MPSoCBench : um framework para avaliação de ferramentas e metodologias para sistemas multiprocessados em chip

Orientador: Rodolfo Jardim de AzevedoTese (doutorado) - Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Instituto de ComputaçãoResumo: Recentes metodologias e ferramentas de projetos de sistemas multiprocessados em chip (MPSoC) aumentam a produtividade por meio da utilização de plataformas baseadas em simuladores, antes de definir os últimos detalhes da arquitetura. No entanto, a simulação só é eficiente quando utiliza ferramentas de modelagem que suportem a descrição do comportamento do sistema em um elevado nível de abstração. A escassez de plataformas virtuais de MPSoCs que integrem hardware e software escaláveis nos motivou a desenvolver o MPSoCBench, que consiste de um conjunto escalável de MPSoCs incluindo quatro modelos de processadores (PowerPC, MIPS, SPARC e ARM), organizado em plataformas com 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32 e 64 núcleos, cross-compiladores, IPs, interconexões, 17 aplicações paralelas e estimativa de consumo de energia para os principais componentes (processadores, roteadores, memória principal e caches). Uma importante demanda em projetos MPSoC é atender às restrições de consumo de energia o mais cedo possível. Considerando que o desempenho do processador está diretamente relacionado ao consumo, há um crescente interesse em explorar o trade-off entre consumo de energia e desempenho, tendo em conta o domínio da aplicação alvo. Técnicas de escalabilidade dinâmica de freqüência e voltagem fundamentam-se em gerenciar o nível de tensão e frequência da CPU, permitindo que o sistema alcance apenas o desempenho suficiente para processar a carga de trabalho, reduzindo, consequentemente, o consumo de energia. Para explorar a eficiência energética e desempenho, foram adicionados recursos ao MPSoCBench, visando explorar escalabilidade dinâmica de voltaegem e frequência (DVFS) e foram validados três mecanismos com base na estimativa dinâmica de energia e taxa de uso de CPUAbstract: Recent design methodologies and tools aim at enhancing the design productivity by providing a software development platform before the definition of the final Multiprocessor System on Chip (MPSoC) architecture details. However, simulation can only be efficiently performed when using a modeling and simulation engine that supports system behavior description at a high abstraction level. The lack of MPSoC virtual platform prototyping integrating both scalable hardware and software in order to create and evaluate new methodologies and tools motivated us to develop the MPSoCBench, a scalable set of MPSoCs including four different ISAs (PowerPC, MIPS, SPARC, and ARM) organized in platforms with 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 32, and 64 cores, cross-compilers, IPs, interconnections, 17 parallel version of software from well-known benchmarks, and power consumption estimation for main components (processors, routers, memory, and caches). An important demand in MPSoC designs is the addressing of energy consumption constraints as early as possible. Whereas processor performance comes with a high power cost, there is an increasing interest in exploring the trade-off between power and performance, taking into account the target application domain. Dynamic Voltage and Frequency Scaling techniques adaptively scale the voltage and frequency levels of the CPU allowing it to reach just enough performance to process the system workload while meeting throughput constraints, and thereby, reducing the energy consumption. To explore this wide design space for energy efficiency and performance, both for hardware and software components, we provided MPSoCBench features to explore dynamic voltage and frequency scalability (DVFS) and evaluated three mechanisms based on energy estimation and CPU usage rateDoutoradoCiência da ComputaçãoDoutora em Ciência da Computaçã

Combining FPGA prototyping and high-level simulation approaches for Design Space Exploration of MPSoCs

Modern embedded systems are parallel, component-based, heterogeneous and finely tuned on the basis of the workload that must be executed on them. To improve design reuse, Application Specific Instruction-set Processors (ASIPs) are often employed as building blocks in such systems, as a solution capable of satisfying the required functional and physical constraints (e.g. throughput, latency, power or energy consumption etc.), while providing, at the same time, high flexibility and adaptability. Composing a multi-processor architecture including ASIPs and mapping parallel applications onto it is a design activity that require an extensive Design Space Exploration process (DSE), to result in cost-effective systems. The work described here aims at defining novel methodologies for the application-driven customizations of such highly heterogeneous embedded systems. The issue is tackled at different levels, integrating different tools. High-level event-based simulation is a widely used technique that offers speed and flexibility as main points of strength, but needs, as a preliminary input and periodically during the iteration process, calibration data that must be acquired by means of more accurate evaluation methods. Typically, this calibration is performed using instruction-level cycleaccurate simulators that, however, turn out to be very slow, especially when complete multiprocessor systems must be evaluated or when the grain of the calibration is too fine, while FPGA approaches have shown to performbetter for this particular applications. FPGA-based emulation techniques have been proposed in the recent past as an alternative solution to the software-based simulation approach, but some further steps are needed before they can be effectively exploitedwithin architectural design space exploration. Firstly, some kind of technology-awareness must be introduced, to enable the translation of the emulation results into a pre-estimation of a prospective ASIC implementation of the design. Moreover, when performing architectural DSE, a significant number of different candidate design points has to be evaluated and compared. In this case, if no countermeasures are taken, the advantages achievable with FPGAs, in terms of emulation speed, are counterbalanced by the overhead introduced by the time needed to go through the physical synthesis and implementation flow. Developed FPGA-based prototyping platform overcomes such limitations, enabling the use of FPGA-based prototyping for micro-architectural design space exploration of ASIP processors. In this approach, to increase the emulation speed-up, two different methods are proposed: the first is based on automatic instantiation of additional hardware modules, able to reconfigure at runtime the prototype, while the second leverages manipulation of application binary code, compiled for a custom VLIW ASIP architecture, that is transformed into code executable on a different configuration. This allows to prototype a whole set of ASIP solutions after one single FPGA implementation flow, mitigating the afore-mentioned overhead.A short overview on the tools used throughout the work will also be offered, covering basic aspects of Intel-Silicon Hive ASIP development toolchain, SESAME framework general description, along with a review of state-of-art simulation and prototyping techniques for complex multi-processor systems. Each proposed approach will be validated through a real-world use case, confirming the validity of this solution

Combining FPGA prototyping and high-level simulation approaches for Design Space Exploration of MPSoCs

Modern embedded systems are parallel, component-based, heterogeneous and finely tuned on the basis of the workload that must be executed on them. To improve design reuse, Application Specific Instruction-set Processors (ASIPs) are often employed as building blocks in such systems, as a solution capable of satisfying the required functional and physical constraints (e.g. throughput, latency, power or energy consumption etc.), while providing, at the same time, high flexibility and adaptability. Composing a multi-processor architecture including ASIPs and mapping parallel applications onto it is a design activity that require an extensive Design Space Exploration process (DSE), to result in cost-effective systems. The work described here aims at defining novel methodologies for the application-driven customizations of such highly heterogeneous embedded systems. The issue is tackled at different levels, integrating different tools. High-level event-based simulation is a widely used technique that offers speed and flexibility as main points of strength, but needs, as a preliminary input and periodically during the iteration process, calibration data that must be acquired by means of more accurate evaluation methods. Typically, this calibration is performed using instruction-level cycleaccurate simulators that, however, turn out to be very slow, especially when complete multiprocessor systems must be evaluated or when the grain of the calibration is too fine, while FPGA approaches have shown to performbetter for this particular applications. FPGA-based emulation techniques have been proposed in the recent past as an alternative solution to the software-based simulation approach, but some further steps are needed before they can be effectively exploitedwithin architectural design space exploration. Firstly, some kind of technology-awareness must be introduced, to enable the translation of the emulation results into a pre-estimation of a prospective ASIC implementation of the design. Moreover, when performing architectural DSE, a significant number of different candidate design points has to be evaluated and compared. In this case, if no countermeasures are taken, the advantages achievable with FPGAs, in terms of emulation speed, are counterbalanced by the overhead introduced by the time needed to go through the physical synthesis and implementation flow. Developed FPGA-based prototyping platform overcomes such limitations, enabling the use of FPGA-based prototyping for micro-architectural design space exploration of ASIP processors. In this approach, to increase the emulation speed-up, two different methods are proposed: the first is based on automatic instantiation of additional hardware modules, able to reconfigure at runtime the prototype, while the second leverages manipulation of application binary code, compiled for a custom VLIW ASIP architecture, that is transformed into code executable on a different configuration. This allows to prototype a whole set of ASIP solutions after one single FPGA implementation flow, mitigating the afore-mentioned overhead.A short overview on the tools used throughout the work will also be offered, covering basic aspects of Intel-Silicon Hive ASIP development toolchain, SESAME framework general description, along with a review of state-of-art simulation and prototyping techniques for complex multi-processor systems. Each proposed approach will be validated through a real-world use case, confirming the validity of this solution

Performance Estimation of Task Graphs Based on Path Profiling

Correctly estimating the speed-up of a parallel embedded application is crucial to efficiently compare different parallelization techniques, task graph transformations or mapping and scheduling solutions. Unfortunately, especially in case of control-dominated applications, task correlations may heavily affect the execution time of the solutions and usually this is not properly taken into account during performance analysis. We propose a methodology that combines a single profiling of the initial sequential specification with different decisions in terms of partitioning, mapping, and scheduling in order to better estimate the actual speed-up of these solutions. We validated our approach on a multi-processor simulation platform: experimental results show that our methodology, effectively identifying the correlations among tasks, significantly outperforms existing approaches for speed-up estimation. Indeed, we obtained an absolute error less than 5 % in average, even when compiling the code with different optimization levels

Elementary operations: a novel concept for source-level timing estimation

Early application timing estimation is essential in decision making during design space exploration of heterogeneous embedded systems in terms of hardware platform dimensioning and component selection. The decisions which have the impact on project duration and cost must be made before a platform prototype is available and software code is ready to be linked and thus timing estimation must be done using high-level models and simulators. Because of the ever increasing need to shorten the time to market, reducing the amount of time required to obtain the results is as important as achieving high estimation accuracy. In this paper, we propose a novel approach to source-level timing estimation with the aim to close the speed-accuracy gap by raising the level of abstraction and improving result reusability. We introduce a concept – elementary operations as distinct parts of source code which enable capturing platform behaviour without having the exact model of the processor pipeline, cache etc. We also present a timing estimation method which relies on elementary operations to craft hardware profiling benchmark and to build application and platform profiles. Experiments show an average estimation error of 5%, with maximum below 16%

Laitteistokiihdytetyn vuoronnuksen suorituskykyanalyysi

Performance analysis of heterogeneous MPSoCs (Multiprocessor System-on-Chip) is difficult. The non-determinism of parallel computation, communication delays and memory accesses force the system components into complex interaction. Hardware acceleration is used both to speed up the computations and the scheduling on MPSoCs. Finding an accompanying software structuring and efficient scheduling algorithms is not a straightforward task. In this thesis we investigate the use of simulation, measurement and modeling methods for analyzing the performance of heterogeneous MPSoCs. The viewpoint of this thesis is in simulation and modeling: How a high abstraction level simulation methodology can be used in modeling and analyzing of parallel systems based on MPSoCs. In particular we are interested in efficient use of hardware accelerated scheduling mechanisms and how they can be analyzed. Both parallel simulation and simulation of parallel systems contains many different methods, tools and approaches that attempt to balance between competing goals and cope with a specific subset of the problem space. Challenge is that in all approaches most of the simulation and modeling related problems remain and new challenges emerge. This thesis shows that the resource network methodology and dynamic scheduling models are a viable approach in modeling heterogeneous MPSoCs with accelerators. Concrete contributions are based on upgrading an existing simulation framework to support parallelism. Main contribution is on one hand that modeling concepts have been widened, and on the other hand that the supporting mechanisms have been implemented. The thesis work in progress was published in a peer reviewed international scientific workshop and the final results in a peer reviewed international scientific conference. The toolset has also been used in multiuniversity organized teaching and by the industry.Heterogeenisten moniydinjärjestelmien suorituskykyanalyysi on haasteellista. Laskennan epä-deterministisyys, kommunikaatioviiveet ja lukuisat muistioperaatiot saattavat järjestelmän komponentit monimutkaisiin vuorovaikutussuhteisiin. Laitteistokiihdytettyjä ajoitusmenetelmiä käytetään nopeuttamaan ajoituspäätöksiä. Sopivan ohjelmarakenteen ja tehokkaiden ajoitusalgoritmien löytäminen ei ole helppoa. Tässä työssä tutkitaan miten simulointi-, mittaus- ja mallinnusmenetelmiä voi käyttää laitteistokiihdytettyjen moniydinjärjestelmien suorituskykyanalyysiin. Työn näkökulma on simuloinnissa ja mallinnuksessa: Miten korkean abstraktiotason simulointimenetelmät soveltuvat moniydinjärjestelmiin pohjautuvien rinnakkaisten järjestelmien mallinnukseen ja suorituskykyanalyysiin. Erityisen kiinnostuksen kohteena on laitteistokiihdytteisten ajoitusmenetelmien tehokas käyttö sekä analysointi. Rinnakkaissimulointi pitää sisällään erilaisia menetelmiä, työkaluja ja lähestymistapoja jotka pyrkivät tasapainottelemaan ristiriitaisten tavoitteiden välillä. Haasteena on se, että kaikissa lähestymistavoissa simulaation ja mallinnuksen useimmat ongelmat säilyvät ja uusia ongelmia ilmaantuu. Työn tulokset viittaavat siihen että resurssiverkkopohjainen menetelmä dynaamisen ajoituksen kanssa on toimiva lähestymistapa rinnakkaisten järjestelmien suorituskykyanalyysiin. Työn konkreettiset tulokset pitävät sisällään olemassa olevan simulointiympäristön päivittämisen rinnakkaisuutta tukevaksi. Keskeinen tulos on toisaalta se että mallinnusmenetelmiä on laajennettu ja toisaalta se että näitä tukevat mekanismit on toteutettu. Keskeneräisen työn tulokset on julkaistu vertaisarvioidussa tieteellisessä seminaarissa ja valmiin työn tulokset vertaisarvioidussa tieteellisessä konferenssissa. Simulointiympäristöä on käytetty usean yliopiston järjestämässä yhteisopetuksessa sekä teollisuudessa

Co-simulation techniques based on virtual platforms for SoC design and verification in power electronics applications

En las últimas décadas, la inversión en el ámbito energético ha aumentado considerablemente. Actualmente, existen numerosas empresas que están desarrollando equipos como convertidores de potencia o máquinas eléctricas con sistemas de control de última generación. La tendencia actual es usar System-on-chips y Field Programmable Gate Arrays para implementar todo el sistema de control. Estos dispositivos facilitan el uso de algoritmos de control más complejos y eficientes, mejorando la eficiencia de los equipos y habilitando la integración de los sistemas renovables en la red eléctrica. Sin embargo, la complejidad de los sistemas de control también ha aumentado considerablemente y con ello la dificultad de su verificación. Los sistemas Hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) se han presentado como una solución para la verificación no destructiva de los equipos energéticos, evitando accidentes y pruebas de alto coste en bancos de ensayo. Los sistemas HIL simulan en tiempo real el comportamiento de la planta de potencia y su interfaz para realizar las pruebas con la placa de control en un entorno seguro. Esta tesis se centra en mejorar el proceso de verificación de los sistemas de control en aplicaciones de electrónica potencia. La contribución general es proporcionar una alternativa a al uso de los HIL para la verificación del hardware/software de la tarjeta de control. La alternativa se basa en la técnica de Software-in-the-loop (SIL) y trata de superar o abordar las limitaciones encontradas hasta la fecha en el SIL. Para mejorar las cualidades de SIL se ha desarrollado una herramienta software denominada COSIL que permite co-simular la implementación e integración final del sistema de control, sea software (CPU), hardware (FPGA) o una mezcla de software y hardware, al mismo tiempo que su interacción con la planta de potencia. Dicha plataforma puede trabajar en múltiples niveles de abstracción e incluye soporte para realizar co-simulación mixtas en distintos lenguajes como C o VHDL. A lo largo de la tesis se hace hincapié en mejorar una de las limitaciones de SIL, su baja velocidad de simulación. Se proponen diferentes soluciones como el uso de emuladores software, distintos niveles de abstracción del software y hardware, o relojes locales en los módulos de la FPGA. En especial se aporta un mecanismo de sincronizaron externa para el emulador software QEMU habilitando su emulación multi-core. Esta aportación habilita el uso de QEMU en plataformas virtuales de co-simulacion como COSIL. Toda la plataforma COSIL, incluido el uso de QEMU, se ha analizado bajo diferentes tipos de aplicaciones y bajo un proyecto industrial real. Su uso ha sido crítico para desarrollar y verificar el software y hardware del sistema de control de un convertidor de 400 kVA

Optimizing Performance and Scalability on Hybrid MPSoCs

Hardware accelerators are capable of achieving significant performance improvement. But design- ing hardware accelerators lacks the flexibility and the productivity. Combining hardware accelerators with multiprocessor system-on-chip (MPSoC) is an alternative way to balance the flexibility, the productivity, and the performance. However, without appropriate programming model it is still a challenge to achieve parallelism on a hybrid (MPSoC) with with both general-purpose processors and dedicated accelerators. Besides, increasing computation demands with limited power budget require more energy-efficient design without performance degradation in embedded systems and mobile computing platforms. Reconfigurable computing with emerging storage technologies is an alternative to enable the optimization of both performance and power consumption. In this work, we present a hybrid OpenCL-like (HOpenCL) parallel computing framework on FPGAs. The hybrid hardware platform as well as both the hardware and software kernels can be generated through this an automatic design flow. In addition, the OpenCL-like programming model is exploited to combine software and hardware kernels running on the unified hardware platform. By using the partial reconfiguration technique, a dynamic reconfiguration scheme is presented to optimize performance without losing the programmable flexibility. Our results show that our automatic design flow can not only significantly minimize the development time, but also gain about 11 times speedup compared with pure software parallel implementation. When partial reconfiguration is enable to conduct dynamic scheduling, the overall performance speedup of our mixed micro benchmarks is around 5.2 times