Computing with cells: membrane systems - some complexity issues.

Membrane computing is a branch of natural computing which abstracts computing models from the structure and the functioning of the living cell. The main ingredients of membrane systems, called P systems, are (i) the membrane structure, which consists of a hierarchical arrangements of membranes which delimit compartments where (ii) multisets of symbols, called objects, evolve according to (iii) sets of rules which are localised and associated with compartments. By using the rules in a nondeterministic/deterministic maximally parallel manner, transitions between the system configurations can be obtained. A sequence of transitions is a computation of how the system is evolving. Various ways of controlling the transfer of objects from one membrane to another and applying the rules, as well as possibilities to dissolve, divide or create membranes have been studied. Membrane systems have a great potential for implementing massively concurrent systems in an efficient way that would allow us to solve currently intractable problems once future biotechnology gives way to a practical bio-realization. In this paper we survey some interesting and fundamental complexity issues such as universality vs. nonuniversality, determinism vs. nondeterminism, membrane and alphabet size hierarchies, characterizations of context-sensitive languages and other language classes and various notions of parallelism

Minimization Strategies for Maximally Parallel Multiset Rewriting Systems

Maximally parallel multiset rewriting systems (MPMRS) give a convenient way to express relations between unstructured objects. The functioning of various computational devices may be expressed in terms of MPMRS (e.g., register machines and many variants of P systems). In particular, this means that MPMRS are computationally complete; however, a direct translation leads to quite a big number of rules. Like for other classes of computationally complete devices, there is a challenge to find a universal system having the smallest number of rules. In this article we present different rule minimization strategies for MPMRS based on encodings and structural transformations. We apply these strategies to the translation of a small universal register machine (Korec, 1996) and we show that there exists a universal MPMRS with 23 rules. Since MPMRS are identical to a restricted variant of P systems with antiport rules, the results we obtained improve previously known results on the number of rules for those systems.Comment: This article is an improved version of [1

Further Remarks on Trace Languages in P Systems with Symport/Antiport

P systems are parallel molecular computing models which process multisets of objects in cell-like membrane structures. In this paper we consider the trace languages of a special symbol, the traveler, in symport/antiport P systems where, instead of multisets of objects, sets of objects were considered. Two different ways to define the trace language are proposed. One of the families of languages obtained in this way is proved to be equal to the family of regular languages and the other one to be strictly smaller. Some ideas for further research are also considered

The Computational Complexity of Tissue P Systems with Evolutional Symport/Antiport Rules

Tissue P systems with evolutional communication (symport/antiport) rules are computational models inspired by biochemical systems consisting of multiple individuals living and cooperating in a certain environment, where objects can be modified when moving from one region to another region. In this work, cell separation, inspired from membrane fission process, is introduced in the framework of tissue P systems with evolutional communication rules.The computational complexity of this kind of P systems is investigated. It is proved that only problems in class P can be efficiently solved by tissue P systems with cell separation with evolutional communication rules of length at most (��, 1), for each natural number �� ≥ 1. In the case where that length is upper bounded by (3, 2), a polynomial time solution to the SAT problem is provided, hence, assuming that P ̸= NP a new boundary between tractability and NP-hardness on the basis of the length of evolutional communication rules is provided. Finally, a new simulator for tissue P systems with evolutional communication rules is designed and is used to check the correctness of the solution to the SAT problem

Catalytic and communicating Petri nets are Turing complete

In most studies about the expressiveness of Petri nets, the focus has been put either on adding suitable arcs or on assuring that a complete snapshot of the system can be obtained. While the former still complies with the intuition on Petri nets, the second is somehow an orthogonal approach, as Petri nets are distributed in nature. Here, inspired by membrane computing, we study some classes of Petri nets where the distribution is partially kept and which are still Turing complete

Efficient simulation of tissue-like P systems by transition cell-like P systems

In the framework of P systems, it is known that the construction of exponential number of objects in polynomial time is not enough to efficiently solve NP-complete problems. Nonetheless, it could be sufficient to create an exponential number of membranes in polynomial time. Working with P systems whose membrane structure does not increase in size, it is known that it is not possible to solve computationally hard problems (unless P = NP), basically due to the impossibility of constructing exponential number of membranes, in polynomial time, using only evolution, communication and dissolution rules. In this paper we show how a family of recognizer tissue P systems with symport/ antiport rules which solves a decision problem can be efficiently simulated by a family of basic recognizer P systems solving the same problem. This simulation allows us to transfer the result about the limitations in computational power, from the model of basic cell-like P systems to this kind of tissue-like P systems.Ministerio de Educación y Ciencia TIN2006-13425Junta de Andalucía TIC-58

Communication in membrana Systems with symbol Objects.

Esta tesis está dedicada a los sistemas de membranas con objetos-símbolo como marco teórico de los sistemas paralelos y distribuidos de procesamiento de multiconjuntos.Una computación de parada puede aceptar, generar o procesar un número, un vector o una palabra; por tanto el sistema define globalmente (a través de los resultados de todas sus computaciones) un conjunto de números, de vectores, de palabras (es decir, un lenguaje), o bien una función. En esta tesis estudiamos la capacidad de estos sistemas para resolver problemas particulares, así como su potencia computacional. Por ejemplo, las familias de lenguajes definidas por diversas clases de estos sistemas se comparan con las familias clásicas, esto es, lenguajes regulares, independientes del contexto, generados por sistemas 0L tabulados extendidos, generados por gramáticas matriciales sin chequeo de apariciones, recursivamente enumerables, etc. Se prestará especial atención a la comunicación de objetos entre regiones y a las distintas formas de cooperación entre ellos.Se pretende (Sección 3.4) realizar una formalización los sistemas de membranas y construir una herramienta tipo software para la variante que usa cooperación no distribuida, el navegador de configuraciones, es decir, un simulador, en el cual el usuario selecciona la siguiente configuración entre todas las posibles, estando permitido volver hacia atrás. Se considerarán diversos modelos distribuidos. En el modelo de evolución y comunicación (Capítulo 4) separamos las reglas tipo-reescritura y las reglas de transporte (llamadas symport y antiport). Los sistemas de bombeo de protones (proton pumping, Secciones 4.8, 4.9) constituyen una variante de los sistemas de evolución y comunicación con un modo restrictivo de cooperación. Un modelo especial de computación con membranas es el modelo puramente comunicativo, en el cual los objetos traspasan juntos una membrana. Estudiamos la potencia computacional de las sistemas de membranas con symport/antiport de 2 o 3 objetos (Capítulo 5) y la potencia computacional de las sistemas de membranas con alfabeto limitado (Capítulo 6).El determinismo (Secciones 4.7, 5.5, etc.) es una característica especial (restrictiva) de los sistemas computacionales. Se pondrá especial énfasis en analizar si esta restricción reduce o no la potencia computacional de los mismos. Los resultados obtenidos para sistemas de bombeo del protones están transferidos (Sección 7.3) a sistemas con catalizadores bistabiles. Unos ejemplos de aplicación concreta de los sistemas de membranas (Secciones 7.1, 7.2) son la resolución de problemas NP-completos en tiempo polinomial y la resolución de problemas de ordenación.This thesis deals with membrane systems with symbol objects as a theoretical framework of distributed parallel multiset processing systems.A halting computation can accept, generate or process a number, a vector or a word, so the system globally defines (by the results of all its computations) a set of numbers or a set of vectors or a set of words, (i.e., a language), or a function. The ability of these systems to solve particular problems is investigated, as well as their computational power, e.g., the language families defined by different classes of these systems are compared to the classical ones, i.e., regular, context-free, languages generated by extended tabled 0L systems, languages generated by matrix grammars without appearance checking, recursively enumerable languages, etc. Special attention is paid to communication of objects between the regions and to the ways of cooperation between the objects.An attempt to formalize the membrane systems is made (Section 3.4), and a software tool is constructed for the non-distributed cooperative variant, the configuration browser, i.e., a simulator, where the user chooses the next configuration among the possible ones and can go back. Different distributed models are considered. In the evolution-communication model (Chapter 4) rewriting-like rules are separated from transport rules. Proton pumping systems (Sections 4.8, 4.9) are a variant of the evolution-communication systems with a restricted way of cooperation. A special membrane computing model is a purely communicative one: the objects are moved together through a membrane. We study the computational power of membrane systems with symport/antiport of 2 or 3 objects (Chapter 5) and the computational power of membrane systems with a limited alphabet (Chapter 6).Determinism (Sections 4.7, 5.5, etc.) is a special property of computational systems; the question of whether this restriction reduces the computational power is addressed. The results on proton pumping systems can be carried over (Section 7.3) to the systems with bi-stable catalysts. Some particular examples of membrane systems applications are solving NP-complete problems in polynomial time, and solving the sorting problem

On Promoters/Inhibitors and Symport/Antiport with Traces in P Systems

This article brings together some rather powerful results on P systems in which the computation is performed by the communication of objects through symport and antiport rules considering the trace of an object through membranes, on the one hand, and by P systems with object-rewriting non-cooperative rules, promoters/inhibitors at the level of rules and only one catalyst, on the other. It is recalled here that computational universality can be reached whit these formalisms and that some of the proofs can be sketched. Three ideas are also put forward to brake the direct relationship (infinite hierarchy) induced by the size of the considered alphabet and the number of the membranes needed in a P system (with traces) to generate recursively enumerable languages on the chosen alphabet

Bridging Membrane and Reaction Systems - Further Results and Research Topics

This paper continues an investigation into bridging two research areas con- cerned with natural computing: membrane computing and reaction systems. More specif- ically, the paper considers a transfer of two assumptions/axioms of reaction systems, non- permanency and the threshold assumption, into the framework of membrane computing. It is proved that: SN P systems with non-permanency of spikes assumption charac- terize the semilinear sets of numbers, and symport/antiport P systems with threshold assumption (translated as ! multiplicity of objects) can solve SAT in polynomial time. Also, several open research problems are stated.Junta de Andalucía P08 – TIC 0420