Resource Allocation in SDN/NFV-Enabled Core Networks

For next generation core networks, it is anticipated to integrate communication, storage and computing resources into one unified, programmable and flexible infrastructure. Software-defined networking (SDN) and network function virtualization (NFV) become two enablers. SDN decouples the network control and forwarding functions, which facilitates network management and enables network programmability. NFV allows the network functions to be virtualized and placed on high capacity servers located anywhere in the network, not only on dedicated devices in current networks. Driven by SDN and NFV platforms, the future network architecture is expected to feature centralized network management, virtualized function chaining, reduced capital and operational costs, and enhanced service quality. The combination of SDN and NFV provides a potential technical route to promote the future communication networks. It is imperative to efficiently manage, allocate and optimize the heterogeneous resources, including computing, storage, and communication resources, to the customized services to achieve better quality-of-service (QoS) provisioning. This thesis makes some in-depth researches on efficient resource allocation for SDN/NFV-enabled core networks in multiple aspects and dimensionality. Typically, the resource allocation task is implemented in three aspects. Given the traffic metrics, QoS requirements, and resource constraints of the substrate network, we first need to compose a virtual network function (VNF) chain to form a virtual network (VN) topology. Then, virtual resources allocated to each VNF or virtual link need to be optimized in order to minimize the provisioning cost while satisfying the QoS requirements. Next, we need to embed the virtual network (i.e., VNF chain) onto the substrate network, in which we need to assign the physical resources in an economical way to meet the resource demands of VNFs and links. This involves determining the locations of NFV nodes to host the VNFs and the routing from source to destination. Finally, we need to schedule the VNFs for multiple services to minimize the service completion time and maximize the network performance. In this thesis, we study resource allocation in SDN/NFV-enabled core networks from the aforementioned three aspects. First, we jointly study how to design the topology of a VN and embed the resultant VN onto a substrate network with the objective of minimizing the embedding cost while satisfying the QoS requirements. In VN topology design, optimizing the resource requirement for each virtual node and link is necessary. Without topology optimization, the resources assigned to the virtual network may be insufficient or redundant, leading to degraded service quality or increased embedding cost. The joint problem is formulated as a Mixed Integer Nonlinear Programming (MINLP), where queueing theory is utilized as the methodology to analyze the network delay and help to define the optimal set of physical resource requirements at network elements. Two algorithms are proposed to obtain the optimal/near-optimal solutions of the MINLP model. Second, we address the multi-SFC embedding problem by a game theoretical approach, considering the heterogeneity of NFV nodes, the effect of processing-resource sharing among various VNFs, and the capacity constraints of NFV nodes. In the proposed resource constrained multi-SFC embedding game (RC-MSEG), each SFC is treated as a player whose objective is to minimize the overall latency experienced by the supported service flow, while satisfying the capacity constraints of all its NFV nodes. Due to processing-resource sharing, additional delay is incurred and integrated into the overall latency for each SFC. The capacity constraints of NFV nodes are considered by adding a penalty term into the cost function of each player, and are guaranteed by a prioritized admission control mechanism. We first prove that the proposed game RC-MSEG is an exact potential game admitting at least one pure Nash Equilibrium (NE) and has the finite improvement property (FIP). Then, we design two iterative algorithms, namely, the best response (BR) algorithm with fast convergence and the spatial adaptive play (SAP) algorithm with great potential to obtain the best NE of the proposed game. Third, the VNF scheduling problem is investigated to minimize the makespan (i.e., overall completion time) of all services, while satisfying their different end-to-end (E2E) delay requirements. The problem is formulated as a mixed integer linear program (MILP) which is NP-hard with exponentially increasing computational complexity as the network size expands. To solve the MILP with high efficiency and accuracy, the original problem is reformulated as a Markov decision process (MDP) problem with variable action set. Then, a reinforcement learning (RL) algorithm is developed to learn the best scheduling policy by continuously interacting with the network environment. The proposed learning algorithm determines the variable action set at each decision-making state and accommodates different execution time of the actions. The reward function in the proposed algorithm is carefully designed to realize delay-aware VNF scheduling. To sum up, it is of great importance to integrate SDN and NFV in the same network to accelerate the evolution toward software-enabled network services. We have studied VN topology design, multi-VNF chain embedding, and delay-aware VNF scheduling to achieve efficient resource allocation in different dimensions. The proposed approaches pave the way for exploiting network slicing to improve resource utilization and facilitate QoS-guaranteed service provisioning in SDN/NFV-enabled networks

An End-to-End Performance Analysis for Service Chaining in a Virtualized Network

Future mobile networks supporting Internet of Things are expected to provide both high throughput and low latency to user-specific services. One way to overcome this challenge is to adopt Network Function Virtualization (NFV) and Multi-access Edge Computing (MEC). Besides latency constraints, these services may have strict function chaining requirements. The distribution of network functions over different hosts and more flexible routing caused by service function chaining raise new challenges for end-to-end performance analysis. In this paper, as a first step, we analyze an end-to-end communications system that consists of both MEC servers and a server at the core network hosting different types of virtual network functions. We develop a queueing model for the performance analysis of the system consisting of both processing and transmission flows. We propose a method in order to derive analytical expressions of the performance metrics of interest. Then, we show how to apply the similar method to an extended larger system and derive a stochastic model for such systems. We observe that the simulation and analytical results coincide. By evaluating the system under different scenarios, we provide insights for the decision making on traffic flow control and its impact on critical performance metrics.Comment: 30 pages. arXiv admin note: substantial text overlap with arXiv:1811.0233

Impact of Processing-Resource Sharing on the Placement of Chained Virtual Network Functions

Network Function Virtualization (NFV) provides higher flexibility for network operators and reduces the complexity in network service deployment. Using NFV, Virtual Network Functions (VNF) can be located in various network nodes and chained together in a Service Function Chain (SFC) to provide a specific service. Consolidating multiple VNFs in a smaller number of locations would allow decreasing capital expenditures. However, excessive consolidation of VNFs might cause additional latency penalties due to processing-resource sharing, and this is undesirable, as SFCs are bounded by service-specific latency requirements. In this paper, we identify two different types of penalties (referred as "costs") related to the processingresource sharing among multiple VNFs: the context switching costs and the upscaling costs. Context switching costs arise when multiple CPU processes (e.g., supporting different VNFs) share the same CPU and thus repeated loading/saving of their context is required. Upscaling costs are incurred by VNFs requiring multi-core implementations, since they suffer a penalty due to the load-balancing needs among CPU cores. These costs affect how the chained VNFs are placed in the network to meet the performance requirement of the SFCs. We evaluate their impact while considering SFCs with different bandwidth and latency requirements in a scenario of VNF consolidation.Comment: Accepted for publication in IEEE Transactions on Cloud Computin

An Optimization-enhanced MANO for Energy-efficient 5G Networks

5G network nodes, fronthaul and backhaul alike, will have both forwarding and computational capabilities. This makes energy-efficient network management more challenging, as decisions such as activating or deactivating a node impact on both the ability of the network to route traffic and the amount of processing it can perform. To this end, we formulate an optimization problem accounting for the main features of 5G nodes and the traffic they serve, allowing joint decisions about (i) the nodes to activate, (ii) the network functions they run, and (iii) the traffic routing. Our optimization module is integrated within the management and orchestration framework of 5G, thus enabling swift and high-quality decisions. We test our scheme with both a real-world testbed based on OpenStack and OpenDaylight, and a large-scale emulated network whose topology and traffic come from a real-world mobile operator, finding it to consistently outperform state-of-the art alternatives and closely match the optimum

Energy-Efficient Softwarized Networks: A Survey

With the dynamic demands and stringent requirements of various applications, networks need to be high-performance, scalable, and adaptive to changes. Researchers and industries view network softwarization as the best enabler for the evolution of networking to tackle current and prospective challenges. Network softwarization must provide programmability and flexibility to network infrastructures and allow agile management, along with higher control for operators. While satisfying the demands and requirements of network services, energy cannot be overlooked, considering the effects on the sustainability of the environment and business. This paper discusses energy efficiency in modern and future networks with three network softwarization technologies: SDN, NFV, and NS, introduced in an energy-oriented context. With that framework in mind, we review the literature based on network scenarios, control/MANO layers, and energy-efficiency strategies. Following that, we compare the references regarding approach, evaluation method, criterion, and metric attributes to demonstrate the state-of-the-art. Last, we analyze the classified literature, summarize lessons learned, and present ten essential concerns to open discussions about future research opportunities on energy-efficient softwarized networks.Comment: Accepted draft for publication in TNSM with minor updates and editin

Power aware resource allocation and virtualization algorithms for 5G core networks

Most of the algorithms that solved the resource allocation problem, used to apply greedy algorithms to select the physical nodes and shortest paths to select the physical edges, without sufficient coordination between selecting the physical nodes and edges. This lack of coordination may degrade the overall acceptance ratios and network performance as whole, in addition, that may include non-necessary physical resources, which will consume more power and computational processing capacities, as well as cause more delays. Therefore, the main objective of this PhD thesis is to develop power aware resource allocation and virtualization algorithms for 5G core networks, which will be achieved through developing a virtualization resource allocation technique to perform virtual nodes and edges allocations in full coordination, and on the least physical resources. The algorithms will be general and solve the resource allocation problem for virtual network embedding and network function virtualization frameworks, while minimizing the total consumed power in the physical network, and consider end-to-end delay and migration as new optional features. This thesis suggested to solve the power aware resource allocation problem through brand new algorithms adopting a new technique called segmentation, which fully coordinates allocating the virtual nodes and edges together, and guarantees to use the very least physical resources to minimize the total power consumption, through consolidating the virtual machines into least number of nodes as much as possible. The proposed algorithms, solves virtual network embedding problem for off-line and on-line scenarios, and solves resource allocations for network function virtualization environment for off-line, on-line, and migration scenarios. The evaluations of the proposed off-line virtual network embedding algorithm, PaCoVNE, showed that it managed to save physical network power consumption by 57% in average, and the on-line algorithm, oPaCoVNE, managed to minimize the average power consumption in the physical network by 24% in average. Regarding allocation times of PaCoVNE and oPaCoVNE, they were in the ranges of 20-40 ms. For network function virtualization environment, the evaluations of the proposed offline NFV power aware algorithm, PaNFV, showed that on average it had lower total costs and lower migration cost by 32% and 65:5% respectively, compared to the state-of-art algorithms, while the on-line algorithm, oPaNFV, managed to allocate the Network Services in average times of 60 ms, and it had very negligible migrations. Nevertheless, this thesis suggests that future enhancements for the proposed algorithms need to be focused around modifying the proposed segmentation technique to solve the resource allocation problem for multiple paths, in addition to consider power aware network slicing, especially for mobile edge computing, and modify the algorithms for application aware resource allocations for very large scale networks. Moreover, future work can modify the segmentation technique and the proposed algorithms, by integrating machine learning techniques for smart traffic and optimal paths prediction, as well as applying machine learning for better energy efficiency, faster load balancing, much accurate resource allocations based on verity of quality of service metrics.La mayoría de los algoritmos que resolvieron el problema de asignación de recursos, se utilizaron para aplicar algoritmos codiciosos para seleccionar los nodos físicos y las rutas más cortas para seleccionar los bordes físicos, sin una coordinación suficiente entre la selección de los nodos físicos y los bordes. Esta falta de coordinación puede degradar los índices de aceptación generales y el rendimiento de la red en su totalidad, además, que puede incluir recursos físicos no necesarios, que consumirán más potencia y capacidades de procesamiento computacional, además de causar más retrasos. Por lo tanto, el objetivo principal de esta tesis doctoral es desarrollar algoritmos de virtualización y asignación de recursos para las redes centrales 5G, que se lograrán mediante el desarrollo de una técnica de asignación de recursos de virtualización para realizar nodos virtuales y asignaciones de bordes en total coordinación, y al menos recursos físicos. Los algoritmos serán generales y resolverán el problema de asignación de recursos para la integración de redes virtuales y los marcos de virtualización de funciones de red, al tiempo que minimizan la potencia total consumida en la red física y consideran el retraso y la migración de extremo a extremo como nuevas características opcionales. Esta tesis sugirió resolver el problema de la asignación de recursos conscientes de la potencia a través de nuevos algoritmos que adoptan una nueva técnica llamada segmentación, que coordina completamente la asignación de los nodos virtuales y los bordes, y garantiza el uso de los recursos físicos mínimos para minimizar el consumo total de energía, a través de consolidar las máquinas virtuales en el menor número de nodos tanto como sea posible. Los algoritmos propuestos solucionan el problema de integración de la red virtual para los escenarios sin conexión y en línea, y resuelve las asignaciones de recursos para el entorno de virtualización de la función de red para los escenarios sin conexión, en línea y de migración. Las evaluaciones del algoritmo de integración de red virtual sin conexión propuesto, PaCoVNE, mostraron que logró ahorrar el consumo de energía de la red física en un 57% en promedio, y el algoritmo en línea, oPaCoVNE, logró minimizar el consumo de energía promedio en la red física en un 24% en promedio. Con respecto a los tiempos de asignación de PaCoVNE y oPaCoVNE, estuvieron en los rangos de 20-40 ms. Para el entorno de virtualización de la función de red, las evaluaciones del algoritmo consciente de la potencia NFV sin conexión propuesto, PaNFV, mostraron que, en promedio, tenía menores costos totales y menores costos de migración en un 32% y 65: 5% respectivamente, en comparación con el estado de la técnica. Los algoritmos, mientras que el algoritmo en línea, oPaNFV, logró asignar los Servicios de Red en tiempos promedio de 60 ms, y tuvo migraciones muy insignificantes. Sin embargo, esta tesis sugiere que las futuras mejoras para los algoritmos propuestos deben centrarse en modificar la técnica de segmentación propuesta para resolver el problema de asignación de recursos para múltiples rutas, además de considerar el corte de la red que requiere energía, especialmente para la computación de borde móvil, y modificar el Algoritmos para asignaciones de recursos conscientes de la aplicación para redes de gran escala. Además, el trabajo futuro puede modificar la técnica de segmentación y los algoritmos propuestos, mediante la integración de técnicas de aprendizaje automático para el tráfico inteligente y la predicción de rutas óptimas, así como la aplicación del aprendizaje automático para una mejor eficiencia energética, un equilibrio de carga más rápido, asignaciones de recursos mucho más precisas basadas en la veracidad de Métricas de calidad de servicio