Performance Evaluation of MPLS in a Virtualized Service Provider Core (with/without Class of Service)

The last decade has witnessed a major change in the types of traffic scaling the Internet. With the development of real-time applications several challenges were faced within traditional IP networks. Some of these challenges are delay, increased costs faced by the service provider and customer, limited scalability, separate infrastructure costs and high administrative overheads to manage large networks etc. To combat these challenges, researchers have steered towards finding alternate solutions. Over the recent years, we have seen an introduction of a number of virtualized platforms and solutions being offered in the networking industry. Virtual load balancers, virtual firewalls, virtual routers, virtual intrusion detection and preventions systems are just a few examples within the Network Function Virtualization world! Service Providers are trying to find solutions where they could reduce operational expenses while at the same time meet the growing bandwidth demands of their customers. The main aim of this thesis is to evaluate the performance of voice, data and video traffic in a virtualized service provider core. Observations are made on how these traffic types perform on congested vs uncongested links and how Quality of Service treats traffic in a virtualized Service Provider Core using Round Trip Time as a performance metric. This thesis also tries to find if resiliency features such as Fast Reroute provide an additional advantage in failover scenarios within virtualized service provider cores. Juniper Networks vSRX are used to replicate virtual routers in a virtualized service provider core. Twenty-Four tests are carried out to gain a better understanding of how real-time applications and resiliency methods perform in virtualized networks. It is observed that a trade-off exists when introducing QoS on congested primary and secondary label switched paths. What can be observed thru the graphs is having Quality of Service enabled drops more packets however gives us the advantage of lower Round Trip Time for in-profile traffic. On the hand, having Quality of Service disabled, permits more traffic but leads to bandwidth contention between the three traffic classes leading to higher Round-Trip Times. The true benefit of QoS is seen in traffic congestion scenarios. The test bed built in this thesis, shows us that Fast Reroute does not add a significant benefit to aid in the reduction of packet loss during failover scenarios between primary and secondary paths. However, in certain scenarios fast reroute does seem to reduce packet loss specifically for data traffic

Signalling of Point to Multipoint Trees in Metro Ethernet and Core Networks

Diplomityössä tutustuttiin IPTV-kanavien siirtoon Core-verkosta MetroEthernet-verkon asiakasta lähinnä olevalle laidalle. Tavoitteena oli kehittää nopeampi ratkaisu monilähetyspuiden konfigurointiin laitevalmistajan toteuttamilla protokollilla. Nykyinen ratkaisu, jossa käytetään Resource reSerVation Protocol:ia MultiProtocol Label Switching-tunneleiden signaloimiseen, Internet Group Management Protocol Snooping:ia halukkaiden vastaanottajien kartoittamiseen sekä Protocol Independent Multicast-Source Specific Multicast:ia runkoverkon monilähetykseen on liian työläs. Uudet ratkaisut, joissa yhdistellään RSVP:tä, point-to-multipoint RSVP:tä, Fast ReRoutea ja PIM-SSM:ia testataan TeliaSoneran tietoverkkolaboratoriossa. Tulosten perusteella ei voida sanoa paljoa varmasti, mutta FRR ME-verkossa vaikuttaa helppokäyttöiseltä ja toimivalta ratkaisulta. Lisäksi P2MP RSVP-TE herätti toiveita nopeammin vikatilanteista toipuvasta monilähetysratkaisusta runkoverkosta, kunhan ilmenneiden vikojen syyt saadaan selville.This master's thesis studies the distribution of IPTV channels from a core network to the edges of a MetroEthernet network. The goal is to find a faster solution for configuring multicast trees using protocols implemented by vendors. The current solution which uses Resource reSerVation Protocol for signalling MultiProtocol Label Switched tunnels, Internet Group Management Protocol Snooping for mapping receivers and Protocol Independent Multicast-Source Specific Multicast for core multicast creates too much work. The new solutions combine RSVP, point-to-multipoint RSVP, Fast ReRoute and PIM-SSM and they are tested in the TeliaSonera networking laboratory. Based on test results there is not much certainty about many things but it can be said that FRR seems to be working well and it is easy to use. Furthermore, P2MP RSVP seemed promising for the core network with faster convergence times in failure cases than PIM-SSM. However, there are few problems to be solved before the protocol is ready for use in the production network

Multi-Link Failure Effects on MPLS Resilient Fast-Reroute Network Architectures

© 2021 IEEE.MPLS has been in the forefront of high-speed Wide Area Networks (WANs), for almost two decades [1, 12]. The performance advantages in implementing Multi-Protocol Label Switching (MPLS) are mainly its superior speed based on fast label switching and its capability to perform Fast Reroute rapidly when failure(s) occur – in theory under 50 ms [16, 17], which makes MPLS also interesting for real-time applications. We investigate the aforementioned advantages of MPLS by creating two real testbeds using actual routers that commercial Internet Service Providers (ISPs) use, one with a ring and one with a partial mesh architecture. In those two testbeds we compare the performance of MPLS channels versus normal routing, both using the Open Shortest Path First (OSPF) routing protocol. The speed of the Fast Reroute mechanism for MPLS when failures are occurring is investigated. Firstly, baseline experiments are performed consisting of MPLS versus normal routing. Results are evaluated and compared using both single and dual failure scenarios within the two architectures. Our results confirm recovery times within 50 ms

Equal cost multipath routing in IP networks

IP verkkojen palveluntarjoajat ja loppukäyttäjät vaativat yhä tehokkaampia ja parempilaatuisia palveluita, mikä vaatii tuotekehittäjiä tarjoamaan hienostuneempia liikennesuunnittelumenetelmiä verkon optimointia ja hallintaa varten. IS-IS ja OSPF ovat standardiratkaisut hoitamaan reititystä pienissä ja keskisuurissa pakettiverkoissa. Monipolkureititys on melko helppo ja yleispätevä tapa parantaa kuorman balansointia ja nopeaa suojausta tällaisissa yhden polun reititykseen keskittyvissä verkoissa. Tämä diplomityö kirjoitettiin aikana, jolloin monipolkureititys toteutettiin Tellabs-nimisen yrityksen 8600-sarjan reitittimiin. Tärkeimpiä kohtia monipolkureitityksen käyttöönotossa ovat lyhyimmän polun algoritmin muokkaukseen ja reititystaulun toimintaan liittyvät muutokset ohjaustasolla sekä kuormanbalansointialgoritmin toteutus reitittimen edelleenkuljetustasolla. Diplomityön tulokset sekä olemassa oleva kirjallisuus osoittavat, että kuormanbalansointialgoritmilla on suurin vaikutus yhtä hyvien polkujen liikenteen jakautumiseen ja että oikean algoritmin valinta on ratkaisevan tärkeää. Hajakoodaukseen perustuvat algoritmit, jotka pitävät suurimman osan liikennevuoista samalla polulla, ovat dominoivia ratkaisuja nykyisin. Tämän algoritmityypin etuna on helppo toteutettavuus ja kohtuullisen hyvä suorituskyky. Liikenne on jakautunut tasaisesti, kunhan liikennevuoiden lukumäärä on riittävän suuri. Monipolkureititys tarjoaa yksinkertaisen ratkaisun, jota on helppo konfiguroida ja ylläpitää. Suorituskyky on parempi kuin yksipolkureititykseen perustuvat ratkaisut ja se haastaa monimutkaisemmat MPLS ratkaisut. Ainoa huolehdittava asia on linkkien painojen asettaminen sillä tavalla, että riittävästi kuormantasauspolkuja syntyy.Increasing efficiency and quality demands of services from IP network service providers and end users drive developers to offer more and more sophisticated traffic engineering methods for network optimization and control. Intermediate System to Intermediate System and Open Shortest Path First are the standard routing solutions for intra-domain networks. An easy upgrade utilizes Equal Cost Multipath (ECMP) that is one of the most general solutions for IP traffic engineering to increase load balancing and fast protection performance of single path interior gateway protocols. This thesis was written during the implementation process of the ECMP feature of Tellabs 8600 series routers. The most important parts in adoption of ECMP are changes to shortest path first algorithm and routing table modification in the control plane and implementation of load balancing algorithm to the forwarding plane of router. The results of the thesis and existing literature prove, that the load balancing algorithm has the largest affect on traffic distribution of equal cost paths and the selection of the correct algorithm is crucial. Hash-based algorithms, that keep the traffic flows in the same path, are the dominating solutions currently. They provide simple implementation and moderate performance. Traffic is distributed evenly, when the number of flows is large enough. ECMP provides a simple solution that is easy to configure and maintain. It outperforms single path solutions and competes with more complex MPLS solutions. The only thing to take care of is the adjustment of link weights of the network in order to create enough load balancing paths

Optimization of BGP Convergence and Prefix Security in IP/MPLS Networks

Multi-Protocol Label Switching-based networks are the backbone of the operation of the Internet, that communicates through the use of the Border Gateway Protocol which connects distinct networks, referred to as Autonomous Systems, together. As the technology matures, so does the challenges caused by the extreme growth rate of the Internet. The amount of BGP prefixes required to facilitate such an increase in connectivity introduces multiple new critical issues, such as with the scalability and the security of the aforementioned Border Gateway Protocol. Illustration of an implementation of an IP/MPLS core transmission network is formed through the introduction of the four main pillars of an Autonomous System: Multi-Protocol Label Switching, Border Gateway Protocol, Open Shortest Path First and the Resource Reservation Protocol. The symbiosis of these technologies is used to introduce the practicalities of operating an IP/MPLS-based ISP network with traffic engineering and fault-resilience at heart. The first research objective of this thesis is to determine whether the deployment of a new BGP feature, which is referred to as BGP Prefix Independent Convergence (PIC), within AS16086 would be a worthwhile endeavour. This BGP extension aims to reduce the convergence delay of BGP Prefixes inside of an IP/MPLS Core Transmission Network, thus improving the networks resilience against faults. Simultaneously, the second research objective was to research the available mechanisms considering the protection of BGP Prefixes, such as with the implementation of the Resource Public Key Infrastructure and the Artemis BGP Monitor for proactive and reactive security of BGP prefixes within AS16086. The future prospective deployment of BGPsec is discussed to form an outlook to the future of IP/MPLS network design. As the trust-based nature of BGP as a protocol has become a distinct vulnerability, thus necessitating the use of various technologies to secure the communications between the Autonomous Systems that form the network to end all networks, the Internet

Concepção e implementação de experiências laboratoriais sobre MPLS

Mestrado em Engenharia Electrónica e TelecomunicaçõesO Multiprotocol Label Switching (MPLS) é um mecanismo de transporte de dados, sob a forma de um protocolo agnóstico, com grande potencial de crescimento e adequação. Opera na “Camada 2.5” do modelo OSI e constitui um mecanismo de alto desempenho utilizado nas redes de núcleo para transportar dados de um nó da rede para outro. O sucesso do MPLS resulta do facto de permitir que a rede transporte todos os tipos de dados, desde tráfego IP a tráfego da camada de ligação de dados, devido ao encapsulamento dos pacotes dos diversos protocolos, permitindo a criação de “links virtuais” entre nós distantes. O MPLS pertence à família das “redes de comutação de pacotes”, sendo os pacotes de dados associados a “etiquetas” que determinam o seu encaminhamento, sem necessidade de examinar o conteúdo dos próprios pacotes. Isto permite a criação de circuitos “extremo-aextremo” através de qualquer tipo de rede de transporte e independentemente do protocolo de encaminhamento que é utilizado. O projecto do MPLS considera múltiplas tecnologias no sentido de prestar um serviço único de transporte de dados, tentando simultaneamente proporcionar capacidades de engenharia de tráfego e controlo “out-of-band”, uma característica muito atraente para uma implementação em grande escala. No fundo, o MPLS é uma forma de consolidar muitas redes IP dentro de uma única rede. Dada a importância desta tecnologia, é urgente desenvolver ferramentas que permitam entender melhor a sua complexidade. O MPLS corre normalmente nas redes de núcleo dos ISPs. No sentido de tornar o seu estudo viável, recorreu-se nesta dissertação à emulação para implementar cenários de complexidade adequada. Existem actualmente boas ferramentas disponíveis que permitem a recriação em laboratório de cenários bastante complicados. Contudo, a exigência computacional da emulação é proporcional à complexidade do projecto em questão, tornando-se rapidamente impossível de realizar numa única máquina. A computação distribuída ou a “Cloud Computing” são actualmente as abordagens mais adequadas e inovadoras apara a resolução deste problema. Esta dissertação tem como objectivo criar algumas experiências em laboratório que evidenciam aspectos relevantes da tecnologia MPLS, usando para esse efeito um emulador computacional, o Dynamips, impulsionado por generosas fontes computacionais disponibilizadas pela Amazon ec2. A utilização destas ferramentas de emulação permite testar cenários de rede e serviços reais em ambiente controlado, efectuando o debugging das suas configurações e optimizando o seu desempenho, antes de os colocar em funcionamento nas redes em operação.The Multiprotocol Label Switching (MPLS) is a highly scalable and agnostic protocol to carry network data. Operating at "Layer 2.5" of the OSI model, MPLS is an highperformance mechanism that is used at the network backbone for conveying data from one network node to the next. The success of MPLS results from the fact that it enables the network to carry all kinds of traffic, ranging from IP to layer 2 traffic, since it encapsulates the packets of the diverse network protocols, allowing the creation of "virtual links" between distant nodes. MPLS belongs to the family of packet switched networks, where labels are assigned to data packets that are forwarded based on decisions that rely only on the label contents, without the need to examine the packets contents. This allows the creation of end-to-end circuits across any type of transport medium, using any protocol. The MPLS design takes multiform transport technologies into account to provide a unified data-carrying service, attempting simultaneously to preserve traffic engineering and out-of-band control, a very attractive characteristic for large-scale deployment. MPLS is the way to consolidate many IP networks into a single one. Due to this obvious potential, it is urgent to develop means and tools to better understand its functioning and complexity. MPLS normally runs at the backbone of Service Providers networks, being deployed across an extensive set of expensive equipment. In order to turn the study of MPLS feasible, emulation was considered as the best solution. Currently, there are very good available tools to recreate, in a lab environment, quite complicated scenarios. However, the computational demand of the emulation is proportional to the complexity of the project, becoming quickly unfeasible in a single machine. Fortunately, distributed computing or Cloud computing are suitable and novel approaches to solve this computation problem. So, this work aims to create some lab experiments that can illustrate/demonstrate relevant aspects of the MPLS technology, using the Dynamips emulator driven by the computational resources that were made available by the Amazon ec2 cloud computing facilities. The utilization of these emulation tools allows testing real networks and service scenarios in a controlled environment, being able to debug their configurations and optimize their performance before deploying them in real operating networks

Análise e otimização da tecnologia MPLS na rede da Universidade do Porto

O presente relatório de projeto foi realizado em ambiente profissional, no âmbito do Mestrado em Tecnologias da Informação, Comunicação e Multimédia do Instituto Universitário da Maia – ISMAI, e teve como principal objetivo o estudo da tecnologia MPLS, e restruturação da mesma, na rede de comunicação de dados da Universidade do Porto. Para tal, a opção metodológica adotada foi a de Action-Research.N/