Handling of IP-Addresses in the Context of Remote Access

Masteroppgave i informasjons- og kommunikasjonsteknologi 2008 – Universitetet i Agder, GrimstadFor various reasons (e.g., security, lack of IPv4-addresses) the services in the home smart space only use private IP addresses. This is unfortunate in the remote service access since these addresses frequently appear in responses sent from a service in the remote smart space (e.g., your home) to the visited smart space (e.g., your friend’s home).The Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) provides some solutions and workarounds for the problem caused by NAT. In this project, the challenge to me is to summarize the available options, rank the options according to which one is preferred for the RA-scenario. I will come up with my practical NAT traversal techniques by testing and gathering data on the reliability of NAT traversal techniques since none of the existing ones seems to work well. A demonstration of the key features will be shown in the thesis. NAT traversal techniques apply to TCP and UDP need to be researched in advance. Handling of peers behind all kinds of NAT need to be tested and determined for the communication. The result of the paper will well improve the evaluation of specific issues on NAT and the creating of an UNSAF proposal

Host Identity Protocol-based Network Address Translator traversal in peer-to-peer environments

Osoitteenmuuntajat aiheuttavat ongelmia vertaisverkkojen yhteyksien luomiselle. Myös koneen identiteetti protokolla (HIP) kärsii osoitteenmuuntajien aiheuttamista ongelmista, mutta sopivilla laajennuksilla sitä voidaan käyttää yleisenä osoitteenmuuntajien läpäisymenetelmänä. Interaktiivinen yhteyden luominen (ICE) on tehokas osoitteenmuuntajien läpäisymenetelmä, joka toimii monissa erilaisissa tilanteissa. Tämän diplomityön tavoitteena on mahdollistaa HIP-pohjainen osoitteenmuuntajien läpäisy käyttämällä ICE-menetelmää, ja arvioida menetelmän toimivuutta implementoinnin ja mittausten avulla. Implementoimme ICE-prototyypin ja testasimme sitä eri tyyppisten osoitteenmuuntajien kanssa. Käytimme mittauksissa verkkoa, jossa kaksi isäntäkonetta olivat eri aliverkoissa, ja suoritimme ICE-yhteystestejä näiden koneiden välillä. Mittasimme testeissä lähetettyjen viestien ja tavujen määrän sekä käytetyn ajan. Mittaustulosten perusteella laskimme myös arvion ICE:n ja HIP:in aiheuttamalle ylimääräisten viestien ja ajankäytön määrälle. ICE onnistui luomaan yhteyden kaikissa testaamissamme tilanteissa, mutta käytti välillä enemmän viestejä ja aikaa kuin olisi tarpeen. Selvitimme työssä syyt ylimääräisille viesteille ja esitimme keinoja viestien määrän vähentämiselle. Saimme myös selville, että suuressa osassa tilanteista 4-5 yhteystestiviestiä riittää yhteyden luomiseksi, mutta tietynlaista osoitteenmuunnosta käyttävät osoitteenmuuntajat voivat helposti tuplata viestien määrän. Joka tapauksessa, yhteystestien luomat liikennemäärät ovat vähäisiä, ja käyttämällä lyhyempiä ajastinaikoja kuin mitä ICE spesifikaatio ehdottaa, voidaan ICE:n tehokkuutta kasvattaa merkittävästi. Käyttämällä HIP:iä ICE:n kanssa vertaisverkko-ohjelmat voivat saada käyttöönsä tehokkaan osoitteenmuuntajien läpäisymenetelmän, joka tukee myös yhteyden turvaominaisuuksia, mobiliteettia, sekä useita yhtäaikaisia verkkoliitäntöjä.Network Address Translators (NATs) cause problems when peer-to-peer (P2P) connections are created between hosts. Also the Host Identity Protocol (HIP) has problems traversing NATs but, with suitable extensions, it can be used as a generic NAT traversal solution. The Interactive Connectivity Establishment (ICE) is a robust NAT traversal mechanism that can enable connectivity in various NAT scenarios. The goal of this thesis is to enable HIP-based NAT traversal using ICE and to evaluate the applicability of the approach by implementation and measurements. We implemented an ICE prototype and tested it with different types of NATs. We used a network where two hosts were in different subnets and run ICE connectivity checks between them. The amount of messages and bytes sent during the process, and also how long the process took, was measured and analyzed. Based on the measurements, we calculated the overhead of using HIP with ICE for NAT traversal. ICE was able to create a connection in all the scenarios, but sometimes using more messages and longer time than expected or necessary. We found reasons why too many messages are exchanged and presented solutions on how some of these redundant messages could be avoided. We also found out that while 4-5 connectivity check messages are enough in many scenarios, NATs with specific address mapping behavior can easily double the amount of needed checks. Still, the generated traffic bitrate is modest, and using shorter timeout values than what the ICE specification suggests can have a significant positive impact on performance. By using HIP with ICE, P2P programs can get an efficient NAT traversal solution that additionally supports security, mobility and multihoming

A session-based architecture for Internet mobility

Thesis (Ph. D.)--Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dept. of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, February 2003.Includes bibliographical references (p. 179-189).The proliferation of mobile computing devices and wireless networking products over the past decade has led to an increasingly nomadic computing lifestyle. A computer is no longer an immobile, gargantuan machine that remains in one place for the lifetime of its operation. Today's personal computing devices are portable, and Internet access is becoming ubiquitous. A well-traveled laptop user might use half a dozen different networks throughout the course of a day: a cable modem from home, wide-area wireless on the commute, wired Ethernet at the office, a Bluetooth network in the car, and a wireless, local-area network at the airport or the neighborhood coffee shop. Mobile hosts are prone to frequent, unexpected disconnections that vary greatly in duration. Despite the prevalence of these multi-homed mobile devices, today's operating systems on both mobile hosts and fixed Internet servers lack fine-grained support for network applications on intermittently connected hosts. We argue that network communication is well-modeled by a session abstraction, and present Migrate, an architecture based on system support for a flexible session primitive. Migrate works with application-selected naming services to enable seamless, mobile "suspend/resume" operation of legacy applications and provide enhanced functionality for mobile-aware, session-based network applications, enabling adaptive operation of mobile clients and allowing Internet servers to support large numbers of intermittently connected sessions. We describe our UNIX-based implementation of Migrate and show that sessions are a flexible, robust, and efficient way to manage mobile end points, even for legacy applications.(cont.) In addition, we demonstrate two popular Internet servers that have been extended to leverage our novel notion of session continuations to enable support for large numbers of suspended clients with only minimal resource impact. Experimental results show that Migrate introduces only minor throughput degradation (less than 2% for moderate block sizes) when used over popular access link technologies, gracefully detects and suspends disconnected sessions, rapidly resumes from suspension, and integrates well with existing applications.by Mark Alexander Connell Snoeren.Ph.D