1,366 research outputs found
Supporting Web-based and Crowdsourced Evaluations of Data Visualizations
User studies play a vital role in data visualization research because they help measure the strengths and weaknesses of different visualization techniques quantitatively. In addition, they provide insight into what makes one technique more effective than another; and they are used to validate research contributions in the field of information visualization. For example, a new algorithm, visual encoding, or interaction technique is not considered a contribution unless it has been validated to be better than the state of the art and its competing alternatives or has been validated to be useful to intended users. However, conducting user studies is challenging, time consuming, and expensive.
User studies generally requires careful experimental designs, iterative refinement, recruitment of study participants, careful management of participants during the run of the studies, accurately collecting user responses, and expertise in statistical analysis of study results. There are several variables that are taken into consideration which can impact user study outcome if not carefully managed. Hence the process of conducting user studies successfully can take several weeks to months.
In this dissertation, we investigated how to design an online framework that can reduce the overhead involved in conducting controlled user studies involving web-based visualizations. Our main goal in this research was to lower the overhead of evaluating data visualizations quantitatively through user studies. To this end, we leveraged current research opportunities to provide a framework design that reduces the overhead involved in designing and running controlled user studies of data visualizations. Specifically, we explored the design and implementation of an open-source framework and an online service (VisUnit) that allows visualization designers to easily configure user studies for their web-based data visualizations, deploy user studies online, collect user responses, and analyze incoming results automatically. This allows evaluations to be done more easily, cheaply, and frequently to rapidly test hypotheses about visualization designs.
We evaluated the effectiveness of our framework (VisUnit) by showing that it can be used to replicate 84% of 101 controlled user studies published in IEEE Information Visualization conferences between 1995 and 2015. We evaluated the efficiency of VisUnit by showing that graduate students can use it to design sample user studies in less than an hour.
Our contributions are two-fold: first, we contribute a flexible design and implementation that facilitates the creation of a wide range of user studies with limited effort; second, we provide an evaluation of our design that shows that it can be used to replicate a wide range of user studies, can be used to reduce the time evaluators spend on user studies, and can be used to support new research
An Overview of Computational Approaches for Interpretation Analysis
It is said that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. But how exactly can we
characterize such discrepancies in interpretation? For example, are there any
specific features of an image that makes person A regard an image as beautiful
while person B finds the same image displeasing? Such questions ultimately aim
at explaining our individual ways of interpretation, an intention that has been
of fundamental importance to the social sciences from the beginning. More
recently, advances in computer science brought up two related questions: First,
can computational tools be adopted for analyzing ways of interpretation?
Second, what if the "beholder" is a computer model, i.e., how can we explain a
computer model's point of view? Numerous efforts have been made regarding both
of these points, while many existing approaches focus on particular aspects and
are still rather separate. With this paper, in order to connect these
approaches we introduce a theoretical framework for analyzing interpretation,
which is applicable to interpretation of both human beings and computer models.
We give an overview of relevant computational approaches from various fields,
and discuss the most common and promising application areas. The focus of this
paper lies on interpretation of text and image data, while many of the
presented approaches are applicable to other types of data as well.Comment: Preprint submitted to Digital Signal Processin
SciTech News Volume 71, No. 1 (2017)
Columns and Reports From the Editor 3
Division News Science-Technology Division 5 Chemistry Division 8 Engineering Division Aerospace Section of the Engineering Division 9 Architecture, Building Engineering, Construction and Design Section of the Engineering Division 11
Reviews Sci-Tech Book News Reviews 12
Advertisements IEEE
Recommended from our members
Bridging the gap between mobile CPU design and user satisfaction via crowdsourcing
This report aims to provide an understanding of how the mobile CPU designs have evolved and its influence on end-user satisfaction. To that end, a quantitative performance analysis is conducted across ten cutting-edge mobile CPU designs studied within top-selling off-the-shelf smartphones released over the past seven years. This analysis is then used to guide a large-scale user study spanning over 25,000 participants via crowdsourcing on the Amazon Mechanical Turk service. The user study asks participants to assess the responsiveness of interactive application use cases for a set of current-generation applications (e.g. Angry Birds and FaceBook) and next-generation applications (i.e. face recognition and augmented reality) relative to the performance capabilities of the devices studied. This framework allows us to quantitatively link how the mobile CPU designs studied impacted end-user satisfaction. The study results indicate that mobile CPU designs have exhibited signifiant performance improvements through aggressive core scaling techniques prevalent in desktop CPUs. Just as was observed in desktop CPU design, these same techniques have lead to excessive mobile CPU power consumption. However, from an end-user perspective this power consumption was not without success. Mobile CPUs have evolved to provide satisfactory experiences for the studied current- generation applications. The reason is that many of these applications rely heavily on single-threaded performance. Other, more recent applications, actually multi-thread user-critical parts of the applications, which also demonstrates that multi- core mobile CPUs are an important design consideration – contrary to conventional wisdom. However, looking ahead, the same mobile CPUs where not able to provide satisfactory experiences for many of the next-generation applications studied, questioning the sustainability of these power-hungry design techniques in future mobile CPU designs.Electrical and Computer Engineerin
- …