A data-oriented network architecture

In the 25 years since becoming commercially available, the Internet has grown into a global communication infrastructure connecting a significant part of mankind and has become an important part of modern society. Its impressive growth has been fostered by innovative applications, many of which were completely unforeseen by the Internet's inventors. While fully acknowledging ingenuity and creativity of application designers, it is equally impressive how little the core architecture of the Internet has evolved during this time. However, the ever evolving applications and growing importance of the Internet have resulted in increasing discordance between the Internet's current use and its original design. In this thesis, we focus on four sources of discomfort caused by this divergence. First, the Internet was developed around host-to-host applications, such as telnet and ftp, but the vast majority of its current usage is service access and data retrieval. Second, while the freedom to connect from any host to any other host was a major factor behind the success of the Internet, it provides little protection for connected hosts today. As a result, distributed denial of service attacks against Internet services have become a common nuisance, and are difficult to resolve within the current architecture. Third, Internet connectivity is becoming nearly ubiquitous and reaches increasingly often mobile devices. Moreover, connectivity is expected to extend its reach to even most extreme places. Hence, applications' view to network has changed radically; it's commonplace that they are offered intermittent connectivity at best and required to be smart enough to use heterogeneous network technologies. Finally, modern networks deploy so-called middleboxes both to improve performance and provide protection. However, when doing so, the middleboxes have to impose themselves between the communication end-points, which is against the design principles of the original Internet and a source of complications both for the management of networks and design of application protocols. In this thesis, we design a clean-slate network architecture that is a better fit with the current use of the Internet. We present a name resolution system based on name-based routing. It matches with the service access and data retrieval oriented usage of the Internet, and takes the network imposed middleboxes properly into account. We then propose modest addressing-related changes to the network layer as a remedy for the denial of service attacks. Finally, we take steps towards a data-oriented communications API that provides better decoupling for applications from the network stack than the original Sockets API does. The improved decoupling both simplifies applications and allows them to be unaffected by evolving network technologies: in this architecture, coping with intermittent connectivity and heterogenous network technologies is a burden of the network stack

Distributed Internet security and measurement

The Internet has developed into an important economic, military, academic, and social resource. It is a complex network, comprised of tens of thousands of independently operated networks, called Autonomous Systems (ASes). A significant strength of the Internet\u27s design, one which enabled its rapid growth in terms of users and bandwidth, is that its underlying protocols (such as IP, TCP, and BGP) are distributed. Users and networks alike can attach and detach from the Internet at will, without causing major disruptions to global Internet connectivity. This dissertation shows that the Internet\u27s distributed, and often redundant structure, can be exploited to increase the security of its protocols, particularly BGP (the Internet\u27s interdomain routing protocol). It introduces Pretty Good BGP, an anomaly detection protocol coupled with an automated response that can protect individual networks from BGP attacks. It also presents statistical measurements of the Internet\u27s structure and uses them to create a model of Internet growth. This work could be used, for instance, to test upcoming routing protocols on ensemble of large, Internet-like graphs. Finally, this dissertation shows that while the Internet is designed to be agnostic to political influence, it is actually quite centralized at the country level. With the recent rise in country-level Internet policies, such as nation-wide censorship and warrantless wiretaps, this centralized control could have significant impact on international reachability

A Brave New World: Studies on the Deployment and Security of the Emerging IPv6 Internet.

Recent IPv4 address exhaustion events are ushering in a new era of rapid transition to the next generation Internet protocol---IPv6. Via Internet-scale experiments and data analysis, this dissertation characterizes the adoption and security of the emerging IPv6 network. The work includes three studies, each the largest of its kind, examining various facets of the new network protocol's deployment, routing maturity, and security. The first study provides an analysis of ten years of IPv6 deployment data, including quantifying twelve metrics across ten global-scale datasets, and affording a holistic understanding of the state and recent progress of the IPv6 transition. Based on cross-dataset analysis of relative global adoption rates and across features of the protocol, we find evidence of a marked shift in the pace and nature of adoption in recent years and observe that higher-level metrics of adoption lag lower-level metrics. Next, a network telescope study covering the IPv6 address space of the majority of allocated networks provides insight into the early state of IPv6 routing. Our analyses suggest that routing of average IPv6 prefixes is less stable than that of IPv4. This instability is responsible for the majority of the captured misdirected IPv6 traffic. Observed dark (unallocated destination) IPv6 traffic shows substantial differences from the unwanted traffic seen in IPv4---in both character and scale. Finally, a third study examines the state of IPv6 network security policy. We tested a sample of 25 thousand routers and 520 thousand servers against sets of TCP and UDP ports commonly targeted by attackers. We found systemic discrepancies between intended security policy---as codified in IPv4---and deployed IPv6 policy. Such lapses in ensuring that the IPv6 network is properly managed and secured are leaving thousands of important devices more vulnerable to attack than before IPv6 was enabled. Taken together, findings from our three studies suggest that IPv6 has reached a level and pace of adoption, and shows patterns of use, that indicates serious production employment of the protocol on a broad scale. However, weaker IPv6 routing and security are evident, and these are leaving early dual-stack networks less robust than the IPv4 networks they augment.PhDComputer Science and EngineeringUniversity of Michigan, Horace H. Rackham School of Graduate Studieshttp://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/bitstream/2027.42/120689/1/jczyz_1.pd

An investigation to cybersecurity countermeasures for global internet infrastructure.

The Internet is comprised of entities. These entities are called Autonomous Systems (ASes). Each one of these ASes is managed by an Internet Service Provider (ISP). In return each group of ISPs are managed by Regional Internet Registry (RIR). Finally, all RIRs are managed by Internet Assigned Number Authority (IANA). The different ASes are globally connected via the inter-domain protocol that is Border Gateway Protocol (BGP). BGP was designed to be scalable to handle the massive Internet traffic; however, it has been studied for improvements for its lack of security. Furthermore, it relies on Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) which, in return, makes BGP vulnerable to whatever attacks TCP is vulnerable to. Thus, many researchers have worked on developing proposals for improving BGP security, due to the fact that it is the only external protocol connecting the ASes around the globe. In this thesis, different security proposals are reviewed and discussed for their merits and drawbacks. With the aid of Artificial Immune Systems (AIS), the research reported in this thesis addresses Man-In-The-Middle (MITM) and message replay attacks. Other attacks are discussed regarding the benefits of using AIS to support BGP; however, the focus is on MITM and message replay attacks. This thesis reports on the evaluation of a novel Hybrid AIS model compared with existing methods of securing BGP such as S-BGP and BGPsec as well as the traditional Negative Selection AIS algorithm. The results demonstrate improved precision of detecting attacks for the Hybrid AIS model compared with the Negative Selection AIS. Higher precision was achieved with S-BGP and BGPsec, however, at the cost of higher end-to-end delays. The high precision shown in the collected results for S-BGP and BGPsec is largely due to S-BGP encrypting the data by using public key infrastructure, while BGPsec utilises IPsec security suit to encapsulate the exchanged BGP packets. Therefore, neither of the two methods (S-BGP and BGPsec) are considered as Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS). Furthermore, S-BGP and BGPsec lack in the decision making and require administrative attention to mitigate an intrusion or cyberattack. While on the other hand, the suggested Hybrid AIS can remap the network topology depending on the need and optimise the path to the destination

A pragmatic approach toward securing inter-domain routing

Internet security poses complex challenges at different levels, where even the basic requirement of availability of Internet connectivity becomes a conundrum sometimes. Recent Internet service disruption events have made the vulnerability of the Internet apparent, and exposed the current limitations of Internet security measures as well. Usually, the main cause of such incidents, even in the presence of the security measures proposed so far, is the unintended or intended exploitation of the loop holes in the protocols that govern the Internet. In this thesis, we focus on the security of two different protocols that were conceived with little or no security mechanisms but play a key role both in the present and the future of the Internet, namely the Border Gateway Protocol (BGP) and the Locator Identifier Separation Protocol (LISP). The BGP protocol, being the de-facto inter-domain routing protocol in the Internet, plays a crucial role in current communications. Due to lack of any intrinsic security mechanism, it is prone to a number of vulnerabilities that can result in partial paralysis of the Internet. In light of this, numerous security strategies were proposed but none of them were pragmatic enough to be widely accepted and only minor security tweaks have found the pathway to be adopted. Even the recent IETF Secure Inter-Domain Routing (SIDR) Working Group (WG) efforts including, the Resource Public Key Infrastructure (RPKI), Route Origin authorizations (ROAs), and BGP Security (BGPSEC) do not address the policy related security issues, such as Route Leaks (RL). Route leaks occur due to violation of the export routing policies among the Autonomous Systems (ASes). Route leaks not only have the potential to cause large scale Internet service disruptions but can result in traffic hijacking as well. In this part of the thesis, we examine the route leak problem and propose pragmatic security methodologies which a) require no changes to the BGP protocol, b) are neither dependent on third party information nor on third party security infrastructure, and c) are self-beneficial regardless of their adoption by other players. Our main contributions in this part of the thesis include a) a theoretical framework, which, under realistic assumptions, enables a domain to autonomously determine if a particular received route advertisement corresponds to a route leak, and b) three incremental detection techniques, namely Cross-Path (CP), Benign Fool Back (BFB), and Reverse Benign Fool Back (R-BFB). Our strength resides in the fact that these detection techniques solely require the analytical usage of in-house control-plane, data-plane and direct neighbor relationships information. We evaluate the performance of the three proposed route leak detection techniques both through real-time experiments as well as using simulations at large scale. Our results show that the proposed detection techniques achieve high success rates for countering route leaks in different scenarios. The motivation behind LISP protocol has shifted over time from solving routing scalability issues in the core Internet to a set of vital use cases for which LISP stands as a technology enabler. The IETF's LISP WG has recently started to work toward securing LISP, but the protocol still lacks end-to-end mechanisms for securing the overall registration process on the mapping system ensuring RLOC authorization and EID authorization. As a result LISP is unprotected against different attacks, such as RLOC spoofing, which can cripple even its basic functionality. For that purpose, in this part of the thesis we address the above mentioned issues and propose practical solutions that counter them. Our solutions take advantage of the low technological inertia of the LISP protocol. The changes proposed for the LISP protocol and the utilization of existing security infrastructure in our solutions enable resource authorizations and lay the foundation for the needed end-to-end security

Optimization of BGP Convergence and Prefix Security in IP/MPLS Networks

Multi-Protocol Label Switching-based networks are the backbone of the operation of the Internet, that communicates through the use of the Border Gateway Protocol which connects distinct networks, referred to as Autonomous Systems, together. As the technology matures, so does the challenges caused by the extreme growth rate of the Internet. The amount of BGP prefixes required to facilitate such an increase in connectivity introduces multiple new critical issues, such as with the scalability and the security of the aforementioned Border Gateway Protocol. Illustration of an implementation of an IP/MPLS core transmission network is formed through the introduction of the four main pillars of an Autonomous System: Multi-Protocol Label Switching, Border Gateway Protocol, Open Shortest Path First and the Resource Reservation Protocol. The symbiosis of these technologies is used to introduce the practicalities of operating an IP/MPLS-based ISP network with traffic engineering and fault-resilience at heart. The first research objective of this thesis is to determine whether the deployment of a new BGP feature, which is referred to as BGP Prefix Independent Convergence (PIC), within AS16086 would be a worthwhile endeavour. This BGP extension aims to reduce the convergence delay of BGP Prefixes inside of an IP/MPLS Core Transmission Network, thus improving the networks resilience against faults. Simultaneously, the second research objective was to research the available mechanisms considering the protection of BGP Prefixes, such as with the implementation of the Resource Public Key Infrastructure and the Artemis BGP Monitor for proactive and reactive security of BGP prefixes within AS16086. The future prospective deployment of BGPsec is discussed to form an outlook to the future of IP/MPLS network design. As the trust-based nature of BGP as a protocol has become a distinct vulnerability, thus necessitating the use of various technologies to secure the communications between the Autonomous Systems that form the network to end all networks, the Internet

Improving Anycast with Measurements

Since the first Distributed Denial-of-Service (DDoS) attacks were launched, the strength of such attacks has been steadily increasing, from a few megabits per second to well into the terabit/s range. The damage that these attacks cause, mostly in terms of financial cost, has prompted researchers and operators alike to investigate and implement mitigation strategies. Examples of such strategies include local filtering appliances, Border Gateway Protocol (BGP)-based blackholing and outsourced mitigation in the form of cloud-based DDoS protection providers. Some of these strategies are more suited towards high bandwidth DDoS attacks than others. For example, using a local filtering appliance means that all the attack traffic will still pass through the owner's network. This inherently limits the maximum capacity of such a device to the bandwidth that is available. BGP Blackholing does not have such limitations, but can, as a side-effect, cause service disruptions to end-users. A different strategy, that has not attracted much attention in academia, is based on anycast. Anycast is a technique that allows operators to replicate their service across different physical locations, while keeping that service addressable with just a single IP-address. It relies on the BGP to effectively load balance users. In practice, it is combined with other mitigation strategies to allow those to scale up. Operators can use anycast to scale their mitigation capacity horizontally. Because anycast relies on BGP, and therefore in essence on the Internet itself, it can be difficult for network engineers to fine tune this balancing behavior. In this thesis, we show that that is indeed the case through two different case studies. In the first, we focus on an anycast service during normal operations, namely the Google Public DNS, and show that the routing within this service is far from optimal, for example in terms of distance between the client and the server. In the second case study, we observe the root DNS, while it is under attack, and show that even though in aggregate the bandwidth available to this service exceeds the attack we observed, clients still experienced service degradation. This degradation was caused due to the fact that some sites of the anycast service received a much higher share of traffic than others. In order for operators to improve their anycast networks, and optimize it in terms of resilience against DDoS attacks, a method to assess the actual state of such a network is required. Existing methodologies typically rely on external vantage points, such as those provided by RIPE Atlas, and are therefore limited in scale, and inherently biased in terms of distribution. We propose a new measurement methodology, named Verfploeter, to assess the characteristics of anycast networks in terms of client to Point-of-Presence (PoP) mapping, i.e. the anycast catchment. This method does not rely on external vantage points, is free of bias and offers a much higher resolution than any previous method. We validated this methodology by deploying it on a testbed that was locally developed, as well as on the B root DNS. We showed that the increased \textit{resolution} of this methodology improved our ability to assess the impact of changes in the network configuration, when compared to previous methodologies. As final validation we implement Verfploeter on Cloudflare's global-scale anycast Content Delivery Network (CDN), which has almost 200 global Points-of-Presence and an aggregate bandwidth of 30 Tbit/s. Through three real-world use cases, we demonstrate the benefits of our methodology: Firstly, we show that changes that occur when withdrawing routes from certain PoPs can be accurately mapped, and that in certain cases the effect of taking down a combination of PoPs can be calculated from individual measurements. Secondly, we show that Verfploeter largely reinstates the ping to its former glory, showing how it can be used to troubleshoot network connectivity issues in an anycast context. Thirdly, we demonstrate how accurate anycast catchment maps offer operators a new and highly accurate tool to identify and filter spoofed traffic. Where possible, we make datasets collected over the course of the research in this thesis available as open access data. The two best (open) dataset awards that were awarded for these datasets confirm that they are a valued contribution. In summary, we have investigated two large anycast services and have shown that their deployments are not optimal. We developed a novel measurement methodology, that is free of bias and is able to obtain highly accurate anycast catchment mappings. By implementing this methodology and deploying it on a global-scale anycast network we show that our method adds significant value to the fast-growing anycast CDN industry and enables new ways of detecting, filtering and mitigating DDoS attacks

Scale-free networks and scalable interdomain routing

Trabalho apresentado no âmbito do Mestrado em Engenharia Informática, como requisito parcial para obtenção do grau de Mestre em Engenharia InformáticaThe exponential growth of the Internet, due to its tremendous success, has brought to light some limitations of the current design at the routing and arquitectural level, such as scalability and convergence as well as the lack of support for traffic engineering, mobility, route differentiation and security. Some of these issues arise from the design of the current architecture, while others are caused by the interdomain routing scheme - BGP. Since it would be quite difficult to add support for the aforementioned issues, both in the interdomain architecture and in the in the routing scheme, various researchers believe that a solution can only achieved via a new architecture and (possibly) a new routing scheme. A new routing strategy has emerged from the studies regarding large-scale networks, which is suitable for a special type of large-scale networks which characteristics are independent of network size: scale-free networks. Using the greedy routing strategy a node routes a message to a given destination using only the information regarding the destination and its neighbours, choosing the one which is closest to the destination. This routing strategy ensures the following remarkable properties: routing state in the order of the number of neighbours; no requirements on nodes to exchange messages in order to perform routing; chosen paths are the shortest ones. This dissertation aims at: studying the aforementioned problems, studying the Internet configuration as a scale-free network, and defining a preliminary path onto the definition of a greedy routing scheme for interdomain routing

Improving the accuracy of spoofed traffic inference in inter-domain traffic

Ascertaining that a network will forward spoofed traffic usually requires an active probing vantage point in that network, effectively preventing a comprehensive view of this global Internet vulnerability. We argue that broader visibility into the spoofing problem may lie in the capability to infer lack of Source Address Validation (SAV) compliance from large, heavily aggregated Internet traffic data, such as traffic observable at Internet Exchange Points (IXPs). The key idea is to use IXPs as observatories to detect spoofed packets, by leveraging Autonomous System (AS) topology knowledge extracted from Border Gateway Protocol (BGP) data to infer which source addresses should legitimately appear across parts of the IXP switch fabric. In this thesis, we demonstrate that the existing literature does not capture several fundamental challenges to this approach, including noise in BGP data sources, heuristic AS relationship inference, and idiosyncrasies in IXP interconnec- tivity fabrics. We propose Spoofer-IX, a novel methodology to navigate these challenges, leveraging Customer Cone semantics of AS relationships to guide precise classification of inter-domain traffic as In-cone, Out-of-cone ( spoofed ), Unverifiable, Bogon, and Unas- signed. We apply our methodology on extensive data analysis using real traffic data from two distinct IXPs in Brazil, a mid-size and a large-size infrastructure. In the mid-size IXP with more than 200 members, we find an upper bound volume of Out-of-cone traffic to be more than an order of magnitude less than the previous method inferred on the same data, revealing the practical importance of Customer Cone semantics in such analysis. We also found no significant improvement in deployment of SAV in networks using the mid-size IXP between 2017 and 2019. In hopes that our methods and tools generalize to use by other IXPs who want to avoid use of their infrastructure for launching spoofed-source DoS attacks, we explore the feasibility of scaling the system to larger and more diverse IXP infrastructures. To promote this goal, and broad replicability of our results, we make the source code of Spoofer-IX publicly available. This thesis illustrates the subtleties of scientific assessments of operational Internet infrastructure, and the need for a community focus on reproducing and repeating previous methods.A constatação de que uma rede encaminhará tráfego falsificado geralmente requer um ponto de vantagem ativo de medição nessa rede, impedindo efetivamente uma visão abrangente dessa vulnerabilidade global da Internet. Isto posto, argumentamos que uma visibilidade mais ampla do problema de spoofing pode estar na capacidade de inferir a falta de conformidade com as práticas de Source Address Validation (SAV) a partir de dados de tráfego da Internet altamente agregados, como o tráfego observável nos Internet Exchange Points (IXPs). A ideia chave é usar IXPs como observatórios para detectar pacotes falsificados, aproveitando o conhecimento da topologia de sistemas autônomos extraído dos dados do protocolo BGP para inferir quais endereços de origem devem aparecer legitimamente nas comunicações através da infra-estrutura de um IXP. Nesta tese, demonstramos que a literatura existente não captura diversos desafios fundamentais para essa abordagem, incluindo ruído em fontes de dados BGP, inferência heurística de relacionamento de sistemas autônomos e características específicas de interconectividade nas infraestruturas de IXPs. Propomos o Spoofer-IX, uma nova metodologia para superar esses desafios, utilizando a semântica do Customer Cone de relacionamento de sistemas autônomos para guiar com precisão a classificação de tráfego inter-domínio como In-cone, Out-of-cone ( spoofed ), Unverifiable, Bogon, e Unassigned. Aplicamos nossa metodologia em análises extensivas sobre dados reais de tráfego de dois IXPs distintos no Brasil, uma infraestrutura de médio porte e outra de grande porte. No IXP de tamanho médio, com mais de 200 membros, encontramos um limite superior do volume de tráfego Out-of-cone uma ordem de magnitude menor que o método anterior inferiu sob os mesmos dados, revelando a importância prática da semântica do Customer Cone em tal análise. Além disso, não encontramos melhorias significativas na implantação do Source Address Validation (SAV) em redes usando o IXP de tamanho médio entre 2017 e 2019. Na esperança de que nossos métodos e ferramentas sejam aplicáveis para uso por outros IXPs que desejam evitar o uso de sua infraestrutura para iniciar ataques de negação de serviço através de pacotes de origem falsificada, exploramos a viabilidade de escalar o sistema para infraestruturas IXP maiores e mais diversas. Para promover esse objetivo e a ampla replicabilidade de nossos resultados, disponibilizamos publicamente o código fonte do Spoofer-IX. Esta tese ilustra as sutilezas das avaliações científicas da infraestrutura operacional da Internet e a necessidade de um foco da comunidade na reprodução e repetição de métodos anteriores