Force-Sensing-Based Multi-Platform Robotic Assistance for Vitreoretinal Surgery

Vitreoretinal surgery aims to treat disorders of the retina, vitreous body, and macula, such as retinal detachment, diabetic retinopathy, macular hole, epiretinal membrane and retinal vein occlusion. Challenged by several technical and human limitations, vitreoretinal practice currently ranks amongst the most demanding fields in ophthalmic surgery. Of vitreoretinal procedures, membrane peeling is the most common to be performed, over 0.5 million times annually, and among the most prone to complications. It requires an extremely delicate tissue manipulation by various micron scale maneuvers near the retina despite the physiological hand tremor of the operator. In addition, to avoid injuries, the applied forces on the retina need to be kept at a very fine level, which is often well below the tactile sensory threshold of the surgeon. Retinal vein cannulation is another demanding procedure where therapeutic agents are injected into occluded retinal veins. The feasibility of this treatment is limited due to challenges in identifying the moment of venous puncture, achieving cannulation and maintaining it throughout the drug delivery period. Recent advancements in medical robotics have significant potential to address most of the challenges in vitreoretinal practice, and therefore to prevent traumas, lessen complications, minimize intra-operative surgeon effort, maximize surgeon comfort, and promote patient safety. This dissertation presents the development of novel force-sensing tools that can easily be used on various robotic platforms, and robot control methods to produce integrated assistive surgical systems that work in partnership with surgeons against the current limitations in vitreoretinal surgery, specifically focusing on membrane peeling and vein cannulation procedures. Integrating high sensitivity force sensing into the ophthalmic instruments enables precise quantitative monitoring of applied forces. Auditory feedback based upon the measured forces can inform (and warn) the surgeon quickly during the surgery and help prevent injury due to excessive forces. Using these tools on a robotic platform can attenuate hand tremor of the surgeon, which effectively promotes tool manipulation accuracy. In addition, based upon certain force signatures, the robotic system can precisely identify critical instants, such as the venous puncture in retinal vein cannulation, and actively guide the tool towards clinical targets, compensate any involuntary motion of the surgeon, or generate additional motion that will make the surgical task easier. The experimental results using two distinct robotic platforms, the Steady-Hand Eye Robot and Micron, in combination with the force-sensing ophthalmic instruments, show significant performance improvement in artificial dry phantoms and ex vivo biological tissues

Doctor of Philosophy

dissertationIn this dissertation, we present methods for intuitive telemanipulation of manipulators that use piezoelectric stick-slip actuators (PSSAs). Commercial micro/nano-manipulators, which utilize PSSAs to achieve high precision over a large workspace, are typically controlled by a human operator at the joint level, leading to unintuitive and time-consuming telemanipulation. Prior work has considered the use of computer-vision-feedback to close a control loop for improved performance, but computer-vision-feedback is not a viable option for many end users. We discuss how open-loop models of the micro/nano-manipulator can be used to achieve desired end-effector movements, and we explain the process of obtaining open-loop models. We propose a rate-control telemanipulation method that utilizes the obtained model, and we experimentally quantify the effectiveness of the method using a common commercial manipulator (the Kleindiek MM3A). The utility of open-loop control methods for PSSAs with a human in the loop depends directly on the accuracy of the open-loop models of the manipulator. Prior research has shown that modeling of piezoelectric actuators is not a trivial task as they are known to suffer from nonlinearities that degrade their performance. We study the effect of static (non-inertial) loads on a prismatic and a rotary PSSA, and obtain a model relating the step size of the actuator to the load. The actuator-specific parameters of the model are calibrated by taking measurements in specific configurations of the manipulator. Results comparing the obtained model to experimental data are presented. PSSAs have properties that make them desirable over traditional DC-motor actuators for use in retinal surgery. We present a telemanipulation system for retinal surgery that uses a full range of existing disposable instruments. The system uses a PSSA-based manipulator that is compact and light enough that it could reasonably be made head-mounted to passively compensate for head movements. Two mechanisms are presented that enable the system to use existing disposable actuated instruments, and an instrument adapter enables quick-change of instruments during surgery. A custom stylus for a haptic interface enables intuitive and ergonomic telemanipulation of actuated instruments. Experimental results with a force-sensitive phantom eye show that telemanipulated surgery results in reduced forces on the retina compared to manual surgery, and training with the system results in improved performance. Finally, we evaluate operator efficiency with different haptic-interface kinematics for telemanipulated retinal surgery. Surgical procedures of the retina require precise manipulation of instruments inserted through trocars in the sclera. Telemanipulated robotic systems have been developed to improve retinal surgery, but there is not a unique mapping of the motions of the surgeon's hand to the lower-dimensional motions of the instrument through the trocar. We study operator performance during a precision positioning task on a force-sensing phantom retina, reminiscent of telemanipulated retinal surgery, with three common haptic-interface kinematics implemented in software on a PHANTOM Premium 6DOF haptic interface. Results from a study with 12 human subjects show that overall performance is best with the kinematics that represent a compact and inexpensive option, and that subjects' subjective preference agrees with the objective performance results

Augmentation Of Human Skill In Microsurgery

Surgeons performing highly skilled microsurgery tasks can benefit from information and manual assistance to overcome technological and physiological limitations to make surgery safer, efficient, and more successful. Vitreoretinal surgery is particularly difficult due to inherent micro-scale and fragility of human eye anatomy. Additionally, surgeons are challenged by physiological hand tremor, poor visualization, lack of force sensing, and significant cognitive load while executing high-risk procedures inside the eye, such as epiretinal membrane peeling. This dissertation presents the architecture and the design principles for a surgical augmentation environment which is used to develop innovative functionality to address the fundamental limitations in vitreoretinal surgery. It is an inherently information driven modular system incorporating robotics, sensors, and multimedia components. The integrated nature of the system is leveraged to create intuitive and relevant human-machine interfaces and generate a particular system behavior to provide active physical assistance and present relevant sensory information to the surgeon. These include basic manipulation assistance, audio-visual and haptic feedback, intraoperative imaging and force sensing. The resulting functionality, and the proposed architecture and design methods generalize to other microsurgical procedures. The system's performance is demonstrated and evaluated using phantoms and in vivo experiments

Optical Coherence Tomography Distal Sensor Based Handheld Microsurgical Tools

Microsurgery is typically differentiated from a general surgery in that it requires a precise sub-millimeter manipulation that could only be achievable under optical magnification. For instance, microsurgeons use surgical microscopes to view surgical sites and train themselves several years to acquire surgical skills to perform the delicate procedures. However, such microsurgical approach imposes considerable physical stress and mental fatigue on the surgeons and these could be sources for surgical risks and complications. For these reasons, a variety of robotic based surgical guidance methods have been developed and studied with the hope of providing safer and more precise microsurgery. These robotic arm based systems have been developed to provide precise tool movement and to remove physiological hand tremor, which is one of the main limiting factors that prevents precise tool manipulation. In another approaches use simpler system that adds robotic functions to existing handheld surgical tools. It is a hybrid system that incorporates the advantages of conventional manual system and robot-assist system. The advantages of such hybrid handheld systems include portability, disposability, and elimination of the large robotic-assist systems in complex surgical environment. The most critical benefit of the hybrid handheld system is its ease of use since it allows surgeons to manipulate tools mostly using their hand. However due to the imprecise nature of tool control using hands, tool tracking is more critical in handheld microsurgical tool systems than that of robotic arm systems. In general, the accuracy of the tool control is largely determined by the resolution of the sensors and the actuators. Therefore, it is essential to develop a real-time high resolution sensor in order to develop a practical microsurgical tools. For this reason, a novel intuitive targeting and tracking scheme that utilizes a common-path swept source optical coherence tomography (CP-SSOCT) distal sensor was developed integrated with handheld microsurgical tools. To achieve micron-order precision control, a reliable and accurate OCT distal sensing method was developed. The method uses a prediction algorithm is necessary to compensate for the system delay associated with the computational, mechanical and electronic latencies. Due to the multi-layered structure of retina, it was also necessary to develop effective surface detection methods rather than simple peak detection. The OCT distal sensor was integrated into handheld motion-guided micro-forceps system for highly accurate depth controlled epiretinal membranectomy. A touch sensor and two motors were used in the forceps design to minimize the motion artifact induced by squeezing, and to independently control the depth guidance of the tool-tip and the grasping action. We also built a depth guided micro-injector system that enables micro-injection with precise injection depth control. For these applications, a smart motion monitoring and a guiding algorithm were developed to provide precise and intuitive freehand control. Finally, phantom and ex-vivo bovine eye experiments were performed to evaluate the performance of the proposed OCT distal sensor and validate the effectiveness of the depth-guided micro-forceps and micro-injector over the freehand performance

Control and Estimation Methods Towards Safe Robot-assisted Eye Surgery

Vitreoretinal surgery is among the most delicate surgical tasks in which physiological hand tremor may severely diminish surgeon performance and put the eye at high risk of injury. Unerring targeting accuracy is required to perform precise operations on micro-scale tissues. Tool tip to tissue interaction forces are usually below human tactile perception, which may result in exertion of excessive forces to the retinal tissue leading to irreversible damages. Notable challenges during retinal surgery lend themselves to robotic assistance which has proven beneficial in providing a safe steady-hand manipulation. Efficient assistance from the robots heavily relies on accurate sensing and intelligent control algorithms of important surgery states and situations (e.g. instrument tip position measurements and control of interaction forces). This dissertation provides novel control and state estimation methods to improve safety during robot-assisted eye surgery. The integration of robotics into retinal microsurgery leads to a reduction in surgeon perception of tool-to-tissue forces at sclera. This blunting of human tactile sensory input, which is due to the inflexible inertia of the robot, is a potential iatrogenic risk during robotic eye surgery. To address this issue, a sensorized surgical instrument equipped with Fiber Bragg Grating (FBG) sensors, which is capable of measuring the sclera forces and instrument insertion depth into the eye, is integrated to the Steady-Hand Eye Robot (SHER). An adaptive control scheme is then customized and implemented on the robot that is intended to autonomously mitigate the risk of unsafe scleral forces and excessive insertion of the instrument. Various preliminary and multi-user clinician studies are then conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of the control method during mock retinal surgery procedures. In addition, due to inherent flexibility and the resulting deflection of eye surgical instruments as well as the need for targeting accuracy, we have developed a method to enhance deflected instrument tip position estimation. Using an iterative method and microscope data, we develop a calibration- and registration-independent (RI) framework to provide online estimates of the instrument stiffness (least squares and adaptive). The estimations are then combined with a state-space model for tip position evolution obtained based on the forward kinematics (FWK) of the robot and FBG sensor measurements. This is accomplished using a Kalman Filtering (KF) approach to improve the instrument tip position estimation during robotic surgery. The entire framework is independent of camera-to-robot coordinate frame registration and is evaluated during various phantom experiments to demonstrate its effectiveness

Fiber bragg gratings for medical applications and future challenges: A review

In the last decades, fiber Bragg gratings (FBGs) have become increasingly attractive to medical applications due to their unique properties such as small size, biocompatibility, immunity to electromagnetic interferences, high sensitivity and multiplexing capability. FBGs have been employed in the development of surgical tools, assistive devices, wearables, and biosensors, showing great potentialities for medical uses. This paper reviews the FBG-based measuring systems, their principle of work, and their applications in medicine and healthcare. Particular attention is given to sensing solutions for biomechanics, minimally invasive surgery, physiological monitoring, and medical biosensing. Strengths, weaknesses, open challenges, and future trends are also discussed to highlight how FBGs can meet the demands of next-generation medical devices and healthcare system

The Hand-Held Force Magnifier: Surgical Tools to Augment the Sense of Touch

Modern surgeons routinely perform procedures with noisy, sub-threshold, or obscured visual and haptic feedback,either due to the necessary approach, or because the systems on which they are operating are exceeding delicate. For example, in cataract extraction, ophthalmic surgeons must peel away thin membranes in order to access and replace the lens of the eye. Elsewhere, dissection is now commonly performed with energy-delivering tools – rather than sharp blades – and damage to deep structures is possible if tissue contact is not well controlled. Surgeons compensate for their lack of tactile sensibility by relying solely on visual feedback, observing tissue deformation and other visual cues through surgical microscopes or cameras. Using visual information alone can make a procedure more difficult, because cognitive mediation is required to convert visual feedback into motor action. We call this the “haptic problem” in surgery because the human sensorimotor loop is deprived of critical tactile afferent information, increasing the chance for intraoperative injury and requiring extensive training before clinicians reach independent proficiency. Tools that enhance the surgeon’s direct perception of tool-tissue forces can therefore potentially reduce the risk of iatrogenic complications and improve patient outcomes. Towards this end, we have developed and characterized a new robotic surgical tool, the Hand-Held Force Magnifier (HHFM), which amplifies forces at the tool tip so they may be readily perceived by the user, a paradigm we call “in-situ” force feedback. In this dissertation, we describe the development of successive generations of HHFM prototypes, and the evaluation of a proposed human-in-the-loop control framework using the methods of psychophysics. Using these techniques, we have verified that our tool can reduce sensory perception thresholds, augmenting the user’s abilities beyond what is normally possible. Further, we have created models of human motor control in surgically relevant tasks such as membrane puncture, which have shown to be sensitive to push-pull direction and handedness effects. Force augmentation has also demonstrated improvements to force control in isometric force generation tasks. Finally, in support of future psychophysics work, we have developed an inexpensive, high-bandwidth, single axis haptic renderer using a commercial audio speaker

Fiber Bragg Gratings for Medical Applications and Future Challenges: A Review

[EN] In the last decades, fiber Bragg gratings (FBGs) have become increasingly attractive to medical applications due to their unique properties such as small size, biocompatibility, immunity to electromagnetic interferences, high sensitivity and multiplexing capability. FBGs have been employed in the development of surgical tools, assistive devices, wearables, and biosensors, showing great potentialities for medical uses. This paper reviews the FBG-based measuring systems, their principle of work, and their applications in medicine and healthcare. Particular attention is given to sensing solutions for biomechanics, minimally invasive surgery, physiological monitoring, and medical biosensing. Strengths, weaknesses, open challenges, and future trends are also discussed to highlight how FBGs can meet the demands of next-generation medical devices and healthcare system.This work was supported in part by INAIL (the Italian National Institute for Insurance against Accident at Work), through the BRIC (Bando ricerche in collaborazione) 2018 SENSE-RISC (Sviluppo di abiti intelligENti Sensorizzati per prevenzione e mitigazione di Rischi per la SiCurezza dei lavoratori) Project under Grant ID10/2018, in part by the UCBM (Universita Campus Bio-Medico di Roma) under the University Strategic HOPE (HOspital to the PatiEnt) Project, in part by the EU Framework Program H2020-FETPROACT-2018-01 NeuHeart Project under Grant GA 824071, by FCT/MEC (Fundacao para a Ciencia e Tecnologia) under the Projects UIDB/50008/2020 - UIDP/50008/2020, and by REACT (Development of optical fiber solutions for Rehabilitation and e-Health applications) FCT-IT-LA scientific action.Lo Presti, D.; Massaroni, C.; Leitao, CSJ.; Domingues, MDF.; Sypabekova, M.; Barrera, D.; Floris, I.... (2020). Fiber Bragg Gratings for Medical Applications and Future Challenges: A Review. IEEE Access. 8:156863-156888. https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2020.3019138S156863156888

Human eye phantom for developing computer and robot-assisted epiretinal membrane peeling

exterior, arcaded gate, 199