Power-constrained aware and latency-aware microarchitectural optimizations in many-core processors

As the transistor budgets outpace the power envelope (the power-wall issue), new architectural and microarchitectural techniques are needed to improve, or at least maintain, the power efficiency of next-generation processors. Run-time adaptation, including core, cache and DVFS adaptations, has recently emerged as a promising area to keep the pace for acceptable power efficiency. However, none of the adaptation techniques proposed so far is able to provide good results when we consider the stringent power budgets that will be common in the next decades, so new techniques that attack the problem from several fronts using different specialized mechanisms are necessary. The combination of different power management mechanisms, however, bring extra levels of complexity, since other factors such as workload behavior and run-time conditions must also be considered to properly allocate power among cores and threads. To address the power issue, this thesis first proposes Chrysso, an integrated and scalable model-driven power management that quickly selects the best combination of adaptation methods out of different core and uncore micro-architecture adaptations, per-core DVFS, or any combination thereof. Chrysso can quickly search the adaptation space by making performance/power projections to identify Pareto-optimal configurations, effectively pruning the search space. Chrysso achieves 1.9x better chip performance over core-level gating for multi-programmed workloads, and 1.5x higher performance for multi-threaded workloads. Most existing power management schemes use a centralized approach to regulate power dissipation. Unfortunately, the complexity and overhead of centralized power management increases significantly with core count rendering it in-viable at fine-grain time slices. The work leverages a two-tier hierarchical power manager. This solution is highly scalable with low overhead on a tiled many-core architecture with shared LLC and per-tile DVFS at fine-grain time slices. The global power is first distributed across tiles using GPM and then within a tile (in parallel across all tiles). Additionally, this work also proposes DVFS and cache-aware thread migration (DCTM) to ensure optimum per-tile co-scheduling of compatible threads at runtime over the two-tier hierarchical power manager. DCTM outperforms existing solutions by up to 12% on adaptive many-core tile processor. With the advancements in the core micro-architectural techniques and technology scaling, the performance gap between the computational component and memory component is increasing significantly (the memory-wall issue). To bridge this gap, the architecture community is pushing forward towards multi-core architecture with on-die near-memory DRAM cache memory (faster than conventional DRAM). Gigascale DRAM Caches poses a problem of how to efficiently manage the tags. The Tags-in-DRAM designs aims at efficiently co-locate tags with data, but it still suffer from high latency especially in multi-way associativity. The thesis finally proposes Tag Cache mechanism, an on-chip distributed tag caching mechanism with limited space and latency overhead to bypass the tag read operation in multi-way DRAM Caches, thereby reducing hit latency. Each Tag Cache, stored in L2, stores tag information of the most recently used DRAM Cache ways. The Tag Cache is able to exploit temporal locality of the DRAM Cache, thereby contributing to on average 46% of the DRAM Cache hits.A mesura que el consum dels transistors supera el nivell de potència desitjable es necessiten noves tècniques arquitectòniques i microarquitectòniques per millorar, o almenys mantenir, l'eficiència energètica dels processadors de les pròximes generacions. L'adaptació en temps d'execució, tant de nuclis com de les cachés, així com també adaptacions DVFS són idees que han sorgit recentment que fan preveure que sigui un àrea prometedora per mantenir un ritme d'eficiència energètica acceptable. Tanmateix, cap de les tècniques d'adaptació proposades fins ara és capaç d'oferir bons resultats si tenim en compte les restriccions estrictes de potència que seran comuns a les pròximes dècades. És convenient definir noves tècniques que ataquin el problema des de diversos fronts utilitzant diferents mecanismes especialitzats. La combinació de diferents mecanismes de gestió d'energia porta aparellada nivells addicionals de complexitat, ja que altres factors com ara el comportament de la càrrega de treball així com condicions específiques de temps d'execució també han de ser considerats per assignar adequadament la potència entre els nuclis del sistema computador. Per tractar el tema de la potència, aquesta tesi proposa en primer lloc Chrysso, una administració d'energia integrada i escalable que selecciona ràpidament la millor combinació entre diferents adaptacions microarquitectòniques. Chrysso pot buscar ràpidament l'adaptació adequada al fer projeccions òptimes de rendiment i potència basades en configuracions de Pareto, permetent així reduir de manera efectiva l'espai de cerca. Chrysso arriba a un rendiment de 1,9 sobre tècniques convencionals d'inhibició de portes amb una càrrega d'aplicacions seqüencials; i un rendiment de 1,5 quan les aplicacions corresponen a programes parla·lels. La majoria dels sistemes de gestió d'energia existents utilitzen un enfocament centralitzat per regular la dissipació d'energia. Malauradament, la complexitat i el temps d'administració s'incrementen significativament amb una gran quantitat de nuclis. En aquest treball es defineix un gestor jeràrquic de potència basat en dos nivells. Aquesta solució és altament escalable amb baix cost operatiu en una arquitectura de múltiples nuclis integrats en clústers, amb memòria caché de darrer nivell compartida a nivell de cluster, i DVFS establert en intervals de temps de gra fi a nivell de clúster. La potència global es distribueix en primer lloc a través dels clústers utilitzant GPM i després es distribueix dins un clúster (en paral·lel si es consideren tots els clústers). A més, aquest treball també proposa DVFS i migració de fils conscient de la memòria caché (DCTM) que garanteix una òptima distribució de tasques entre els nuclis. DCTM supera les solucions existents fins a un 12%. Amb els avenços en la tecnologia i les tècniques de micro-arquitectura de nuclis, la diferència de rendiment entre el component computacional i la memòria està augmentant significativament. Per omplir aquest buit, s'està avançant cap a arquitectures de múltiples nuclis amb memòries caché integrades basades en DRAM. Aquestes memòries caché DRAM a gran escala plantegen el problema de com gestionar de forma eficaç les etiquetes. Els dissenys de cachés amb dades i etiquetes juntes són un primer pas, però encara pateixen per tenir una alta latència, especialment en cachés amb un grau alt d'associativitat. En aquesta tesi es proposa l'estudi d'una tècnica anomenada Tag Cache, un mecanisme distribuït d'emmagatzematge d'etiquetes, que redueix la latència de les operacions de lectura d'etiquetes en les memòries caché DRAM. Cada Tag Cache, que resideix a L2, emmagatzema la informació de les vies que s'han accedit recentment de les memòries caché DRAM. D'aquesta manera es pot aprofitar la localitat temporal d'una caché DRAM, fet que contribueix en promig en un 46% dels encerts en les caché DRAM

性能と消費電力を考慮したキャッシュメモリアーキテクチャに関する研究

Tohoku University小林 広明課

Software development of reconfigurable real-time systems : from specification to implementation

This thesis deals with reconfigurable real-time systems solving real-time tasks scheduling problems in a mono-core and multi-core architectures. The main focus in this thesis is on providing guidelines, methods, and tools for the synthesis of feasible reconfigurable real-time systems in a mono-processor and multi-processor architectures. The development of these systems faces various challenges particularly in terms of stability, energy consumption, response and blocking time. To address this problem, we propose in this work a new strategy of i) placement and scheduling of tasks to execute real-time applications on mono-core and multi-core architectures, ii) optimization step based on Mixed integer linear programming (MILP), and iii) guidance tool that assists designers to implement a feasible multi-core reconfigurable real-time from specification level to implementation level. We apply and simulate the contribution to a case study, and compare the proposed results with related works in order to show the originality of this methodology.Echtzeitsysteme laufen unter harten Bedingungen an ihre Ausführungszeit. Die Einhaltung der Echtzeit-Bedingungen bestimmt die Zuverlässigkeit und Genauigkeit dieser Systeme. Neben den Echtzeit-Bedingungen müssen rekonfigurierbare Echtzeitsysteme zusätzliche Rekonfigurations-Bedingungen erfüllen. Diese Arbeit beschäftigt sich mit rekonfigurierbaren Echtzeitsystemen in Mono- und Multicore-Architekturen. An die Entwicklung dieser Systeme sind verschiedene Anforderungen gestellt. Insbesondere muss die Rekonfigurierbarkeit beachtet werden. Dabei sind aber Echtzeit-Bedingungen und Ressourcenbeschränkungen weiterhin zu beachten. Darüber hinaus werden die Kosten für die Entwicklung dieser Systeme insbesondere durch falsche Designentscheidungen in den frühen Phasen der Entwicklung stark beeinträchtigt. Das Hauptziel in dieser Arbeit liegt deshalb auf der Bereitstellung von Handlungsempfehlungen, Methoden und Werkzeugen für die zielgerichtete Entwicklung von realisierbaren rekonfigurierbaren Echtzeitsystemen in Mono- und Multicore-Architekturen. Um diese Herausforderungen zu adressieren wird eine neue Strategie vorgeschlagen, die 1) die Funktionsallokation, 2) die Platzierung und das Scheduling von Tasks, 3) einen Optimierungsschritt auf der Basis von Mixed Integer Linear Programming (MILP) und 4) eine entscheidungsunterstützende Lösung umfasst, die den Designern hilft, eine realisierbare rekonfigurierbare Echtzeitlösung von der Spezifikationsebene bis zur Implementierungsebene zu entwickeln. Die vorgeschlagene Methodik wird auf eine Fallstudie angewendet und mit verwandten Arbeiten vergliche

ACCURATE: Accuracy Maximization for Real-Time Multi-core systems with Energy Efficient Way-sharing Caches

Improving result-accuracy in approximate computing (AC) based real-time applications without violating deadline has recently become an active research domain. Execution-time of AC real-time tasks can individually be separated into: execution of the mandatory part to obtain a result of acceptable quality, followed by a partial/complete execution of the optional part to improve result-accuracy of the initial result within a given deadline. However, obtaining higher result-accuracy at the cost of enhanced execution time may lead to deadline violation, along with higher energy usage.We present ACCURATE, a novel hybrid offline-online approximate real-time scheduling approach that first schedules AC-based tasks on multi-core with an objective to maximize result-accuracy and determines operational processing speeds for each task constrained by system-wide power limit, deadline, and task-dependency. At runtime, by employing a waysharing technique (WH LLC) at the last level cache, ACCURATE improves performance, which is further leveraged, to enhance result-accuracy by executing more from the optional part, and to improve energy efficiency of the cache by turning off a controlled number of cache-ways. ACCURATE also exploits the slacks either to improve result-accuracy of the tasks, or to enhance energy efficiency of the underlying system, or both. ACCURATE achieves 85% QoS with 36% average reduction in cache leakage consumption with a 24% average gain in energy delay product for a 4-core based chip-multiprocessor with 6.4% average improvement in performance

高エネルギ効率マイクロプロセッサのためのハードウェア・ソフトウェア協調型キャッシュメモリシステムに関する研究

Tohoku University小林広明課

Vector coprocessor sharing techniques for multicores: performance and energy gains

Vector Processors (VPs) created the breakthroughs needed for the emergence of computational science many years ago. All commercial computing architectures on the market today contain some form of vector or SIMD processing. Many high-performance and embedded applications, often dealing with streams of data, cannot efficiently utilize dedicated vector processors for various reasons: limited percentage of sustained vector code due to substantial flow control; inherent small parallelism or the frequent involvement of operating system tasks; varying vector length across applications or within a single application; data dependencies within short sequences of instructions, a problem further exacerbated without loop unrolling or other compiler optimization techniques. Additionally, existing rigid SIMD architectures cannot tolerate efficiently dynamic application environments with many cores that may require the runtime adjustment of assigned vector resources in order to operate at desired energy/performance levels. To simultaneously alleviate these drawbacks of rigid lane-based VP architectures, while also releasing on-chip real estate for other important design choices, the first part of this research proposes three architectural contexts for the implementation of a shared vector coprocessor in multicore processors. Sharing an expensive resource among multiple cores increases the efficiency of the functional units and the overall system throughput. The second part of the dissertation regards the evaluation and characterization of the three proposed shared vector architectures from the performance and power perspectives on an FPGA (Field-Programmable Gate Array) prototype. The third part of this work introduces performance and power estimation models based on observations deduced from the experimental results. The results show the opportunity to adaptively adjust the number of vector lanes assigned to individual cores or processing threads in order to minimize various energy-performance metrics on modern vector- capable multicore processors that run applications with dynamic workloads. Therefore, the fourth part of this research focuses on the development of a fine-to-coarse grain power management technique and a relevant adaptive hardware/software infrastructure which dynamically adjusts the assigned VP resources (number of vector lanes) in order to minimize the energy consumption for applications with dynamic workloads. In order to remove the inherent limitations imposed by FPGA technologies, the fifth part of this work consists of implementing an ASIC (Application Specific Integrated Circuit) version of the shared VP towards precise performance-energy studies involving high- performance vector processing in multicore environments

ADACORE: Achieving Energy Efficiency via Adaptive Core Morphing at Runtime

Heterogeneous multicore processors offer an energy-efficient alternative to homogeneous multicores. Typically, heterogeneous multi-core refers to a system with more than one core where all the cores use a single ISA but differ in one or more micro-architectural configurations. A carefully designed multicore system consists of cores of diverse power and performance profiles. During execution, an application is run on a core that offers the best trade-off between performance and energy-efficiency. Since the resource needs of an application may vary with time, so does the optimal core choice. Moving a thread from one core to another involves transferring the entire processor state and cache warm-up. Frequent migration leads to large performance overhead, negating any benefits of migration. Infrequent migration on the other hand leads to missed opportunities. Thus, reducing overhead of migration is integral to harnessing benefits of heterogeneous multicores. \par This work proposes \textit{AdaCore}, a novel core architecture which pushes the heterogeneity exploited in the heterogeneous multicore into a single core. \textit{AdaCore} primarily addresses the resource bottlenecks in workloads. The design attempts to adaptively match the resource demands by reconfiguring on-chip resources at a fine-grain granularity. The adaptive core morphing allows core configurations with diverse power and performance profiles within a single core by adaptive voltage, frequency and resource reconfiguration. Towards this end, the proposed novel architecture while providing energy savings, improves performance with a low overhead in-core reconfiguration. This thesis further compares \textit{AdaCore} with a standard Out-of-Order core with capability to perform Dynamic Voltage and Frequency Scaling (DVFS) designed to achieve energy efficiency. The results presented in this thesis indicate that the proposed scheme can improve the performance/Watt of application, on average, by 32\% over a static out-of-order core and by 14\% over DVFS. The proposed scheme improves $IPS^{2}/Watt$ by 38\% over static out-of-order core

Dynamic Processor Reconfiguration for Power, Performance and Reliability Management

Technology advancements allowed more transistors to be packed in a smaller area, while the improved performance helped in achieving higher clock frequencies. This, unfortunately led to a power density problem, forcing processor industry to lower the clock frequency and integrate multiple cores on the same die. Depending on core characteristics, the multiple cores in the die could be symmetric or asymmetric. Asymmetric multi-core processors (AMPs) have been proposed as an alternative to symmetric multi-cores to improve power efficiency. AMPs comprise of cores that implement the same ISA, but differ in performance and power characteristics due to varying sizes of micro-architectural resources. As the computational bottleneck of a workload shifts from one resource to another during its course of execution, reassigning it to another core (where it runs more efficiently), can improve the overall power efficiency. Thus achieving high power efficiency in AMPs requires (i) a diverse set of cores that are optimized for various program phases, (ii) runtime analysis to determine the best core to run on, and (iii) low overhead of re-assigning a thread to a different core type. Decisions to swap threads between AMPs are made at coarse grain granularity of millions of instructions, to mitigate the impact of thread migration overhead. But the computational needs of the program rapidly change during the course of its execution. The best core configuration for an application such that, both power consumption and performance are optimized, changes over time rapidly at fine granularity of thousands of instructions. This dissertation explores ways to design core micro-architecture such that high power efficiency could be achieved, if switching overhead could be lowered, enabling fine grain switching. To take advantage of power saving opportunities at fine grain granularity, this thesis explores reconfigurable/morphable architectures where core resources are reconfigured on demand to suit the needs of the executing application. At first, we explore reconfigurable architectures consisting of two kinds of cores: out-of-order (OOO) big cores and in-order (InO) small cores. The big cores provide higher performance while the small cores are more power efficient. In this proposed architecture, OOO core reconfigures into InO core at run time. Our proposed online management scheme decides to switch between these core types such that we obtain significant power benefits without impacting performance. We also observe that, resource requirements of applications can be quite diverse and consequently, resource bottlenecks or excesses can vary considerably. Thus, reconfiguration between just two core modes may not fully exploit power and performance improvement opportunities. We therefore, explore reconfigurable architectures consisting of diverse core types that not limited to big and little cores. A single core can reconfigure into multiple core modes where each mode has unique power and performance characteristics. Workload performance on a particular core mode depends on a large set of processor resources. Some workloads are highly memory intensive, some exhibit large instruction dependency, some experience high rates of branch mis-prediction, while other workloads exhibit large exploitable instruction level parallelism. A diverse set of core modes is needed, that could address shifting resource needs during various program phases of an application. Different trade-offs in power and performance could be achieved by reducing or expanding the size of various resource. Trade-offs for each core mode are also affected by operating voltage and frequency. We therefore, propose joint core resource resizing with dynamic voltage and frequency scaling (DVFS), which is important for applications whose performance is sensitive to changes in frequency. Thus, at fine granularity, the core should adapt to varying instruction window sizes, execution bandwidth and frequency to meet the demands of the workload at run-time to improve power efficiency. Many current processors employ DVFS aggressively to improve power efficiency and maximize performance. This dissertation studies the tradeoff in power efficiency in using fine grain DVFS and reconfigurable architectures mentioned above.We also explore another important problem due to continued scaling of devices which results in higher vulnerability to soft-errors. We consider dynamic core reconfiguration from the perspectives of both power efficiency and vulnerability to soft-errors. An online management scheme is proposed such that core reconfiguration upon a thread switch not only improves power efficiency but also does not increase the vulnerability to soft errors. In summary, we propose in this thesis several solutions for improving power efficiency by integrating heterogeneity within the core. We also address how popular power reduction techniques like DVFS are comparable to our approach. Finally, we address reliability challenges along with improving power efficiency

Cross-Layer Automated Hardware Design for Accuracy-Configurable Approximate Computing

Approximate Computing trades off computation accuracy against performance or energy efficiency. It is a design paradigm that arose in the last decade as an answer to diminishing returns from Dennard\u27s scaling and a shift in the prominent workloads. A range of modern workloads, categorized mainly as recognition, mining, and synthesis, features an inherent tolerance to approximations. Their characteristics, such as redundancies in their input data and robust-to-noise algorithms, allow them to produce outputs of acceptable quality, despite an approximation in some of their computations. Approximate Computing leverages the application tolerance by relaxing the exactness in computation towards primary design goals of increasing performance or improving energy efficiency. Existing techniques span across the abstraction layers of computer systems where cross-layer techniques are shown to offer a larger design space and yield higher savings. Currently, the majority of the existing work aims at meeting a single accuracy. The extent of approximation tolerance, however, significantly varies with a change in input characteristics and applications. In this dissertation, methods and implementations are presented for cross-layer and automated design of accuracy-configurable Approximate Computing to maximally exploit the performance and energy benefits. In particular, this dissertation addresses the following challenges and introduces novel contributions: A main Approximate Computing category in hardware is to scale either voltage or frequency beyond the safe limits for power or performance benefits, respectively. The rationale is that timing errors would be gradual and for an initial range tolerable. This scaling enables a fine-grain accuracy-configurability by varying the timing error occurrence. However, conventional synthesis tools aim at meeting a single delay for all paths within the circuit. Subsequently, with voltage or frequency scaling, either all paths succeed, or a large number of paths fail simultaneously, with a steep increase in error rate and magnitude. This dissertation presents an automated method for minimizing path delays by individually constraining the primary outputs of combinational circuits. As a result, it reduces the number of failing paths and makes the timing errors significantly more gradual, and also rarer and smaller on average. Additionally, it reveals that delays can be significantly reduced towards the least significant bit (LSB) and allows operating at a higher frequency when small operands are computed. Precision scaling, i.e., reducing the representation of data and its accuracy is widely used in multiple abstraction layers in Approximate Computing. Reducing data precision also reduces the transistor toggles, and therefore the dynamic power consumption. Application and architecture level precision scaling results in using only LSBs of the circuit. Arithmetic circuits often have less complexity and logic depth in LSBs compared to most significant bits (MSB). To take advantage of this circuit property, a delay-altering synthesis methodology is proposed. The method finds energy-optimal delay values under configurable precision usage and assigns them to primary outputs used for different precisions. Thereby, it enables dynamic frequency-precision scalable circuits for energy efficiency. Within the hardware architecture, it is possible to instantiate multiple units with the same functionality with different fixed approximation levels, where each block benefits from having fewer transistors and also synthesis relaxations. These blocks can be selected dynamically and thus allow to configure the accuracy during runtime. Instantiating such approximate blocks can be a lower dynamic power but higher area and leakage cost alternative to the current state-of-the-art gating mechanisms which switch off a group of paths in the circuit to reduce the toggling activity. Jointly, instantiating multiple blocks and gating mechanisms produce a large design space of accuracy-configurable hardware, where energy-optimal solutions require a cross-layer search in architecture and circuit levels. To that end, an approximate hardware synthesis methodology is proposed with joint optimizations in architecture and circuit for dynamic accuracy scaling, and thereby it enables energy vs. area trade-offs