Evaluating named entity recognition tools for extracting social networks from novels

The analysis of literary works has experienced a surge in computer-assisted processing. To obtain insights into the community structures and social interactions portrayed in novels, the creation of social networks from novels has gained popularity. Many methods rely on identifying named entities and relations for the construction of these networks, but many of these tools are not specifically created for the literary domain. Furthermore, many of the studies on information extraction from literature typically focus on 19th and early 20th century source material. Because of this, it is unclear if these techniques are as suitable to modern-day literature as they are to those older novels. We present a study in which we evaluate natural language processing tools for the automatic extraction of social networks from novels as well as their network structure. We find that there are no significant differences between old and modern novels but that both are subject to a large amount of variance. Furthermore, we identify several issues that complicate named entity recognition in our set of novels and we present methods to remedy these. We see this work as a step in creating more culturally-aware AI systems

Extracting Social Network from Literary Prose

This thesis develops an approach to extract social networks from literary prose, namely, Jane Austen’s published novels from eighteenth- and nineteenth- century. Dialogue interaction plays a key role while we derive the networks, thus our technique relies upon our ability to determine when two characters are in conversation. Our process involves encoding plain literary text into the Text Encoding Initiative’s (TEI) XML format, character name identification, conversation and co-occurrence detection, and social network construction. Previous work in social network construction for literature have focused on drama, specifically manually TEI-encoded Shakespearean plays in which character interactions are much easier to track in due to their dialogue-driven narrative structure. In contrast, prose is structured quite differently; character speeches are not very clearly formatted, making it more difficult to assign specific dialogue to each character. We implement two different parsing strategies based on context size (chapter scope and paragraph scope) to detect character interactions. To check the accuracy of our methods, we conduct one evaluation that is based on network statistics and another evaluation that involves measuring similarity (edit distance) between the networks constructed from manually encoded novels versus our constructed graphs. Our findings suggest that the choice of context size is non-trivial and can have a substantial influence on the resulting networks. In general, the paragraph level interaction approach seemed to be more accurate

Event-based Access to Historical Italian War Memoirs

The progressive digitization of historical archives provides new, often domain specific, textual resources that report on facts and events which have happened in the past; among these, memoirs are a very common type of primary source. In this paper, we present an approach for extracting information from Italian historical war memoirs and turning it into structured knowledge. This is based on the semantic notions of events, participants and roles. We evaluate quantitatively each of the key-steps of our approach and provide a graph-based representation of the extracted knowledge, which allows to move between a Close and a Distant Reading of the collection.Comment: 23 pages, 6 figure

Automatic Description: A Novel Approach to Documenting Character Description for Consistency in Long – Form Prose

Currently, continuity editing for narrative fiction is performed manually. Many hours of human effort are required to comb through written works for inconsistencies. This study investigates the use of syntactic patterns of descriptions in narrative text and subject identification techniques like named entity recognition (NER) and coreferent resolution in narrative text as a step toward automated continuity analysis. This investigation involved examining natural English language to identify patterns used in descriptions and using natural language processing (NLP) techniques to identify those patterns and sentence subjects programmatically. Results were assessed by using the content of well-known works of fiction and two algorithms developed to identify sentence subjects and descriptions, to promising results. With the fragmented, iterative cycle of writing long-form prose and the limitations of human memory and reading speed, maintaining a clear and consistent image of a character\u27s appearance and personality is a difficult task for human authors and editors to complete manually. The results of this research provide a starting point to automate and improve the process writing and proofreading narrative works

From Information Overload to Knowledge Graphs: An Automatic Information Process Model

Continuously increasing text data such as news, articles, and scientific papers from the Internet have caused the information overload problem. Collecting valuable information as well as coding the information efficiently from enormous amounts of unstructured textual information becomes a big challenge in the information explosion age. Although many solutions and methods have been developed to reduce information overload, such as the deduction of duplicated information, the adoption of personal information management strategies, and so on, most of the existing methods only partially solve the problem. What’s more, many existing solutions are out of date and not compatible with the rapid development of new modern technology techniques. Thus, an effective and efficient approach with new modern IT (Information Technology) techniques that can collect valuable information and extract high-quality information has become urgent and critical for many researchers in the information overload age. Based on the principles of Design Science Theory, the paper presents a novel approach to tackle information overload issues. The proposed solution is an automated information process model that employs advanced IT techniques such as web scraping, natural language processing, and knowledge graphs. The model can automatically process the full cycle of information flow, from information Search to information Collection, Information Extraction, and Information Visualization, making it a comprehensive and intelligent information process tool. The paper presents the model capability to gather critical information and convert unstructured text data into a structured data model with greater efficiency and effectiveness. In addition, the paper presents multiple use cases to validate the feasibility and practicality of the model. Furthermore, the paper also performed both quantitative and qualitative evaluation processes to assess its effectiveness. The results indicate that the proposed model significantly reduces the information overload and is valuable for both academic and real-world research

Grounding Characters and Places in Narrative Texts

Tracking characters and locations throughout a story can help improve the understanding of its plot structure. Prior research has analyzed characters and locations from text independently without grounding characters to their locations in narrative time. Here, we address this gap by proposing a new spatial relationship categorization task. The objective of the task is to assign a spatial relationship category for every character and location co-mention within a window of text, taking into consideration linguistic context, narrative tense, and temporal scope. To this end, we annotate spatial relationships in approximately 2500 book excerpts and train a model using contextual embeddings as features to predict these relationships. When applied to a set of books, this model allows us to test several hypotheses on mobility and domestic space, revealing that protagonists are more mobile than non-central characters and that women as characters tend to occupy more interior space than men. Overall, our work is the first step towards joint modeling and analysis of characters and places in narrative text.Comment: 12 pages, 4 figures, 5 tables; to appear in the proceedings of ACL 202

Knowledge extraction from fictional texts

Knowledge extraction from text is a key task in natural language processing, which involves many sub-tasks, such as taxonomy induction, named entity recognition and typing, relation extraction, knowledge canonicalization and so on. By constructing structured knowledge from natural language text, knowledge extraction becomes a key asset for search engines, question answering and other downstream applications. However, current knowledge extraction methods mostly focus on prominent real-world entities with Wikipedia and mainstream news articles as sources. The constructed knowledge bases, therefore, lack information about long-tail domains, with fiction and fantasy as archetypes. Fiction and fantasy are core parts of our human culture, spanning from literature to movies, TV series, comics and video games. With thousands of fictional universes which have been created, knowledge from fictional domains are subject of search-engine queries - by fans as well as cultural analysts. Unlike the real-world domain, knowledge extraction on such specific domains like fiction and fantasy has to tackle several key challenges: - Training data: Sources for fictional domains mostly come from books and fan-built content, which is sparse and noisy, and contains difficult structures of texts, such as dialogues and quotes. Training data for key tasks such as taxonomy induction, named entity typing or relation extraction are also not available. - Domain characteristics and diversity: Fictional universes can be highly sophisticated, containing entities, social structures and sometimes languages that are completely different from the real world. State-of-the-art methods for knowledge extraction make assumptions on entity-class, subclass and entity-entity relations that are often invalid for fictional domains. With different genres of fictional domains, another requirement is to transfer models across domains. - Long fictional texts: While state-of-the-art models have limitations on the input sequence length, it is essential to develop methods that are able to deal with very long texts (e.g. entire books), to capture multiple contexts and leverage widely spread cues. This dissertation addresses the above challenges, by developing new methodologies that advance the state of the art on knowledge extraction in fictional domains. - The first contribution is a method, called TiFi, for constructing type systems (taxonomy induction) for fictional domains. By tapping noisy fan-built content from online communities such as Wikia, TiFi induces taxonomies through three main steps: category cleaning, edge cleaning and top-level construction. Exploiting a variety of features from the original input, TiFi is able to construct taxonomies for a diverse range of fictional domains with high precision. - The second contribution is a comprehensive approach, called ENTYFI, for named entity recognition and typing in long fictional texts. Built on 205 automatically induced high-quality type systems for popular fictional domains, ENTYFI exploits the overlap and reuse of these fictional domains on unseen texts. By combining different typing modules with a consolidation stage, ENTYFI is able to do fine-grained entity typing in long fictional texts with high precision and recall. - The third contribution is an end-to-end system, called KnowFi, for extracting relations between entities in very long texts such as entire books. KnowFi leverages background knowledge from 142 popular fictional domains to identify interesting relations and to collect distant training samples. KnowFi devises a similarity-based ranking technique to reduce false positives in training samples and to select potential text passages that contain seed pairs of entities. By training a hierarchical neural network for all relations, KnowFi is able to infer relations between entity pairs across long fictional texts, and achieves gains over the best prior methods for relation extraction.Wissensextraktion ist ein Schlüsselaufgabe bei der Verarbeitung natürlicher Sprache, und umfasst viele Unteraufgaben, wie Taxonomiekonstruktion, Entitätserkennung und Typisierung, Relationsextraktion, Wissenskanonikalisierung, etc. Durch den Aufbau von strukturiertem Wissen (z.B. Wissensdatenbanken) aus Texten wird die Wissensextraktion zu einem Schlüsselfaktor für Suchmaschinen, Question Answering und andere Anwendungen. Aktuelle Methoden zur Wissensextraktion konzentrieren sich jedoch hauptsächlich auf den Bereich der realen Welt, wobei Wikipedia und Mainstream- Nachrichtenartikel die Hauptquellen sind. Fiktion und Fantasy sind Kernbestandteile unserer menschlichen Kultur, die sich von Literatur bis zu Filmen, Fernsehserien, Comics und Videospielen erstreckt. Für Tausende von fiktiven Universen wird Wissen aus Suchmaschinen abgefragt – von Fans ebenso wie von Kulturwissenschaftler. Im Gegensatz zur realen Welt muss die Wissensextraktion in solchen spezifischen Domänen wie Belletristik und Fantasy mehrere zentrale Herausforderungen bewältigen: • Trainingsdaten. Quellen für fiktive Domänen stammen hauptsächlich aus Büchern und von Fans erstellten Inhalten, die spärlich und fehlerbehaftet sind und schwierige Textstrukturen wie Dialoge und Zitate enthalten. Trainingsdaten für Schlüsselaufgaben wie Taxonomie-Induktion, Named Entity Typing oder Relation Extraction sind ebenfalls nicht verfügbar. • Domain-Eigenschaften und Diversität. Fiktive Universen können sehr anspruchsvoll sein und Entitäten, soziale Strukturen und manchmal auch Sprachen enthalten, die sich von der realen Welt völlig unterscheiden. Moderne Methoden zur Wissensextraktion machen Annahmen über Entity-Class-, Entity-Subclass- und Entity- Entity-Relationen, die für fiktive Domänen oft ungültig sind. Bei verschiedenen Genres fiktiver Domänen müssen Modelle auch über fiktive Domänen hinweg transferierbar sein. • Lange fiktive Texte. Während moderne Modelle Einschränkungen hinsichtlich der Länge der Eingabesequenz haben, ist es wichtig, Methoden zu entwickeln, die in der Lage sind, mit sehr langen Texten (z.B. ganzen Büchern) umzugehen, und mehrere Kontexte und verteilte Hinweise zu erfassen. Diese Dissertation befasst sich mit den oben genannten Herausforderungen, und entwickelt Methoden, die den Stand der Kunst zur Wissensextraktion in fiktionalen Domänen voranbringen. • Der erste Beitrag ist eine Methode, genannt TiFi, zur Konstruktion von Typsystemen (Taxonomie induktion) für fiktive Domänen. Aus von Fans erstellten Inhalten in Online-Communities wie Wikia induziert TiFi Taxonomien in drei wesentlichen Schritten: Kategoriereinigung, Kantenreinigung und Top-Level- Konstruktion. TiFi nutzt eine Vielzahl von Informationen aus den ursprünglichen Quellen und ist in der Lage, Taxonomien für eine Vielzahl von fiktiven Domänen mit hoher Präzision zu erstellen. • Der zweite Beitrag ist ein umfassender Ansatz, genannt ENTYFI, zur Erkennung von Entitäten, und deren Typen, in langen fiktiven Texten. Aufbauend auf 205 automatisch induzierten hochwertigen Typsystemen für populäre fiktive Domänen nutzt ENTYFI die Überlappung und Wiederverwendung dieser fiktiven Domänen zur Bearbeitung neuer Texte. Durch die Zusammenstellung verschiedener Typisierungsmodule mit einer Konsolidierungsphase ist ENTYFI in der Lage, in langen fiktionalen Texten eine feinkörnige Entitätstypisierung mit hoher Präzision und Abdeckung durchzuführen. • Der dritte Beitrag ist ein End-to-End-System, genannt KnowFi, um Relationen zwischen Entitäten aus sehr langen Texten wie ganzen Büchern zu extrahieren. KnowFi nutzt Hintergrundwissen aus 142 beliebten fiktiven Domänen, um interessante Beziehungen zu identifizieren und Trainingsdaten zu sammeln. KnowFi umfasst eine ähnlichkeitsbasierte Ranking-Technik, um falsch positive Einträge in Trainingsdaten zu reduzieren und potenzielle Textpassagen auszuwählen, die Paare von Kandidats-Entitäten enthalten. Durch das Trainieren eines hierarchischen neuronalen Netzwerkes für alle Relationen ist KnowFi in der Lage, Relationen zwischen Entitätspaaren aus langen fiktiven Texten abzuleiten, und übertrifft die besten früheren Methoden zur Relationsextraktion