to analyse software developed in Java that, thanks to the metamodel driven approach, would allow users to easily define new software metrics without having to change a single line of Java code. To achieve our goals, we devised the Eclipse Java Metamodel, a new Java metamodel based on data provided by Eclipse’s Java Development Tools and implemented it on a prototype Eclipse plug-in. We have also formalized certain software metrics and an existing library for metrics extraction called FLAME, as sets of queries over our developed metamodel using the Object Constraint Language, which can be used directly on our prototype.Nesta dissertacão apresentamos uma nova extensão para o ambiente de desenvolvimento integrado Eclipse para o cálculo de metricas de qualidade de software através da medicão por metamodelos. Medicão por metamodelos é uma abordagem à medicão de software que surgiu com a popularização de sistemas orientados por objectos e design de software através de modelos. Esta técnica consiste em medir software através de definições formalizadas de métricas como queries sobre um metamodelo representativo da linguagem sobre a qual o software foi conceptualizado ou desenvolvido. Os nossos objectivos consistem em criar uma nova extensão para Eclipse para analisar software desenvolvido em Java que, graças ao uso de metamodelos, permite a utilizadores calcular novas métricas de software facilmente sem ter que programar uma única linha de código em Java. Para concretizar estes objectivos, desenvolvemos o Eclipse JavaMetamodel, um metamodelo da linguagem Java baseado nas Java Development Tools oferecidas pelo Eclipse e implementamos uma extensão protótipo. Também formalizamos certas métricas de software e uma biblioteca existente para o auxílio de cálculo de métricas chamada FLAME, como conjuntos de queries sobre o metamodelo feitas com a Object Constraint Language, que podem ser usadas directamente no nosso protótipo

Fundamental Approaches to Software Engineering

This open access book constitutes the proceedings of the 25th International Conference on Fundamental Approaches to Software Engineering, FASE 2022, which was held during April 4-5, 2022, in Munich, Germany, as part of the European Joint Conferences on Theory and Practice of Software, ETAPS 2022. The 17 regular papers presented in this volume were carefully reviewed and selected from 64 submissions. The proceedings also contain 3 contributions from the Test-Comp Competition. The papers deal with the foundations on which software engineering is built, including topics like software engineering as an engineering discipline, requirements engineering, software architectures, software quality, model-driven development, software processes, software evolution, AI-based software engineering, and the specification, design, and implementation of particular classes of systems, such as (self-)adaptive, collaborative, AI, embedded, distributed, mobile, pervasive, cyber-physical, or service-oriented applications