Reduced reference image and video quality assessments: review of methods

With the growing demand for image and video-based applications, the requirements of consistent quality assessment metrics of image and video have increased. Different approaches have been proposed in the literature to estimate the perceptual quality of images and videos. These approaches can be divided into three main categories; full reference (FR), reduced reference (RR) and no-reference (NR). In RR methods, instead of providing the original image or video as a reference, we need to provide certain features (i.e., texture, edges, etc.) of the original image or video for quality assessment. During the last decade, RR-based quality assessment has been a popular research area for a variety of applications such as social media, online games, and video streaming. In this paper, we present review and classification of the latest research work on RR-based image and video quality assessment. We have also summarized different databases used in the field of 2D and 3D image and video quality assessment. This paper would be helpful for specialists and researchers to stay well-informed about recent progress of RR-based image and video quality assessment. The review and classification presented in this paper will also be useful to gain understanding of multimedia quality assessment and state-of-the-art approaches used for the analysis. In addition, it will help the reader select appropriate quality assessment methods and parameters for their respective applications

Reduced reference image and video quality assessments: review of methods

With the growing demand for image and video-based applications, the requirements of consistent quality assessment metrics of image and video have increased. Different approaches have been proposed in the literature to estimate the perceptual quality of images and videos. These approaches can be divided into three main categories; full reference (FR), reduced reference (RR) and no-reference (NR). In RR methods, instead of providing the original image or video as a reference, we need to provide certain features (i.e., texture, edges, etc.) of the original image or video for quality assessment. During the last decade, RR-based quality assessment has been a popular research area for a variety of applications such as social media, online games, and video streaming. In this paper, we present review and classification of the latest research work on RR-based image and video quality assessment. We have also summarized different databases used in the field of 2D and 3D image and video quality assessment. This paper would be helpful for specialists and researchers to stay well-informed about recent progress of RR-based image and video quality assessment. The review and classification presented in this paper will also be useful to gain understanding of multimedia quality assessment and state-of-the-art approaches used for the analysis. In addition, it will help the reader select appropriate quality assessment methods and parameters for their respective applications

Full Reference Objective Quality Assessment for Reconstructed Background Images

With an increased interest in applications that require a clean background image, such as video surveillance, object tracking, street view imaging and location-based services on web-based maps, multiple algorithms have been developed to reconstruct a background image from cluttered scenes. Traditionally, statistical measures and existing image quality techniques have been applied for evaluating the quality of the reconstructed background images. Though these quality assessment methods have been widely used in the past, their performance in evaluating the perceived quality of the reconstructed background image has not been verified. In this work, we discuss the shortcomings in existing metrics and propose a full reference Reconstructed Background image Quality Index (RBQI) that combines color and structural information at multiple scales using a probability summation model to predict the perceived quality in the reconstructed background image given a reference image. To compare the performance of the proposed quality index with existing image quality assessment measures, we construct two different datasets consisting of reconstructed background images and corresponding subjective scores. The quality assessment measures are evaluated by correlating their objective scores with human subjective ratings. The correlation results show that the proposed RBQI outperforms all the existing approaches. Additionally, the constructed datasets and the corresponding subjective scores provide a benchmark to evaluate the performance of future metrics that are developed to evaluate the perceived quality of reconstructed background images.Comment: Associated source code: https://github.com/ashrotre/RBQI, Associated Database: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1bg8YRPIBcxpKIF9BIPisULPBPcA5x-Bk?usp=sharing (Email for permissions at: ashrotreasuedu

Stereoscopic video quality assessment using binocular energy

Stereoscopic imaging is becoming increasingly popular. However, to ensure the best quality of experience, there is a need to develop more robust and accurate objective metrics for stereoscopic content quality assessment. Existing stereoscopic image and video metrics are either extensions of conventional 2D metrics (with added depth or disparity information) or are based on relatively simple perceptual models. Consequently, they tend to lack the accuracy and robustness required for stereoscopic content quality assessment. This paper introduces full-reference stereoscopic image and video quality metrics based on a Human Visual System (HVS) model incorporating important physiological findings on binocular vision. The proposed approach is based on the following three contributions. First, it introduces a novel HVS model extending previous models to include the phenomena of binocular suppression and recurrent excitation. Second, an image quality metric based on the novel HVS model is proposed. Finally, an optimised temporal pooling strategy is introduced to extend the metric to the video domain. Both image and video quality metrics are obtained via a training procedure to establish a relationship between subjective scores and objective measures of the HVS model. The metrics are evaluated using publicly available stereoscopic image/video databases as well as a new stereoscopic video database. An extensive experimental evaluation demonstrates the robustness of the proposed quality metrics. This indicates a considerable improvement with respect to the state-of-the-art with average correlations with subjective scores of 0.86 for the proposed stereoscopic image metric and 0.89 and 0.91 for the proposed stereoscopic video metrics

Methods and Tools for Image and Video Quality Assessment

Disertační práce se zabývá metodami a prostředky pro hodnocení kvality obrazu ve videosekvencích, což je velmi aktuální téma, zažívající velký rozmach zejména v souvislosti s digitálním zpracováním videosignálů. Přestože již existuje relativně velké množství metod a metrik pro objektivní, tedy automatizované měření kvality videosekvencí, jsou tyto metody zpravidla založeny na porovnání zpracované (poškozené, například komprimací) a originální videosekvence. Metod pro hodnocení kvality videosekvení bez reference, tedy pouze na základě analýzy zpracovaného materiálu, je velmi málo. Navíc se takové metody převážně zaměřují na analýzu hodnot signálu (typicky jasu) v jednotlivých obrazových bodech dekódovaného signálu, což je jen těžko aplikovatelné pro moderní komprimační algoritmy jako je H.264/AVC, který používá sofistikovené techniky pro odstranění komprimačních artefaktů. V práci je nejprve podán stučný přehled dostupných metod pro objektivní hodnocení komprimovaných videosekvencí se zdůrazněním rozdílného principu metod využívajících referenční materiál a metod pracujících bez reference. Na základě analýzy možných přístupů pro hodnocení video sekvencí komprimovaných moderními komprimačními algoritmy je v dalším textu práce popsán návrh nové metody určené pro hodnocení kvality obrazu ve videosekvencích komprimovaných s využitím algoritmu H.264/AVC. Nová metoda je založena na sledování hodnot parametrů, které jsou obsaženy v transportním toku komprimovaného videa, a přímo souvisí s procesem kódování. Nejprve je provedena úvaha nad vlivem některých takových parametrů na kvalitu výsledného videa. Následně je navržen algoritmus, který s využitím umělé neuronové sítě určuje špičkový poměr signálu a šumu (peak signal-to-noise ratio -- PSNR) v komprimované videosekvenci -- plně referenční metrika je tedy nahrazována metrikou bez reference. Je ověřeno několik konfigurací umělých neuronových sítí od těch nejjednodušších až po třívrstvé dopředné sítě. Pro učení sítí a následnou analýzu jejich výkonnosti a věrnosti určení PSNR jsou vytvořeny dva soubory nekomprimovaných videosekvencí, které jsou následně komprimovány algoritmem H.264/AVC s proměnným nastavením kodéru. V závěrečné části práce je proveden rozbor chování nově navrženého algoritmu v případě, že se změní vlastnosti zpracovávaného videa (rozlišení, střih), případně kodéru (formát skupiny současně kódovaných snímků). Chování algoritmu je analyzováno až do plného vysokého rozlišení zdrojového signálu (full HD -1920 x 1080 obrazových bodů).The doctoral thesis is focused on methods and tools for image quality assessment in video sequences, which is a very up-to-date theme, undergoing a rapid evolution with respect to digital video signal processing, in particular. Although a variety of metrics for objective (automated) video sequence quality measurement has been developed recently, these methods are mostly based on comparison of the processed (damaged, e.g. with compression) and original video sequences. There are very few methods operating without reference, i.e. only on the processed video material. Moreover, such methods are usually analyzing signal values (typically luminance) in picture elements of the decoded signal, which is hardly applicable for modern compression algorithms such as the H.264/AVC as they use sophisticated techniques to remove compression artifacts. The thesis first gives a brief overview of the available metrics for objective quality measurements of compressed video sequences, emphasizing the different approach of full-reference and no-reference methods. Based on an analysis of possible ideas for measuring quality of video sequences compressed using modern compression algorithms, the thesis describes the design process of a new quality metric for video sequences compressed with the H.264/AVC algorithm. The new method is based on monitoring of several parameters, present in the transport stream of the compressed video and directly related to the encoding process. The impact of bitstream parameters on the video quality is considered first. Consequently, an algorithm is designed, employing an artificial neural network to estimate the peak signal-to-noise ratios (PSNR) of the compressed video sequences -- a full-reference metric is thus replaced by a no--reference metric. Several neural network configurations are verified, reaching from the simplest to three-layer feedforward networks. Two sets of video sequences are constructed to train the networks and analyze their performance and fidelity of estimated PSNRs. The sequences are compressed using the H.264/AVC algorithm with variable encoder configuration. The final part of the thesis deals with an analysis of behavior of the newly designed algorithm, provided the properties of the processed video are changed (resolution, cut) or encoder configuration is altered (format of group of pictures coded together). The analysis is done on video sequences with resolution up to full HD (1920 x 1080 pixels, progressive)