How a nonconvergent recovered Hessian works in mesh adaptation

Hessian recovery has been commonly used in mesh adaptation for obtaining the required magnitude and direction information of the solution error. Unfortunately, a recovered Hessian from a linear finite element approximation is nonconvergent in general as the mesh is refined. It has been observed numerically that adaptive meshes based on such a nonconvergent recovered Hessian can nevertheless lead to an optimal error in the finite element approximation. This also explains why Hessian recovery is still widely used despite its nonconvergence. In this paper we develop an error bound for the linear finite element solution of a general boundary value problem under a mild assumption on the closeness of the recovered Hessian to the exact one. Numerical results show that this closeness assumption is satisfied by the recovered Hessian obtained with commonly used Hessian recovery methods. Moreover, it is shown that the finite element error changes gradually with the closeness of the recovered Hessian. This provides an explanation on how a nonconvergent recovered Hessian works in mesh adaptation.Comment: Revised (improved proofs and a better example

A comparative numerical study of meshing functionals for variational mesh adaptation

We present a comparative numerical study for three functionals used for variational mesh adaptation. One of them is a generalisation of Winslow's variable diffusion functional while the others are based on equidistribution and alignment. These functionals are known to have nice theoretical properties and work well for most mesh adaptation problems either as a stand-alone variational method or combined within the moving mesh framework. Their performance is investigated numerically in terms of equidistribution and alignment mesh quality measures. Numerical results in 2D and 3D are presented.Comment: Additional example (H1), journal referenc

A comparative numerical study of meshing functionals for variational mesh adaptation

We present a comparative numerical study for three functionals used for variational mesh adaptation. One of them is a generalization of Winslow's variable diffusion functional while the others are based on equidistribution and alignment. These functionals are known to have nice theoretical properties and work well for most mesh adaptation problems either as a stand-alone variational method or combined within the moving mesh framework. Their performance is investigated numerically in terms of equidistribution and alignment mesh quality measures. Numerical results in 2D and 3D are presented

Unstructured Grid Adaptation: Status, Potential Impacts, and Recommended Investments Towards CFD 2030

International audienceUnstructured grid adaptation is a powerful tool to control Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) discretization error. It has enabled key increases in the accuracy, automation, and capacity of some fluid simulation applications. Slotnick et al. provide a number of case studies in the CFD Vision 2030 Study: A Path to Revolutionary Computational Aerosciences to illustrate the current state of CFD capability and capacity. The study authors forecast the potential impact of emerging High Performance Computing (HPC) environments forecast in the year 2030 and identify that mesh generation and adaptivity will continue to be significant bottlenecks in the CFD workflow. These bottlenecks may persist because very little government investment has been targeted in these areas. To motivate investment, the impacts of improved grid adaptation technologies are identified. The CFD Vision 2030 Study roadmap and anticipated capabilities in complementary disciplines are quoted to provide context for the progress made in grid adaptation in the past fifteen years, current status, and a forecast for the next fifteen years with recommended investments. These investments are specific to mesh adaptation and impact other aspects of the CFD process. Finally, a strategy is identified to di↵use grid adaptation technology into production CFD work flows

Polynomial Preserving Recovery For Weak Galerkin Methods And Their Applications

Gradient recovery technique is widely used to reconstruct a better numerical gradient from a finite element solution, for mesh smoothing, a posteriori error estimate and adaptive finite element methods. The PPR technique generates a higher order approximation of the gradient on a patch of mesh elements around each mesh vertex. It can be used for different finite element methods for different problems. This dissertation presents recovery techniques for the weak Galerkin methods and as well as applications of gradient recovery on various of problems, including elliptic problems, interface problems, and Stokes problems. Our first target is to develop a boundary strategy for the current PPR algorithm. The current accuracy of PPR near boundaries is not as good as that in the interior of the domain. It might be even worse than without recovery. Some special treatments are needed to improve the accuracy of PPR on the boundary. In this thesis, we present two boundary recovery strategies to resolve the problem caused by boundaries. Numerical experiments indicate that both of the newly proposed strategies made an improvement to the original PPR. Our second target is to generalize PPR to the weak Galerkin methods. Different from the standard finite element methods, the weak Galerkin methods use a different set of degrees of freedom. Instead of the weak gradient information, we are able to obtain the recovered gradient information for the numerical solution in the generalization of PPR. In the PPR process, we are also able to recover the function value at the nodal points which will produce a global continuous solution instead of piecewise continuous function. Our third target is to apply our proposed strategy and WGPPR to interface problems. We treat an interface as a boundary when performing gradient recovery, and the jump condition on the interface can be well captured by the function recovery process. In addition, adaptive methods based on WGPPR recovery type a posteriori error estimator is proposed and numerically tested in this thesis. Application on the elliptic problem and interface problem validate the effectiveness and robustness of our algorithm. Furthermore, WGPPR has been applied to 3D problem and Stokes problem as well. Superconvergent phenomenon is again observed

Recovery Techniques For Finite Element Methods And Their Applications

Recovery techniques are important post-processing methods to obtain improved approximate solutions from primary data with reasonable cost. The practical us- age of recovery techniques is not only to improve the quality of approximation, but also to provide an asymptotically exact posteriori error estimators for adaptive meth- ods. This dissertation presents recovery techniques for nonconforming finite element methods and high order derivative as well as applications of gradient recovery. Our first target is to develop a systematic gradient recovery technique for Crouzeix- Raviart element. The proposed method uses finite element solution to build a better approximation of the exact gradient based on local least square fittings. Due to poly- nomial preserving property of least square fitting, it is easy to show that the new proposed method preserves quadratic polynomials. In addition, the proposed gra- dient recovery is linearly bounded. Numerical tests indicate the recovered gradient is superconvergent to the exact gradient for both second order elliptic equation and Stokes equation. The gradient recovery technique can be used in a posteriori error estimates for Crouzeix-Raviart element, which is relatively simple to implement and problem independent. Our second target is to propose and analyze a new effective Hessian recovery for continuous finite element of arbitrary order. The proposed Hessian recovery is based on polynomial preserving recovery. The proposed method preserves polynomials of degree (k + 1) on general unstructured meshes and polynomials of degree (k + 2) on translation invariant meshes. Based on it polynomial preserving property, we can able to prove superconvergence of the proposed method on mildly structured meshes. In addition, we establish the ultraconvergence result for the new Hessian recovery technique on translation invariant finite element space of arbitrary order. Our third target is to demonstrate application of gradient recovery in eigenvalue computation. We propose two superconvergent two-grid methods for elliptic eigen- value problems by taking advantage of two-gird method, two-space method, shifted- inverse power method, and gradient recovery enhancement. Theoretical and numer- ical results reveal that the proposed methods provide superconvergent eigenfunction approximation and ultraconvergent eigenvalue approximation. In addition, two mul- tilevel adaptive methods based recovery type a posterior error estimate are proposed