Network epidemiology of cattle and cattle farms in Great Britain

Infectious diseases of livestock can cause substantial production losses and have detrimental impacts upon human health, and animal health and welfare. To limit the impact of diseases, understanding more about the dynamics of transmission can assist in the control and prevention of infectious disease. In particular, understanding infection transmission on networks, ‘network epidemiology’, offers a flexible approach, incorporating between-host heterogeneity in potentially infectious contacts drawn from empirical study of interactions among individual animals, or among farms. Trading animals and optimising productivity are vital to the commercial viability of farms, however they necessarily involve compromises in biosecurity, animal health, and welfare. Better understanding of the relationships among these multiple factors might facilitate the development of sustainable livestock industries that are more resilient to disease outbreaks. In this thesis I examine cattle interactions at two spatial scales, first at a national-level by studying the trading connections among farms, and then at a finer scale by analysing the social interactions among cattle. First, I introduce the concept of superspreaders, hosts that generate many more secondary infections than the rest of the population, and evaluate evidence for the notion that some farms might act as superspreaders of infection. I utilise the example of bovine tuberculosis (bTB) to illustrate this concept and find that farms might act as superspreaders in three main ways; first, via exceptional trading between farms, second, by factors that facilitate high within-herd transmission and trading of high-risk animals, and third, by harbouring undetected infection for long periods. I find mechanisms that align with all three processes in the cattle industry in Great Britain that might allow superspreader farms to contribute to the current bTB epidemic. At a national level, I describe cattle movements among farms over time, finding that some farms consistently act as ‘hubs’ in trading networks, functioning in a similar way to markets, in that they are highly connected to other farms by many direct trades. Utilising the temporal network measure of ‘contact chains’, I quantify the farms that represent potential sources of infection (ingoing contact chains) and the potential farms that a farm might infect over 1 year periods. Farms divide into two groups: those with very few connections (less than 10 farms) that are relatively isolated from the network, and those with very many connections (more than 1000 farms) that are highly connected within the network. I find that a substantial number of farms have over 10,000 farms in both their ingoing and outgoing contact chains, such that, if infected, they might potentially act as superspreaders by being more at risk of both acquiring and spreading infection. Building on my previous analysis, I then characterise the ‘source farms’ in the ingoing contact chains, in terms of their location and bTB history. I find that after controlling for previously-established risk factors for bTB, having more source farms in areas of higher bTB risk in the ingoing contact chain increases the odds of a bTB incident on the root farm, whilst having more source farms in lower risk areas is associated with lower odds of a bTB incident on the root farm. At a finer scale of contacts among animals, I explore interactions among dairy cattle in multiple herds using automated proximity sensors and GPS devices. When aggregated over long periods, cattle interactions appear dense and unstructured, however finer time spatial and temporal perspectives revealed structure and variation in contacts. Herds in our study had variable grazing and housing access, allowing us to determine that cattle interact with more other cows, for longer time periods when they are in buildings compared to contacts at pasture. Cattle exhibited heterogeneity in their number and duration of contacts, and although the majority of cattle interacted more equally with other cows, a small proportion of cows in each group showed evidence of stronger social ties. Next, I consider associations between social interactions, production, and health. I review the existing literature on social parameters such as dominance rank and re-grouping of cattle, and find inconclusive outcomes regarding their impact on milk yield and somatic cell count, an indicator of udder health. I perform my own analysis to examine the relationship between the time cows spend with other cows, milk yield and somatic cell count, and do not find a statistically significant relationship. In considering social preference, cows that had experienced the same number of lactations were more likely to interact, but cows spending more time with cows in the same lactation did not appreciably affect their milk yield or somatic cell count. Finally, I draw together the findings of this thesis and reflect on how the identification of higher-risk farms might be useful in the control of livestock infections, and specifically bTB in Great Britain. I conclude that network analysis is a valuable tool to study the interactions of cattle and cattle farms, identifying unique opportunities for targeted approaches to disease control.Animal Health Veterinary Laboratories Agency BBSRC - BB/M015874/

Individual and network characteristic associated with hospital-acquired Middle East Respiratory Syndrome coronavirus

Background: During outbreaks of infectious diseases, transmission of the pathogen can form networks of infected individuals connected either directly or indirectly. Methods: Network centrality metrics were used to characterize hospital-acquired Middle East Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus (HA-MERS) outbreaks in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia between 2012 and 2016. Covariate-adjusted multivariable logistic regression models were applied to assess the effect of individual level risk factors and network level metrics associated with increase in length of hospital stay and risk of deaths from MERS. Results: About 27% of MERS cases were hospital acquired during the study period. The median age of healthcare workers and hospitalized patients were 35 years and 63 years, respectively, Although HA-MERS were more connected, we found no significant difference in degree centrality metrics between HA-MERS and non-HA-MERS cases. Pre-existing medical conditions (adjusted Odds ratio (aOR) = 2.43, 95% confidence interval: (CI) [1.11–5.33]) and hospitalized patients (aOR = 29.99, 95% CI [1.80–48.65]) were the strongest risk predictors of death from MERS. The risk of death associated with 1-day increased length of stay was significantly higher for patients with comorbidities. Conclusion: Our investigation also revealed that patients with an HA-MERS infection experienced a significantly longer hospital stay and were more likely to die from the disease. Healthcare worker should be reminded of their potential role as hubs for pathogens because of their proximity to and regular interaction with infected patients. On the other hand, this study has shown that while healthcare workers acted as epidemic attenuators, hospitalized patients played the role of an epidemic amplifier

Statistical model checker for Epidemics Progression on Complex Network

In this thesis uses the susceptible-infected-recovered (SIR) model to show how the epi-demic spread over the complex network, which can be used for the early prediction for epidemic spread, so we can determine the proper cause of the action. The propagation of epidemics on a small-world network with and without immunization has been shown. Immunization helps to control the outbreaks of the epidemics. Our approach is to using the modeling the SIR model with Discrete event simulation which is one way to simulate the complex systems, which allows us to ask the interesting queries regarding how the epidemics spread over the time, at what time will be the peak time for spread and many more. In this work we uses the one of java lib. i.e. Graph Stream for our purpose to generate the small world network and we have also uses MultiVesta tool which is a Statical model checker tool. This work can be use in application of modeling the human disease as well as modeling the computer malware because it has similarity with spreading the human disease as the computer viruses

Epidemic processes in complex networks

In recent years the research community has accumulated overwhelming evidence for the emergence of complex and heterogeneous connectivity patterns in a wide range of biological and sociotechnical systems. The complex properties of real-world networks have a profound impact on the behavior of equilibrium and nonequilibrium phenomena occurring in various systems, and the study of epidemic spreading is central to our understanding of the unfolding of dynamical processes in complex networks. The theoretical analysis of epidemic spreading in heterogeneous networks requires the development of novel analytical frameworks, and it has produced results of conceptual and practical relevance. A coherent and comprehensive review of the vast research activity concerning epidemic processes is presented, detailing the successful theoretical approaches as well as making their limits and assumptions clear. Physicists, mathematicians, epidemiologists, computer, and social scientists share a common interest in studying epidemic spreading and rely on similar models for the description of the diffusion of pathogens, knowledge, and innovation. For this reason, while focusing on the main results and the paradigmatic models in infectious disease modeling, the major results concerning generalized social contagion processes are also presented. Finally, the research activity at the forefront in the study of epidemic spreading in coevolving, coupled, and time-varying networks is reported.Comment: 62 pages, 15 figures, final versio

Epidemics on dynamic networks

In many populations, the patterns of potentially infectious contacts are transients that can be described as a network with dynamic links. The relative timescales of link and contagion dynamics and the characteristics that drive their tempos can lead to important differences to the static case. Here, we propose some essential nomenclature for their analysis, and then review the relevant literature. We describe recent advances in they apply to infection processes, considering all of the methods used to record, measure and analyse them, and their implications for disease transmission. Finally, we outline some key challenges and opportunities in the field. Keywords: Social network analysis, Disease models, Network metrics, Network dat

Unlinking super-linkers : the topology of epidemic response (Covid-19)

A key characteristic of the spread of infectious diseases is their ability to use efficient transmission paths within contact graphs. This enables the pathogen to maximise infection rates and spread within a target population. In this work, we devise techniques to localise infections and decrease infection rates based on a principled analysis of disease transmission paths within human-contact networks (proximity graphs). Experimental results of disease transmission confirms that contact tracing requires both significant visibility (at least 60\%) into the proximity graph and the ability to place half of the population under isolation, in order to stop the disease. We find that pro-actively isolating super-links -- key proximity encounters -- has significant benefits -- targeted isolation of a fourth of the population based on 35\% visibility into the proximity graph prevents an epidemic outbreak. It turns out that isolating super-spreaders is more effective than contact tracing and testing but less effective than targeting super-links. We highlight the important role of topology in epidemic outbreaks. We argue that proactive innoculation of a population by disabling super-links and super-spreaders may have an important complimentary role alongside contact tracing and testing as part of a sophisticated public-health response to epidemic outbreaks

Disruption and disease: How does population management affect disease risk in wild bird populations?

Despite the ubiquity of wildlife management, from reintroductions and supplemental feeding to culling and habitat destruction, very little is known of the effects of management practices on species’ social dynamics. Species’ social structure has the potential to affect not only behaviour and evolution but also the transmission of information or disease. Understanding the effects of population management on social behaviour and organisation is a key step in understanding these species’ ecology. This thesis examines the differences between individuals’ roles in the social structure and what this means for the transmission of disease. It demonstrates how similarity in movement behaviour scales with increasing social circles, how seasonality in movement and seasonality in association rates covary as well as detailing post-cull behavioural changes. It finds that there is the potential for certain individuals (most likely non-breeding individuals) to transmit infection far and wide. It reveals the similarities in movement behaviour and body condition that birds share with their pair and social group. It emphasises the importance of autumn and winter movement in the transmission of infectious disease and it follows the short- and long-term changes in social structure and movement behaviour following a cull. Cull survivors were observed to retain a higher proportion of associations with their previous associates and moved less far in the year following the cull than in the year preceding it. This is the first application of social network analysis to quantify social structure before and after culling. The findings suggest that culling an infected population may facilitate rather than constrain the transmission of disease

An Agent-Based Modeling Approach to Reducing Pathogenic Transmission in Medical Facilities and Community Populations

The spread of infectious diseases is a significant and ongoing problem in human populations. In hospitals, the cost of patients acquiring infections causes many downstream effects, including longer lengths of stay for patients, higher costs, and unexpected fatalities. Outbreaks in community populations cause more significant problems because they stress the medical facilities that need to accommodate large numbers of infected patients, and they can lead to the closing of schools and businesses. In addition, epidemics often require logistical considerations such as where to locate clinics or how to optimize the distribution of vaccinations and food supplies. Traditionally, mathematical modeling is used to explore transmission dynamics and evaluate potential infection control measures. This methodology, although simple to implement and computationally efficient, has several shortcomings that prevent it from adequately representing some of the most critical aspects of disease transmission. Specifically, mathematical modeling can only represent groups of individuals in a homogenous manner and cannot model how transmission is affected by the behavior of individuals and the structure of their interactions. Agent-based modeling and social network analysis are two increasingly popular methods that are well-suited to modeling the spread of infectious diseases. Together, they can be used to model individuals with unique characteristics, behavior, and levels of interaction with other individuals. These advantages enable a more realistic representation of transmission dynamics and a much greater ability to provide insight to questions of interest for infection control practitioners. This dissertation presents several agent-based models and network models of the transmission of infectious diseases at scales ranging from hospitals to networks of medical facilities and community populations. By employing these methods, we can explore how the behavior of individual healthcare workers and the structure of a network of patients or healthcare facilities can affect the rate and extent of hospital-acquired infections. After the transmission dynamics are properly characterized, we can then attempt to differentiate between different types of transmission and assess the effectiveness of infection control measures