Distributed and Collaborative Processing of Audio Signals: Algorithms, Tools and Applications

Tesis por compendio[ES] Esta tesis se enmarca en el campo de las Tecnologías de la Información y las Comunicaciones (TIC), especialmente en el área del procesado digital de la señal. En la actualidad, y debido al auge del Internet de los cosas (IoT), existe un creciente interés por las redes de sensores inalámbricos (WSN), es decir, redes compuestas de diferentes tipos de dispositivos específicamente distribuidos en una determinada zona para realizar diferentes tareas de procesado de señal. Estos dispositivos o nodos suelen estar equipados con transductores electroacústicos así como con potentes y eficientes procesadores con capacidad de comunicación. En el caso particular de las redes de sensores acústicos (ASN), los nodos se dedican a resolver diferentes tareas de procesado de señales acústicas. El desarrollo de potentes sistemas de procesado centralizado han permitido aumentar el número de canales de audio, ampliar el área de control o implementar algoritmos más complejos. En la mayoría de los casos, una topología de ASN distribuida puede ser deseable debido a varios factores tales como el número limitado de canales utilizados por los dispositivos de adquisición y reproducción de audio, la conveniencia de un sistema escalable o las altas exigencias computacionales de los sistemas centralizados. Todos estos aspectos pueden llevar a la utilización de nuevas técnicas de procesado distribuido de señales con el fin de aplicarlas en ASNs. Para ello, una de las principales aportaciones de esta tesis es el desarrollo de algoritmos de filtrado adaptativo para sistemas de audio multicanal en redes distribuidas. Es importante tener en cuenta que, para aplicaciones de control del campo sonoro (SFC), como el control activo de ruido (ANC) o la ecualización activa de ruido (ANE), los nodos acústicos deben estar equipados con actuadores con el fin de controlar y modificar el campo sonoro. Sin embargo, la mayoría de las propuestas de redes distribuidas adaptativas utilizadas para resolver problemas de control del campo sonoro no tienen en cuenta que los nodos pueden interferir o modificar el comportamiento del resto. Por lo tanto, otra contribución destacable de esta tesis se centra en el análisis de cómo el sistema acústico afecta el comportamiento de los nodos dentro de una ASN. En los casos en que el entorno acústico afecta negativamente a la estabilidad del sistema, se han propuesto varias estrategias distribuidas para resolver el problema de interferencia acústica con el objetivo de estabilizar los sistemas de ANC. En el diseño de los algoritmos distribuidos también se han tenido en cuenta aspectos de implementación práctica. Además, con el objetivo de crear perfiles de ecualización diferentes en zonas de escucha independientes en presencia de ruidos multitonales, se han presentado varios algoritmos distribuidos de ANE en banda estrecha y banda ancha sobre una ASN con una comunicación colaborativa y compuesta por nodos acústicos. Se presentan además resultados experimentales para validar el uso de los algoritmos distribuidos propuestos en el trabajo para aplicaciones prácticas. Para ello, se ha diseñado un software de simulación acústica que permite analizar el rendimiento de los algoritmos desarrollados en la tesis. Finalmente, se ha realizado una implementación práctica que permite ejecutar aplicaciones multicanal de SFC. Para ello, se ha desarrollado un prototipo en tiempo real que controla las aplicaciones de ANC y ANE utilizando nodos acústicos colaborativos. El prototipo consiste en dos sistemas de control de audio personalizado (PAC) compuestos por un asiento de coche y un nodo acústico, el cual está equipado con dos altavoces, dos micrófonos y un procesador con capacidad de comunicación entre los dos nodos. De esta manera, es posible crear dos zonas independientes de control de ruido que mejoran el confort acústico del usuario sin necesidad de utilizar auriculares.[CA] Aquesta tesi s'emmarca en el camp de les Tecnologies de la Informació i les Comunicacions (TIC), especialment en l'àrea del processament digital del senyal. En l'actualitat, i a causa de l'auge de la Internet dels coses (IoT), existeix un creixent interés per les xarxes de sensors sense fils (WSN), és a dir, xarxes compostes de diferents tipus de dispositius específicament distribuïts en una determinada zona per a fer diferents tasques de processament de senyal. Aquests dispositius o nodes solen estar equipats amb transductors electroacústics així com amb potents i eficients processadors amb capacitat de comunicació. En el cas particular de les xarxes de sensors acústics (ASN), els nodes es dediquen a resoldre diferents tasques de processament de senyals acústics. El desenvolupament de potents sistemes de processament centralitzat han permés augmentar el nombre de canals d'àudio, ampliar l'àrea de control o implementar algorismes més complexos. En la majoria dels casos, una topologia de ASN distribuïda pot ser desitjable a causa de diversos factors tals com el nombre limitat de canals utilitzats pels dispositius d'adquisició i reproducció d'àudio, la conveniència d'un sistema escalable o les altes exigències computacionals dels sistemes centralitzats. Tots aquests aspectes poden portar a la utilització de noves tècniques de processament distribuït de senyals amb la finalitat d'aplicar-les en ASNs. Per a això, una de les principals aportacions d'aquesta tesi és el desenvolupament d'algorismes de filtrat adaptatiu per a sistemes d'àudio multicanal en xarxes distribuïdes. És important tindre en compte que, per a aplicacions de control del camp sonor (SFC), com el control actiu de soroll (ANC) o l'equalització activa de soroll (ANE), els nodes acústics han d'estar equipats amb actuadors amb la finalitat de controlar i modificar el camp sonor. No obstant això, la majoria de les propostes de xarxes distribuïdes adaptatives utilitzades per a resoldre problemes de control del camp sonor no tenen en compte que els nodes poden modificar el comportament de la resta. Per tant, una altra contribució destacable d'aquesta tesi se centra en l'anàlisi de com el sistema acústic afecta el comportament dels nodes dins d'una ASN. En els casos en què l'entorn acústic afecta negativament a l'estabilitat del sistema, s'han proposat diverses estratègies distribuïdes per a resoldre el problema d'interferència acústica amb l'objectiu d'estabilitzar els sistemes de ANC. En el disseny dels algorismes distribuïts també s'han tingut en compte aspectes d'implementació pràctica. A més, amb l'objectiu de crear perfils d'equalització diferents en zones d'escolta independents en presència de sorolls multitonales, s'han presentat diversos algorismes distribuïts de ANE en banda estreta i banda ampla sobre una ASN amb una comunicació col·laborativa i composta per nodes acústics. Es presenten a més resultats experimentals per a validar l'ús dels algorismes distribuïts proposats en el treball per a aplicacions pràctiques. Per a això, s'ha dissenyat un programari de simulació acústica que permet analitzar el rendiment dels algorismes desenvolupats en la tesi. Finalment, s'ha realitzat una implementació pràctica que permet executar aplicacions multicanal de SFC. Per a això, s'ha desenvolupat un prototip en temps real que controla les aplicacions de ANC i ANE utilitzant nodes acústics col·laboratius. El prototip consisteix en dos sistemes de control d'àudio personalitzat (PAC) compostos per un seient de cotxe i un node acústic, el qual està equipat amb dos altaveus, dos micròfons i un processador amb capacitat de comunicació entre els dos nodes. D'aquesta manera, és possible crear dues zones independents de control de soroll que milloren el confort acústic de l'usuari sense necessitat d'utilitzar auriculars.[EN] This thesis fits into the field of Information and Communications Technology (ICT), especially in the area of digital signal processing. Nowadays and due to the rise of the Internet of Things (IoT), there is a growing interest in wireless sensor networks (WSN), that is, networks composed of different types of devices specifically distributed in some area to perform different signal processsing tasks. These devices, also referred to as nodes, are usually equipped with electroacoustic transducers as well as powerful and efficient processors with communication capability. In the particular case of acoustic sensor networks (ASN), nodes are dedicated to solving different acoustic signal processing tasks. These audio signal processing applications have been undergone a major development in recent years due in part to the advances made in computer hardware and software. The development of powerful centralized processing systems has allowed the number of audio channels to be increased, the control area to be extended or more complex algorithmms to be implemented. In most cases, a distributed ASN topology can be desirable due to several factors such as the limited number of channels used by the sound acquisition and reproduction devices, the convenience of a scalable system or the high computational demands of a centralized fashion. All these aspects may lead to the use of novel distributed signal processing techniques with the aim to be applied over ASNs. To this end, one of the main contributions of this dissertation is the development of adaptive filtering algorithms for multichannel sound systems over distributed networks. Note that, for sound field control (SFC) applications, such as active noise control (ANC) or active noise equalization (ANE), acoustic nodes must be not only equipped with sensors but also with actuators in order to control and modify the sound field. However, most of the adaptive distributed networks approaches used to solve soundfield control problems do not take into account that the nodes may interfere or modify the behaviour of the rest. Therefore, other important contribution of this thesis is focused on analyzing how the acoustic system affects the behavior of the nodes within an ASN. In cases where the acoustic environment adversely affects the system stability, several distributed strategies have been proposed for solving the acoustic interference problem with the aim to stabilize ANC control systems. These strategies are based on both collaborative and non-collaborative approaches. Implementation aspects such as hardware constraints, sensor locations, convergenge rate or computational and communication burden, have been also considered on the design of the distributed algorithms. Moreover and with the aim to create independent-zone equalization profiles in the presence of multi-tonal noises, distributed narrowband and broadband ANE algorithms over an ASN with a collaborative learning and composed of acoustic nodes have been presented. Experimental results are presented to validate the use of the distributed algorithms proposed in the work for practical applications. For this purpose, an acoustic simulation software has been specifically designed to analyze the performance of the developed algorithms. Finally, the performance of the proposed distributed algorithms for multichannel SFC applications has been evaluated by means of a real practical implementation. To this end, a real-time prototype that controls both ANC and ANE applications by using collaborative acoustic nodes has been developed. The prototype consists of two personal audio control (PAC) systems composed of a car seat and an acoustic node, which is equipped with two loudspeakers, two microphones and a processor with communications capability. In this way, it is possible to create two independent noise control zones improving the acoustic comfort of the user without the use of headphones.Antoñanzas Manuel, C. (2019). Distributed and Collaborative Processing of Audio Signals: Algorithms, Tools and Applications [Tesis doctoral no publicada]. Universitat Politècnica de València. https://doi.org/10.4995/Thesis/10251/130209TESISCompendi

Development of Novel Techniques to Study Nonlinear Active Noise Control

Active noise control has been a field of growing interest over the past few decades. The challenges thrown by active noise control have attracted the notice of the scientific community to engage them in intense level of research. Cancellation of acoustic noise electronically in a simple and efficient way is the vital merit of the active noise control system. A detailed study about existing strategies for active noise control has been undertaken in the present work. This study has given an insight regarding various factors influencing performance of modern active noise control systems. The development of new training algorithms and structures for active noise control are active fields of research which are exploiting the benefits of different signal processing and soft- computing techniques. The nonlinearity contributed by environment and various components of active noise control system greatly affects the ultimate performance of an active noise canceller. This fact motivated to pursue the research work in developing novel architectures and algorithms to address the issues of nonlinear active noise control. One of the primary focus of the work is the application of artificial neural network to effectively combat the problem of active noise control. This is because artificial neural networks are inherently nonlinear processors and possesses capabilities of universal approximation and thus are well suited to exhibit high performance when used in nonlinear active noise control. The present work contributed significantly in designing efficient nonlinear active noise canceller based on neural network platform. Novel neural filtered-x least mean square and neural filtered-e least mean square algorithms are proposed for nonlinear active noise control taking into consideration the nonlinear secondary path. Employing Legendre neural network led the development of a set new adaptive algorithms such as Legendre filtered-x least mean square, Legendre vi filtered-e least mean square, Legendre filtered-x recursive least square and fast Legendre filtered-x least mean square algorithms. The proposed algorithms outperformed the existing standard algorithms for nonlinear active noise control in terms of steady state mean square error with reduced computational complexity. Efficient frequency domain implementation of some the proposed algorithms have been undertaken to exploit its benefits. Exhaustive simulation studies carried out have established the efficacy of the proposed architectures and algorithms

Control of feedback for assistive listening devices

Acoustic feedback refers to the undesired acoustic coupling between the loudspeaker and microphone in hearing aids. This feedback channel poses limitations to the normal operation of hearing aids under varying acoustic scenarios. This work makes contributions to improve the performance of adaptive feedback cancellation techniques and speech quality in hearing aids. For this purpose a two microphone approach is proposed and analysed; and probe signal injection methods are also investigated and improved upon

The removal of environmental noise in cellular communications by perceptual techniques

This thesis describes the application of a perceptually based spectral subtraction algorithm for the enhancement of non-stationary noise corrupted speech. Through examination of speech enhancement techniques, explanations are given for the choice of magnitude spectral subtraction and how the human auditory system can be modelled for frequency domain speech enhancement. It is discovered, that the cochlea provides the mechanical speech enhancement in the auditory system, through the use of masking. Frequency masking is used in spectral subtraction, to improve the algorithm execution time, and to shape the enhancement process making it sound natural to the ear. A new technique for estimation of background noise is presented, which operates during speech sections as well as pauses. This uses two microphones placed on opposite ends of the cellular handset. Using these, the algorithm determines whether the signal is speech, or noise, by examining the current and next frames presented to each microphone. This allows operation in non-stationary conditions, as the estimation is calculated for each frame, and a speech pause is not required for updating. A voting decision process decides the presence of speech or noise which determines which microphone the estimation is calculated from. The importance of an accurate noise estimate is highlighted with a new technique to reduce the effect of musical noise artifacts in the processed speech. This is a classic drawback of spectral subtraction techniques, and it is shown, that the trade off between noise reduction and speech distortion can be extended by this process. A new method for dealing with musical noise is described, which uses a combination of energy and variance examination of the spectrogram to segregate potential musical noise from desired speech sections. By examination of the spectrogram points surrounding musical noise sections, perceptually relevant values replace the corruption leading to cleaner enhanced speech. Any perceptual speech system requires accurate estimates of the clean speech masking thresholds, to prevent noisy sections being passed through the enhancement untouched. In this thesis, a method for the calculation of the estimated clean speech masking thresholds is derived. Classically, this requires an estimation of the clean speech before the thresholds can be derived, but this results in inaccuracy due to the presence of musical noise and spectral nulls. The new algorithm examines the thresholds produced by the corrupted speech, and the background noise, and from these determines the relationship between the two, to produce an estimate of the clean thresholds, with no operation performed on the actual speech signal. A discrepancy is found between the results for male and female speech, which, by examination of the perceptual process, is shown to be due to the different formant positions in male and female speech. Following the development of these parts, the entire enhancement algorithm is tested on a range of noise scenarios, using male and female speech. The results show, that the proposed algorithm is able to provide adequate performance in terms of noise reduction and speech quality

Theory and Design of Spatial Active Noise Control Systems

The concept of spatial active noise control is to use a number of loudspeakers to generate anti-noise sound waves, which would cancel the undesired acoustic noise over a spatial region. The acoustic noise hazards that exist in a variety of situations provide many potential applications for spatial ANC. However, using existing ANC techniques, it is difficult to achieve satisfying noise reduction for a spatial area, especially using a practical hardware setup. Therefore, this thesis explores various aspects of spatial ANC, and seeks to develop algorithms and techniques to promote the performance and feasibility of spatial ANC in real-life applications. We use the spherical harmonic analysis technique as the basis for our research in this work. This technique provides an accurate representation of the spatial noise field, and enables in-depth analysis of the characteristics of the noise field. Incorporating this technique into the design of spatial ANC systems, we developed a series of algorithms and methods that optimizes the spatial ANC systems, towards both improving noise reduction performance and reducing system complexity. Several contributions of this work are: (i) design of compact planar microphone array structures capable of recording 3D spatial sound fields, so that the noise field can be monitored with minimum physical intrusion to the quiet zone, (ii) derivation of a Direct-to-Reverberant Energy Ratio (DRR) estimation algorithm which can be used for evaluating reverberant characteristics of a noisy environment, (iii) propose a few methods to estimate and optimize spatial noise reduction of an ANC system, including a new metric for measuring spatial noise energy level, and (iv) design of an adaptive spatial ANC algorithm incorporating the spherical harmonic analysis technique. The combination of these contributions enables the design of compact, high performing spatial ANC systems for various applications