Fibers are not (P)Threads: The Case for Loose Coupling of Asynchronous Programming Models and MPI Through Continuations

Asynchronous programming models (APM) are gaining more and more traction, allowing applications to expose the available concurrency to a runtime system tasked with coordinating the execution. While MPI has long provided support for multi-threaded communication and non-blocking operations, it falls short of adequately supporting APMs as correctly and efficiently handling MPI communication in different models is still a challenge. Meanwhile, new low-level implementations of light-weight, cooperatively scheduled execution contexts (fibers, aka user-level threads (ULT)) are meant to serve as a basis for higher-level APMs and their integration in MPI implementations has been proposed as a replacement for traditional POSIX thread support to alleviate these challenges. In this paper, we first establish a taxonomy in an attempt to clearly distinguish different concepts in the parallel software stack. We argue that the proposed tight integration of fiber implementations with MPI is neither warranted nor beneficial and instead is detrimental to the goal of MPI being a portable communication abstraction. We propose MPI Continuations as an extension to the MPI standard to provide callback-based notifications on completed operations, leading to a clear separation of concerns by providing a loose coupling mechanism between MPI and APMs. We show that this interface is flexible and interacts well with different APMs, namely OpenMP detached tasks, OmpSs-2, and Argobots.Comment: 12 pages, 7 figures Published in proceedings of EuroMPI/USA '20, September 21-24, 2020, Austin, TX, US

Fast and generic concurrent message-passing

Communication hardware and software have a significant impact on the performance of clusters and supercomputers. Message passing model and the Message-Passing Interface (MPI) is a widely used model of communications in the High-Performance Computing (HPC) community with great success. However, it has recently faced new challenges due to the emergence of many-core architecture and of programming models with dynamic task parallelism, assuming a large number of concurrent, light-weight threads. These applications come from important classes of applications such as graph and data analytics. Using MPI with these languages/runtimes is inefficient because MPI implementation is not able to perform well with threads. Using MPI as a communication middleware is also not efficient since MPI has to provide many abstractions that are not needed for many of the frameworks, thus having extra overheads. In this thesis, we studied MPI performance under the new assumptions. We identified several factors in the message-passing model which were inherently problematic for scalability and performance. Next, we analyzed the communication of a number of graph, threading and data-flow frameworks to identify generic patterns. We then proposed a low-level communication interface (LCI) to bridge the gap between communication architecture and runtime. The core of our idea is to attach to each message a few simple operations which fit better with the current hardware and can be implemented efficiently. We show that with only a few carefully chosen primitives and appropriate design, message-passing under this interface can easily outperform production MPI when running atop of multi-threaded environment. Further, using LCI is simple for various types of usage