A Survey and Evaluation of FPGA High-Level Synthesis Tools

High-level synthesis (HLS) is increasingly popular for the design of high-performance and energy-efficient heterogeneous systems, shortening time-to-market and addressing today's system complexity. HLS allows designers to work at a higher-level of abstraction by using a software program to specify the hardware functionality. Additionally, HLS is particularly interesting for designing field-programmable gate array circuits, where hardware implementations can be easily refined and replaced in the target device. Recent years have seen much activity in the HLS research community, with a plethora of HLS tool offerings, from both industry and academia. All these tools may have different input languages, perform different internal optimizations, and produce results of different quality, even for the very same input description. Hence, it is challenging to compare their performance and understand which is the best for the hardware to be implemented. We present a comprehensive analysis of recent HLS tools, as well as overview the areas of active interest in the HLS research community. We also present a first-published methodology to evaluate different HLS tools. We use our methodology to compare one commercial and three academic tools on a common set of C benchmarks, aiming at performing an in-depth evaluation in terms of performance and the use of resources

Methodology for complex dataflow application development

This thesis addresses problems inherent to the development of complex applications for reconfig- urable systems. Many projects fail to complete or take much longer than originally estimated by relying on traditional iterative software development processes typically used with conventional computers. Even though designer productivity can be increased by abstract programming and execution models, e.g., dataflow, development methodologies considering the specific properties of reconfigurable systems do not exist. The first contribution of this thesis is a design methodology to facilitate systematic develop- ment of complex applications using reconfigurable hardware in the context of High-Performance Computing (HPC). The proposed methodology is built upon a careful analysis of the original application, a software model of the intended hardware system, an analytical prediction of performance and on-chip area usage, and an iterative architectural refinement to resolve identi- fied bottlenecks before writing a single line of code targeting the reconfigurable hardware. It is successfully validated using two real applications and both achieve state-of-the-art performance. The second contribution extends this methodology to provide portability between devices in two steps. First, additional tool support for contemporary multi-die Field-Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) is developed. An algorithm to automatically map logical memories to hetero- geneous physical memories with special attention to die boundaries is proposed. As a result, only the proposed algorithm managed to successfully place and route all designs used in the evaluation while the second-best algorithm failed on one third of all large applications. Second, best practices for performance portability between different FPGA devices are collected and evaluated on a financial use case, showing efficient resource usage on five different platforms. The third contribution applies the extended methodology to a real, highly demanding emerging application from the radiotherapy domain. A Monte-Carlo based simulation of dose accumu- lation in human tissue is accelerated using the proposed methodology to meet the real time requirements of adaptive radiotherapy.Open Acces

Improving low latency applications for reconfigurable devices

This thesis seeks to improve low latency application performance via architectural improvements in reconfigurable devices. This is achieved by improving resource utilisation and access, and by exploiting the different environments within which reconfigurable devices are deployed. Our first contribution leverages devices deployed at the network level to enable the low latency processing of financial market data feeds. Financial exchanges transmit messages via two identical data feeds to reduce the chance of message loss. We present an approach to arbitrate these redundant feeds at the network level using a Field-Programmable Gate Array (FPGA). With support for any messaging protocol, we evaluate our design using the NASDAQ TotalView-ITCH, OPRA, and ARCA data feed protocols, and provide two simultaneous outputs: one prioritising low latency, and one prioritising high reliability with three dynamically configurable windowing methods. Our second contribution is a new ring-based architecture for low latency, parallel access to FPGA memory. Traditional FPGA memory is formed by grouping block memories (BRAMs) together and accessing them as a single device. Our architecture accesses these BRAMs independently and in parallel. Targeting memory-based computing, which stores pre-computed function results in memory, we benefit low latency applications that rely on: highly-complex functions; iterative computation; or many parallel accesses to a shared resource. We assess square root, power, trigonometric, and hyperbolic functions within the FPGA, and provide a tool to convert Python functions to our new architecture. Our third contribution extends the ring-based architecture to support any FPGA processing element. We unify E heterogeneous processing elements within compute pools, with each element implementing the same function, and the pool serving D parallel function calls. Our implementation-agnostic approach supports processing elements with different latencies, implementations, and pipeline lengths, as well as non-deterministic latencies. Compute pools evenly balance access to processing elements across the entire application, and are evaluated by implementing eight different neural network activation functions within an FPGA.Open Acces

Just In Time Assembly (JITA) - A Run Time Interpretation Approach for Achieving Productivity of Creating Custom Accelerators in FPGAs

The reconfigurable computing community has yet to be successful in allowing programmers to access FPGAs through traditional software development flows. Existing barriers that prevent programmers from using FPGAs include: 1) knowledge of hardware programming models, 2) the need to work within the vendor specific CAD tools and hardware synthesis. This thesis presents a series of published papers that explore different aspects of a new approach being developed to remove the barriers and enable programmers to compile accelerators on next generation reconfigurable manycore architectures. The approach is entitled Just In Time Assembly (JITA) of hardware accelerators. The approach has been defined to allow hardware accelerators to be built and run through software compilation and run time interpretation outside of CAD tools and without requiring each new accelerator to be synthesized. The approach advocates the use of libraries of pre-synthesized components that can be referenced through symbolic links in a similar fashion to dynamically linked software libraries. Synthesis still must occur but is moved out of the application programmers software flow and into the initial coding process that occurs when programming patterns that define a Domain Specific Language (DSL) are first coded. Programmers see no difference between creating software or hardware functionality when using the DSL. A new run time interpreter is introduced to assemble the individual pre-synthesized hardware accelerators that comprise the accelerator functionality within a configurable tile array of partially reconfigurable slots at run time. Quantitative results are presented that compares utilization, performance, and productivity of the approach to what would be achieved by full custom accelerators created through traditional CAD flows using hardware programming models and passing through synthesis

A Hybrid Partially Reconfigurable Overlay Supporting Just-In-Time Assembly of Custom Accelerators on FPGAs

The state of the art in design and development flows for FPGAs are not sufficiently mature to allow programmers to implement their applications through traditional software development flows. The stipulation of synthesis as well as the requirement of background knowledge on the FPGAs\u27 low-level physical hardware structure are major challenges that prevent programmers from using FPGAs. The reconfigurable computing community is seeking solutions to raise the level of design abstraction at which programmers must operate, and move the synthesis process out of the programmers\u27 path through the use of overlays. A recent approach, Just-In-Time Assembly (JITA), was proposed that enables hardware accelerators to be assembled at runtime, all from within a traditional software compilation flow. The JITA approach presents a promising path to constructing hardware designs on FPGAs using pre-synthesized parallel programming patterns, but suffers from two major limitations. First, all variant programming patterns must be pre-synthesized. Second, conditional operations are not supported. In this thesis, I present a new reconfigurable overlay, URUK, that overcomes the two limitations imposed by the JITA approach. Similar to the original JITA approach, the proposed URUK overlay allows hardware accelerators to be constructed on FPGAs through software compilation flows. To this basic capability, URUK adds additional support to enable the assembly of presynthesized fine-grained computational operators to be assembled within the FPGA. This thesis provides analysis of URUK from three different perspectives; utilization, performance, and productivity. The analysis includes comparisons against High-Level Synthesis (HLS) and the state of the art approach to creating static overlays. The tradeoffs conclude that URUK can achieve approximately equivalent performance for algebra operations compared to HLS custom accelerators, which are designed with simple experience on FPGAs. Further, URUK shows a high degree of flexibility for runtime placement and routing of the primitive operations. The analysis shows how this flexibility can be leveraged to reduce communication overhead among tiles, compared to traditional static overlays. The results also show URUK can enable software programmers without any hardware skills to create hardware accelerators at productivity levels consistent with software development and compilation

A multi-level functional IR with rewrites for higher-level synthesis of accelerators

Specialised accelerators deliver orders of magnitude higher energy-efficiency than general-purpose processors. Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) have become the substrate of choice, because the ever-changing nature of modern workloads, such as machine learning, demands reconfigurability. However, they are notoriously hard to program directly using Hardware Description Languages (HDLs). Traditional High-Level Synthesis (HLS) tools improve productivity, but come with their own problems. They often produce sub-optimal designs and programmers are still required to write hardware-specific code, thus development cycles remain long. This thesis proposes Shir, a higher-level synthesis approach for high-performance accelerator design with a hardware-agnostic programming entry point, a multi-level Intermediate Representation (IR), a compiler and rewrite rules for optimisation. First, a novel, multi-level functional IR structure for accelerator design is described. The IRs operate on different levels of abstraction, cleanly separating different hardware concerns. They enable the expression of different forms of parallelism and standard memory features, such as asynchronous off-chip memories or synchronous on-chip buffers, as well as arbitration of such shared resources. Exposing these features at the IR level is essential for achieving high performance. Next, mechanical lowering procedures are introduced to automatically compile a program specification through Shir’s functional IRs until low-level HDL code for FPGA synthesis is emitted. Each lowering step gradually adds implementation details. Finally, this thesis presents rewrite rules for automatic optimisations around parallelisation, buffering and data reshaping. Reshaping operations pose a challenge to functional approaches in particular. They introduce overheads that compromise performance or even prevent the generation of synthesisable hardware designs altogether. This fundamental issue is solved by the application of rewrite rules. The viability of this approach is demonstrated by running matrix multiplication and 2D convolution on an Intel Arria 10 FPGA. A limited design space exploration is conducted, confirming the ability of the IR to exploit various hardware features. Using rewrite rules for optimisation, it is possible to generate high-performance designs that are competitive with highly tuned OpenCL implementations and that outperform hardware-agnostic OpenCL code. The performance impact of the optimisations is further evaluated showing that they are essential to achieving high performance, and in many cases also necessary to produce hardware that fits the resource constraints

Embedded electronic systems driven by run-time reconfigurable hardware

Abstract This doctoral thesis addresses the design of embedded electronic systems based on run-time reconfigurable hardware technology –available through SRAM-based FPGA/SoC devices– aimed at contributing to enhance the life quality of the human beings. This work does research on the conception of the system architecture and the reconfiguration engine that provides to the FPGA the capability of dynamic partial reconfiguration in order to synthesize, by means of hardware/software co-design, a given application partitioned in processing tasks which are multiplexed in time and space, optimizing thus its physical implementation –silicon area, processing time, complexity, flexibility, functional density, cost and power consumption– in comparison with other alternatives based on static hardware (MCU, DSP, GPU, ASSP, ASIC, etc.). The design flow of such technology is evaluated through the prototyping of several engineering applications (control systems, mathematical coprocessors, complex image processors, etc.), showing a high enough level of maturity for its exploitation in the industry.Resumen Esta tesis doctoral abarca el diseño de sistemas electrónicos embebidos basados en tecnología hardware dinámicamente reconfigurable –disponible a través de dispositivos lógicos programables SRAM FPGA/SoC– que contribuyan a la mejora de la calidad de vida de la sociedad. Se investiga la arquitectura del sistema y del motor de reconfiguración que proporcione a la FPGA la capacidad de reconfiguración dinámica parcial de sus recursos programables, con objeto de sintetizar, mediante codiseño hardware/software, una determinada aplicación particionada en tareas multiplexadas en tiempo y en espacio, optimizando así su implementación física –área de silicio, tiempo de procesado, complejidad, flexibilidad, densidad funcional, coste y potencia disipada– comparada con otras alternativas basadas en hardware estático (MCU, DSP, GPU, ASSP, ASIC, etc.). Se evalúa el flujo de diseño de dicha tecnología a través del prototipado de varias aplicaciones de ingeniería (sistemas de control, coprocesadores aritméticos, procesadores de imagen, etc.), evidenciando un nivel de madurez viable ya para su explotación en la industria.Resum Aquesta tesi doctoral està orientada al disseny de sistemes electrònics empotrats basats en tecnologia hardware dinàmicament reconfigurable –disponible mitjançant dispositius lògics programables SRAM FPGA/SoC– que contribueixin a la millora de la qualitat de vida de la societat. S’investiga l’arquitectura del sistema i del motor de reconfiguració que proporcioni a la FPGA la capacitat de reconfiguració dinàmica parcial dels seus recursos programables, amb l’objectiu de sintetitzar, mitjançant codisseny hardware/software, una determinada aplicació particionada en tasques multiplexades en temps i en espai, optimizant així la seva implementació física –àrea de silici, temps de processat, complexitat, flexibilitat, densitat funcional, cost i potència dissipada– comparada amb altres alternatives basades en hardware estàtic (MCU, DSP, GPU, ASSP, ASIC, etc.). S’evalúa el fluxe de disseny d’aquesta tecnologia a través del prototipat de varies aplicacions d’enginyeria (sistemes de control, coprocessadors aritmètics, processadors d’imatge, etc.), demostrant un nivell de maduresa viable ja per a la seva explotació a la indústria

Energy-efficient hardware design based on high-level synthesis

This dissertation describes research activities broadly concerning the area of High-level synthesis (HLS), but more specifically, regarding the HLS-based design of energy-efficient hardware (HW) accelerators. HW accelerators, mostly implemented on FPGAs, are integral to the heterogeneous architectures employed in modern high performance computing (HPC) systems due to their ability to speed up the execution while dramatically reducing the energy consumption of computationally challenging portions of complex applications. Hence, the first activity was regarding an HLS-based approach to directly execute an OpenCL code on an FPGA instead of its traditional GPU-based counterpart. Modern FPGAs offer considerable computational capabilities while consuming significantly smaller power as compared to high-end GPUs. Several different implementations of the K-Nearest Neighbor algorithm were considered on both FPGA- and GPU-based platforms and their performance was compared. FPGAs were generally more energy-efficient than the GPUs in all the test cases. Eventually, we were also able to get a faster (in terms of execution time) FPGA implementation by using an FPGA-specific OpenCL coding style and utilizing suitable HLS directives. The second activity was targeted towards the development of a methodology complementing HLS to automatically derive power optimization directives (also known as "power intent") from a system-level design description and use it to drive the design steps after HLS, by producing a directive file written using the common power format (CPF) to achieve power shut-off (PSO) in case of an ASIC design. The proposed LP-HLS methodology reduces the design effort by enabling designers to infer low power information from the system-level description of a design rather than at the RTL. This methodology required a SystemC description of a generic power management module to describe the design context of a HW module also modeled in SystemC, along with the development of a tool to automatically produce the CPF file to accomplish PSO. Several test cases were considered to validate the proposed methodology and the results demonstrated its ability to correctly extract the low power information and apply it to achieve power optimization in the backend flow

Automatic generation of high-throughput systolic tree-based solvers for modern FPGAs

Tree-based models are a class of numerical methods widely used in financial option pricing, which have a computational complexity that is quadratic with respect to the solution accuracy. Previous research has employed reconfigurable computing with small degrees of parallelism to provide faster hardware solutions compared with general-purpose processing software designs. However, due to the nature of their vector hardware architectures, they cannot scale their compute resources efficiently, leaving them with pricing latency figures which are quadratic with respect to the problem size, and hence to the solution accuracy. Also, their solutions are not productive as they require hardware engineering effort, and can only solve one type of tree problems, known as the standard American option. This thesis presents a novel methodology in the form of a high-level design framework which can capture any common tree-based problem, and automatically generates high-throughput field-programmable gate array (FPGA) solvers based on proposed scalable hardware architectures. The thesis has made three main contributions. First, systolic architectures were proposed for solving binomial and trinomial trees, which due to their custom systolic data-movement mechanisms, can scale their compute resources efficiently to provide linear latency scaling for medium-size trees and improved quadratic latency scaling for large trees. Using the proposed systolic architectures, throughput speed-ups of up to 5.6X and 12X were achieved for modern FPGAs, compared to previous vector designs, for medium and large trees, respectively. Second, a productive high-level design framework was proposed, that can capture any common binomial and trinomial tree problem, and a methodology was suggested to generate high-throughput systolic solvers with custom data precision, where the methodology requires no hardware design effort from the end user. Third, a fully-automated tool-chain methodology was proposed that, compared to previous tree-based solvers, improves user productivity by removing the manual engineering effort of applying the design framework to option pricing problems. Using the productive design framework, high-throughput systolic FPGA solvers have been automatically generated from simple end-user C descriptions for several tree problems, such as American, Bermudan, and barrier options.Open Acces

Architectures for Adaptive Low-Power Embedded Multimedia Systems

This Ph.D. thesis describes novel hardware/software architectures for adaptive low-power embedded multimedia systems. Novel techniques for run-time adaptive energy management are proposed, such that both HW & SW adapt together to react to the unpredictable scenarios. A complete power-aware H.264 video encoder was developed. Comparison with state-of-the-art demonstrates significant energy savings while meeting the performance constraint and keeping the video quality degradation unnoticeable